• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

An observation...

kompir

New member
I've been reading a lot of the threads in the Politics section and I've come to a realisation. And it is as follows.

The Balkan region is far too preoccupied with petty, trivial politics and as a region, is ignoring (at its peril) the politics of far greater import. I consider the role private banking plays in the economies of all of the countries on the Balkan peninsula as far more important politically as the consequences of the actions of private banks are far more devastating than any ethnically driven political table thumping.

Think about what has happened in Macedonia since the nation became "sovereign":

- Private debt levels have skyrocketed, moreso in the formative years of the nation, but actully accelerated in the early years of the 21st century. I attribute this to far more readily available access to credit (cheap or otherwise) than pre-nationhood.
- Unemployment has not declined as a percentage of the population since attaining statehood.
- Wages have not increased in line with inflation.
- Foreign interests are having a far greater say in the affairs of the country than ever before.
- Corruption is as rife today as it ever has been, despite the token efforts of the government to eradicate it.

All of this has happened on the watch of either political "team". Much like here in Australia with the Labor and Liberal parties, I put it to the forum that ultimately, there are no differences between SDSM and the current incarnation of VMRO. I also put it to the forum that they are but the two sides of the same political coin.

The name issue with the Greeks, the threat posed by Albanian extremists and their expansionist modus operandi are but distractions designed to keep the attention off the real issues the nation has. For when you ask Klime ribarot what concerns him the most, he'll tell you that losing sleep at night as he ponders where the next meal will come from is at the top of his list of priorities.

And yes, a large percentage of the population is in that predicament.

Ultimately, I contend that the real power (political and otherwise) lies with an entity that transcends the various governments of the Balkans.

Discuss.
 
Last edited:
I think that applies to the majority of the world's countries, not just the Balkan nations. Private financial interests have for centuries paved the way for wars, suffering and poverty. It's a struggle that transcends countries and regions, and it's a never ending saga. The whole globe is the board and while the players change, the game doesn't. Greed, power, hatred and selfishness are traits that are not going to be bred out of the human species any time soon.

Regarding your Klime example: I do not believe the situation is that bad in Macedonia...most Macedonians are not concerned where there food is going to come from, but rather how they can compete with the rest of their countrymen and Europe and the world with the accumulation of goods and job creation...even the "poor" villagers have enough to eat.

Unfortunately there are tons of problems facing Macedonia, as well as all countries. Now, just because Macedonia shares some similar problems as other Balkan countries, and as other world countries, I don't think that warrants considering country specific problems as petty or trivial. The name issue and extremism has serious consequences for Macedonia and Macedonians.

Which issue should be a priority? I don't know. They all affect the culture, identity and livelihoods of Macedonians in different ways. I believe, however, that many of the problems can be solved, or settled, if countries, corporations and peoples respect one essential rule: self-determination...the people decide. Whether it's the building of dams in villages or the name of the country, self-determination should rule all.

And that's a problem not going away from the world any time soon. That's the fight Macedonians have against financial institutions, corporate interests, government officials, Albanian extremists, and chauvinists in Greece and Bulgaria.
 
Centuries... I was thinking more along the lines of millenia.

I was in Macedonia last year during the summer (July) and I was blown away by how much had changed since my previous visit. My Klime example was based on my most recent experience. In 2008, by and large most weren't concerned about their next meal, the agrarian nature of the country ensured that people were fed. But last year, I was hearing story after story of things being that dire that many were Klime. This wasn't just from city dwellers, this was from many through the Pelagonski sela, the breadbasket of Macedonia. So many crop failures and the cost of living skyrocketing will cause such anguish.

In that case, I would consider country-specific problems as trivial, even though on their own they are quite pressing. It is only when one looks at the big picture do they pale into relative insignificance. To elaborate further, I'll bring into the discussion Abraham Maslow. He has his detractors, but his hierarchy of needs idea has loads of merit, with much research validating the idea that humans have universal needs. Private banking and the march towards corportocracy threatens the two basest needs: physiological and safety. In the context of Maslow, I would place the name issue at the top of the pyramid as identity is a part of national self-actualization.

You mentioned self-determination. The powers-that-be have fought tooth and nail to shut it down, which they have achieved via social programming and is most evident in the West; political apathy in the US and Australia is rampant.

Hypothetical time.
We somehow have the ability to remove Greece and Bulgaria from the equation. How does Macedonia's situation improve? What do they gain from the absence of their respective table thumping and chauvinism?
 
