• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Greeks, seriously.

Hmm. You would find yourself (don't know whether you answered that question finally before I disappeared a time) holding a Australian passport (let's say) more Macedonian than an Albanian speaking person holding a Macedonian passport, who lives there, was born there and grew up there.

Greek logic,
if you have a greek passport than your ethnicity is Greek. Doesn't matter if your ancestors spoke Turkish, Macedonian, Shiptar or Vlach.

Rest of the world,
Your ethnicity is a heritage from your grandparents, grandparents ...
Not what your passport says and definitely not which orthodox church you attend.
 
Most Greeks cannot even remember their Grandparents spoke a completely different language. So there is no need to worry about discordance amongst Macedonians too much my friend.

I am as Greek as you are Chinese.

I have no idea what you are hoping to convey with your text above. But your flawed logic says only Greeks have a claim on Ancient Macedonia. Why is this? Do you claim the Venetians as well? They represent a very significant part of the region's history.

Here it is (according to a realist):

Ancient Macedonians
- No academic has confirmed their native language. It was not understood by people to the South of them.
- They went through a Hellenistic period for a few hundred years.
- They went through a Roman period for a few hundred years.
- They went through a Slavic period for 1500 years.
- They went through an Ottoman period for 500 of those slavic years.
= Modern Macedonians
.

I claim continual evolution. Greeks claim continuity. Who is closer to the truth ... well mine is easier to achieve. And our DNA appears to support my claims.

If you want to tell me the Greekness of Macedonians ... well you are talking about the Greekness of Greeks in a modern sense and will run around in circles until the better fed cows from Macedonia come home.

Perhaps you could advise Dora to call the Southern part of Macedonia as ANCIENT MACEDONIA. I am sure it will give Greeks that warm feeling of cultural superiority that they strive for. I think it is a genuine solution that suits Greece entirely. Macedonians are quite simply a modern race just like Greeks. If you want to read any more into it, then be prepared for a thorough de-construction of the modern Greek identity.



Risto, I've always pondered the option of Ellada referring to her Macedonia as Ancient Macedonia, proto Macedonians and simply leaving the Republic of Macedonia and its nationality as status quo. Not a stupid concept. What you highlight in terms of what the Macedonian region has gone through in terms of periods is undisputable.
 
Last edited:
Greek logic,
if you have a greek passport than your ethnicity is Greek. Doesn't matter if your ancestors spoke Turkish, Macedonian, Shiptar or Vlach.

Rest of the world,
Your ethnicity is a heritage from your grandparents, grandparents ...
Not what your passport says and definitely not which orthodox church you attend.

Actually, it's the logic on this board. Those who fled Turkey are Turks it seems, so I guess all you who have some sort of ancestry in Greece are Greeks.
 
I think the English lesson was very important for you. Your academics use this term. For this reason, you really need to understand the significance of this suffix. Please stop calling it the spread of Greekness. Alexander was around 2100 years before "Greece". The Hellenistic period was simply that, one where leanings were obvious. There were other periods too. You seem to keep forgetting about them.

I have never said that Greek was spoken in today's Turkey. Please do not misquote me. I believe some Hellenic languages had continued there. Mostly thanks to the church. If you are going to call the language as Greek, then you will have to explain to my people in Greece why they had to learn perfect modern Greek in schools and could not understand a word of what the imported races spoke when they used their own languages.

In English we would call the ancestor of our language as Olde English.
When the Philhellenes tried to communicate with your Greeks, they spoke the "Olde Greek" only to be looked at blankly by the local hotchpotch of people in Greece. Naturally, this was before the "cleansing" of your adopted language.

Your definition for "spread of civilisation" is interesting. It is like the Philippines conquering a neighbouring country and imposing English as the language. Which it would do, given the chance. This is in the modern day and they even have their own written language, but would still do this because they perceive it as a higher culture. A bit like the Russian and Greek respect for the French, it was perceived as "higher". Remember the days of legal documents in French in modern Greece? A Napoleon for your thoughts.

But the other features ... architecture etc, well this is part of the Greek myth. Egyptian philosophers taught the Hellenes a thing or two. As did the Persian mathematicians. So in your assessment we find the Hellenes transported various "Civilisation for Dummies" books across the developed world at the time. I don't buy it. The Egyptians had done it all before and moved on. The Persians had culture whilst the Athenians were making fire.

