• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Chentovist the Slav

I don't think the thread title is fair.

Anyone should be able to declare whatever they feel closest to.
If this bloke defines himself as a faceless "Slav", so be it.
A more accurate title in my opinion would be -

'Chentovist the Slave'
 
OK guys I see where this is going. No point in continuing. You have opened a thread to slander me. Good on you. You guys are great at hating on other Macedonians. How bout you take on some greeks, serbs, shiptars or bulgars?

Since I cannot delete my account here, please ban me.

Now go and pray to Zeus or Heracles or whoever the fcuk you ancient Macedonians prey to. Not sure what language you use though, since Macedonian is a Slavic language and wouldn't be understood by any of the ancient Macedonians.

Centovist
Do you have any evidence to back this up with:
since Macedonian is a Slavic language and wouldn't be understood by any of the ancient Macedonians.
Or is this merely an ASSUmption on your behalf? :asshole:
 
[...]
Yeh, obviously very limited and you hang your hat on chentovist is 1 and 2 Bill Nicholov who created that link you posted as being gospel.

I noticed this same quote on 'professional's post in the Ilirian forum and in the second link you posted....

Which was created by Bill Nicholov (whoever the f... He is)

"Today's Macedonians know who they are. They trace their name to the empire of Alexander the Great in the fourth century B.C. They trace their ethnicity to the Slavs...and their faith to the Byzantine Empire that brought them into the Eastern Orthodox Church." 2


I don't believe in coincidences, but I do believe stooges always trip up and give themselves away. I Guess you are the 'commanding moderator 'professional'. ffs this name is ridiculous, you must be such a wanker.
Which was created by Bill Nicholov (whoever the f... He is)
Bill Nicholov, like many of the Macedonian DIASPORA "intelligentsia" who took (probably still take) their cue from the MK (and previously the YuoSLAV) establishment was really just promoting (and obviously supporting) the Gligorov ideological line here. It is a shame because Bill Nicholov is a long-time, hard-working and dedicated Macedonian Human Rights activists who is still the President of MHRMI, a group that many on MTO seem to politically align with.

MHRMI Executive
President: Bill Nicholov
Vice-President: Luby Vidinovski
Secretary: Mark Opashinov
Treasurer: Dr. Andy Plukov
http://www.mhrmi.org/about.asp



"Today's Macedonians know who they are. They trace their name to the empire of Alexander the Great in the fourth century B.C. They trace their ethnicity to the Slavs...and their faith to the Byzantine Empire that brought them into the Eastern Orthodox Church." 2
The above was taken from a 1996 (if memory serves me right) National Geographic article that more or less reflected the official RM (and old YugoSLAV) narrative about Macedonian ethno-genesis (that, sadly, continues to be current there even today) emanating from the then Gligorov (and Crvenkovski) regime and its agencies.

Lastly, IMHO, it would seem that we first and foremost have a lot of work to do in cleaning up ideological anomalies amongst the "leading" Macedonian Diaspora organisations before we start to condemn the ordinary Macedonians in the republic. :)
 
Last edited:
I don't know why Macedonian's would bother being on shiptar forums with greeks, serbs and other trash...?

"If you lie down with dogs , you will get up with fleas."
 
Last edited:
Many on this forum are already aware of my view on this issue, some have even tried to manipulate it into something else. I don't agree with the notion of a single Slavic ethnicity or the existence of a uniform culture among the nations who speak tongues that are classified as being part of the Slavic linguistic group. But to deny there are certain similarities (in varying degees based on geographic proximity), particularly where it concerns languages, is to deny the obvious. Do not be ignorant and mistake this statement as support for those who deny the historical Macedonian identity. Our origin as a people began in antiquity. But I wonder, is there a brave enough soul to provide an honest and logical explanation as to why our forefathers called our language Sloven'ski 1000 years ago?
 
I am not entirely sure of the meaning of the word slavic, I lean towards it being associated with a group of languages who may have their roots in a common place. I don't see it as being an ethnicity. If it were, the slavs would be a huge race of people who occupy majority of Europe and many Baltic states.I am not blood related to anyone from Poland, Russia et al. A few google results will show that the meaning of slav is slave.