I was in Macedonia last year during the summer (July) and I was blown away by how much had changed since my previous visit. My Klime example was based on my most recent experience. In 2008, by and large most weren't concerned about their next meal, the agrarian nature of the country ensured that people were fed. But last year, I was hearing story after story of things being that dire that many were Klime. This wasn't just from city dwellers, this was from many through the Pelagonski sela, the breadbasket of Macedonia. So many crop failures and the cost of living skyrocketing will cause such anguish.

I was there in the summer as well, and I heard a few stories like that too...but it was usually from young people who managed to have enough denari to go to the café every day/night. And if they lived in the village, they refused to work their parents' land or farms because they have a college degree and farming is not going to bring them their happiness, aka the material possessions that everyone else seems to have that they don't. I'm not saying there aren't people who have it pretty bad -- there are. But it's not really affecting their physiological requirements.

Though I do agree that it is getting worse because family and small farms are closing at record rates and people are moving to urban centers looking for work that is not there. Some of this is externally cause and some, as I alluded to earlier, is self-inflicted: Macedonians do not want the agrarian lifestyle, especially the younger generation, but they know there is hardly much work in the industrial or white collar job market, so they are putting themselves in this position to either have no work or move abroad. They'd rather have no work or move than go back to farming. Shoot, it's why so many Macedonians left the villages in the 60s and 70s. Opportunity to do something other than live off the land.


In that case, I would consider country-specific problems as trivial, even though on their own they are quite pressing. It is only when one looks at the big picture do they pale into relative insignificance. To elaborate further, I'll bring into the discussion Abraham Maslow. He has his detractors, but his hierarchy of needs idea has loads of merit, with much research validating the idea that humans have universal needs. Private banking and the march towards corportocracy threatens the two basest needs: physiological and safety. In the context of Maslow, I would place the name issue at the top of the pyramid as identity is a part of national self-actualization.

I'm not a fan of Maslow: I believe you can't really classify such needs based on a hierarchy as a lot of them are interwoven and essential parts of human nature. Still, yes, private banking and corporatization threatens Macedonians' needs and culture. But the name issue (and the consequences of changing or not changing the name) can also be a part of: love/belonging; esteem; and safety.

You mentioned self-determination. The powers-that-be have fought tooth and nail to shut it down, which they have achieved via social programming and is most evident in the West; political apathy in the US and Australia is rampant.

That's very true.

Hypothetical time.
We somehow have the ability to remove Greece and Bulgaria from the equation. How does Macedonia's situation improve? What do they gain from the absence of their respective table thumping and chauvinism.

I think our grandparents know the answer to that question: WW2 and the Greek Civil War are good places to start. If Gr and Bg are removed from the equation, Macedonians feel safer in the physical, psychological and cultural senses. They can reallocate that time and those resources against other threats to their culture and lifestyles, and to fulfilling other needs.
 
For when you ask Klime ribarot what concerns him the most, he'll tell you that losing sleep at night as he ponders where the next meal will come from is at the top of his list of priorities.

When I stated some time ago on this forum that the full bellies of my family is my top priority I was almost crucified here.
I'm glad there's someone else that sees the real consern of Macedonians in the republic.
The Macedonian "average Joe" today isn't preocupied whether it's DPMNE or SDSM in power,whether he's "FYROMian" or Macedonian,whether he's in EU and NATO or not etc. ,but as Kompir pointed out - how to provide the next meal at the table.
There are Macedonians that took DUI party membership so that they can get some well-paid government job.I can't say that I blame them,but it is really sad how far Macedonians would go these days to ensure their families existence.
For most of us Macedonians here, - nous sommes Klime.
 
Good post Kompir, however i only agree with about 90% with what you have had to say.

I agree that there is a certain 'political elite' that controls the populations in the west, the so called top 1% controlling the remaining 99%. You will find these people sitting in the USA, UK, Brussels, Berlin and to a lesser extent Paris. I also agree on your views on the 'banking system' as well.

These people have ruined the balkans and eastern europe, and are now trying to make their tentacles reach into the middle east and Africa.

Of course if you try talk about this you will be considered a nut job conspiracy theorist or 'anti-american'. I guess this goes back to your point on social conditioning.

In the past i used to look down on the old Yugoslavia and other communist european countries; but looking back now there are too many people from the former yugoslavia and also other eastern european countries such as Romania and even eastern germany that view those days as 'good times'. Maybe Capitalism worked in the past but it seems like it is spiraling out of control and eliminating the middle class....

