• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

A sad realisation

has anyone heard about the whoosh bird it flies in a circle and whoosh eventually dissapears up its own arse.This is what this thread reminds me of.
 
I haven't used one bit of emotion in my posts. Phoenix on the other hand...got a little heated over Gocka's generalization of Macedonians in Macedonia.

It would appear that he was not alone in that regard, how about you? what are your thoughts on conveying views on RoMacedonians that are as ignorant as the common views RoMacedonians convey about the Diaspora?, productive?, offensive?, correct?, perhaps sexy?, how about including a bit of substance about why you “don’t necessarily agree with” Gocka’s point, which if I was to abbreviate in laymen’s terms from his original post “if we want to instill a desire for change in RoMacedonians, start f*cking with their lifestyle” (a theory applicable universally if you ask me so it can hardly be seen as an epiphany of sorts, nor a morally viable solution for the resolution of RoMacedonia’s issues). I’d say that should be the pivotal point of discussion wouldn’t you agree?, rather than arguing with all those who expressed opposition to the original statement about their supposed “incorrect interpretation” of the statement, after all did you not state that you thought Gocka’s point was worth discussing and exploring?, well discuss, what’s your stance on the matter, apparently you do have one since you don’t necessarily agree with Gocka’s point?, what exactly don’t you necessarily agree with and why?, please elaborate to allow others explore it with you (unless of course you’re really only interested in farting in the wind)

And actually, TM, you didn't generalize. So, essentially, your cleverness fails.

I’m not sure whether to interpret this as a good thing or a bad thing?, either way, please excuse my possible incompetence in adequately applying the term in my post, after all us Australians are a rather uncivilized bunch (did I get it right this time?)

Unless, of course, by "very emotional people" you didn't mean "a lot of our brothers across the Pacific", and instead meant just "our brothers across the Pacific". If you did intend to generalize, then you have clarity issues that need to be resolved. In that case, I would make an appeal for a little more logic and thought in your posts and a little less...well...clouded emotional judgment.

Ok buddy, in future I’ll try to do better, but I sure would appreciate it if you weren’t too harsh on me when I fail to equal the pinnacle that is your standard…
 
Last edited:
It would appear that he was not alone in that regard, how about you? what are your thoughts on conveying views on RoMacedonians that are as ignorant as the common views RoMacedonians convey about the Diaspora?, productive?, offensive?, correct?, perhaps sexy?, how about including a bit of substance about why you “don’t necessarily agree with” Gocka’s point, which if I was to abbreviate in laymen’s terms from his original post “if we want to instill a desire for change in RoMacedonians, start f*cking with their lifestyle” (a theory applicable universally if you ask me so it can hardly be seen as an epiphany of sorts, nor a morally viable solution for the resolution of RoMacedonia’s issues). I’d say that should be the pivotal point of discussion wouldn’t you agree?, rather than arguing with all those who expressed opposition to the original statement about their supposed “incorrect interpretation” of the statement, after all did you not state that you thought Gocka’s point was worth discussing and exploring?, well discuss, what’s your stance on the matter, apparently you do have one since you don’t necessarily agree with Gocka’s point?, what exactly don’t you necessarily agree with and why?, please elaborate to allow others explore it with you (unless of course you’re really only interested in farting in the wind)



I’m not sure whether to interpret this as a good thing or a bad thing?, either way, please excuse my possible incompetence in adequately applying the term in my post, after all us Australians are a rather uncivilized bunch (did I get it right this time?)



Ok buddy, in future I’ll try to do better, but I sure would appreciate it if you weren’t too harsh on me when I fail to equal the pinnacle that is your standard…

Whether he was alone or not in responding emotionally, I cannot say. Though, it seems like Gocka may have gotten emotional in response to Phoenix's rudeness.

You interjected yourself in this thread without offering an opinion about the topic in order to satisfy some of your own farting in the wind. Apparently, you have no interest in truly exploring the issue, either. Sure, I thought, at first, it would be helpful to direct the conversation away from about how "Gocka is living a greedy lifestyle" and how Gocka "can't handle the hamster wheel." Maybe get people to talk about why the Macedonian Diaspora should or shouldn't, and can or can't successfully, be involved in bringing some sort of lifestyle change to Macedonians.