Does the world slovenski mean slavic? I may be off the mark here but I have half a theory about the word slovenski:

The word slovenski may mean nothing to those that do not understand our language. But if we break it down it contains the word слов. Direct translation of слов is word. Therefore slovenski can mean 'the people of the word'. We are 'the people of the word'. Our language is rich in a way where single words can explain a whole sentence. E.g. the word знаме - flag, but the direct translation would be 'we know what it is'. Вода - water, direct translation is 'to lead' or 'it leads'. There are too many of these words in our language to make it a coincidence.

'People of the word' could also mean Christians. Were the Macedonians not the first Christians of Europe through Paul's conversion of Lydia?

In what context did our forefathers use the word Sloven'ski?
 
I am not entirely sure of the meaning of the word slavic, I lean towards it being associated with a group of languages who may have their roots in a common place. I don't see it as being an ethnicity. If it were, the slavs would be a huge race of people who occupy majority of Europe and many Baltic states.I am not blood related to anyone from Poland, Russia et al. A few google results will show that the meaning of slav is slave.

Does the world slovenski mean slavic? I may be off the mark here but I have half a theory about the word slovenski:

The word slovenski may mean nothing to those that do not understand our language. But if we break it down it contains the word слов. Direct translation of слов is word. Therefore slovenski can mean 'the people of the word'. We are 'the people of the word'. Our language is rich in a way where single words can explain a whole sentence. E.g. the word знаме - flag, but the direct translation would be 'we know what it is'. Вода - water, direct translation is 'to lead' or 'it leads'. There are too many of these words in our language to make it a coincidence.

'People of the word' could also mean Christians. Were the Macedonians not the first Christians of Europe through Paul's conversion of Lydia?

In what context did our forefathers use the word Sloven'ski?

I like your theory, it does hold some water.

My understanding is that people 1000 years ago did not have the understanding of race, religion, nationality, etc. As you say what does the word slovenski really mean and what did it mean to our ancestors. Did they know what slavs were and what were they to them, how did they view them and how aware were they of thier presence. How can we be a 100% sure the slovenski means what today is "slav". Alot more research needs to be done before we come to such simplistic conclusions.
 
When using a language descriptor that basically means "word" surely it has no national or ethnic connotations. I'm not even sure English was used to describe the language of the Danish/Germanic/Roman etc. tribes of England 1000 years ago.
 
I have never met a stupider reaction or response than yours momce .Settling for opinions of politicians.There are irrefutable facts & books as pointed out by TM & others on this forum that the Macedonian Language has allways existed throughout the milleniums as the macedonian language.Macedonian language is resgistered in the world codex as an identifier to the macedonian language & people.Anything else that you have added is crap.
We were under the turks for 500 years what did they say we are Macedonian not slav macedonian.What is our language Macedonian not slav macedonian.Good riddanceto an idiot who doesn't know who he is or what he speaks.
Also i rember reading that in 1925 they the league of nations & greece was asked to teach the abcdar for the people the league recognized the macedonian language.You can hide & become ignorant as you are but the truth has prevailed.There is no more slavic in us than people all over the balkans.You so reradily accept & beleive the slavic smear propaganda.That's right you are regirgitating serbian.greek.bulgarian etc propaganda.:sorcerer::sorcerer::sorcerer::sorcerer:
 
Last edited:
But to deny there are certain similarities (in varying degees based on geographic proximity), particularly where it concerns languages, is to deny the obvious.
I don't think anyone serious would deny that similarities exist (to varying degrees) within this linguistic group (as languages in other linguistic groups also have similarities) but how they came about and what the designation/label/name of that linguist group is (or should be) could be contested.

Do not be ignorant and mistake this statement as support for those who deny the historical Macedonian identity.
But I wonder how helpful it is in the practical defence of the Macedonian identity and MACEDONIAN LAND to use such terminology?

Our origin as a people began in antiquity.
In what way? Gligorov (and the Slavists) also say/s that we (as "Slav settlers") "borrowed" the name from the land that was called Macedonia.

Secondly, what antiquity are we talking about, Macedonian or "Slav" ("Pripet marshes") antiquity? :) I think you mean Macedonian antiquity but your statement is not clear enough to make that obvious.

But I wonder, is there a brave enough soul to provide an honest and logical explanation as to why our forefathers called our language Sloven'ski 1000 years ago?
I am "BRAVE" enough to ask you a few questions that need clarification in what you have stated in the above paragraph.

