• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Football Thread!

What difference would going to Victory games make?
Difference would be, that you would get your facts right. You seem to think you know about all the 16 year old Muzzas and the large Greek community but you have not yet attended a game :confused1:

I didn't need to have an interest in the league to interact with avid Victory fans.
So you make judgements on a club based on a few avid Victory fans that you might know out of 20,000 average that turn up to games?

I didn't say it was a Greek club,
But you did say they have a large following (implying stay away Grci se) but nothing to back these claims except for mabe knowing a few avid Victory fans. Well you haven't attended any games to mingle amongst the crowd, so how would you know?

I'm simply defending against your absurd claims.
Not attending games, knowing only a handful of avid Victory fans, only recently took up interest in the league, admit you only support one club and its pasive at best, then you think you are qualified to make ridiculous unfounded claims. Who is really absurd?

Whatever, I don't really care. Clubs in the A-League aren't ethnic based, so it doesn't really matter.
I never said they are ethnic based (not yet for Sth Melbourne Heart) But Lavce came up with "Grci se" and you follow with bullshit Victory has a large Greek following. All i am doing is pulling you guys up on this false information and asking you in particulor to back this up. All you can come up with is you know a few avid Victory fans :ohmy:

Not sure why you are getting so worked up about this.
Initially it was typical Victory v Fart
Victory v WSW banter amongst you, Momce and i, Momce laughed it off but then you start with fairy tales, You probably know to many Greeks and the lying is rubbing off on you.

Again, I don't really care. If some bloke on the Melbourne Victory forums says they have a large maco supporter base,
Mate you wanted proof. Showing you a statement made by someone who would know more than anyone else the ethnic composition in our club, is more than you can produce. I could have told you i have followed this club since day 1 and attended games since 2007 and have came across many many Preston Supporters and hearing plenty of Macedonian being spoken amongst groups, but your stubbornness would not allow you to take my word for it.

There is no hope in hell that South Melbourne will be given a license,
You are repeating what i said. Though i used fat chance. But same shit nonetheless.

unless the FFA is prepared to backtrack on the very reason they formed the A-League.
No they wont (backtrack), which is why Sth Melbournes only alternative is to cunningly take over an existing one. What do you think will happen if Heart becomes their bitch after using their facilities? Do you doubt Greeks are cunning lying bastards? do you think Hellas fans adopting the club then the club using followers as a reason to merge or change the name to Sth Melbourne Heart, as something unachievable or improbable?

Heart is steadily growing, and any decent football fan should be happy to see that
Steady as a rock. Not going anywhere mate. Infact, i find it hard to come up with a current A League team that Heart has more numbers of supporters. Its not a boast, but a fact.

and any decent football fan should be happy to see that.
Any decent Heart fan should not bite the hand thats feeding it. Mate, if it wasn't for that 25,000 Victory supporters attending your home games once or twice a season, Heart would sink. 25,000 is more than 4 times your home games takings. Thats a fact and you know it. Or probably have no idea...yeh most likely the latter.

If you want soccer to always be the 4th or 5th most popular sport in Australia, then continue this 'one team in Melbourne' bullshit and keep hoping that Heart folds.
lol

1st of all, Football (soccer) isn't in 4th or 5th position. Thats another inaccuracy of yours. There are more kids playing Soccer than any other sport, mabe only Aussie rules has taken over this mantle recently. I don't know what your reasons are for a sport to be ranked at a certain position, but i bet its going to be funny lol

The only loser will be the sport.
Oh Please, Heart are hardly the vitality this sport needs and depends upon. You are to stubborn to admit the only way for Heart to have a chance of succeeding, is to relocate. Geelong might be the best option (though many there are already staunch Victory supporters) or the Sth East suburbs of Melbourne, even back to Morwell. Melbourne (Central) aint big enough for the two clubs and don't kid yourself if you think Victory fans will keep on converting. The rivalry is deep rooted and so are the followers to their clubs. Heart can't continue on the way things are.

I hate Geelong with a passion in the AFL, yet I respect them greatly. Why can't Victory supporters show even a shred of respect for other A-League teams.
To begin with, You guys are shite. Re WSW......don't wary there is respect for the new boys. Both sets of supporters claim are the best in the nation and we welcome the challenge both on the field and on the terraces. We welcome the news that there finally is a challenge, it makes the sport more exiting which is good for the sport. Sydney FC.....well the rivalry between the two cities has been going on for 100 years in all sports. You know the joke? they deliberately put Canberra in between to separate the two so we don't become neighbours and war. Sydney disrespect us as much as Melbournians do to them. I don't know which other clubs you are refering to as we don't respect. I suppose its another one of your imaginations.