How about you interject next time with a: "Hey Phoenix, simply say 'Gocka, your description of Macedonians is too general and not accurate, therefore messing with their lifestyles can't possibly happen, as you suggest... and on top of that, we shouldn't.' " But you didn't. So to me it appears that: a) you think that the so-called "honest" deliverance of misinformed character attacks are productive to a discussion; and b) your interest in this topic isn't the topic. You're not sincere in your words, and neither were you many months ago about discussing the local government and community alternative to nation-states.

As far as generalizations, making them are fine :) But if you're going to make them, prepare to defend them. This is what Phoenix expected out of Gocka but didn't expect out of himself. A little fairness ought to do.
 
Whether he was alone or not in responding emotionally, I cannot say. Though, it seems like Gocka may have gotten emotional in response to Phoenix's rudeness.

You interjected yourself in this thread without offering an opinion about the topic in order to satisfy some of your own farting in the wind. Apparently, you have no interest in truly exploring the issue, either. Sure, I thought, at first, it would be helpful to direct the conversation away from about how "Gocka is living a greedy lifestyle" and how Gocka "can't handle the hamster wheel." Maybe get people to talk about why the Macedonian Diaspora should or shouldn't, and can or can't successfully, be involved in bringing some sort of lifestyle change to Macedonians.

How about you interject next time with a: "Hey Phoenix, simply say 'Gocka, your description of Macedonians is too general and not accurate, therefore messing with their lifestyles can't possibly happen, as you suggest... and on top of that, we shouldn't.' " But you didn't. So to me it appears that: a) you think that the so-called "honest" deliverance of misinformed character attacks are productive to a discussion; and b) your interest in this topic isn't the topic. You're not sincere in your words, and neither were you many months ago about discussing the local government and community alternative to nation-states.

As far as generalizations, making them are fine :) But if you're going to make them, prepare to defend them. This is what Phoenix expected out of Gocka but didn't expect out of himself. A little fairness ought to do.

Viktor, why don't you explain why you didn't agree with Gocka instead of spending page after page whining about my delivery of the same message...

You Americans are very fragile and so easily bruised.
 
You interjected yourself in this thread without offering an opinion about the topic in order to satisfy some of your own farting in the wind.

Yes I did, seeing that all that appeared to be going on was just that (a direction I would personally opine was heavily influenced by some of your posts), I saw no reason not to join in some of the fun:001_smile:

Apparently, you have no interest in truly exploring the issue, either.

So am I to take the above to mean that you now actually have no interest in truly exploring the issue?, sorry, it’s just that this statement kind of contradicts this earlier one you made:
I can't say I completely agree with it, but I think it is worth discussing and exploring.
So again some clarity would be appreciated, but yes, you are correct in assuming that I personally have no interest in exploring the issue at this stage, perhaps if it developed into something with a bit more substance I would be able to also develop some more in depth personal opinions on the points being discussed which I would be happy to convey, but right now there is not much more to add on the topic to what has previously been stated by other forum members


Sure, I thought, at firs, it would be helpful to direct the conversation away from about how "Gocka is living a greedy lifestyle" and how Gocka "can't handle the hamster wheel." Maybe get people to talk about why the Macedonian Diaspora should or shouldn't, and can or can't successfully, be involved in bringing some sort of lifestyle change to Macedonians.

Funny, I thought the undertones in my initial post alluded to the same goal except at a later stage of the discussion, albeit in an indirect and more satirical manner (can’t always be too serious don’t you agree?), nevertheless a more direct approach (direct to you that is, seeing that you appeared to actually have an opinion on the matter) was utilised in my second post, which I note you have conveniently ignored. In this respect, it is hard to argue against Phoenix’s presumptions on your character when you act in accordance with them.

How about you interject next time with a: "Hey Phoenix, simply say 'Gocka, your description of Macedonians is too general and not accurate, therefore messing with their lifestyles can't possibly happen, as you suggest... and on top of that, we shouldn't.' " But you didn't.