Firstly, what do you mean by "our forefathers" and how can you trace your ancestry that far back in order to definitely (and not assumingly) say that somebody 1,000 years ago is YOUR forefather?

I have not researched my ancestry but it is likely to not be traceable past 1,800 C.E. due to lack of documented records. Also, I do know that my late Grandmother (who was born around 1900) never used "Slav" to describe anything but used rather different designation as a result of her growing up during Ottoman rule. She used terms such as "Nashi" and "Kauri" (and less often Makedonci/te) as a self-designations and definitely referred to the Bulgars as "Bugarite" (The Bulgarians), meaning as not ours ("Nashite"), i.e. those others. Thus, based on my personal experience, I can easily dismiss any claims made by anti-Macedonian propagandists that use some Krste Misirkov statements ("we used to call ourselves Bulgarians") to claim, in a similar manner to you above regarding the language name, that Macedonians (or "OUR FOREFATHERS") identified as "Bulgarians".

Secondly, as most Macedonians (and peasants in general the world over) in those years were poor and illiterate, I would doubt they (the vast majority of "our forefathers") used such designations to describe their language (or at least it would not be scientifically possible to prove one way or the other).

Lastly (for now), what is the source/s you use to make your claim and is/are the source Manuscript/s original or a copy/copies? If the source is not original, would you allow for the possibilities of amendations and additions to the original source by latter-day copyists and how could that affect the authenticity of what the original author/s wrote?
 
Last edited:
I have become very fond of you Pelagon, good job.

I too was wondering the same thing. 1000 years ago most people were completely illiterate and knew nothing about history sometimes they didn't even know much about their surroundings. During that time period most people didn't even know what a "Slav" in the modern context was. They certainly didn't think much in terms ethnicities, and nationalities didn't exist at all. Nashite i drugite was as far in dept as it got for most. Very little is even written about "Slavs" which is why the subject is that much more difficult to study and which is why it is shocking that it is not debated more. It is more or less accepted and I think that the communist period in Eastern Europe is the main reason for that.

No matter how you slice it there is little to no proof that an all encompassing "Slav" ethnicity exists.

We are certainly not related what so ever to Russians, Poles, Slovaks, Ukrainians, Belarusians, Lithuanians. I mean all you have to do is just look at us and look at them, we look nothing alike. You can spot a polish person from 10 miles away, they look nothing like us, we might as well be Chinese in comparison. No one in the Balkans looks anything like the countries I named so how can we all be of a similar ethnicity? Even our languages are not very similar. I think Spanish Italian and French are much more similar to each other then Russian and Macedonian. Does that mean those 3 nations are the same ethnicity? Take away Cyrillic and Orthodoxy and what do we have in common? Even Cyrillic originated in the Balkans, I say it originated in Macedonia but even if you don't agree with that it didn't originate in the north, so it's not even a uniting factor.
What happened to all the different tribes that populated Eastern Europe? Did they all just get wiped out by one tiny tribe that originated in Ukraine? Give me a break, not only is there little proof of this it is also illogical. How many ethnicities existed prior to the "Slav invasions" How many "Slavs" were there for crying out loud?

This topic pisses me off. I believe it is rooted in racism. Its because of a deep dislike of Eastern Europeans by Western ones. So they just lump us all together as one barbaric petty tribe that just can't get along. That is how they want to see us, and the "Slav" theory fits into that thinking perfectly. When the fucking British were living in trees like monkeys, and the Vikings skinning each other alive and raping their own daughters, our people were laying the foundations of humanity and modern thinking. Then they have the nerve to label us as backwards and primitive. If Alexander had went to present day England he would have been in shock.

There are no fucking Slavs get it through your heads. Thousands of years of history and culture and 100's of ethnicities didn't all just disappear and become one. So fuck off.
 
Just have a read, this is just from wiki, but it outlines the problems with the Slav migration theory and why it's almost impossible to define what a Slav was or is.

Discourse on the early Slavs





Slavs ca. 650 A.D.
The meaning of the term Slav depends upon the context in which it is used. This term refers to a culture (or cultures) living north of the Danube River, east of the Elbe River, and west of the Vistula River during the five hundred thirties AD.[46] In addition, Slav is an identifier for the common ethnic group.[47] Furthermore, Slav denotes any language with linguistic ties to the modern Slavic language family (which has no connection to a common culture or shared ethnicity).[48] Despite the various notions of Slav, it is unclear whether any of these descriptions add to an accurate representation of that group's history, since historians, such as George Vernadsky, Florin Curta, and Michael Karpovich have called into question how, why, and to what degree the Slavs were cohesive as a society between the 6th and 9th centuries CE.[49] When discussing the evidence that specialists use to construct a plausible history of the Slavs, the information tends to fall into three avenues of research: the archeological, the historiographic, and the linguistic.