This kind of arrogance has become a disease amongst your fans, and frankly it's quite disturbing.
I find your assessments of Victory disturbing. Our club show arrogance, disrespect etc etc...yet all the other clubs are in bed with each other lol
Give me a break, its sport...and not just any sport, its Football FFS. Which club don't show arrogance and pride.

Yeh, we get you're the biggest club in the league...
And don't forget it....ooops sorry the frigan arrogance in me lol

But ffs your not ultras or some kind of firm. Start supporting the sport as a whole and not just Victory.
yawwwwwwwn.......:sleeping:
 
Last edited:
Difference would be, that you would get your facts right. You seem to think you know about all the 16 year old Muzzas and the large Greek community but you have not yet attended a game :confused1:

But they aren't even facts lol. You can attend every game of the season and still not know the ethnic composition of a supporter base. It's only fact if you actually conduct an official census, and I highly doubt that this has taken place. Again, I was only providing a counter-argument to your claim that Melbourne Heart will become a Greek team (i.e South Melbourne)...which mind you is completely ridiculous.

So you make judgements on a club based on a few avid Victory fans that you might know out of 20,000 average that turn up to games?

Well, how many of those 20,000 do you know personally or have spoken to? I don't need to attend Victory games to know Victory supporters. I happen to know a fair few, and I'd say their opinion is just as informed as yours. I don't mean the ethnic background of those few Victory supporters I know. I'm talking about their views on the club.

But you did say they have a large following (implying stay away Grci se) but nothing to back these claims except for mabe knowing a few avid Victory fans. Well you haven't attended any games to mingle amongst the crowd, so how would you know?

When did I imply to stay away from Melbourne Victory because 'grci se'? Obviously I'm going to tell others to support Heart. They need all the support they can get at the moment. Victory has enough supporters to sustain a long-term and viable existence. How many Heart games have you attended to mingle with the crowd? What gives your opinion more authority than mine? If someone chooses to support Victory, that is their choice. I certainly wouldn't base my choice on the ethnic composition of an A-League club. All fans unite under the same name.

Not attending games, knowing only a handful of avid Victory fans, only recently took up interest in the league, admit you only support one club and its pasive at best, then you think you are qualified to make ridiculous unfounded claims. Who is really absurd?

I was passive in previous seasons, but follow the team quite closely now. I'll probably purchase a membership next season. I don't need to attend games to be in the loop and know what's going on. There is plenty of information in the news and on the web for me to read up on. I don't go to matches to research the demographics of a supporter base.

I never said they are ethnic based (not yet for Sth Melbourne Heart) But Lavce came up with "Grci se" and you follow with bullshit Victory has a large Greek following. All i am doing is pulling you guys up on this false information and asking you in particulor to back this up. All you can come up with is you know a few avid Victory fans :ohmy:

Firstly, South Melbourne will not change their name. Not sure how many times I have to say this, but it isn't going to happen. Perhaps it's some kind of dream of yours to see Heart fold and for a Greek team to take over, but these kind of rumours have absolutely no foundation. You ask me to back up my 'false information' yet you continue to push this South Melbourne crap with out a shred of evidence. That is far more ludicrous than me talking about 16 year old muzzas (which mind you was not meant to be taken seriously).

Initially it was typical Victory v Fart
Victory v WSW banter amongst you, Momce and i, Momce laughed it off but then you start with fairy tales, You probably know to many Greeks and the lying is rubbing off on you.

Bill, I'm all for banter, but what you said in your initial post seemed more like an insult than banter. Making comparisons with Greek and Serbian teams, accusing us of being weird looking rubbish reject supporters and a teamed destined to become South Melbourne...where's the banter in that. I don't think many Macos appreciate being compared to Serbs/Greeks or told that a club they support will become Greek. The banter between you and Momce was fine and is how it should be.

Mate you wanted proof. Showing you a statement made by someone who would know more than anyone else the ethnic composition in our club, is more than you can produce. I could have told you i have followed this club since day 1 and attended games since 2007 and have came across many many Preston Supporters and hearing plenty of Macedonian being spoken amongst groups, but your stubbornness would not allow you to take my word for it.

Some post by a Victory fan on their boards is meaningless to me. He hasn't conducted a census either. All this speculation of the ethnic composition of our clubs is a waste of time and not even relevant. I'll take your word for it, but since when did this become a game of who has more Macos supporting their team? Obviously there will be supporters of all sorts of ethnic backgrounds supporting Victory. They had a 4 year head-start on Heart...do the math.

