• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

A letter from Melbourne

Prolet

New member
This is a good read, its asking for the our people in Stari Kraj to treat us as Macedonians

И јас сум македонец, дозволи ми да гласам!

I_love_Macedonia-300.jpg


Македонија е земја од која со тешко срце се излегува, земја која не оставила рамнодушен ниту еден што стапнал на нејзино тло.

Економскиот пад, невработеноста, политички причини, геноцид, предизвикани од долгогодишни превирања, војни за национална, културна, политичка и економска слобода си го направија своето.

Се дојде до состојба на масовно иселување од својата земја, посебно во шеесеттите и седумдесеттите години. Македонците денес се насекаде во светот, не затоа што сакаат, но затоа што беше неминовно да се бара подобра егзистенција, повисок стандард и задоволување на основните човекови потреби. Но македонецот не би бил Македонец ако го заборави своето минато, своето потекло.

На сите континенти каде си оформил свој дом, нашиот човек понесе македонски дух, понесе одлики на чесност, трудољубивост, правичност, свест дека треба и понатаму да се задржи силниот дух на македонското битие, да се твори и живее како Македонец. Македонските иселеници ја понесоа Македонија со себе. Македонците во иселеништво и покрај огромните тешкотии и културни шокови во новото место на живеење, сепак мислат, живеат, творат, лобираат за Македонија, зборуваат Македонски , секој ден, секоја минута. Нели е тоа доволен доказ за тоа колку се сака, колку се грижи македонскиот човек за Македонија.

Излишно е да се зборува за тоа дека на иселениците не треба да им се даде право на глас, излишно и дискриминаторски е да во овие времиња кога се одлучува за судбината за самото постоење на Република Македонија, се полемизира и од некои политички партии во Македонија забранува демократското право на иселениците да гласаат за доброто утре на својата мајка.

Иселениците во никој случај не прифаќаат ускратување на правото на глас и остро се спртивставуваат на намерите од ЛДП да го поминат предлогот за измени во Изборниот законик со кој се бара укинување на гласањето на дијаспората.

Време е тој однос спрема иселениците да се смени.

Македонските иселеници во Австралија често пати се навредувани и добиваат етикети ‘Патриоти‘,или коментари во стилот ‘Лесно е да се брани татковината од далеку‘, Сте се размавтале со шеснаесет кракото сонце од Кутлеш а никаде ве нема‘.

Дијаспората е нераскинлив дел од својата земја, затоа што постојано вложува, инвестира во македонската економија, туризам, бизнис.

Ако си надвор од Македонија, не значи дека не си Македонец и дека треба да бидеш заборавен од својата мајка. Која мајка ќе си го заборави и отфрли своето чедо, само затоа што живее во друга земја.

Самите податоци за прилив од една милијарда евра во државната каса на Маедонија, доаѓа од иселениците. Без овие пари, Македонија би била во уште потешка ситуација. И наместо да се дистанцираме едни од други, да се расправаме дали и колку е важна дијаспората, нели е подобро за да се започне со градење на вистински мостови на соработка. Само на тој начин навистина би допринеле за напредок на Македонија но и за духовна и лична среќа на секој Македонец било каде да се наоѓа во светот. Без разлика на политичка определеност или етничка припадност, живеј и твори за земјата на твоето потекло, земјата во која живееш.

Дијаспората е и треба да се гледа како битен политички субјект кој допринесува за зачувување на македонскиот идентитет, јазик, култура, обичаи, традиции надвор од своите огништа. Македонското иселеништво сите овие години се чуствува отрфрлено и изолирано поради незаинтересираноста на поранешните Влади да донесат одлука за нејзино вклучување.

Исто така изразува незадоволство од недоволно развиена мрежа на стабилни врски преку агенцијата за иселеништво или други форми на здружување.

Од голема важност е да се вброи македонската дијаспора во гласачкиот список во својата родна земја и на тој начин да се претстави пореална етнографска слика на Македонија како важно географско подрачје во светот . Со почит кон нашето минато, тоа непроценливо богатство што го наследивме од нашите претци, должни сме да го сочуваме а и самите да направиме нешто повеќе за Македонија.