I agree on what you said about VMRO and SDSM being two sides of the same coin. I wish both where eliminated and new (better) parties would take their place. In saying that i was old enough to remember how treacherous SDSM was so if i had to chose one party, it would be VMRO.

I also agree that people in the balkans are not looking at the 'bigger picture' and that we are mere pawns. And that things like the 'name issue' are distractions used by the greek and macedonian government.

What i dont agree on with you:
1) Our neighbours where big reasons as to why the country has gone to shit. Remember the Greek embargo in the early 90s? That pretty much put macedonia 5-10 years behind every one in the balkans and killed the economy. You could even say macedonia has never recovered from it. I put a lot of blame on the pathetic state of macedonians economy on the Greeks.
Serbia taking all of macedonia's military and leaving it defenseless? Serbia pushing close to 500 thousand shiptar refugees into macedonia which sent the country into chaos and not function properly?
The shiptars have also pretty much have made macedonia into a country that is non functional. Which western country wants to invest in a country where almost a quarter of it is self governed and could erupt into another war as well?

I agree the sad state of affairs in Macedonia is due to macedonian incompetence, greed, corruption and short sightedness - but you have to be fair and realize our neighbors have contributed to a lot of this.


2) I think its bit of a stretch people in macedonia are close to starvation and are close to having nothing to eat. A lot of macedonians on my facebook still go to Ohrid every summer. A lot even still go to greece, albania, Montenegro etc as well. Most older people always complain that young people just go to bars to drink and smoke every night.
The situation in macedonia in my opinion is that its not where the next meal is going to come from but that there is no real career progress in macedonia, or will be paycheck be delayed for another month again.

I also believe macedonia is a much better position then countries like albanian, kosovo, bosnia, Ukraine, Moldova and on the same level as Serbia. Remember we dont have people fleeing the country in great numbers like in kosovo. And we have macedonian men going to Albania or Ukraine to marry desperate women wanting to get out - we dont have the same situation with macedonian women.
 
...there are too many people from the former yugoslavia and also other eastern european countries such as Romania and even eastern germany that view those days as 'good times'. Maybe Capitalism worked in the past but it seems like it is spiraling out of control and eliminating the middle class.....
Couldn't agree more.

1) Our neighbours where big reasons as to why the country has gone to shit. Remember the Greek embargo in the early 90s? That pretty much put macedonia 5-10 years behind every one in the balkans and killed the economy. You could even say macedonia has never recovered from it. I put a lot of blame on the pathetic state of macedonians economy on the Greeks.
Serbia taking all of macedonia's military and leaving it defenseless? Serbia pushing close to 500 thousand shiptar refugees into macedonia which sent the country into chaos and not function properly?
The shiptars have also pretty much have made macedonia into a country that is non functional. Which western country wants to invest in a country where almost a quarter of it is self governed and could erupt into another war as well?

I agree the sad state of affairs in Macedonia is due to macedonian incompetence, greed, corruption and short sightedness - but you have to be fair and realize our neighbors have contributed to a lot of this.
Also correct.


2) I think its bit of a stretch people in macedonia are close to starvation and are close to having nothing to eat. A lot of macedonians on my facebook still go to Ohrid every summer. A lot even still go to greece, albania, Montenegro etc as well. Most older people always complain that young people just go to bars to drink and smoke every night.
The situation in macedonia in my opinion is that its not where the next meal is going to come from but that there is no real career progress in macedonia, or will be paycheck be delayed for another month again
To help the diaspora members understand life in Macedonia,here are the results of the latest research regarding the economic situation of Macedonian citizens:
http://kanal77.com.mk/mk/vesti/makedonija/item/13186-shtip-i-kochani-so-najgolema-nevrabotenost.html#

Or to cut things shorts,I'll highlight the most important points
(Google translated,for those that don't speak Macedonian):
28.6% of the population in the country lives in poverty

46% of the population are unemployed and poor

31% of children aged 0 to 17 years are poor

32,000 denars is syndication cart (minimum necessary means for a decent life

a 4-membered family)

21.500 denars is the average salary in the Republic of Macedonia

71% of employees in Macedonia receive below average salary

29% of employees in Macedonia receive a salary of 8,000 to 12,000 denars

82.5% of the total number of unemployed in Macedonia are long-term unemployed (waiting for a job for more than 4 years)

51.7% of the young are unemployed

I think that about says enough.
 