Archaeologically, a myriad of physical evidence from that time period pertains to the Slavs. This evidence ranges from hill forts, to ceramic pots and fragments, to abodes. However, there are three major problems in studying the spread of early Slavic groups by purely archaeological methods. Archaeologists face difficulties in distinguishing which finds are truly Slavic and which are not.[50] In addition, many of these findings are either inaccurately carbon-dated or so isolated that they do not reflect organized Slavic settlement.[51] The combination of these facts makes it difficult to create a reliable chronology of ceramic materials, hill forts, houses, brooches, and other small artifacts. As a result, using archaeological finds without other forms of evidence is not wholly reliable for historical debates about this group.[52] The lack of grave sites also diminishes archaeologists' abilities to assess how the Slavs changed as a people, both in terms of their social behavior and their migratory patterns.[citation needed] Consequently, discerning where in northern Europe Slavic groups lived during the 6th to 9th centuries represents a challenge. The cumulative effects of these difficulties prevents the construction of a thorough history of Slavic development in Northern Europe during this period through archaeological evidence alone.[original research?]

Historiographically, a number of sources describe the Slavs. However, there are several problems using these texts to build upon the available knowledge of the early Slavs, even when used in a multidisciplinary fashion. The useful historical information about the Slavs from these texts is either cryptic or lacks any mention of their sources.[53] Moreover, these works tend to discuss the Slavs only in terms of their effects on surrounding empires, particularly the Byzantines and the Franks. The variety of names from historiographic texts that refer to the Slavs, such as the Antes, Sclaveni, and Venethi, in addition to the locales and regions which they at one point or another occupied, makes it laborious to establish a geographical boundary for major Slavic settlement. This is a troublesome task when the names of these places have not always remained the same or even survived. Most importantly, the majority of the texts utilized to describe the Slavs during this period are either second-hand accounts or describe an encounter with these groups years, decades, or centuries after it occurred. While earlier texts contextualize the Slavs' early history and later development, texts written about an event long after it had occurred make the relevant information less reliable. Unfortunately, neither earlier nor later texts directly aid understanding of the Slavs during the five hundreds to eight hundreds CE.[citation needed]





Statue of "Radegast an old god of Slavic mythology
Linguistically, the pursuit of a Slavic history is also problematic. This pursuit has focused on three main areas of study: Slavic geographical names, names of flora and fauna, and "lexical and structural similarities and differences between Slavic and other languages.[54]" The use of ethnic identifiers in written texts during and after the 500s CE, such as the description of the Slavs as Antes, Sclaveni, and Venethi by their immediate neighbors, produces problems. Moreover, the concept of ethnicity during this period was so fluid that different ethnicities would be ascribed to the same group depending upon the situation of the encounter, such as in Michal Parczewski's map. This map, a conglomeration of different written fragments about the Slavs' homeland, selectively draws upon these fragments. In order to validate his preconceived theories about Slavic migration, Parczewski omitted information from his sources which directly contradicted his conclusions, thus making the map of Slavic settlement in relation to their neighbors during the 6th century CE extremely suspect.[55] Moreover, the association of particular styles of pots and burials with specific ethnonyms by archaeologists, and extremely selective use of historiographic materials, presumes a direct connection between language and ethnicity. These facts reinforce how subjective ethnic identification can be, especially in a region where many tribal groups existed and identified themselves as distinct from one another.[56]

The history of the early Slavs is inseparable from the political agenda behind much 19th and 20th century archaeological, linguistic, and historiographic research. Florin Curta, an expert on the history of the early Slavs, contends that the process of creating such a history "was a function of both ethnic formation and ethnic identification".[57] However, this process became extremely blurred by a myriad of interests. These agendas ranged from Pan-Slavic researchers in Central and Eastern Europe during the 18th and 19th centuries,[58] to post-World War Two European nations strengthening their newfound legitimacy,[59] to contemporary politicization of historical, archaeological, and linguistic discourse.[60]