Да се дозволи право на глас на иселениците е неминовна потреба, и придобивка за секој што и мисли добро на Македонија, за секој што се грижи за напредок и зачувување на ова парче земја која не смееме да дозволиме да ни го уништат, да го продадат , т.е да го обезличат алчните за власт или за материјално богатсво.

Со Македонија никој не смее повеќе да тргува.

Да се ускрати правото на глас, иселениците го гледаат како Македонија да се откажува и ги отфрла своите чеда кои толку многу можат да дадат со нивното активно инволвирање во економијата, политиката, и општо во сите сфери на општеството.

Да се каже ‘Јас сум Македонец, доаѓам од Македонија‘ е гордост на секој иселеник , и потврда за постоење на македонска нација, за своето потекло, за македонскиот идентитет.

Не дозволувајте да го уништите тоа во душата на вашите во дијаспората.

Заедно сите да и помогнеме на Македонија да зачекори по патот кон трајна стабилност, просперитет и зачувување на својот идентитет и свето име Македонија.

И ЈАС СУМ МАКЕДОНЕЦ, ДОЗВОЛИ МИ ДА ГЛАСАМ!


http://www.mn.mk/iselenici-region/1336-I-jas-sum-makedonec-dozvoli-mi-da-glasam

http://translate.google.com/transla...um-makedonec-dozvoli-mi-da-glasam&sl=mk&tl=en
 
True, we are all Macedonians and we should all care for Macedonia and should be part of the decision regarding our country, be it from Australia or someone who 'is now also Bulgarian' or UK. I can understand the differences between the Diaspora and the Macedonians in Macedonia. That saying: Lesno e od dijasporata da si patriot' is 100% true. In the Diaspora people have hospitals to an acceptable level, education, jobs while in Macedonia, well we know the situation. The Macedonians will always want a gov that will spend money, effort into the things that are a priority for them while the priority for the Diaspora is to be more nationalistic/ patriotic. Ama ebem ti patriotstvo koga ja nemam leb da jadem. That is the difference and this is why it's difficult.
So before Prolet jumps to my throat again, this is me just pointing out the difference.If it was up to me tho and I were the gov I will allow only the Macedonians with permenent residence in Macedonia to vote but that is just my opinion.
An uncle of mine went to Australia 40 years ago and never ever returned. He should not be allowed to vote.
 
Last edited:
Both sides of the argument seem to have valid points but time changes things. Unless blood ties are maintained or renewed by marriage eventually 2nd cousins become 3rd then 4th then you get told who the hell are you if it hasn’t already happened before.:ninja:

Last time I was there I once had someone say to me stranci edni:chinese: in a very derogatory tone but made to feel it a number of times:glare:. But for the diaspora we never forget where we are from:thumbup1:.

Its funny how many people started with the idea we will be there for 5 years to specali and as we know Macedonians started coming out to Australia in larger numbers in the late 60s and early 70s some 40 years ago:oops:hahaha.
 
Ama ebem ti patriotstvo koga ja nemam leb da jadem.

I understand your points Jankovska.

If I give them all free bread, will they become patriotic?
If I give them free bread + meat, will they become patriotic?
If I give them free bread + meat + german car, will they become patriotic?
If I give them free bread + meat + german car + apartment in Ohrid, will they become patriotic?

When do we have to stop feeling sorry for them? When can we be proud of them for digging their heels in and saying enough is enough?

As an aside, nobody gave my parents free bread + meat + german car + apartment in Ohrid ... they left everything behind with nothing in their pockets. My father Bog da go prosti wore a dress as a child because they had no money. He had no food as a child and his relatives even hid food from him when he visited as a 5 year old. You would think he would have been kissing Australia's arse and hating Macedonia (and especially Greece) for his suffering. Instead he dedicated his entire life to furthering the Macedonian Cause.

I think no amount of money will ever make the Macedonians in Macedonia happy. Because they will always think we have more. And that is why we in the Diaspora are almost held in contempt by many Macedonians from the Republic.
 
