Cross and Crescent Divide up Macedonia
In the last ten years, Macedonia has seen the construction of hundreds of new churches and mosques - but the race between the two great religions to ‘mark out’ their territories has disturbing consequences.
Aleksandar Pisarev BIRN Skopje
In the last ten years, Macedonia has seen the construction of hundreds of new churches and mosques - but the race between the two great religions to ‘mark out’ their territories has disturbing consequences.
Macedonia now has 1,952 churches and 580 mosques, and at least 50 churches and ten mosques are either under construction or renovation. This means one church or mosque per 831 residents, unlike the European average, where there is one religious structure for every 10,000 to 12,000 members of the population.
A survey in Macedonia conducted at the end of 2012 by the Konrad Adenauer foundation showed 74.2 per cent of Orthodox Christian respondents believe there are now enough churches in the country, while 20.4 percent believe that there are too many.
Among the Muslims surveyed, 44.6 per cent think there are enough mosques, while 43.1 believe there are too many.
Unlike these ordinary citizens, the two largest religious communities in the country, the Macedonian Orthodox Church and the Islamic Religious Community, as well as smaller religious groups, believe the opposite.
Each insists that the number of religious facilities is not enough to meet its needs. Each also accuses the other of aggression and disrespect for the laws in the field of religious buildings’ construction.
Chaotic-looking landscape
The constant construction of new churches, chapels, high crosses, minarets and mosques is creating a chaotic landscape. The greatest dynamic in the construction of new religious buildings in Macedonia is in the Skopje municipality of Aerodrom.
A trend towards intensive church construction was introduced here by the former mayor in 2008, when the building of five new churches in the neighborhood was launched.
The new Mayor of Aerodrom, Ivica Konevski, takes an even more ambitious approach to the construction of new churches and religious symbols.
Within the past five years, a new church has sprung up at almost every intersection, while the central area now hosts a total of eight. Locals say that only one of them, the Church of St Elijah, is regularly visited, while the others are permanently locked.
Recently, the headstone was laid for another church, of the Holy Trinity, which is clearly meant to mark the area in and around the Jane Sandanski sports complex and the Hotel Russia, which is under construction.
The donor here is a Russian businessman, Sergei Samsonenko. Plans are meanwhile afoot to construct a new church near the same municipality, while the Skopje diocese has also announced the construction of new churches in an additional six municipalities.
Muslims are equally busy. In the last ten years, 350 new mosques were built in Macedonia, of which as many as 88 are in the Skopje-Tetovo-Gostivar area and in villages located under the Shar Mountain.
Some are in completely uninhabited locations in Suva Gora and on the western slopes of Mt Vodno.
In the Gostivar–Bogovine section alone, ten new mosques have been built, and in the region of Kichevo, seven mosques were restored or built in the last eight years. Recently, the headstone was laid for an eighth mosque there.
However, the Islamic Community, IRC, is adamant that the 580 mosques in Macedonia do not match the current needs of its flock. “Muslim believers of different ethnic backgrounds make up to 40 per cent of the country's population,” Afrim Tahiri, General Secretary of the IRC, maintained.
“Our believers are forced to say their Friday prayers in yards and outside mosques because there is not enough room inside,” he added.
“In Prilep, over 10,000 believers have nowhere to pray because the restoration of the Charsii Mosque, which suffered a fire a few years ago, is not allowed,” he continued.
He believes that a wrong impression is being created in the public that many mosques are being built, while at the same time the real needs of the faithful are neglected.
Marking out territories
Professor Cane Mojanoski, former chairman of the Commission for Relations with Religious Communities and Religious Groups, says there are too many churches and mosques in Macedonia compared to the real number of believers who regularly attend them. The purpose of many of these religious sites is to seal an ethnic division, he believes.
“They are markers of the territory conquered by ethnically defined political parties. For them, religious buildings stopped being places of worship long ago,” he said.