Last edited:
Dragan:

Yes, the economic conditions are pretty bad. But those numbers don't paint the entire picture and rather are the same thing repeated over and over again (Macedonians don't have "work" (it doesn't mean they don't have land to work on) and Macedonians don't make a lot of money compared to other Europeans. But the people aren't starving; there's not a poverty akin to the slums of certain Asian, African and South American cities (eg. Macedonians aren't selling their kidneys to the black market by the thousands just so they can get food on the table). And Macedonians are happy. At least consider this: Macedonian kids are the happiest in the world.

Macedonian children - the happiest in the world

September 03rd 2014

The children in the tiny southern European country of Macedonia are the happiest in the world, whereas those in the United States and Turkey are the saddest. This rating is based on a new report by the Britain-based Children's Society organization. The "Good Childhood Report," published last week, is based on a ranking of the feelings of happiness and satisfaction of some 50,000 children in 39 countries.

http://www.i24news.tv/en/news/international/42412-140903-macedonian-children-the-happiest-in-the-world


America is so "rich", yet so unhappy. Macedonia is so "poor", yet so happy. So no, I don't think those numbers say "enough" about the conditions in Macedonia. If you're curious, the kids in the above survey were asked about the following: family and home life, money and/or belongings, health, friends, appearance, school. Out of all those things, they felt happier than all other children surveyed. Not such a gloomy picture of Macedonia, is it?
 
Dragan:

Yes, the economic conditions are pretty bad. But those numbers don't paint the entire picture and rather are the same thing repeated over and over again (Macedonians don't have "work" (it doesn't mean they don't have land to work on) and Macedonians don't make a lot of money compared to other Europeans. But the people aren't starving; there's not a poverty akin to the slums of certain Asian, African and South American cities (eg. Macedonians aren't selling their kidneys to the black market by the thousands just so they can get food on the table). And Macedonians are happy. At least consider this: Macedonian kids are the happiest in the world.



http://www.i24news.tv/en/news/international/42412-140903-macedonian-children-the-happiest-in-the-world


America is so "rich", yet so unhappy. Macedonia is so "poor", yet so happy. So no, I don't think those numbers say "enough" about the conditions in Macedonia. If you're curious, the kids in the above survey were asked about the following: family and home life, money and/or belongings, health, friends, appearance, school. Out of all those things, they felt happier than all other children surveyed. Not such a gloomy picture of Macedonia, is it?

I think the Macedonian people deserve a better leadership, regardless of which party is in power, they deserve higher levels of employee rights and consumer and legal protection...the living standards of most Macedonians is far too low for a country that has good demographics and big potential.

It's not good enough that Gruevski's team continues to broadcast it's 'successful' investment programs and the creation of new jobs when the norm is still that many workers go unpaid for months on end. Or that nepotism, bribery and party affiliations remain a persons only qualifications toward gainful employment.

Macedonia needs a 21st century mindset but it's leadership has been mired by Ottoman era culture and self serving.

In regards to the happiness of young children, sadly they quickly grow up and that happiness is just as quickly extinguished.
 
I do believe that happiness would extinguish pretty fast; they should do a graph with 15-20, 25-30 etc... where it would most likely be next to or worse than America.

Then again, the majority of students are travelling to different countries to pursue university degree's and work so that would not longer be categorized as Macedonia.
 
I think the Macedonian people deserve a better leadership, regardless of which party is in power, they deserve higher levels of employee rights and consumer and legal protection...the living standards of most Macedonians is far too low for a country that has good demographics

That's true.

the living standards of most Macedonians is far too low for a country that has good demographics and big potential.

Potential for what?

It's not good enough that Gruevski's team continues to broadcast it's 'successful' investment programs and the creation of new jobs when the norm is still that many workers go unpaid for months on end. Or that nepotism, bribery and party affiliations remain a persons only qualifications toward gainful employment.

No, it's not. And when the people want to stand up and take away his power, they will. But they keep on voting him and VMRO into office.

In regards to the happiness of young children, sadly they quickly grow up and that happiness is just as quickly extinguished.

What do you mean?
 
Last edited:
I do believe that happiness would extinguish pretty fast; they should do a graph with 15-20, 25-30 etc... where it would most likely be next to or worse than America.

What, do you think Americans' happiness is increasing as they get older? It's probably downhill for everyone across the board until retirement, in which case, still, probably at least half the seniors in the US are on a variety of meds, in a nursing home, or spend the whole day watching TV, whereas Macedonian seniors are active, have social circles, and have people taking care of them that love them.