When I visit Macedonia.. I get called KANGROO (Kangaroo)
Here in Australia I get called Wog...
So I don't know what the Fcuk I am...lol

Lets face it...majority of Macedonia Tourists are the Macedonian Diaspora, if we don't get respected while visiting our home land then many will visit less and less..
And that will be devastating for the Macedonian economy..
I agree, we Diaspora should have a say for the current and future of Macedonia…
If Macedonia was to prosper and have a good living standard..many will not look at leaving the country and some portion of Macedonians will return...
 
I understand your points Jankovska.

If I give them all free bread, will they become patriotic?
If I give them free bread + meat, will they become patriotic?
If I give them free bread + meat + german car, will they become patriotic?
If I give them free bread + meat + german car + apartment in Ohrid, will they become patriotic?
When do we have to stop feeling sorry for them? When can we be proud of them for digging their heels in and saying enough is enough?

As an aside, nobody gave my parents free bread + meat + german car + apartment in Ohrid ... they left everything behind with nothing in their pockets. My father Bog da go prosti wore a dress as a child because they had no money. He had no food as a child and his relatives even hid food from him when he visited as a 5 year old. You would think he would have been kissing Australia's arse and hating Macedonia (and especially Greece) for his suffering. Instead he dedicated his entire life to furthering the Macedonian Cause.

I think no amount of money will ever make the Macedonians in Macedonia happy. Because they will always think we have more. And that is why we in the Diaspora are almost held in contempt by many Macedonians from the Republic.



I admire the way you have put it. Fala ti!

That is the way I would like to see every Macedonian think.
 
Last edited:
Jankovska I don’t know how long you have been in the uk but you seem like a newbie. Wait one day if your are made to feel like a stranger in the place you were born in:chinese:. maybe this will be later for you because you left as an adult with established relationships and also being the uk it is a short and inexpensive trip so maybe you will go back more often. Judging from the few post here it sounds like many members could trade stories about the welcome or lack thereof in Macedonia.

I think the issue of feeling welcome touches on the core issue of this thread which is should the diaspora have a vote. Are the diaspora Macedonian enough to have a say or are they Macedonian in name only no pun intended. The predominant attitude from the republic of Macedonia is no, you are not Macedonian enough:blink:, you have your own lives with different economic circumstances and issues.

To rephrase the famous American saying no taxation without representation the republic of Macedonia and people there take the attitude of no representation without contribution. This is not true. Now as a member of the diaspora - welcome to dark side - have you ever sent money back to your relatives there. Many people do. Also lets face it most tourist to Macedonia are Macedonians from the diaspora and those that aren’t stay a week or two or less if its part of European tour trip over many countries. I know you are smart enough to know there are a lot of places far better than Macedonia to visit so if its not the look of the place then the diaspora who mostly spend one to three months there are either too stupid to discover these more attractive holiday places and put up with substandard everything:6: or there is some other value in play:stupid:.

I don’t know, maybe it could be the place I was born or the place my parents were born and keeping in touch with cousins and maybe it is the place that represents a part of their identity. I think many in the diaspora feel they have so called paid there dues but regardless of this the main thing the diaspora feel is on top of the distancing and sense of loss of parents siblings cousins and familiarity they are now made to feel a loss of identity to be told you are not Macedonian enough:eek1::glare: for your opinion to count with a vote. To be told stand aside and be a spectator, cross your fingers and hope for the best while we discuss your identity is very disempowering:glare:. Now that you have joined the dark side do you still think the diaspora should not have a say in the Macedonian name issue:oops:.
 