You are repeating what i said. Though i used fat chance. But same shit nonetheless.

They aren't going to take over Melbourne Heart FC.

No they wont (backtrack), which is why Sth Melbournes only alternative is to cunningly take over an existing one. What do you think will happen if Heart becomes their bitch after using their facilities? Do you doubt Greeks are cunning lying bastards? do you think Hellas fans adopting the club then the club using followers as a reason to merge or change the name to Sth Melbourne Heart, as something unachievable or improbable?

Cunningly??? Are you serious? How in God's name would that be 'cunning?' It'd be pretty damn obvious I reckon. I know the FFA are dumb, but I don't think they are that stupid. I'm sure a fair few South Melbourne fans would be opposed to changing the name to South Melbourne Heart. They aren't that plastic.

Steady as a rock. Not going anywhere mate. Infact, i find it hard to come up with a current A League team that Heart has more numbers of supporters. Its not a boast, but a fact.

No, attendance numbers are slowly increasing. That is a FACT and the only fact that has probably been presented so far in this dialogue. I'm happy to back that up with numbers if you'd like. Did you expect Heart to become a huge success in 3 seasons? I guess you don't really understand that having one team in Melbourne for 4 years has an impact on the introduction of a second team. It is inevitable that the second team will take far longer to grow. WSW is an exception because people in Sydney use 'east' and 'west' as a divider far more than we do in Melbourne.

Any decent Heart fan should not bite the hand thats feeding it. Mate, if it wasn't for that 25,000 Victory supporters attending your home games once or twice a season, Heart would sink. 25,000 is more than 4 times your home games takings. Thats a fact and you know it. Or probably have no idea...yeh most likely the latter.

Well at the last derby (Heart home game) the crowd attendance was 26,457. In fact, the previous two Heart homes games against Victory had similar attendance figures. In each case, there were more than 1000 Heart fans there. Get your facts right.

lol

1st of all, Football (soccer) isn't in 4th or 5th position. Thats another inaccuracy of yours. There are more kids playing Soccer than any other sport, mabe only Aussie rules has taken over this mantle recently. I don't know what your reasons are for a sport to be ranked at a certain position, but i bet its going to be funny lol

In terms of attendance figures, the A-League is ranked 4th or 5th. That's another fact Bill, I'm not pulling these out of my arse. It wouldn't hurt for you to look into these figures before you comment. At grass roots soccer has always been successful. But I'm talking about different leagues and codes put head to head. AFL, NRL, Rugby and even some cricket competitions have a larger average attendance than the A-League.

Oh Please, Heart are hardly the vitality this sport needs and depends upon. You are to stubborn to admit the only way for Heart to have a chance of succeeding, is to relocate. Geelong might be the best option (though many there are already staunch Victory supporters) or the Sth East suburbs of Melbourne, even back to Morwell. Melbourne (Central) aint big enough for the two clubs and don't kid yourself if you think Victory fans will keep on converting. The rivalry is deep rooted and so are the followers to their clubs. Heart can't continue on the way things are.

No, I agree. I think that Geelong would have been a great place for Heart to be based out of. It wouldn't hurt to play a few matches there every season. Similarly, the SE suburbs has a massive population catchment that could prove successful. Heart lacks a geographic distinction to set it apart from Victory. Melbourne is big enough for two teams, it's just a matter of selling the product properly.

To begin with, You guys are shite. Re WSW......don't wary there is respect for the new boys. Both sets of supporters claim are the best in the nation and we welcome the challenge both on the field and on the terraces. We welcome the news that there finally is a challenge, it makes the sport more exiting which is good for the sport. Sydney FC.....well the rivalry between the two cities has been going on for 100 years in all sports. You know the joke? they deliberately put Canberra in between to separate the two so we don't become neighbours and war. Sydney disrespect us as much as Melbournians do to them. I don't know which other clubs you are refering to as we don't respect. I suppose its another one of your imaginations.

Of course it's good for the sport. That's what I've been saying all along. But for some reason when it comes to Heart trying to expand, it isn't good for the sport in your view. Bit hypocritical.

I find your assessments of Victory disturbing. Our club show arrogance, disrespect etc etc...yet all the other clubs are in bed with each other lol
Give me a break, its sport...and not just any sport, its Football FFS. Which club don't show arrogance and pride.

Show arrogance if you want, that's fine. But stop trying to dictate everything that happens in this city. Let the Hearts be. I'm sure you will miss the banter and derby games if Heart were to fold and Melbourne returned to one team. Victory pales in comparison to Australian football clubs of the past. But it's all good if Victory fans go to derby matches with 'Against modern football' banners...I guess their 7 year history in the A-League speaks of real football culture.
 