There is debate about whether the New Testament was originally written in Koine. Certainly some sections have gathered great debate on this issue. I must admit, it was an interesting choice ... it had to be something different from Aramaic I guess, and since the Romans were the enemy of the Christians, well then why not another well developed written language of that time like Koine? Particularly bearing in mind the Arabic languages still did not have vowels in theirs.

You mention an ordinary footsoldier writing something. We all know that Alexander's army was gathered from all of the known world at the time. Hardly compelling. We also know the Ancient Macedonians could not be understood by their southern neighbours when they spoke. Do you really want me to quote the people you feel akin to in relation to this? You keep avoiding it. It is not a shaky claim, it is a fact that that the language could not be understood.

About the Christian Turks ... well like I said, there were other ethnicities "waiting to happen" in Turkey. They were not allowed to flower there. They were not Greek, so it is difficult to find useful names for them. "Christian Turks with a penchant for modern Greece" CTWAPFMG? might be more appropriate. Just like the Macedonians who have signed some little declaration of Bulgarianness to get jobs in the EU .... well, they are not Bulgarians. The Christian Turks did the same thing to get in Europe. Either to Romania (or further up) or to modern Greece. Toss a coin. Don't tell me it came from the heart or something ... there are too many proud Romanians from Turkey to tell me something is not right about your argument. And let us not forget the (rare) CTWAPFMG who felt he was absolutely superior to the lowly peasants of modern Greece. How they left a superior culture behind in Turkey. I say rare because the majority were simply church going people who had embraced their new masters and spoke the local tongue of the time. The fact they learned modern Greek should not place a definition on these people from a historic perspective.

I asked for one sentence in question form from you. You pasted a quote by me and a few sentences of dribble about it. What do actually want me to answer? Do you speak like this in your native language? What about in Modern Greek?

Risto, you use a lot of words too but it changes absolutely nothing about the fact that Alexander spread Hellinism. That seems to annoy you but this is fact.

Your arguments are below any level I expected. Alexander existed before there was a country was founded that we call modern Greece. Indeed. So what? what does that prove? Just read back what you wrote. Does the fact that Greece was founded as a country later really disqualify what Alexander the Great did, spreading Hellinism ?
Does that mean now that what he did was not spreading Hellinism ?

Of course not. This is what history books say and this is the evidence shows us in most places he set foot. That evidence is not open to interpretation, it is very clear. let me put it differently, what else did he spread then?
You correctly mentioned that his interest in Persian culture and customs in the previous message. Why did he not also spread that then too?

You disappoint me with these technicalities about whether is was Koine or not. Every language changes over the years and Greek is no exception. The continuity of Greek in all its forms is fortunately well documented. And then these theories again.... This time about the New testimony.
FACT is that the New Testimony was written Greek. What did He say again, I am the Alpha and the omega ... This is not a topic where you are going to score points with.

You deny a distinct form of Greek (or Hellenic if you want to be more accurate) architecture since you claim (and you're probably right) that Hellenes learned a thing or 2 from Egyptians. Since when does that disqualify a distinct form of Hellenic architecture ? Do you deny a significant difference between the 2 forms of architecture? (Hellenic versus Egyptian) Disappointing.. I repeat, the proof of the difference is is abundant.

The footsoldier ... I am well aware of the quotes you will produce, and you are well aware of how I will counter those. We can perform that little show if you feel it will add something to this discussion.

Fact remains that we have found writings of Greek foot soldiers in the Middle East. I mentioned in my previous message that it does not exclude the possibility that there were non Greek speakers who could have done the same in their language but again ... they didn't. Not only in this example did they not. Not ever. We have never found any proof of that mysterious ancient Macedonian language. Never.

My definition of the spread of civilization is accurate.

Your incoherent attempts to discredit that, telling that story about the respect for French does not change any of that, even if it is not untrue.
It has no significance to what I said, and besides I was not talking only talking about language.

Then the icing on the cake: Your paragraph about 'Christian Turks'. Just read that back a bit and tell me what you really want to tell me because it is not clear to me. It seems that you are now trying to convince me that Christian Turks is somehow accurate and you make all kinds of assumptions here that are supposed to convince me. You seem to suggest that they were not Greek but just trying to get a free trip to Europe. Have you any idea what kind of mess Europe was. Do you really believe that those you call 'Christian Turks' were not really that happy to leave all their possessions behind to go to a bankrupt country called Greece that had just been defeated on Turkish soil by the Turkish? They were Greek, and whether or not some of them spoke it or not does not change that, try to look at the big picture.