That’s because similar views like the above had already been conveyed by other forum members. I’m not an overly big fan of repetition, unless of course I feel it’s needed, which in this case, I didn’t.



So to me it appears that: a) you think that the so-called "honest" deliverance of misinformed character attacks are productive to a discussion; and b) your interest in this topic isn't the topic.

How about c) for those who actually have something productive to add to the original topic of the thread, speak up, and for those who don’t, I think thus far a fair share of farting in the wind has been undertaken, so let’s just call it a day for now or alternatively create another thread specifically for that reason.


You're not sincere in your words, and neither were you many months ago about discussing the local government and community alternative to nation-states.

Vicsinad, if you still wanted to discuss your “local government and community alternative to nation-states” theory that was brought up previously you could have simply started a thread to do so. The only reason why I ceased to pursue the subject at that time was because a direct request was made by the owners of this website to not engage in other topics with you until you had first addressed some other outstanding items that had been raised. I did not see this to be an unreasonable request, hence why I respected it. If there is no objection to it now, we can pursue it if that is your wish, although to be honest, judging from our exchanges since that time, it is I who feels that you may not be entirely sincere in actually following though the exploration of your theory, nevertheless, I’m willing to at least give it a shot, so just say the word and I’ll personally look to create a new thread the next chance I get, however please note that this time of year is particularly taxing of my time, so if you could be kind enough to exercise some patience when it comes to me responding to your posts, it would be much appreciated, I will endeavour to address them as best as I can, when I can. Again let me know.
 
So am I to take the above to mean that you now actually have no interest in truly exploring the issue?, sorry, it’s just that this statement kind of contradicts this earlier one you made:

Actually, my use of either was rather poor word-choice on my part, as it was intended to serve as an "also" or "in addition" in relation to my statement in the first sentence. But I apologize: I can see now how both sentences are pretty much relating to the same point, and that "either" "also" and "in addition" would have all been unnecessary.


if it developed into something with a bit more substance I would be able to also develop some more in depth personal opinions on the points being discussed which I would be happy to convey, but right now there is not much more to add on the topic to what has previously been stated by other forum members

Sure. But, from my perspective, it was not my posts that detracted from the purpose of Gocka's post. I simply was trying to direct the conversation off the side topics and onto the main topic so then a discussion could ensue.


nevertheless a more direct approach (direct to you that is, seeing that you appeared to actually have an opinion on the matter) was utilised in my second post, which I note you have conveniently ignored

I did not conveniently ignore it. Rather, I have my own suspicions of your motivations and intentions. And that is enough, for me, to withhold directly engaging you on the issue, for it is not your interest for the people in this topic to hold a discussion on this topic, or else you would request further elaboration from others.

That’s because similar views like the above had already been conveyed by other forum members. I’m not an overly big fan of repetition, unless of course I feel it’s needed, which in this case, I didn’t.

But apparently you are a fan of repetition, because the point(s) you made in your initial post were merely repetition of earlier views, with a little more artistic flare.

How about c) for those who actually have something productive to add to the original topic of the thread, speak up, and for those who don’t, I think thus far a fair share of farting in the wind has been undertaken, so let’s just call it a day for now or alternatively create another thread specifically for that reason.

Well, I'm trying to be productive. I repeatedly asked Pheonix to demonstrate his evidence that the typical American is socially, morally and intellectually greedy and forces his US-centrist visions and ideals on others. (This of course relates to his initial assessment of Gocka being greedy and how he was wrong to be so.) If he can't, or won't, demonstrate that, then he should move on from railing on Gocka about whether Gocka's generalization was accurate or not so the heart of the matter, whether the Diaspora should or can, get involved in some sort of lifestyle change. Of course, however, you have your own perception, as evidenced by your initial post.

Vicsinad, if you still wanted to discuss your “local government and community alternative to nation-states” theory that was brought up previously you could have simply started a thread to do so.

I invited you to do so.

The only reason why I ceased to pursue the subject at that time was because a direct request was made by the owners of this website to not engage in other topics with you until you had first addressed some other outstanding items that had been raised.