"WSW is an exception because people in Sydney use 'east' and 'west' as a divider far more than we do in Melbourne." Agree with that I could never jump on the bandwagon and start supporting Sydney FC and all the rich boys from the Eastern Suburbs. WSW is the best thing they have done to the A-League to date in my opinion. You have people who were always against the A-League and even NRL fans attending the games. Is there really no divider like east and west in Melbourne??
 
You got it wrong Lavce. Come to the Sth End amongst the supporters and you would think you are at Tumbe Kafe.

Macedonians were the first to jump on this club at the inception of the club and league. We had no club in the top flight to support. While the Hellarss and Croatia were still throthing over the state league. Even today, Hellarss hate Victory and visa versa because of envy that Victory taking the mantle as being the biggest club in the country. Not only that, Hellarss are pushing to enter the A league, but fat chance.

LOL......

There's only one team in Melbourne mate and it aint that Olympiacos/Crvena Zvezda jumper wearing club of yours that have a habit of collecting Melbourne Victory rejects. But seriously, your team is a joke and it wont be long before they suffer Gold Coast demise. You have a handful of supporters that are turncoats and very weird looking ones at that. But atleast you guys don't have to wary about pre purchasing tickets or lining up at food stalls or toilets. Shit you are lucky lol.

PS: Rumours going around you soon are to relocate to Bob Jane Stadium because of financial reason. The beginning of the takeover by St Melbourne.

I hear Falafel is a good seller at your home ground. :001_tt2:

Mate, wait till all this hysteria (which naturally occurs not long after inception of a new club) subsides. The hype will wear out after it becomes old and You will be another Sydney FC (samo pomalce pederi).

Melbourne Victory Hellass :p
 
"WSW is an exception because people in Sydney use 'east' and 'west' as a divider far more than we do in Melbourne." Agree with that I could never jump on the bandwagon and start supporting Sydney FC and all the rich boys from the Eastern Suburbs. WSW is the best thing they have done to the A-League to date in my opinion. You have people who were always against the A-League and even NRL fans attending the games. Is there really no divider like east and west in Melbourne??

There is, but not to the extent of Sydney I don't think. I often use the terms western and eastern suburbs but not really in terms of a rivalry. I live in the east but most macos live in the western suburbs, so from my personal perspective there's no point creating territorial divisions.
 
You can attend every game of the season and still not know the ethnic composition of a supporter base.
Well i'll be......

You seem to know the ethnic composition of the supporter base of Victory........ even Hearts
Infact you have seen them :confused1:

From what I've seen Melbourne Victory have a large Greek following...... Melbourne Heart seems to have a larger Turk/Croat and even Maco supporter base.

It's only fact if you actually conduct an official census,
sega nogu barash i nogu drapash.

Your claims that "Victory has a large Greek following" was intended by you to come across as "Fact" and no census was needed back then.

Well, how many of those 20,000 do you know personally or have spoken to?
Irrelevent.....i didn't make a claim what ethnic base and size of them that follow a particular club. You did and you based it on a few avid Victory supporters you knew. I stated that i will not deny there are Greeks that support the club, i just challenged this Large amount you dreamed about. I also mentioned how i have (personal expeiriance) noticed there is a large numbers of Macedonians at the club, i even supplied a comment made by a non Macedonian who is head of the Melbourne Victory supporters group, which large majority of our supporters know him personaly (and obviously visa versa) who is also involved at club meetings as a representative on behalf of the supporters and is privy to certain information such as lists of names of members. But you want a census, (and there could have been one at the club for all we know for the sake of marketing) but next you would probably only accept a UN sanctioned one only lol
Your stubbornness can't be pleased.


Bill, I'm all for banter, but what you said in your initial post seemed more like an insult than banter.
Mate.....you have the problem for feeling insulted. Banter is banter.

Making comparisons with Greek and Serbian teams, accusing us of being weird looking rubbish reject supporters and a teamed destined to become South Melbourne...where's the banter in that.
Yeh funny wasn't it lol
Get a spine mate. I spoke in a similar manner to Momce and he took it on the chin.

I don't think many Macos appreciate being compared to Serbs/Greeks
Is this a joke??? seriously, is it a joke? za grevota si dete, which Maco did i compare to a Serb or Greek?

The banter between you and Momce was fine and is how it should be.
Bagged his club just the same, no difference numbnuts :clown: JK

Some post by a Victory fan on their boards is meaningless to me.
Anything anyone says is meaningless to you. Geeeeeesh, now i know what Vangelovski was dealing with.