Final point, the quote:

First of all, I am not your servant that you can order around. You made another wild and unsubstantiated claim in an earlier discussion, and even if I wonder if you are not 24 hours on the net, you had no time to substantiate it at the time. That is your fault, not mine.

And then you conveniently forget all about it. I consider that to be weak. If you can not provide me proof, then it doesn't matter to admit that. I would actually respect you for that. But you conveniently forgot about that, so I helped you by finding the original message. have I broken any rule here by re-posting your own message?

So, you have your quote, I would appreciate a clarification but I somehow doubt that I will get one...
 
Alexander existed before there was a country was founded that we call modern Greece. Indeed. So what? what does that prove? Just read back what you wrote. Does the fact that Greece was founded as a country later really disqualify what Alexander the Great did, spreading Hellinism ?
Does that mean now that what he did was not spreading Hellinism ?
Macedonians existed before (modern) Macedonia existed too. We all came from the same place. Not from other countries to "unite". I agree that Alexander helped spread the Hellenic culture. Even though he dropped it like it was hot when he found other cultures of wonder. You are talking about a pre-cursor to Western civilisation. So, implementing banking systems etc in a modern sense would entail looking at systems in operation in today's finest markets, so what? Does it mean he was Greek? I think you genuinely believe this.

You correctly mentioned that his interest in Persian culture and customs in the previous message. Why did he not also spread that then too?
If he lived another 30 years, we might all be wearing towels on our heads.

FACT is that the New Testimony was written Greek. What did He say again, I am the Alpha and the omega ... This is not a topic where you are going to score points with.
Koine was indeed the most likely language used. I gave my reasons for its probable usage. You keep calling it Greek. It irks me somewhat.


You deny a distinct form of Greek (or Hellenic if you want to be more accurate) architecture since you claim (and you're probably right) that Hellenes learned a thing or 2 from Egyptians. Since when does that disqualify a distinct form of Hellenic architecture ? Do you deny a significant difference between the 2 forms of architecture? (Hellenic versus Egyptian) Disappointing.. I repeat, the proof of the difference is is abundant.
Thanks for saying "Hellenic to be more accurate" it gives hope. In the 1980's we saw everybody copying American architecture here in Australia. We even have Tuscan inspired houses. I do not believe I denied a Hellenic form of architecture. That would be stupid.

The footsoldier ... I am well aware of the quotes you will produce, and you are well aware of how I will counter those. We can perform that little show if you feel it will add something to this discussion.
I am not really sure how you would counter those, but antiquity bores me a little anyway. Modern Macedonians have moved on a little more than the Greeks have in this regard.


Your incoherent attempts to discredit that, telling that story about the respect for French does not change any of that, even if it is not untrue.
It has no significance to what I said, and besides I was not talking only talking about language.
But c'mon, in 2000 years time they will see the French contracts and say it was the French period of modern Greekistan. Very relevant.

Then the icing on the cake: Your paragraph about 'Christian Turks'. Just read that back a bit and tell me what you really want to tell me because it is not clear to me. It seems that you are now trying to convince me that Christian Turks is somehow accurate and you make all kinds of assumptions here that are supposed to convince me. You seem to suggest that they were not Greek but just trying to get a free trip to Europe. Have you any idea what kind of mess Europe was. Do you really believe that those you call 'Christian Turks' were not really that happy to leave all their possessions behind to go to a bankrupt country called Greece that had just been defeated on Turkish soil by the Turkish? They were Greek, and whether or not some of them spoke it or not does not change that, try to look at the big picture.
I have seen people in Greece get emotional talking about the movies they watch over there about the poor displaced Christians from Turkey. They seem as if they are caring people. Then they get all violent talking about "Skopyani". This caring nature disappears immediately. A product of your Government's mind meld. The Christians ones that came had an affinity for Greeks, that is all I can agree with. They could not be Greeks from a modern sense. I stand by my statement. Imagine Germany was taken over by Turkey (might happen soon), well ... they celebrated mass in Latin as recent as 50 years ago. Naturally they would move to a Latin country and be embraced by eg. Italians as one and the same???????? Different experiences, language, culture .... sorry, they were not Italians. They will eventually become Italians. But they were not.


First of all, I am not your servant that you can order around. You made another wild and unsubstantiated claim in an earlier discussion, and even if I wonder if you are not 24 hours on the net, you had no time to substantiate it at the time. That is your fault, not mine.