Quality of life in Macedonia, in my opinion, outweighs the quality of life in the US. Economic opportunities in the US far outweigh those in Macedonia.

But I think my original point is this: Macedonians aren't starving, and most Macedonians, probably nearly all Macedonians, are not really worried about where their next meal will come from.
 
What, do you think Americans' happiness is increasing as they get older? It's probably downhill for everyone across the board until retirement, in which case, still, probably at least half the seniors in the US are on a variety of meds, in a nursing home, or spend the whole day watching TV, whereas Macedonian seniors are active, have social circles, and have people taking care of them that love them.

Quality of life in Macedonia, in my opinion, outweighs the quality of life in the US. Economic opportunities in the US far outweigh those in Macedonia.

But I think my original point is this: Macedonians aren't starving, and most Macedonians, probably nearly all Macedonians, are not really worried about where their next meal will come from.

Nope, I said it would become parallel with America's (not implying American's become happier).
Implying they would be just as unhappy as grown up Americans or worse.

You're right they aren't starving, I feel it's more on the basis of opportunities to pursue whatever they want to do with their lives.
 
Dragan:

Yes, the economic conditions are pretty bad. But those numbers don't paint the entire picture and rather are the same thing repeated over and over again (Macedonians don't have "work" (it doesn't mean they don't have land to work on) and Macedonians don't make a lot of money compared to other Europeans. But the people aren't starving; there's not a poverty akin to the slums of certain Asian, African and South American cities (eg. Macedonians aren't selling their kidneys to the black market by the thousands just so they can get food on the table). And Macedonians are happy. At least consider this: Macedonian kids are the happiest in the world.

I can't believe you actually wrote the above segment.

Yes,Macedonians HAVE work,and do you know what they work and how much (and how often) do they get paid for that work?
For Christ's sake just look at the stats man,71% of employees earn less than the average paycheck (21500 denars equals 350 EUR,392 USD or 500 AUD depending on the currency you use),while the minimum means for a decent life are 32000 denars (520 EUR,583 USD or 750 AUD,take your pick).Meaning,all those people can barely make their ends meet every month and you're telling me macedonians are happy?!Are you listening to yourself?
Add to that,almost a third of the employed people earn between 8000 and 12000 denars (130 to 200 EUR).In a 21st century European country all these stats are devastating by every standard.

And you're saying a country isn't poor until the population starts selling their kidneys to survive?Is that the red line that defines poverty?Not last time I checked.

Also,you take the kid's happiness as a reference to the general population's happiness?Good luck with that.
Does the survey say how many kids were included in it?
Kid's biggest consern is whether he'll be on time for his favorite cartoon or whether his friend will have a better toy than him.And that's it.Phoenix and Nikolaj made some valid points about this.

Now,I haven't lived abroad and thus I can't say how good/bad it is there,but I live in Macedonia my whole life and i think I can give you a pretty good picture of how hard life here is from first hand.
And believe me,it isn't like what you present it to be at all.

... at least half the seniors in the US are on a variety of meds, in a nursing home, or spend the whole day watching TV, whereas Macedonian seniors are active, have social circles, and have people taking care of them that love them.

Quality of life in Macedonia, in my opinion, outweighs the quality of life in the US.

Half the seniors in the US can afford cruising in the Bahamas with their pensions too (trust me,I worked on a cruise ship and nearly 70% of all the passangers were old people),while in Macedonia they can hardly afford anything with it.
And as meds are conserned - old people here use a variety of meds as well,my grandparents spent a lot of money on pills.It's common everywhere in the world when it comes to old people.
As for your last sentence - in my opinion no,it doesn't.
 
Last edited:
In the past i used to look down on the old Yugoslavia and other communist european countries; but looking back now there are too many people from the former yugoslavia and also other eastern european countries such as Romania and even eastern germany that view those days as 'good times'. Maybe Capitalism worked in the past but it seems like it is spiraling out of control and eliminating the middle class....

My two cents is that the "capitalism" in the Balkans (and the world in general) is not really pure capitalism, but crony capitalism.

When you mix crony capitalism with Balkan politics, you have deep poverty and corruption.

The rich get richer, the poor get poorer, and the middle class disappears.

Some Macedonians long for the old Tito days, and this number is probably growing by the day.

Socialism and communism are pretty ingrained in the Balkans, including Greece.
 