He hasn't conducted a census either.
Neither have you, so next time molchi.

All this speculation of the ethnic composition of our clubs is a waste of time and not even relevant.
Then why bring it up

I'll take your word for it,
No you wont, you want a census, have you forgotten?

They aren't going to take over Melbourne Heart FC.
Yes they would, they need your witches hats, the only thing thats worth anything at your club

THIS IS ALSO BANTER MATE PLEASE DON"T HAVE A BABY


No, I agree. I think that Geelong would have been a great place for Heart to be based out of. It wouldn't hurt to play a few matches there every season. Similarly, the SE suburbs has a massive population catchment that could prove successful. Heart lacks a geographic distinction to set it apart from Victory. Melbourne is big enough for two teams, it's just a matter of selling the product properly.
Its easier just to pull the plug on those inbreeds
AGAIN THIS IS ALSO BANTER WHAT DO YOU EXPECT A VICTORY SUPPORTER TO SAY


But for some reason when it comes to Heart trying to expand, it isn't good for the sport in your view. Bit hypocritical.
I wouldn't say Heart trying to expand isn't good for the sport, its just that this expansion idea is unattainable proof is in the pudding. Though i will say, televised games with empty seats is bad advertisement for the sport, therfor.....its detrimental to the game.

Show arrogance if you want, that's fine. But stop trying to dictate everything that happens in this city. Let the Hearts be.
:scared: OMG
I think people in here have overestimated you, in particular your mentality. Seriously wtf is all this about.

Melbourne Victory Hellass :p
:001_tt2: :001_tt2:
 
Well i'll be......

You seem to know the ethnic composition of the supporter base of Victory........ even Hearts
Infact you have seen them :confused1:

Why do you keep bringing this up? I already said that we can't know for sure without an official census. Anything else is just speculation.



sega nogu barash i nogu drapash.

Your claims that "Victory has a large Greek following" was intended by you to come across as "Fact" and no census was needed back then.

Nope, I used the words 'from what I've seen' and 'seems.' These imply a personal opinion, not a fact. If I were expressing a fact I would've used the words 'I know' or 'does.' Read my posts more carefully or brush up on your English chojek. I'll say it one last time, I don't care. Let's say hypothetically Melbourne Heart has a larger Greek following as a percentage of their supporter base. And...? Unless they decide to bring politics into a non-ethnic club, I'm struggling to see what the issue is here.


Irrelevent.....i didn't make a claim what ethnic base and size of them that follow a particular club. You did and you based it on a few avid Victory supporters you knew. I stated that i will not deny there are Greeks that support the club, i just challenged this Large amount you dreamed about. I also mentioned how i have (personal expeiriance) noticed there is a large numbers of Macedonians at the club, i even supplied a comment made by a non Macedonian who is head of the Melbourne Victory supporters group, which large majority of our supporters know him personaly (and obviously visa versa) who is also involved at club meetings as a representative on behalf of the supporters and is privy to certain information such as lists of names of members. But you want a census, (and there could have been one at the club for all we know for the sake of marketing) but next you would probably only accept a UN sanctioned one only lol
Your stubbornness can't be pleased.

Lavce mentioned that Melbourne Victory are grci. I just replied with my opinion in regards to the ethnic composition of the two Melbourne clubs. Why do you find this offensive? I note that you're only pissed off about my opinion on the Victory supporters...you didn't pull me up on my claim that I believe a fair few Turks follow the Heart. Obviously you don't want Melbourne Victory to be associated with Greeks in any shape or form, and you find this offensive. No different to how I found your references to Olympiakos, Red Star and South Melbourne in poor taste.

I highly doubt he has met the majority of Melbourne Victory supporters. People may know who he is, but he won't know every Melbourne Victory supporter...unless he has met tens of thousands of people. I don't want a census, I'm just saying that it is the only way that you can possibly declare the ethnic composition of clubs as fact. Members don't disclose their nationality when they sign up as a member, so a list of names (let alone only members) is barely adequate to satisfy the requirements of a census.

No I don't need a UN sanctioned census either. I don't care who follows Melbourne Victory or Melbourne Heart. They are only supporting the world game.

Mate.....you have the problem for feeling insulted. Banter is banter.

Yeh funny wasn't it lol
Get a spine mate. I spoke in a similar manner to Momce and he took it on the chin.

There's a difference between bagging the actual club (which is banter) and bringing in completely irrelevant ethnic based attacks. FWIW, Victory have blue and white as their colours...go figure. Childish isn't it?