And then you conveniently forget all about it. I consider that to be weak. If you can not provide me proof, then it doesn't matter to admit that. I would actually respect you for that. But you conveniently forgot about that, so I helped you by finding the original message. have I broken any rule here by re-posting your own message?
You are so bossy. Are you like this with your boyfriends too?
I did not order you around. I merely wanted you to ask me a concise question so I could answer it for you. Your textual diarrhea often gets in the way of knowing exactly what on Earth you were asking. I still genuinely do not know.
 
Risto, I've always pondered the option of Ellada referring to her Macedonia as Ancient Macedonia, proto Macedonians and simply leaving the Republic of Macedonia and its nationality as status quo. Not a stupid concept. What you highlight in terms of what the Macedonian region has gone through in terms of periods is undisputable.
Thanks AD. It could help us all move forward.
The "undisputables" you mentioned are very real. Yet from a Greek perspective they represent evidence that can be utilised to chip away or de-construct an ethnicity. Many Greeks choose to live in a world where they cannot admit similar realities. To their detriment.
 
Thanks AD. It could help us all move forward.
The "undisputables" you mentioned are very real. Yet from a Greek perspective they represent evidence that can be utilised to chip away or de-construct an ethnicity. Many Greeks choose to live in a world where they cannot admit similar realities. To their detriment.

Cheers Risto, may I add to the "undisputables", that during these periods and transitions, we must also consider the CARRY FORWARDS, people with whatever ethnic conscious at that time be it, Hellenic, Muslim, Bulgarian, Maco, Vlach etc.
 
Indeed, the CARRY FORWARDS are extremely valid.
The Greeks have a unique and extra special reason to thank Orthodoxy more so than any other ethnic group.
 
Let me start with the last point. You wrote earlier :

"Rather than a natural erosion of identity after moving country, we are talking about indigenous people losing their identity. This is prevalent in Greece and at least 10 times faster than any other region on the Balkans."

I asked you then whether you could back that up. You said you would but didn't have time then. You must have forgotten about that. I hope you do have time now, probably a hundred posts later. Do I need to enlighten you any more on that? I am asking you this because of the pattern I see of unsubstantiated claims from your side.

Going back to the top point by point:

- Alexander did not drop spreading Hellinism, even if he flirted with other cultures such as the Persian and he never started spreading other. This has nothing to do with his early date of death. But if you have other information that disproves what I say, please educate me.

- Whatever might have happened ... as you say is just another example of your unsubstantiated claims. I do not hear that much clear evidence from you. A lot of speculation, instead of looking at the obvious evidence (such as the spread of civilization that you somehow are trying to disprove)

- As for the use of language: Me calling Koine Greek is not the problem here. The problem is your reaction. Greek is one of the languages with clear continuity. Modern Greek is not Koine, it is the result of thousands of years of development and continuity and Koine was one of the phases it went through. This applies to many languages and Greek is no exception.

- If antiquity bores you as you say, why did you bring it up in this thread where I was just objecting to you guys calling Greek refugees Turkish Christians. ( I repeat so that it is 100% clear to you: you are not the worst offender at all but you seem to defend it). I mentioned several times that we are drifting from the original point but you seem to want to carry on.

- The usage of French in Greece and in Russia: You are conveniently missing a very important point. In both cases of Greece and Russia, we know that their own languages were spoken by anybody else then aristocrats or elite. (or whover wanted to pass as such)
In the case of Macedonians, we have no clue what that mysterious language sounded like, how it is written, ... nothing. I claim that in those days (the glory days of Macedonians) that is impossible.
It is impossible to simply lose a complete language even of we buy your theory that their 'elite' communicated in another than their own. So I do not accept that example: from my point of view it is disqualified.

- You confusing story about Turks, Germans, and Italian mass.... Again a lot of ' If's and but's '.

No one will say that Germans were Italians because the Roman Catholic part of the German population held masses in Latin 50 years ago, here you go again drifting away with fantastic claims.
Half of today's Germany was atheist 50 years ago Risto, when they were called the DDR. I believe that only in Yuguslavia churches were founded by atheists, the others did their best to suppress them. Then you forget that actually many Germans are not Roman Catholic but Protestant which originated in Germany. But never mind, let's not go into details, you are making a point. And my point is that again we see a lot of speculation from your side instead of looking at the obvious that is right in front of you.You are not short of imagination. Trust me, no one will say they were Italian because of the Roman Catholic masses. (like the will not think that in any of the other countries where they held masses in Latin. Latin is no Italian and Turks will not take over Germany, even if they have a large population. here you go again ...