“Instead, they treat them as tools for achieving and demonstrating political power. But this homogenization on a religious basis can only bring harm to Macedonia,” Mojanoski added.
In a sense, the Church admits this. The Macedonian Orthodox Church sees the construction of churches as a way of repelling the “invading tendencies of the Muslims”, who are beginning to settle into traditionally Christian areas, Fr Boban Mitevski, professor at the Theological Faculty and chief of staff to the head of the Ohrid Archbishopric, observed.
“But the construction of religious buildings should not and must not be placed in the context of ‘marking’ national territory, because then they would lose their basic essence,” he said.
“However, the real situation on site shows that Muslims conquer territory and mark it with religious objects even when in reality there are no people or believers living on that territory,” he added. “In response, we build churches, place crosses and defend our territory from invaders.”
Immediately after the announcement that a 100-storey skyscraper was to be built in Aerodrom by Sky City, which is a part of the Turkish company Dzevair’s holding - and that the apartments would be offered mainly to citizens of mainly Albanian Tetovo and Kosovo - the World Macedonian Congress, supported by the city and local authorities, decided to build a 51-metre-high cross next to the complex.
Todor Petrov, president of the World Macedonian Congress, during a ceremony, told the crowd: “Macedonians, Christians, recognize their ethnic space and need to mark it with a symbol in which they believe. The cross is an identification of Macedonians and they are entitled to mark their ethnic territory with it.”
In this context, the Church justifies the construction of the large cross in Aerodrom as a way of defending a territory that belongs to Christians.
“The irresponsible and hasty decision of the local authorities to entrust the construction of the residential complex and the sale of apartments to a Muslim company provoked this reaction from the World Macedonian Congress,” Fr Mitevski maintained.
“The construction of the Cross should deter Muslims from settling where there is already a Christian symbol,” he added.
Another striking example of building religious objects to mark territory was the start of construction at the beginning of 2011 of a church-museum in Kale, in the old part of Skopje, which prompted riots and clashes between Macedonians and Albanians. The Citadel has been closed to visitors ever since.
A similar example of labeling a public space with religious objects has occurred in the National Park of Mavrovo, where a church was built in the summer of 2014 in the area around the former Hotel Plaza. The donor was the family of the former Finance Minister, Boris Stoimenov.
Politicians and celebs move in
Many celebrities, current and former politicians and businessmen who publicly declare themselves as donors meanwhile organize state-church events for the laying of headstones, marking the start of construction of these religious objects.
The headstone for the new bell tower of the Church of St Nicholas in the village of Ljubanci, whose donor is Johan Tarculovski - who was convicted in the summer of 2014 of war crimes by the Hague Tribunal - was laid in the presence of the Minister of Culture, Elizabeta Kancevska-Mileska.
The state often financially supports the construction of religious buildings, starting with the construction of the Millennium Cross on top of Mt Vodno and a church in Plaosnik.
Immediately after the 2006 parliamentary elections, the government decided to finance the construction of the church of Sts Constantine and Elena in Skopje’s central Macedonia Square, appointing the Ministry of Culture as the project leader. The construction of the church is in the final stage.
The government also donated 150,000 euros to start the construction of the Church of All Saints in Bitola. This drew a sharp reaction from the Islamic Community, which then demanded the building or restoration of the Burmali Mosque in the centre of Skopje.
The example of central government has been followed by almost all municipalities, which have launched their own initiatives and offered financial incentives and exemptions from municipal taxes for church donors.
Builders of churches are exempted from tax obligations in the field of construction, too.
It has all prompted a race between businessmen, public figures and politicians to prove who can build more churches and in more remarkable locations.
The former President of the Commission for Relations with Religious Communities, Cane Mojanovski, considers the construction of such features a political strategy on the part of the government aimed towards the ethnic and religious demarcation of territories. In the long term, these signs are intended to indicate that “others” are not welcome on already marked territories.