We as Macedonians esspecially from the Diaspora are known to be dignati glavi when we go to Macedonia. Maybe not so much now as beforem so why expect to be liked. While I was growing up in Macedonia I have seen the Canadian Macedonians, the Australian coming in complaining how we sleep on a couch or how we still listen to cassetes while you have CDs, that their gardens are huge and their armchairs are bigger than our sofas. I have seen it, heard it and I have not just disliked this people, I actually in a way hated them. I am not saying everyone is like that but majority are and we have all seen it and heard it. No one in Macedonia thinks I have more than them because I don't behave like I do. While growing up I have not once but a zillion times been made to feel small by the 'stranci'. Than I moved out as well and you know what I realised. They are all liars. They work like bloody slaves for a year to save 1000 euros to go and show of in Macedonia. They take crediti to buy a new flash car so they can show to the MAcedonians how rich they are, how they made it. I don't have many friends here in the UK because and I say this to everyone is they are most like that. They clean fucking houses with me and wait in restaurants and when in Macedonia they come up with stories of money and success they haven't even dreamt of. I HATE people like that and it seems like it's in the Macedonian blood to be like that. My friend was shocked that I have been telling people in Palanka that I was a cleaner when I moved to the UK, she thought I should make up shit. Many have asked me to lie if someone asked me what they do in the UK. When they go with their stories of I don't know what and make everyone in Macedonia feel small I understand the Macedonians why they don't like them. Every Macedonian think fuck off, you have your BMW and your company (the BMW that you will be paying off for the next 20 years and the mortgage for the rest of your life) and I am trying to put bread on my table and I should listen to you? The Macedonian Diaspora or many of them have made their bed and should not be upset that people in Macedonia don't like them. I moved out 10 years ago and all I tell people in Macedonia is NOT TO Believe all the stories they hear, most are made up shit. This is something that I tried to explain to my husband who couldnt' understand it until he moved here. Risto I understand that your parents were poor, I came to the UK with 70 german marks in my pocket, hardly enough for a cab back to the airport but I made it somehow, not because I am great, becuase you have many opporutnities here or in OZ. In Macedonia people don't have those. Plus most people who go there from the Diaspora go there to show how much better they are than the Macedonians.
I also firmly believe that if you have left Macedonia and haven't had any ties for over a decade you should not be allowed to vote.
What I am saying is not to make you feel sorry for the Macedonians in Macedonia, but to explain why most see us as 'stranci'. I have never been called the anglicanka, never. My best friend from Kriva Palanka is all the time. Everytime I go back people say: Eee Jankovska deka i da ides ti si si ista, ludicka, otkacena ama ista si si. Tebe Anglija ne te menja. Most people don't even make time for my friend coz they are tired of listening to the storied of boat trips and limos and travelling and I don;t know what else.
 
Jankovska there is much to what you say. I have heard stories both here and there of how people have behaved:shifty:. Some might say well it just is we have more in the dispoia and are we supposed to feel bad for this. I think people who say this some might out of a negative experience there but I do think many instance are out of a lack of basic human dignity and tact or revenge. I think back to the Macedonian story of the guptin who was made king for a day. I think you know what I mean.:blink:

I think much of what goes on is down to human nature unfortunately Macedonians both here and there avail themselves to the darker sides of this nature more often then not.:glare:

It is possible both here and there to have friends or relatives of different financial means. It is still possible for them to get along by using tact to leave each other some dignity. On my last trip to Macedonia a cousin of mine remarked I wasn’t like other Australians. Having grown up in Australia I hold many Australian attitudes so I thought oh yeah, this’ll be good, so I interjected with, “well other Australians backgrounds are from England and Ireland and don’t have that special touch of Macedonian about them.”:thumbup1: He laughed and went on to say, “no, I meant other Macedonian Australians. Most of them cant stop bragging about what they have or what they’ve done and you haven’t bragged once yet I know that you could.” In a rather nonchalant way I simply replied, “would you rather I did. I thought it would just bore both of us”, and carried on with the other topic of our conversation.:21: But this is neither here no there my reason for posing was the issue of voting.:gunsmilie:

I know the people on the ground are more in tune with the day to day issues and are probably more entitled to have a say in their outcome but one issue I don’t think they have the exclusive licence to is the name issue and the affect it has on our collective identity. But even without the name issue I don’t like being made to feel like a jafa in the place I was born.:eek1: A point lost on many Macedonians there. Even if I was a jafa any place that derives a large portion of their income from tourism needs to know how to play nice with the tourists. Hate them as much as you like but there is no need to let them know let alone so blatantly. The old saying familiarity breeds contempt is ever true in Macedonia. The Macedonians there know that Macedonia to the diaspora is not just another place in the world to visit but the only place we can go to visit our birth place and catch up with relatives. What irks the diaspora is the Macedonians there say whatever disparaging thing they feel with a smirk in there voice as if to say I know you’ll be back haha.:6: Why would the disporia care. Because its part of our identity too. On this one issue the diaspora should have a say. Its not exclusively theirs to bargain with.:45:
 
Jankovska, you are right about the boastful stranci. They are peasants and nothing will change them. It is common for all races and is nothing more than basic human nature. These people left everything behind and are now justifying their move. Cleaning toilets for 30 years is justified by the big house etc. They make the rest of us look bad when they boast about the quality of life. But they are fading fast and their children have grown up with more all of their lives. They will be less boastful. It should not mean any of them are less Macedonian. In fact, whichever way you look at it, it is a reminder of Macedonia's past.
 