I'm just sick of hearing the same shit everytime I say I go for Hearts. It gets rather old, trust me.

Is this a joke??? seriously, is it a joke? za grevota si dete, which Maco did i compare to a Serb or Greek?

Bagged his club just the same, no difference numbnuts :clown: JK

You compared Heart to Greek and Serb clubs. I happen to support Hearts. Even in my reply to that 'banter' I was relatively tolerant and just wanted to express how I happened to start following the Heart. I turn around and throw in an association between Greeks and Victory and you get pissed off all of a sudden. What's the difference? Am I the only one who is meant to brush it off as banter, yet you can't adhere to the same standard?

Anything anyone says is meaningless to you. Geeeeeesh, now i know what Vangelovski was dealing with.

I may disagree with Tom on a few topics, but his opinion is always well informed. He does his research, something you haven't done here. You continue to tip-toe around the facts I've presented in my last few posts. Perhaps because I pointed out the misinformation you were spreading, and now those comments you made look somewhat unhelpful to the agenda you are pushing here.

Neither have you, so next time molchi.

I don't need to, it doesn't bother me who supports the Heart. I'm happy to see anyone from any ethnic background jumping on board.

Then why bring it up

I'm more than happy to end the discussion on the ethnic composition of the clubs right now.

No you wont, you want a census, have you forgotten?

No, I'm saying that anything that has been said thus far is simply speculation. If you want fact, go do your own census.

Yes they would, they need your witches hats, the only thing thats worth anything at your club

THIS IS ALSO BANTER MATE PLEASE DON"T HAVE A BABY


Its easier just to pull the plug on those inbreeds
AGAIN THIS IS ALSO BANTER WHAT DO YOU EXPECT A VICTORY SUPPORTER TO SAY

Wheelie Bin FC, Green Seat Elite, etc...heard all this before. I find it pretty funny and am fine with that kind of banter.

I wouldn't say Heart trying to expand isn't good for the sport, its just that this expansion idea is unattainable proof is in the pudding. Though i will say, televised games with empty seats is bad advertisement for the sport, therfor.....its detrimental to the game.

Hopefully one FTA game per week on SBS will help boost interest in the league next season. Should be good. There is always going to be empty seats. You can't expect to introduce a new team and pack out the stadium in the first game. Most teams struggle to fill up their respective stadiums, so empty seats are inevitable. Hardly worth folding a club over.

:scared: OMG
I think people in here have overestimated you, in particular your mentality. Seriously wtf is all this about.

:001_tt2: :001_tt2:

Think what you want about me. You were pretty quick to get stuck into me over barely anything, so you've probably held this opinion for a while now. By all means, keep using this thread as fuel. If you've got an issue with me then PM me and we'll discuss it there. No point creating dramas on the main board, this dialogue just seems to be in a loop at the moment.
 
Last edited:
Why do you keep bringing this up?
A reminder for you to see what exactly it was you said :001_tongue:

I already said that we can't know for sure without an official census. Anything else is just speculation.
Yeh you did back peddle (slightly) after i challenged your ludicrous unfounded estimation.

Nope, I used the words 'from what I've seen
And what you have seen, is a few avid Victory supporters that you know, and based your assumption from that.

Then you go on to say how seeing is not believing QUOTE: "You can attend every game of the season and still not know the ethnic composition of a supporter base." and would only accept a census.lol

These imply a personal opinion, not a fact.
Spare me your English lesson.
I challenged your Personal opinion (its all i did) and it came out to be this opinion of yours is definitely not a fact but in your head, im sure it will remain a fact.

If I were expressing a fact I would've used the words 'I know' or 'does.'
'Does' = 'Have' same shit.
QUOTE=EgejskaMakedonia: "Melbourne Victory have a large Greek following"

Oh and you, QUOTE: "seen it" (just to make it sound more a fact...... a mate).

I note that you're only pissed off about my opinion on the Victory supporters...

No different to how I found your references to Olympiakos, Red Star and South Melbourne in poor taste.

Why do you find this offensive?
pak se fati vo stapica lol
Questioning (sounding dumb founded) to my feelings and reactions while you admit to react the same way to similar banter.
Is this a double standard or what.