I understand that. But, as I'm sure you're a thorough man, you have read the rules and regulations of this forum, and there is simply no requirement for one to address outstanding items in order to make a post. There is stuff about off-topic rambling and irrelevancy to the Macedonian cause and Macedonian community, but nothing about the former. But i understand: this is a privately owned forum and the rules and regulations are subject to...well...the owners' whims. (Though, they are definitely more lenient than they are consistent.)


If there is no objection to it now, we can pursue it if that is your wish, although to be honest, judging from our exchanges since that time, it is I who feels that you may not be entirely sincere in actually following though the exploration of your theory

I do object -- it's done with, it was many months ago, I merely brought it up to emphasize a pattern I was beginning to observe. But you shattered that theory by confirming another suspicion that a certain owner/owners requested you refrain.
 
Viktor, stop rambling and wasting space...just explain to all why you didn't agree with Gocka's original post.
 
...Although while I didn't completely agree with some of your (gocka's) generalizations in your first post (post #1)...

...I can't say I completely agree with it, but I think it is worth discussing and exploring.

Well, cough it up sunshine, let's hear why you don't "completely agree" with Gocka's generalizations but lets hear your discussions and explorations on the subject.
You've wasted page after page of drivel, even Gocka has disappeared but you continue to waste time arguing bullshit points with anyone prepared to highlight your inherent stupidity and your donkey bred inaet.
 
This is even a sadder realisation when your Prime Minister even refers his own country to FYROM Skopje..Refer to the letter....

http://www.utrinski.com.mk/WBStorage/Articles/F564D7B062B1DB46B99FC43CD67E303A.jpg

I wonder if it's a genuine letter?
I'm assuming a genuine letter from the prime minister of Macedonia would have some official government seal on display and would be hand signed, at least these 2 elements, I imagine would be a requirement for the diplomatic exchange of letters...

just a thought and wishful thinking on my behalf.
 
I wonder if it's a genuine letter?
I'm assuming a genuine letter from the prime minister of Macedonia would have some official government seal on display and would be hand signed, at least these 2 elements, I imagine would be a requirement for the diplomatic exchange of letters...

just a thought and wishful thinking on my behalf.

Pheonix, would you think that if Grujo was sending a letter to arse kiss to the Greek Govt he would apply the official stamps that have Republic of Macedonia? I don't think so...
 
What the hell is wrong with you people. Your acting like a bunch of little kids. From the first reply on my original post this entire thread some how went 7 freaking pages on pure bullshit alone.

Phoenix,

What did you accomplish? What did you want to accomplish? I gave a generalization, then you said you shouldn't generalize and then proceeded to try and insult me with a generalization of your own. What makes you think I'm offended by you criticizing Americans? I am Macedonian so I dont really care what you think of Americans, My name is GOCE not bob or bil or jim etc, I am Macedonian and that is the only group I can associate to, and the only one I care about.

Your criticisms of me, generalizations, and Americans were so hypocritical I have a hard time believing that you didn't intentionally speak hypocritically, or at least I sincerely hope it was on purpose or else....

At least out of the two of us, I more likely know way more Macedonians then you know Americans.

Your hinging your whole argument against me on the assumption that I like and promote American culture and mentality. Since I am not a fan of either I have no idea what your problem is exactly.

You never once asked me to clarify, you simply came, went off like a loony, and then came back and did it again and again, and Americans are emotional? You never once tried to have an actual debate about what I said, you never once pointed out exactly what you didn't like or agree with, other then your hate for Americans (which I can understand way more then any of the other garbage that you spewed).

I tried to respond politely but you just keep on going, for someone who doesn't see this forum as a place for Foes or friends you certainly approached me like a foe, and why cant we be friends? Why do Macedonians have such a hard time getting along, you certainly dont act like this with non Macedonians. There is another generalization I b believe is true. Macedonians have absolutely no respect for each other, and this whole forum is a perfect example of that.

Much of what I wrote was a purposeful over dramatization, The reason being to show how differently diaspora Macedonians and RM Macedonians approach and see life.

What I have been suggesting all along is that We can angry at them, why dont they do this or why dont they do that, they must be blind they must be stupid, maybe they just dont know. Hasn't time shown us perhaps that they know much more then we assume, that they simply have a different outlook and different priorities then ours in the Diaspora. I'm not saying right or wrong just yet, but simply that we are expecting them to do one thing when they really just want to do another, and its not a matter of knowledge, or guts, its a matter of preference.