Afrim Tahiri, secretary general of the Islamic Religious Community, complains that the Orthodox Church enjoys an exclusive position in society, and acts in alliance with government institutions, reflected in their routine presence and participation at events where no religious community has a place.
“Priests consecrate or lay headstones at public facilities and secular buildings that are designed for all categories of people, irrespective of their religion,” he said.
“By participating in such events and by placing religious symbols in public places and public buildings, they acknowledge that they are dominant and that they are enclosing their own space,” he added.
He said that the secular constitution of the state was being directly undermined also by the government’s decision to build churches within the “Skopje 2014” project, which is intended to beautify the capital.
“These trends are followed by local governments and government ministers,” Tahiri maintained.
A semi-secular state:
Professor Mirjana Najchevska, former president of the Helsinki Committee for Human Rights and a civil activist, says that belonging to a particular religion is a human right that should not be imperiled.
However, she adds that the state “often interferes openly in religious matters and, under the guise of protecting national interests, puts the Macedonian Orthodox Church in a unique position, directly influencing the infringement of the secular character of the state.
“Taking into consideration Macedonia’s ethnic bi-nationality, the ICR demands (and gets) the same in territories that they have marked as their own, which in the end leads to the separation of citizens on religious grounds, which in fact is supported by the state,” Najchevska added.
Saso Ordanoski, a journalist and political analyst, says Macedonia now belongs to a category of “semi-secular” states, which are neither one thing nor the other.
“Macedonia is not completely secular like France, for example, neither it is fully non-secular, like some eastern theocracy,” he said.
“It operates rather on the German model, where church and state are separated but where the state supports the church indirectly and ‘invisibly’.
“When nationalists are in power, like VMRO for example, then that support is visible, direct and demonstrative,” Ordanoski added.
Religious expert Ramadan Ramadani says that the state backs the Macedonian Orthodox Church openly, in part to compensate for the Church’s weak position internationally, in the Orthodox world.
“Because of non-recognition of the Macedonian Church by its sister churches and its exclusion from the Orthodox communion, it enjoys a unique position,” he said.
“There is a strange symbiosis between the state and the Church hierarchy in which they help each other to achieve their own interests.
“On the other hand, such a relationship between the Church and the state leads to an asymmetric form of secularity. What is not considered secular when it comes to the Church is always applied as secularity when it comes to the IRC,” he added.
Thus, while the state supports the construction of a 51-metre cross in the municipality of Aerodrom, which is not deemed a violation of secularity, it opposes the restoration of demolished mosques in the Madzirmaalo neighborhood in the Skopje municipality of Centar, and in the municipality of Aerodrom, because that would “infringe on the secularity of the state”.
“Spreading the stereotype that, for Macedonians, all Albanians are Muslims and for Albanians, all Macedonians are Orthodox Christians, directly creates a code of identification and leads to segregation,” Ramadani said.
Fr Mitevski believes that Macedonia cannot be a totally secular state because of a centuries-old interweaving of culture, tradition and history with religion.
But he insists that the Macedonian Orthodox Church does not see itself as “a protector of citizens along ethnic lines, because if it did so, it would lose its basic substance”.
Sociology Professor Ilija Acevski says the Church continues to enjoy an exclusive position in the state - and that the relationship between Church and politics in Macedonian society is worryingly close.
“Speeches by religious leaders increasingly resemble political speeches, which have no a place and meaning in a democracy,” he said.
http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/cross-and-crescent-divide-up-macedonia
Interesting piece, worthy of discussion.
We know and they know, that these places of worship are not being built for such purposes, but for marking territory on a ethnic basis. That's obvious, but, simply, if the Macedonians stop constructing churches, but the Albanians continue, then you have a problem, and that's vice versa.
In my opinion, the construction of such places needs to be regulated by an external body, free from pressure from the government and church. It's a bit ridiculous now. Imagine where the money could be better spent, especially if it's coming directly from the state.