Obviously you don't want Melbourne Victory to be associated with Greeks in any shape or form,
Nonsense, I just challenged your figures after your defence (more a confirmation on your behalf) of Lavce implying Victory is a Greek club "Grci se"

Note i didn't take offence with to Lavce (so much for your association with Greeks theory) i just corrected his theory and gave him advise if he wanted to see my point. But you are different, you babble on about we Ultras, firm, leave us Heart alone and don't tell you what to do, census, now you see it now you don't etc etc. :wacko:

FWIW, Victory have blue and white as their colours...go figure. Childish isn't it?
Well since you brought it up, dete.......all Victorian representitive clubs in all sports wear the Navy blue with white and some with the V. VFL (Aussie rules) Bush Rangers (Cricket) etc. Its the Victorian colours stemming from the Eureka Flag in Victory's case, (apart from sticking with Victorian tradition) the idea was it represents a Union amongst many nationalities colour or race, (not just Greeks). I know you are being silly, but i thought i will give a history lesson of my club. What is yours? Why red and white stripes? Are they possibly marketing for Olympiakos fans (Greeks) who would be a large number in Melbourne? I'm only guessing.


You compared Heart to Greek and Serb clubs.
To use your words, "Why do you find this offensive?"
By the way, Do you deny there is a big resemblance in the strip of all three clubs?

You continue to tip-toe around the facts I've presented in my last few posts.
Facts or opinions, i cant keep up with you mate.
Re tip toe, we've seen your back peddling and double standards mate trying to weasel away from ridiculous comments you made.



I'm more than happy to end the discussion on the ethnic composition of the clubs right now.
I accept your surrender. Next time ne se pray nogu pameten deka sve snajsh za site.



Think what you want about me. You were pretty quick to get stuck into me over barely anything, so you've probably held this opinion for a while now..
Don't give us this victim crap, if you (a passive supporter who recently found interest) can't handle the heat stay out of the kitchen.

If you've got an issue with me then PM me and we'll discuss it there. No point creating dramas on the main board,
Oh please....we are discussing a football matter on a forum and nothing to hide. Why and what would i pm you, i love you? if you can't handle this stop writing fucken responses like a smart ass in the size of dictionaries like you always do. Two can play that game. Initialy, all i asked was how you came to the number of Greeks conclusion. Rest was club banter.

this dialogue just seems to be in a loop at the moment.
Caused by you straying

"I am offended, Why are you offended", "ive seen it, No i haven't", "its Fact........ no hang on its an opinion" "its Banter.....no its not"
 
Last edited:
Wheelie Bin FC, Green Seat Elite, etc...heard all this before. I find it pretty funny and am fine with that kind of banter.
With the injuries, retirements, players exiting this week, (what a rabble) Here is your starting line up for this week. lol

Wheelies fcuk line up

Redmayne

Munn SIDWELL BRUCE ( THE WHEELIE BIN CLEANER)


FOXE(PIZZA BOY) GRELLA(cardboard cutout) BECKHAM (cardboard cutout)

Egejska Makedonia

DIDILUCA(WHO) GONZO(yarraside nerd) VIDUKA(cardboard cutout)
 
With the injuries, retirements, players exiting this week, (what a rabble) Here is your starting line up for this week. lol

Wheelies fcuk line up

Redmayne

Munn SIDWELL BRUCE ( THE WHEELIE BIN CLEANER)


FOXE(PIZZA BOY) GRELLA(cardboard cutout) BECKHAM (cardboard cutout)

Egejska Makedonia

DIDILUCA(WHO) GONZO(yarraside nerd) VIDUKA(cardboard cutout)

Lol, with all the recent departures this month we'll probably need a few cardboard cutouts soon.

I've only sat in/next to the active area once but I might have already spotted who this Gonzo guy is.
 
Lol, with all the recent departures this month we'll probably need a few cardboard cutouts soon.
You might be getting Lucas Neil. He quit (or sacked by) his Arab club Al Wasl. Scott Munt on SEN this morning said they were talking to two players, both Aussies, one local and one overseas.

The local could be according to a source, Wheelhouse released from jets to Heart, will almost be in a heart shirt for the derby.
 
You might be getting Lucas Neil. He quit (or sacked by) his Arab club Al Wasl. Scott Munt on SEN this morning said they were talking to two players, both Aussies, one local and one overseas.

The local could be according to a source, Wheelhouse released from jets to Heart, will almost be in a heart shirt for the derby.

Lucas Neil could be alright, but I'm a bit sick of Heart targeting all these Socceroo or ex-socceroo players. We saw what happened with Grella, played 20 or so minutes and realises he is no longer up to it.