Now,I haven't lived abroad and thus I can't say how good/bad it is there,but I live in Macedonia my whole life and i think I can give you a pretty good picture of how hard life here is from first hand.
And believe me,it isn't like what you present it to be at all.


How did I present it? People aren't starving, kids are happy, and the quality of life is good.

Sure, life is hard. It's hard everywhere. When I went to Macedonia last summer, the cafes and beaches were packed with 20-30 year olds all day and all night. I asked so many about working conditions: there's no jobs. What can you do about it? "Wait until the government makes more jobs." Default: blame the government. Most the unemployed village youth refuse to work the fields and their parents land but still go out nearly every day and night. "There are no jobs for me." Yes, same thing in the US. 70% of Americans are unhappy or depressed with the jobs they do and aren't working in their field. My uncle who lives in Resen was explaining to me why you only see the Roma sweeping the streets: because Macedonians are too "embarrassed" to take jobs like that...it's beneath them. So they'd rather be out of work than be looked at as a street-sweeper. That doesn't seem like a hard life to me. I sympathize with those who work hard and are struggling. I don't sympathize with those who mope around all day complaining and waiting for other people to mend their woes while not taking initiative to improve their conditions. It goes for Macedonians and Americans and everyone.

And you're saying a country isn't poor until the population starts selling their kidneys to survive?Is that the red line that defines poverty?Not last time I checked.

No, I'm not saying that. I'm saying they probably are not worried about where their next meal is coming from until they start selling their kidneys.

Kid's biggest consern is whether he'll be on time for his favorite cartoon or whether his friend will have a better toy than him.

That's not true. If it was, then America's kids would be the happiest because they can watch any cartoon at any time, and definitely have better and more toys than everyone else in the world.

For Christ's sake just look at the stats man,71% of employees earn less than the average paycheck (21500 denars equals 350 EUR,392 USD or 500 AUD depending on the currency you use),while the minimum means for a decent life are 32000 denars (520 EUR,583 USD or 750 AUD,take your pick).Meaning,all those people can barely make their ends meet every month and you're telling me macedonians are happy?!Are you listening to yourself?

Let me give you some statistics. 66% of Americans earn less than the average pay check (which is pretty close to Macedonia's 71%). 15% of Americans are on food stamps (meaning, they need the government to give them money to buy food). 6% of Americans actually don't know if they will have enough food for them or their kids next week. 20% of American children are living in poverty. Over half of the unemployed (combined long term and short term) in US are between 18 and 35 are Sure, the US salary is much higher but it's all relative to the cost of living. These statistics are (un)surprisingly pretty close to the statistics you gave about Macedonia, with a little more about Americans and food security. Or as an article says, despite 20% of Macedonians living in destitute poverty, "Food security and poor nutrition are not direct development issues in the country." I guess my question is: what makes someone poor -- the lack of dollars in their pockets or the lack of food in their belly?

http://www.zakat.org/country/macedonia/

http://www.mybudget360.com/how-much-do-americans-earn-what-is-the-average-us-income/

http://www.feedingamerica.org/hunger-in-america/impact-of-hunger/hunger-and-poverty/hunger-and-poverty-fact-sheet.html

http://www.theguardian.com/money/us-money-blog/2014/mar/27/us-long-term-unemployed-ghosts-economy-jobs

I didn't say Macedonians are happy because they're poor. I didn't equate the two. I'm saying that despite their poverty, most Macedonians have a better quality of life than most Americans. And it's quite obvious I'm not basing quality of life on the number of dollars in your pockets or the amount of "goods" the people consume.
 
How did I present it? People aren't starving, kids are happy, and the quality of life is good.
A kid will be happy if you buy him a chocolate too,or a candy,a toy...There are numerous ways of making kids happy,and their definition of happiness is not a reference for the general population's happiness.

My uncle who lives in Resen was explaining to me why you only see the Roma sweeping the streets: because Macedonians are too "embarrassed" to take jobs like that...it's beneath them. So they'd rather be out of work than be looked at as a street-sweeper.
That is an overstatement.There are people with a great ego that wouldn't work anything "beneath" them everywhere in the world ,not just Macedonia.However,most Macedonians here would work anything to provide food to the table.
My father has a degree in agriculture,he spent 20+ years working as a chief technologist in production of alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages.Then transition struck and most people lost their jobs including him.
My parents ,my sister and me were left to live off my mother's textile worker's salary.My dad struggled to find a job matching his qualifications and when he saw he had no choice he had to do whatever he could find.
He's now a "maintenance-man" at a local green park and he earns 100 euros a month.An agronomist engineer, earns even less then the Roma your uncle mentioned.