Proto-Slavic, sometimes referred to as Common Slavic or Late Proto-Slavic, is defined as the last stage of the language preceding the geographical split of the historical Slavic languages. That language was uniform, and on the basis of borrowings from foreign languages and Slavic borrowings into other languages, cannot be said to have any recognizable dialects, suggesting a comparatively compact homeland.[98] Slavic linguistic unity was to some extent visible as late as Old Church Slavonic manuscripts which, though based on local Slavic speech of Thessaloniki, could still serve the purpose of the first common Slavic literary language.[99]

Pan slavism

Pan-Slavism was a movement in the mid-19th century aimed at unity of all the Slavic peoples. The main focus was in the Balkans where the South Slavs had been ruled for centuries by other empires, Byzantine Empire, Austria-Hungary, the Ottoman Empire, and Venice. It was also used as a political tool by both the Russian Empire and the Soviet Union, which gained political-military influence and control over all Slavic-majority nations between 1945 and 1948.[citation
 
Its a good thing the mods banned 'momce'. It was Rex the Gheg peasant from the Illyrian forums pretending to be macedonian:
http://illyria.proboards.com/thread/37026/macedonians-pustec-albania-celebrate-renaming

Who did rex have to kill to obtain a computer? Im surprised a peasant like him knows how to operate a PC, i thought shovel and axe would be his proffered tool.

Looking at Chentovists other posts on that shit-hole of a forum, i see him prasing the likes of Ivanov and Gruevski as some sort of 'hard liners' LOLOLOL

Interesting people out there on the internet
 
I don't think anyone serious would deny that similarities exist (to varying degrees) within this linguistic group (as languages in other linguistic groups also have similarities) but how they came about and what the designation/label/name of that linguist group is (or should be) could be contested.
How do you think the similarities came about?
But I wonder how helpful it is in the practical defence of the Macedonian identity and MACEDONIAN LAND to use such terminology?
If in its proper context, it is much less harmful that some of the creativity of certain crackpot theorists.
In what way? Gligorov (and the Slavists) also say/s that we (as "Slav settlers") "borrowed" the name from the land that was called Macedonia.
What do you mean "also"? Don't deliberately misrepresent what I write. Neve have I suggested that Macedonians "borrowed" their name.
Secondly, what antiquity are we talking about, Macedonian or "Slav" ("Pripet marshes") antiquity? :) I think you mean Macedonian antiquity but your statement is not clear enough to make that obvious.
Macedonian antiquity. You know exactly what I mean.
Firstly, what do you mean by "our forefathers" and how far can you trace your ancestry that far back in order to definitely (and not assumingly) say that somebody 1,000 years ago is YOUR forefather?
There is a difference between "our" (plural) and "my" / "your" (singular). I believe that Cyril, Methodius, Clement, etc are the ancestors of the Macedonian people. Do you disagree? Do you find it easier to trace our ancestry to people who lived 1000 years earlier than them?
I do know that my late Grandmother (who was born around 1900) never used "Slav" to describe anything but used rather different designation as a result of her growing up during Ottoman rule. She used terms such as "Nashi" and "Kauri" (and less often Makedonci/te)........
The linguistic knowledge of simple peasants from the Ottoman era rarely transcended their own villages.
Thus, based on my personal experience, I can easily dismiss any claims made by anti-Macedonian propagandists that use some Krste Misirkov statements ("we used to call ourselves Bulgarians")..........
Better to explain why Misirkov and others said what they did, rather than pretend it never happened, like some deluded Macedonians have done and continue to do.
..........what is the source/s you use to make your claim and is/are the source Manuscript/s original or a copy/copies? If the source is not original, would you allow for the possibilities of amendations and additions to the original source by latter-day copyists and how could that affect the authenticity of what the original author/s wrote?
The sources are the life of Cyril and life of Methodius. What do you mean by "original"? Are you suggesting that they have been manipulated to include the term Sloven'ski? Can you provide any credible evidence that they have been amended by "latter-day copyists"? Do you have the "original" of Demosthenes' Phillipics? Can you verify their authenticity in a more definitive way?
I am "BRAVE" enough to ask you a few questions that need clarification in what you have stated in the above paragraph.
Based on your above responses it appears that your bravery doesn't extend to addressing the elephant in the room.
 