Here are the squads for Saturday:

Melbourne Victory Squad: 1. Tando Velaphi (GK), 2. Matthew Foschini, 3. Adama Traore, 5. Mark Milligan, 6. Leigh Broxham, 8. Jonathan Bru, 9. Marcos Flores, 10. Archie Thompson, 11. Marco Rojas, 14. Billy Celeski, 18. Francesco Stella, 22. Jesse Makarounas, 23. Adrian Leijer, 24.Nick Ansell, 26. Andrew Nabbout, 31. Scott Galloway, 39. Nathan Coe (GK) (Two to be omitted)

Ins: 2. Matthew Foschini, 22. Jesse Makarounas, 31. Scott Galloway (all promoted)

Outs: 13. Diogo Ferreira (suspended), 25. Luke O’DEA (injured)



Melbourne Heart FC Squad: 1.Clint Bolton (Gk), 3. Cameron Edwards, 6. Patrick Gerhardt, 8. Matthew Thompson, 10. Josip Tadic, 11. Richard Garcia, 13. Jonatan Germano,14. Golgol Mebrahtu, 15. David Williams, 18. David Vrankovic, 19. Ben Garuccio, 20. Andrew Redmayne (GK), 22. Nick Kalmar, 24. Sam Mitchinson, 25. Jeremy Walker, 26. Ersin Kaya, 27. Stefan Mauk, 36. Eli Babalj (Three to be omitted)

Ins: 3. Cameron Edwards, 14. Golgol Mebrathu, 19. Ben Garuccio, 24. Sam Mitchinson, 26. Ersin Kaya, 27. Stefan Mauk

Outs: 17. Jason Hoffman (suspended – five cautions), 31. Vince Grella (retired)




Thank God Hoffman was forced out of the side...he is a liability.
 
We have two of them, Foschini and Lejer. I can't stand these imbeciles. Atleast if we had cardboard cut outs for these two, opposition forwards would have to run around them.

Lol, makes you wonder how some of these players make it into the team. Your mob has plenty of talent to cover liabilities. However Rojas looks like he will be on his way eventually, number of international teams seem interested.
 
Rojas looks like he will be on his way eventually, number of international teams seem interested.
Wasn't one of the reasons for creating the A League, to have a good professional league so we don't loose our young talent to overseas?

I know Rojas is a kiwi, but he plays on our shores and will be a great loss for the league. They've nick named him the Kiwi Messi lol
But you have players going to do their trade in places like China, India, Singapore.....god knows where else. I would understand if its a major European club, But India and Singapore??? FFS
So much for the idea of keeping them here.

If you want soccer to always be the 4th or 5th most popular sport in Australia,
Sorry to bring this up again. We probably disagree with where we would rank the A League amongst other sports in Australia. But would you agree that Football (A League), has overtaken AFL in NRL areas and it has overtaken NRL in AFL areas?

I was basing this on a Comparison of Victory's attendance compared to Storm, and Wanderers to GWS.

Thats some food for thought.
 
Wasn't one of the reasons for creating the A League, to have a good professional league so we don't loose our young talent to overseas?

I know Rojas is a kiwi, but he plays on our shores and will be a great loss for the league. They've nick named him the Kiwi Messi lol
But you have players going to do their trade in places like China, India, Singapore.....god knows where else. I would understand if its a major European club, But India and Singapore??? FFS
So much for the idea of keeping them here.

Sorry to bring this up again. We probably disagree with where we would rank the A League amongst other sports in Australia. But would you agree that Football (A League), has overtaken AFL in NRL areas and it has overtaken NRL in AFL areas?

I was basing this on a Comparison of Victory's attendance compared to Storm, and Wanderers to GWS.

Thats some food for thought.

Yeh it's a shame that our quality players are poached by European clubs. Our geographical position (including time difference) is a major factor. We don't get much exposure overseas, so players would probably rather move to Europe where they have more opportunities. I don't see the appeal in countries like China, India, etc...beats me why they'd want to play in those leagues. Drogba played in China for the last year and was unheard of, but thankfully now he is moving back to Europe.

I pretty much know nothing about NRL, so I can't really comment on that. But I'd say that a fair few Bulldogs (NRL) supporters also support WSW. For some reason it seems to me that AFL and NRL is almost a choice, then soccer is the other sport that both sets of supporters (AFL and NRL) follow during the off-season. So I think when put in that perspective it is difficult to measure A-League vs NRL or AFL.

But if I had to take a guess then quite possibly it has. Mind you though, WSW is only pulling 11k or so average. That's fairly strong for a soccer stadium crowd, but relatively small when compared with an AFL stadium crowd. GWS is still getting decent crowds in an NRL dominated area, during a time where both codes are competing on a weekly basis. I think if the A-League season were to coincide with one of these other two codes, then attendance figures would take a hit.
 
Back
Top