At one stage,when my wife quit her job so she could take care of our sick baby and I got somehow stuck in between jobs,we used to "wrinkle" (карширање is the macedonian word for the process,wrinkling is the closest word I could find to describe it) men's shirts at home in order to make it through the month.It's a process that takes 2 people to do,so both of us had to work together and we ended up earning just some 300 eur (both of us together,not each) per month.And I was never ashamed of that.

No, I'm not saying that. I'm saying they probably are not worried about where their next meal is coming from until they start selling their kidneys.
Uh...which is basically the same thing,but OK.

Let me give you some statistics. 66% of Americans earn less than the average pay check (which is pretty close to Macedonia's 71%). 15% of Americans are on food stamps (meaning, they need the government to give them money to buy food). 6% of Americans actually don't know if they will have enough food for them or their kids next week. 20% of American children are living in poverty. Over half of the unemployed (combined long term and short term) in US are between 18 and 35 are

If all of the above is true,then why are people from all over the world moving in the US for a better life instead of being the other way around?


I'm saying that despite their poverty, most Macedonians have a better quality of life than most Americans.
Again,101% of Macedonians disagree with that.

Like I said,I can't comment on how good/bad life is abroad,but please,don't tell me how life in Macedonia is.
 
Last edited:
A kid will be happy if you buy him a chocolate too,or a candy,a toy...There are numerous ways of making kids happy,and their definition of happiness is not a reference for the general population's happiness.

Sure. None of that explains why kids in America, Britain, and other European countries don't feel as happy as Macedonian children.

That is an overstatement.There are people with a great ego that wouldn't work anything "beneath" them everywhere in the world ,not just Macedonia.However,most Macedonians here would work anything to provide food to the table.

Maybe it was an overstatement. But so is the statement that the number one thing on most Macedonians' minds is where their next meal is going to come from. Maybe that's more of an overstatement.


My father has a degree in agriculture,he spent 20+ years working as a chief technologist in production of alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages.Then transition struck and most people lost their jobs including him.
My parents ,my sister and me were left to live off my mother's textile worker's salary.My dad struggled to find a job matching his qualifications and when he saw he had no choice he had to do whatever he could find.
He's now a "maintenance-man" at a local green park and he earns 100 euros a month.An agronomist engineer, earns even less then the Roma your uncle mentioned.

At one stage,when my wife quit her job so she could take care of our sick baby and I got somehow stuck in between jobs,we used to "wrinkle" (карширање is the macedonian word for the process,wrinkling is the closest word I could find to describe it) men's shirts at home in order to make it through the month.It's a process that takes 2 people to do,so both of us had to work together and we ended up earning just some 300 eur (both of us together,not each) per month.And I was never ashamed of that.

That sucks, it really does -- it must be hard. I hope your baby is doing better.

If all of the above is true,then why are people from all over the world moving in the US for a better life instead of being the other way around?

Jobs and opportunities that have to do with other than working the land or farming. I asked my parents, my uncles, and a whole bunch of people who left the villages in the 60s and 70s: why did you leave? "Jobs." Why didn't you want stay on the village and work the land? "We could have, but we wanted more than that life could offer us." Essentially, people come to America for several reasons, but one is because they want more of something. Sometimes that's freedoms, sometimes that's money, sometimes it's both.

Another reason people come here is misconception: that more jobs and money will lead to better quality of life and happiness. Do you consider two-thirds of the population being overweight and one-third obese as a quality of life? Is that the future you want for you kids? Do you consider having to pay between $10,000 and $30,000 US a year for your students' college education (depending on the type of quality you want your kids to get) a quality education deal? That means that your typical mom and dad have to work 2-3 years to pay for one child's education. So they don't...many kids take out tens of thousands in loans or don't go to college. (Actually, 40% don't get a college degree).

How about the world's highest imprisonment rate? Or the fact that every EU country has a lower homicide rate (and the US's is 3 times higher than Macedonia's)? Or that the US suicide rate is 3 times as high as Macedonia's? Or that 10% of Americans are clinically depressed? Or that the divorce rate for first time married US couples is 45%? Or that the US has the 6th highest cancer rate whereas Macedonia the 40th? Or that the depression rate is twice as high in the US? Or that out of the EU, Canada, Australia, and NZ, US health care ranked last even though we spend the most money on health care? We're also in the bottom 10% of countries when it comes to infant mortality rates, and 50th in life expectancy! 10% of our population has diabetes, which is surely the same as Macedonia, but the autism rate in the US is now at 1 in 68. There are only four countries in the world that don't mandate paid leave for new mothers, and one of them is the US.