....We are certainly not related what so ever to Russians, Poles, Slovaks, Ukrainians, Belarusians, Lithuanians. I mean all you have to do is just look at us and look at them, we look nothing alike. You can spot a polish person from 10 miles away, they look nothing like us, we might as well be Chinese in comparison.
You and Big Bad Sven are two guys who are using critical thinking via simple physical observation and it makes very good sense to me. One does not need to get themselves into a knot theorising needlessly to see the obvious.

No one in the Balkans looks anything like the countries I named so how can we all be of a similar ethnicity?
Depends if one considers Catholic Croatians and Slovenians as part of the Balkans, where they may be somewhat culturally related and even physically in their northern regions.

Even our languages are not very similar. I think Spanish Italian and French are much more similar to each other then Russian and Macedonian. Does that mean those 3 nations are the same ethnicity? Take away Cyrillic and Orthodoxy and what do we have in common? Even Cyrillic originated in the Balkans, I say it originated in Macedonia but even if you don't agree with that it didn't originate in the north, so it's not even a uniting factor.
That is exactly the point, they use one law for us and another for the rest of "western" Europe.
What happened to all the different tribes that populated Eastern Europe? Did they all just get wiped out by one tiny tribe that originated in Ukraine? Give me a break, not only is there little proof of this it is also illogical. How many ethnicities existed prior to the "Slav invasions" How many "Slavs" were there for crying out loud?

This topic pisses me off. I believe it is rooted in racism. Its because of a deep dislike of Eastern Europeans by Western ones. So they just lump us all together as one barbaric petty tribe that just can't get along. That is how they want to see us, and the "Slav" theory fits into that thinking perfectly. When the fucking British were living in trees like monkeys, and the Vikings skinning each other alive and raping their own daughters, our people were laying the foundations of humanity and modern thinking. Then they have the nerve to label us as backwards and primitive. If Alexander had went to present day England he would have been in shock.

There are no fucking Slavs get it through your heads. Thousands of years of history and culture and 100's of ethnicities didn't all just disappear and become one. So fuck off.

The following are some excerpts from the cover sleeve of "Macedonia, its people and history" by Stoyan Pribichevich:

Macedonia, its people and history

Stoyan Pribichevich

Pennsylvania State University Press, 1982 - History - 270 pages
An introduction to one of the significant peoples of the Balkan peninsula, this book presents the achievements and problems of the Macedonians from ancient times to the present.Most Macedonians today live in Yogoslavia, where they comprise one of the five major national groups and dominate one of the six federated Republics, but a sizable number reside in Bulgaria and Greece. The introductory chapter outlines the complex geography, ethnography, and ancient history of the Balkans. The mysterious Macedonians of the Classical Period vanished with Philip and Alexander, to be replaced in the 6th and 7th centuries A.D by a Slavic people who came from the Russo-Polish-Ukranian plains in the Great Migration to the Byzantine empire. The Macedonians adopted Eastern Orthodoxy, and their language, written in Cyrillic script, became one of three principal languages of Yugoslavia.The Macedonians have preserved a rich cultural identity through 13 centuries of political turmoil and partition. Macedonia- including the Greek and Bulgarian parts- has distinctive customs, folklore, art, and architecture.

http://books.google.com.au/books?id=G2O5AAAAIAAJ&q=inauthor:"Stoyan+Pribichevich"

Stoyan Pribichevich, who died shortly after completing this book, was for many years Associated Editor of 'Fortune', a frequent contributor to Foreign Policy Association publications, and author of 'World Without End'. He was a 'Time' correspondent during World War II, at one point representing the American press in Tito's headquarters.

This was really a trigger for me to reject western "scholarship" as totally politically biased and without any academic objectivity, especially in regards to Macedonian matters. As far as I am concerned, where it concerns Macedonia, you can go and stick western "peer reviewed" scholarship where the sun does not shine!


Stoyan Pribichevich, who died shortly after completing this book, was for many years Associated Editor of 'Fortune', a frequent contributor to Foreign Policy Association publications, and author of 'World Without End'. He was a 'Time' correspondent during World War II, at one point representing the American press in Tito's headquarters.

I do believe Pribicevic, who has many of the right credentials, was presenting the official American (Western) political ideology vis-a-vis Macedonia and was most likely sponsored by the USA to write and publish the book as preparation for the demise of the USSR and SFRY.