We as Macedonians esspecially from the Diaspora are known to be dignati glavi when we go to Macedonia. Maybe not so much now as beforem so why expect to be liked. While I was growing up in Macedonia I have seen the Canadian Macedonians, the Australian coming in complaining how we sleep on a couch or how we still listen to cassetes while you have CDs, that their gardens are huge and their armchairs are bigger than our sofas. I have seen it, heard it and I have not just disliked this people, I actually in a way hated them. I am not saying everyone is like that but majority are and we have all seen it and heard it. No one in Macedonia thinks I have more than them because I don't behave like I do. While growing up I have not once but a zillion times been made to feel small by the 'stranci'. Than I moved out as well and you know what I realised. They are all liars. They work like bloody slaves for a year to save 1000 euros to go and show of in Macedonia. They take crediti to buy a new flash car so they can show to the MAcedonians how rich they are, how they made it. I don't have many friends here in the UK because and I say this to everyone is they are most like that. They clean fucking houses with me and wait in restaurants and when in Macedonia they come up with stories of money and success they haven't even dreamt of. I HATE people like that and it seems like it's in the Macedonian blood to be like that. My friend was shocked that I have been telling people in Palanka that I was a cleaner when I moved to the UK, she thought I should make up shit. Many have asked me to lie if someone asked me what they do in the UK. When they go with their stories of I don't know what and make everyone in Macedonia feel small I understand the Macedonians why they don't like them. Every Macedonian think fuck off, you have your BMW and your company (the BMW that you will be paying off for the next 20 years and the mortgage for the rest of your life) and I am trying to put bread on my table and I should listen to you? The Macedonian Diaspora or many of them have made their bed and should not be upset that people in Macedonia don't like them. I moved out 10 years ago and all I tell people in Macedonia is NOT TO Believe all the stories they hear, most are made up shit. This is something that I tried to explain to my husband who couldnt' understand it until he moved here. Risto I understand that your parents were poor, I came to the UK with 70 german marks in my pocket, hardly enough for a cab back to the airport but I made it somehow, not because I am great, becuase you have many opporutnities here or in OZ. In Macedonia people don't have those. Plus most people who go there from the Diaspora go there to show how much better they are than the Macedonians.
I also firmly believe that if you have left Macedonia and haven't had any ties for over a decade you should not be allowed to vote.
What I am saying is not to make you feel sorry for the Macedonians in Macedonia, but to explain why most see us as 'stranci'. I have never been called the anglicanka, never. My best friend from Kriva Palanka is all the time. Everytime I go back people say: Eee Jankovska deka i da ides ti si si ista, ludicka, otkacena ama ista si si. Tebe Anglija ne te menja. Most people don't even make time for my friend coz they are tired of listening to the storied of boat trips and limos and travelling and I don;t know what else.

100% in agreemenent with you Jankovska. Most stranci are fake and the ill treatment they receive, they do deserve it.

If you are true to yourself, then there is no issues in Maco with the average citizen.

In terms of voting, if you dont pay taxes in Maco and dont live there, what do you want???? You are not a citizen of Macedonia, because you are patriot does not mean a vote.

At times most stranci see the RoM citizens as greedy or envy. What do you expect, when the stranci constantly boast about the quality of life they live in stranstvo, they just want a piece of that!!! if they dont get it, then they see the stranci as selfish!!
 
Macedonia relies heavily on assistance from the diaspora, there needs to be vehicle for our voice and influence. Wether that is through voting rights or a diaspora representative group within the government, there needs to be something.
 
i think we need a voice definitely, but i am not comofortable with having a vote in the parliament, i think that should be restricted to citizens who are permanent residents.
 