As far as number of US seniors taking these exotic cruises and freely traveling to foreign countries: only 1/3 of Americans have passports...or, only 5% of Americans travel to somewhere other than Canada or Mexico each year, and more than 50% of Americans haven't even been to Canada or Mexico. Both car thefts and fast food sales as percentage of a population are the highest in the world -- I don't know how they are related, but they both suck. Americans watch, on average, over 30 hours of television a week. That's over 4 hours a day. Sleep, work, eat, watch TV, repeat. We also are number one for teen pregnancy, woo! And school shootings. And child abuse death rate. No other country has a higher prescription drug rates than us, or mental disorder rates. Or superficial plastic surgery rates, eating disorder deaths, most time stuck in traffic, and the most laws!

Or let's put things in an economic perspective: the average American spends one-fourth of his income on food and heat. One-third of Americans can't afford their mortgage (home) payments. Our credit-card debt is 8 times larger than it was 30 years ago. Americans owe $1 trillion on student loans. Add to that that about 50% of college graduates under 25 are unemployed (good luck paying back those loans). 75% of Americans live "paycheck to paycheck". 3% of Americans own 97% of the wealth. Interestingly, or not, out of the "developed" nations, the US has the 3rd worst poverty rate. 60% of all Americans who declare bankruptcy do so because they can't afford medical costs. Combine that with my previous post of the number of Americans in poverty and on food stamps.

God bless the USA for being so fantastically rich.

You might not have had an idea of what life is like in the US, but now you are getting a better picture. You maybe can get past the picture that things are so dandy here: people put on such a show, "look at my clothes, look at my house, look at my cars, look at my degrees." Just as with anywhere in the world, in Macedonia, or the US: if you've got it made, you've got it made. If you don't, you don't.

So maybe they come here because they are disillusioned what life will be like. And maybe we should stop primarily basing quality of life, for entire societies, solely or primarily on how much money we have.

One thing I can guarantee you for sure: there are, as a percentage of the total population, more Americans going hungry right now than Macedonians. All this is said not to trivialize Macedonia's economic situation. I get it -- it sucks. Life is hard. But it's not easy for most people around the world, and that's not going to change any time soon.

Edit: Check this out, latest CNN article on poverty in the US. In one of the richest areas in the US, 1 in 3 children face hunger. Not much different in Macedonia, or worse?

http://www.cnn.com/interactive/2015/03/opinion/ctl-child-poverty/
 
Last edited:
Interesting input Dragan. It is fairly consistent to the information I have access to.

So what are your thoughts on how to reverse the economic woes in the country?

Do you believe it should be a bottom up movement? A top down? Should the people wait for government?

Is government the problem?

If so, what is the solution?

What are your thoughts?
 
Dragan and Vic.
Both of you have such compelling arguments. You almost made my lunch taste bad. Then I realised I should be happy I have my lunch.

I tend to think that most Macedonians in Macedonia would be extremely enthusiastic about the prospects for prosperity in a country like USA. This observation helps me conclude that Macedonians are indeed worse off because they simply have no hope.

I would be curious to know how recent migrants from Macedonia to USA have fared. Vic, can you comment on this? Most of the Macedonians who have come to Australia probably punch above their weight with respect to their demonstrated savings/earnings.

Macedonia will never be a USA or Australia or Germany. It will be another Balkan country with "issues". However, it can be wrapped up into a cute little tourist destination. The NY Times rated it a top 10 destination to visit here:
http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/01/11/travel/52-places-to-go-in-2015.html?_r=0

Of course, waiters and management would have to learn to be more enthusiastic and proactive. My memories of classy establishments in Macedonia are where they treat you as though you are comrade Tito reincarnate. I would much prefer really friendly, accommodating and anticipating staff.

Until there is resolution to the ethnic tension in Macedonia and no more nepotism and jobs for the boys, it will never really be a magnet to industry. It is a shame. I have a (real) Hugo Boss shirt that was manufactured in Macedonia that I am proud to wear. Things can be made there to a high level of quality. I was seriously putting together a business initiative for something of significance to the country a few years ago. But the whole country is fickle and inconsistent. It simply is not a place for the average investor.
 
Back
Top