Ancient Macedonians (Page 37)
"....The Macedonians were the first to develop iron civilisation there and introduce cavalry. The Greeks, though mixed, have stayed where they settled until present day. Descendants of the Illyrians live in present-day Albania; Tsintsars and Vlachs are the descendants of the Thracians. The Macedonians have left no descendants.
How the above view can be published and promoted via (western "peer reviewed") academic circles is beyond comprehension. :)
 
How do you think the similarities came about?
At this stage it does not interest me that much to discuss it but there are quite a few THEORIES as how it came about and you have already been through them with others [Here].

If in its proper context, it is much less harmful that some of the creativity of certain crackpot theorists.
If you think so.

What do you mean "also"? Don't deliberately misrepresent what I write.
They also claim "continuity" of the name but as a borrowed one. :)

Never have I suggested that Macedonians "borrowed" their name.
How did they/we get the name then? Ethnic continuity over the millennias or by some other means? AMHRC and Vinozhito, amongst others, claim that it was only a 19th century development that led to Macedonians becoming aware of their identity as Macedonians. I do not subscribe to that theory but that proposition has some following amongst Macedonian political left circles.

Macedonian antiquity. You know exactly what I mean.
I can not read minds, I am sorry. :)

There is a difference between "our" (plural) and "my" / "your" (singular). I believe that Cyril, Methodius, Clement, etc are the ancestors of the Macedonian people.
They are NOT as clear cut identifiable as Macedonians as are Kings Filip II and Aleksandar III of Macedon(ia) as far as I am aware and are contested by others. But who was Cyril and Methodius working for and what was the political agenda of their mission on behalf of the "Roman State"?

Do you disagree? Do you find it easier to trace our ancestry to people who lived 1000 years earlier than them?
I find it is politically easier and more prudent (i.e standing on a solid national foundation) when we have a clearly defined Macedonian state to build upon and so did the Macedonian national revivalists of the 19th century.

The linguistic knowledge of simple peasants from the Ottoman era rarely transcended their own villages.
I don't know about that as many were also often working as pecalbari within the empire or outside it. My Grandfather, though after WWI, worked in Turkey and Argentina (and as NAZI conscript labor in Germany during most of WWII).

Better to explain why Misirkov and others said what they did, rather than pretend it never happened, like some deluded Macedonians have done and continue to do.
No doubt but to claim that just because he said or wrote something that it applies to all and is the gospel truth needs to be checked against the facts and circumstances (and context) in which he wrote whatever he wrote. Clearly it would easily exclude all the Macedonians aligning with the Greeks or the Serbs as well as the majority of the peasantry who did not identify as such. One can also refer to Slavejkov where he has to finally admit that the great majority of Macedonians see themselves as descendants of the ancient Macedonians and not as related to the Bulgars, whom they called Tatars. :)

The sources are the life of Cyril and life of Methodius.
Can you give some more details about the manuscript source? Publisher, author and translator and relevant passages (with page references).

What do you mean by "original"?
Original means just that - ORIGINAL. If a given author is said to have written a book or manuscript, you either have the original or NON-ORIGINAL copies of copies of copies, and etc. If there is no original, it should NOT be assumed that all the contents of the existing copies are exactly as they were in the original and claims about what this or that author said should be taken with a grain of salt.

Are you suggesting that they have been manipulated to include the term Sloven'ski?
I am not saying that but it is possible that some or much of the content could have been altered or added by later copyists. There plenty of examples of this happening in other classical manuscripts that have been copied over the centuries.

Can you provide any credible evidence that they have been amended by "latter-day copyists"?
I don't have a copy of the manuscript and usually a specialist translator and historian would provide that in a commentary of the particular manuscript. But some years ago a Bulgarian historian mentioned some issues about that Manuscript and hinted of a pending publication by a Grk colleague of his that was going provide some critical analysis (from their perspective) of it.



Do you have the "original" of Demosthenes' Phillipics? Can you verify their authenticity in a more definitive way?
:) Now you are thinking critically!

No, not much of history is really original source and there is too much blind acceptance of what historians decide to present (interpret), IMO.

Based on your above responses it appears that your bravery doesn't extend to addressing the elephant in the room.

Give me the quotes and the source references so that we can actually see whether it is an elephant or a mouse. :)

Cheers
 
Back
Top