I wrote this some time ago as a response to the question as to whether the Macedonians around the world should be able to vote.

Perhaps someone can translate it.
---------------------------------------------------------------------


Би требало сите државјани, односно сите со државјанство на Република Македонија, без разлика на место на живеење, да бидат рамноправни и да уживаат исти права.

Се разбира, во тоа се опфатува и правото на глас.

Така е ширум светот во најразвиените и слободните држави, тоа е еден суштински дел од демократијата.

Иако, се повеќе изгледа одредени групи во Република Македонија не ја почитуваат Македонската дијаспора, сепак таа иста дијаспора е најзначајниот фактор коишто ја крепи Македонската економија (преку нивното постојано испракање на пари кон своите роднини во Република Македонија) - се работи за 500 милиони до 1 миљарда долари годишно, односно околу 10% од Бруто Домашниот Производ (GDP).

Очигледно и неспорно е тоа што дијаспората е веќе значаен економски фактор во Република Македонија.

Би требало да биде и политички фактор, со што ке се отворат сите граници за организирано лобирање низ цел свет за Република Македонија и нејзините национални интереси.

Понатаму, како одговор на тие со ставот дека Македонците надвор од Република Македонија не ја разбираат политичката сцена во Македонија; тие Македонци надвор од Република Македонија кои би се интересирале доволно да излезат на гласање, исто така се тие истите кои ја следат и разбираат политицката сцена во Република Македонија.

Но, покрај сето тоа, како одговор на прашањето 'Дали Македонците низ светот би требало да имаат право на глас' произлегува едно по-суштинско и значајно прашање:

Дали Република Македонија е држава на нејзините граѓани, односно тие кои жиевеат во неа, или е држава на Македонскиот народ? Со тоа, дали Република Македонија е претставник само на нејзините граѓани, или на целокупниот Македонскиот народ?

Со одговор на тоа суштинско идеолошко прашање, лесно се знае и одговор на тоа дали Македонската дијаспора би требало да има право на глас.
 
Last edited:
osiris; 39 said:
i think we need a voice definitely, but i am not comofortable with having a vote in the parliament, i think that should be restricted to citizens who are permanent residents.



I think its important Macedonians world wide should be eligible to vote on certain matters. Our voice will only be heard by voting other wise we will be ignored i'm afraid.
 
I wrote this some time ago as a response to the question as to whether the Macedonians around the world should be able to vote.

Perhaps someone can translate it.
---------------------------------------------------------------------

All citizens - i.e. all those with citizenship of the Republic of Macedonia - should be equal and enjoy the same rights, regardless of their place of residency. This of course includes the right to vote. It is an essential element of democracy, as evident in the most advanced and freest states across the world.

Although it appears that certain groups in the Republic of Macedonia do not respect the Macedonian Diaspora, that Diaspora is still the most important factor that supports the Macedonian economy (through constant remittance to their relatives in the Republic of Macedonia) – in question are some 500 million – one billion dollars per annum, or rather 10% of GDP.

It is obvious and inarguable that the Diaspora is already an important economic factor in the Republic of Macedonia.

It needs to also be a political factor, which would open all barriers to organized lobbying throughout the whole world, on behalf of the national interests of the Republic of Macedonia.

Furthermore, as an answer to all those with the stance that the Macedonians outside of the Republic of Macedonia do not understand the political scene in Macedonia, those Macedonians outside the borders of the Republic of Macedonia with sufficient interest to come out and vote, are the same ones who follow and understand the political scene in the Republic of Macedonia.

Still, besides all this, as an answer to the question - ‘Do the Macedonians throughout the world should have the right to vote?” - emerges an even more fundamental question:

Is the Republic of Macedonia a state of its citizens [resident citizens??], i.e. those who reside within her borders, or is it the state of the Macedonian people? Given this, does the Republic of Macedonia represent only its citizens [resident citizens??] or the whole of the Macedonian people?

By answering that fundamental ideological question, the answer to whether the Macedonian Diaspora should have the right to vote becomes obvious.



-------------------------------------
 
Last edited:
Back
Top