Generalization or not, I think you would have to be at the least a bit ignorant to say that there is not a huge difference in lifestyles, and life choices between the diaspora and ROM? Anyone who has spent any length of time in ROM knows this, and those experiences are written all over this forum. Most of the things I said can be plucked not only from my experiences but from many on this forum.

The last thing I want to address is your criticism of my using the term FYROMCI. You are correct, initially I didn't like it, and I found it harmful, I still find it harmful to be honest, but I cant think of a better way to describe the phenomenon that I see. In my opinion a real Macedonian would not allow the total Albanian domination of Macedonia, they would treat fellow Macedonians with more respect then they do others, not less, they would proudly demand their rightful flag, they would proudly demand their god given identity, they would try and make Macedonia a better place, not curse it and abuse, and drain it for every penny that can be had (Pasco Kuzman) What else do you call these people? I dont consider them Macedonians, what else are they other then Fyromci?

In my opinion a generalization is true when the status quo reflects the generalization. Whether my generalization covers 90% or 10% of Macedonians is not important, what is important is that clearly there are enough of them to continue the status quo. I dont think you can deny that there is almost no push against the farce that is FYROM, until that isn't true, i think my generalization holds true.

If anyone wish to actually discuss, how they think RM Macedonians live and think, then please I'm interested to know what other peoples perception is of them and what parts of my perception you think are contrary to yours.

If you wish to squabble and moan like children then please dont post at all, its a waist of space and time.

Finally, please take into consideration, that the endless nitpicking, and arguing about nothing, is just as much of a problem than anything going on in ROM. We are all Macedonians, there are not many of us, no one else supports us, no one else even likes us, if we dont like each other and at least give each other the benefit of the doubt then we might as well just sign away our identity right now,
 
you all look silly as hell you are resolving nothing by arguing with each other.It's getting sillier too good for words as time goes on.
 
Gocka, I strongly believe that your post was and is still way out of order.
I don't care for the sarcasm in your post and I don't need Viktors acid trip to discover your creative writing skills.

There are many hard working and loyal Macedonians, people who put their lives on the line in 2001, people who work their butts off just trying to make ends meet.
Show some respect to those people you fuckin imbecile.

If it still doesn't make sense to you, I'll give you another installment shortly...
 
couldn't this thread be a closed thread???you have all made your point let it die in the arse.Stop proping it up.
 
Gocka, I strongly believe that your post was and is still way out of order.
I don't care for the sarcasm in your post and I don't need Viktors acid trip to discover your creative writing skills.

There are many hard working and loyal Macedonians, people who put their lives on the line in 2001, people who work their butts off just trying to make ends meet.
Show some respect to those people you fuckin imbecile.

If it still doesn't make sense to you, I'll give you another installment shortly...


What is way out of order is you constant use of insults and profanity. I asked you many questions many times and every time you come back with some profanity and an insult. Another hypocritical step in a long line of them. If I recall correctly when i criticized and unnamed person, he shall remain unnamed so to not invoke whining on your behalf, when I criticized this persons for being rude, and insulting you were one of the people who jumped in and agreed that there was no need for it. Now I've tried to be polite on every occasion and you keep insulting me. If I didn't explain myself well enough the first time, surely I have clarified what I am saying by now.

To answer to your rant. There are many like you describe and I believe there are at least as many and probably more who are the exact opposite. Like I said if a large majority were as you describe then guess what, Macedonia would be in a totally different situation then it is now. If everyone wanted to defend Macedonia the Albanians wouldn't be taking over. The reality is that Macedonia is not some twilight zone, the countries is and functions as the majority wish it too.

External forces can only do so much, clearly there is not internal force which can only be blamed on Macedonians and no one else.

If you can not make a point or if you can not write with out profanity and insults, then please just leave the thread.
 
If anyone wish to actually discuss, how they think RM Macedonians live and think, then please I'm interested to know what other peoples perception is of them and what parts of my perception you think are contrary to yours.



From my minimal first-hand and second-hand accounts, I think a more dominant attitude in Macedonia and among Macedonians (and not just Macedonians in Macedonia) than I have experienced in America and among Americans is that they have no control over what happens around them. They accept that the system is corrupt, that liars, cheaters and self-serving scum prevail, and will always prevail. Here, in America, I see more of a disillusioned sense that good, right and hope are prevailing and will prevail, and that only the individual has complete control of his destiny. Yet, even this is fading.

In essence, I find that the Macedonians are a little less optimistic about the future and have a little less faith and trust in society-at-large and their institutions. On the flip side, they tend to value, and make time for, personal and community relationships. In many areas, the village is (or recently was) the focus. In America, it tends to be entertainment, work, or the self.

I think, however, that as citizens of Macedonia, they have every right not to be subjected to having exterior influences decide their course(s). What is right and beneficial, in the Diaspora's eyes, for Macedonia and the Macedonian citizens does not necessarily correlate with the conclusions they draw from their perceptions of their society. They face the consequences and reap the benefits. They are directly, and wholly, affected by anything that involves Macedonia. We in the Diaspora are only partly affected, and only in some instances directly affected.

How and to what extent outside forces meddle and influence their democratic duties, responsibilities and choices, can diminish the value and benefits of whatever it is they create for themselves. Yes, the whole world has become a battlefield for peoples of one place promoting and advancing interests in another place of which that they are not a citizen: from human rights organizations, NGOs, corporations, governmental agencies, banks, and the likes. Sometimes places and people request these outsiders. However, it's a conflicting mess when some want it, some don't, and some don't care. Beyond that, just because it has become common (and probably never will fade away in a world where communication and transportation finding new ways to make us interconnected), it doesn't make it effective or right.

And arguments have also been made for the necessity of outside influence in other places: weak pollution regulations in developing countries effects global health; internal and regional wars can have a domino effect; human rights abuses are despicable regardless of race or citizenship; and so on. In the end, we may believe we are doing good, or the right thing; then again, this sort of globalization may actually be hampering local and regional peoples from exerting their own direct control of democracies because so many interests are involved by different people who are not necessarily facing the consequences of action or inaction.

However, in the case of Macedonia, I believe the argument for any sort of "Diaspora" intervention is not as strong. Many may not like the results of Albanianization, the name issue, the "lack of progress", or the attitude and mentalities of Macedonians with regards to their real problems, the Diaspora's perception of problems, and their own perceived problems. Yet, as citizens and permanent residents of other countries, we are removed from the majority of the consequences and benefits that will result over there. We are better off tending to our own communities' concerns and serving as examples of how to generate citizen movements or initiatives to address our own woes.

The control of their society and democracy should be their control; and if we perceive that they are not in control, the reality is that they are in control of whether or not they want to control, or attempt to control their democracy. The same applies to us in our own communities.
 
Referring back to the original post, aside from painting all Macedonians as FYROMIANS, I don't think the observations were that far from the truth for a significant portion (if not majority) of RoMacedonians.

Gocka said:
if a large majority were as you describe then guess what, Macedonia would be in a totally different situation then it is now. If everyone wanted to defend Macedonia the Albanians wouldn't be taking over. The reality is that Macedonia is not some twilight zone, the countries is and functions as the majority wish it too.
Hard to dispute.

Why is this thread so confrontational? I would think all of us Macedonians in the Diaspora are disappointed the Macedonians in RoMacedonia have not asserted their rights in a fashion we would have hoped for.
 
Referring back to the original post, aside from painting all Macedonians as FYROMIANS, I don't think the observations were that far from the truth for a significant portion (if not majority) of RoMacedonians.

Hard to dispute.

Why is this thread so confrontational? I would think all of us Macedonians in the Diaspora are disappointed the Macedonians in RoMacedonia have not asserted their rights in a fashion we would have hoped for.

The problem is the perceived arrogance that the Macedonians would view us in the diaspora as having, when making these observations, whether those observations are right or wrong it doesn't matter, it's the delivery of the message that's critical and decisive.

If you're to win over the 'hearts and minds' of the Macedonians in the Republic, as is the critical 'battle' in any 'war' that's to be waged, you must ensure the message isn't tainted from the outset.

Imagine you're a Macedonian doing it pretty hard in the Republic, the last thing you'd want to hear from the diaspora is that you're just not working as hard as poor Gocka or Viktor, when he can be dragged away from his piano lessons.

Also, the perceived arrogance of the diaspora can be taken another step further in the cases of Mr Gocka and Mr Viktor...now here's 2 blokes banging on about the impotence of the Macedonians in confronting issues of state and human rights but their own government has an endemic spying program of every one of its (and the Western worlds) citizens, as well as being involved in countless actions of war for half a century without barely a fart of protest other than a few chicken scratchings on an Internet forum.
 
Well thought out and well written. I agree with almost everything. I suppose the only thing I do not agree with is that we as a diaspora should have no direct influence on Macedonian affairs. I think we have been blessed to grow up, be educated, and live in such diverse and relatively safe and stable countries. This has allowed us to see issues from a different perspective, it has allowed us to analyze Macedonian matter without a fear or bias that might have if we lived in Macedonia. Is it better? I think so, you cant always see things from one perspective and expect to know what is best for everyone. In my opinion when more Macedonians from the diaspora move to Macedonia, and a larger intermingling of ideas and attitudes happens, maybe, just maybe then we can all come to a common middle ground and move Macedonia forward. Until then I'm afraid we are too disconnected to be any good to each other. Let me also take this chance to criticize all of us, we too can not claim to know absolutely everything about internal Macedonian affairs and everyday life. I've lived there for 6 months at a time, 4 times in my life, then the occasional vacation, 2-3 months 4 more times. Combined that amounts to at most 3 years, only three years of my entire life. So, everything considered, it doesn't mean we should stop all criticism, we should not stop trying to have influence, because there are things that we know better, but I suppose we also cant get too angry either because there are probably a lot of things we dont truly understand, kind of like how people from RM dont know that life in the USA or Australia, is not all milk and honey, that there are a lot of difficult aspects of life here as well. Sekoj so svoja tezina taka?

My sad realization is, ROM Macedonians dont want what I thought they wanted, generally speaking of course, life, politics, culture. I had an idealized picture and more and more I see that certain things that I find very important like personal identity, personal progression (self improvement), goals and motivations in life, providing for your family and kids, stability, etc: Maybe some of these things are not that important to a lot of people in Macedonia at this time. What i see a lot of is, people worshiping money, status, gossip, sex, even drugs are on the up, along with adultery. They are starting to resemble a real life version of sex and the city.


From my minimal first-hand and second-hand accounts, I think a more dominant attitude in Macedonia and among Macedonians (and not just Macedonians in Macedonia) than I have experienced in America and among Americans is that they have no control over what happens around them. They accept that the system is corrupt, that liars, cheaters and self-serving scum prevail, and will always prevail. Here, in America, I see more of a disillusioned sense that good, right and hope are prevailing and will prevail, and that only the individual has complete control of his destiny. Yet, even this is fading.

In essence, I find that the Macedonians are a little less optimistic about the future and have a little less faith and trust in society-at-large and their institutions. On the flip side, they tend to value, and make time for, personal and community relationships. In many areas, the village is (or recently was) the focus. In America, it tends to be entertainment, work, or the self.

I think, however, that as citizens of Macedonia, they have every right not to be subjected to having exterior influences decide their course(s). What is right and beneficial, in the Diaspora's eyes, for Macedonia and the Macedonian citizens does not necessarily correlate with the conclusions they draw from their perceptions of their society. They face the consequences and reap the benefits. They are directly, and wholly, affected by anything that involves Macedonia. We in the Diaspora are only partly affected, and only in some instances directly affected.

How and to what extent outside forces meddle and influence their democratic duties, responsibilities and choices, can diminish the value and benefits of whatever it is they create for themselves. Yes, the whole world has become a battlefield for peoples of one place promoting and advancing interests in another place of which that they are not a citizen: from human rights organizations, NGOs, corporations, governmental agencies, banks, and the likes. Sometimes places and people request these outsiders. However, it's a conflicting mess when some want it, some don't, and some don't care. Beyond that, just because it has become common (and probably never will fade away in a world where communication and transportation finding new ways to make us interconnected), it doesn't make it effective or right.

And arguments have also been made for the necessity of outside influence in other places: weak pollution regulations in developing countries effects global health; internal and regional wars can have a domino effect; human rights abuses are despicable regardless of race or citizenship; and so on. In the end, we may believe we are doing good, or the right thing; then again, this sort of globalization may actually be hampering local and regional peoples from exerting their own direct control of democracies because so many interests are involved by different people who are not necessarily facing the consequences of action or inaction.

However, in the case of Macedonia, I believe the argument for any sort of "Diaspora" intervention is not as strong. Many may not like the results of Albanianization, the name issue, the "lack of progress", or the attitude and mentalities of Macedonians with regards to their real problems, the Diaspora's perception of problems, and their own perceived problems. Yet, as citizens and permanent residents of other countries, we are removed from the majority of the consequences and benefits that will result over there. We are better off tending to our own communities' concerns and serving as examples of how to generate citizen movements or initiatives to address our own woes.

The control of their society and democracy should be their control; and if we perceive that they are not in control, the reality is that they are in control of whether or not they want to control, or attempt to control their democracy. The same applies to us in our own communities.


From my minimal first-hand and second-hand accounts, I think a more dominant attitude in Macedonia and among Macedonians (and not just Macedonians in Macedonia) than I have experienced in America and among Americans is that they have no control over what happens around them. They accept that the system is corrupt, that liars, cheaters and self-serving scum prevail, and will always prevail. Here, in America, I see more of a disillusioned sense that good, right and hope are prevailing and will prevail, and that only the individual has complete control of his destiny. Yet, even this is fading.

In essence, I find that the Macedonians are a little less optimistic about the future and have a little less faith and trust in society-at-large and their institutions. On the flip side, they tend to value, and make time for, personal and community relationships. In many areas, the village is (or recently was) the focus. In America, it tends to be entertainment, work, or the self.

I think, however, that as citizens of Macedonia, they have every right not to be subjected to having exterior influences decide their course(s). What is right and beneficial, in the Diaspora's eyes, for Macedonia and the Macedonian citizens does not necessarily correlate with the conclusions they draw from their perceptions of their society. They face the consequences and reap the benefits. They are directly, and wholly, affected by anything that involves Macedonia. We in the Diaspora are only partly affected, and only in some instances directly affected.

How and to what extent outside forces meddle and influence their democratic duties, responsibilities and choices, can diminish the value and benefits of whatever it is they create for themselves. Yes, the whole world has become a battlefield for peoples of one place promoting and advancing interests in another place of which that they are not a citizen: from human rights organizations, NGOs, corporations, governmental agencies, banks, and the likes. Sometimes places and people request these outsiders. However, it's a conflicting mess when some want it, some don't, and some don't care. Beyond that, just because it has become common (and probably never will fade away in a world where communication and transportation finding new ways to make us interconnected), it doesn't make it effective or right.

And arguments have also been made for the necessity of outside influence in other places: weak pollution regulations in developing countries effects global health; internal and regional wars can have a domino effect; human rights abuses are despicable regardless of race or citizenship; and so on. In the end, we may believe we are doing good, or the right thing; then again, this sort of globalization may actually be hampering local and regional peoples from exerting their own direct control of democracies because so many interests are involved by different people who are not necessarily facing the consequences of action or inaction.

However, in the case of Macedonia, I believe the argument for any sort of "Diaspora" intervention is not as strong. Many may not like the results of Albanianization, the name issue, the "lack of progress", or the attitude and mentalities of Macedonians with regards to their real problems, the Diaspora's perception of problems, and their own perceived problems. Yet, as citizens and permanent residents of other countries, we are removed from the majority of the consequences and benefits that will result over there. We are better off tending to our own communities' concerns and serving as examples of how to generate citizen movements or initiatives to address our own woes.

The control of their society and democracy should be their control; and if we perceive that they are not in control, the reality is that they are in control of whether or not they want to control, or attempt to control their democracy. The same applies to us in our own communities.
 
Back
Top