The Turks in Germany will eventually lose links with their homeland, and the 2nd generation is already losing the ability to speak correct Turkish. They will be integrated, and some will go back depending on the economic development in Turkey. When that process is finished then they will not call it cultural genocide. They will say that Turks were successfully absorbed into the German society.

Nice day to you Risto, looking forward to new fantastic revelations from your side.

Giorikas
 
Nice day to you Risto, looking forward to new fantastic revelations from your side.

Giorikas

gee what going on here young risto veliki. chummy with greek posters is not a good look bro. he is a white fellow bro, a hellene wannaaabbee, dangerous avec une accent francais.
 
gee what going on here young risto veliki. chummy with greek posters is not a good look bro. he is a white fellow bro, a hellene wannaaabbee, dangerous avec une accent francais.

I am not an Australian if that's what you mean. I am glad that I am now just a wannabee Hellene and not a wannabee Christian Turk. That's what I call progress.

Good day to you too Osiris.

Giorikas
 
i have no problem with whatever you feel you are giorikas, i am more than happy for you to be a hellene. its your right as a human being to self identify, it strikes at the most basic existential feelings of ego. to paraphrase descartes.

i think whatever i am. therefore i am.

be well giorikas and be what you think you are, thats what is most important, not what i think or what i think some historian or knowledgable person may think.

i think i am a macedonian, and if it did not affetc the human righst of some people today it would not bother me how greeks felt about my identity. my identity is mine and no one can give or take it away.
 
"Rather than a natural erosion of identity after moving country, we are talking about indigenous people losing their identity. This is prevalent in Greece and at least 10 times faster than any other region on the Balkans."

I asked you then whether you could back that up. You said you would but didn't have time then. You must have forgotten about that. I hope you do have time now, probably a hundred posts later. Do I need to enlighten you any more on that? I am asking you this because of the pattern I see of unsubstantiated claims from your side.
Now I know what you are talking about. You should re-read what you stated a few posts ago in relation to this. It was very different and certainly not as clear as this. Well done.

Well, the massive population transplant was unheard of in the 20th century except for in Greece. To have an influx of people who constituted something like 50% of the revised population from elsewhere mixed into your villages and cities was unheard of. The fact that they were paid to spy on the native population and report them to authorities for speaking their native languages amongst other things ... accelerated the transformation of these people like no other place in the Balkans much less in Europe. 10 times faster? Hey maybe 100 times faster. How do you propose I measure it? The only country (not in Europe) that comes close is Israel. How on Earth all those Yiddish speakers became 100% Israelis is beyond me. Did such a population transplant exist anywhere else in the Balkans last century? Deny all you like, but the Greek experiment of the 20th century appears to have paid off. Please don't use it as an example of continuity though.

- Alexander did not drop spreading Hellinism, even if he flirted with other cultures such as the Persian and he never started spreading other. This has nothing to do with his early date of death. But if you have other information that disproves what I say, please educate me.
Define the Hellenism Alexander spread, and be sure to identify how it departed from modern Western civilisation. Wow, what a deep discussion that would make. What I am saying is that if we take Hellenism as a pre-cursor to Western civilisation (and many do) then the "civilisation" that Alexander spread can hardly belong to a single ethnicity. Do Greeks claim Western civilisation too? You are using very Philhellenic ideals to look back at history.

Go and have a look at the excellent work "True Macedonian" has posted of late on Maknews if you want to see how easily proven the Hellenes were long gone from the country now called Greece.


- As for the use of language: Me calling Koine Greek is not the problem here. The problem is your reaction. Greek is one of the languages with clear continuity. Modern Greek is not Koine, it is the result of thousands of years of development and continuity and Koine was one of the phases it went through. This applies to many languages and Greek is no exception.
No, I know modern Greek is not Koine, Thanks for finally admitting it. We have progress.

- If antiquity bores you as you say, why did you bring it up in this thread where I was just objecting to you guys calling Greek refugees Turkish Christians. ( I repeat so that it is 100% clear to you: you are not the worst offender at all but you seem to defend it). I mentioned several times that we are drifting from the original point but you seem to want to carry on.
Why don't you read the first post in this thread? Where do you see anything about Christian Turks? I see something about "5 million years of Hellenic bullshit" ... your objections have nothing to do with the intent of this thread. Is your Ego too much to accept this?

You keep wanting to defend that hotchpotch of potential ethnicities from Turkey. You must have an affinity for them. Even though they are completely diverse groups of people, they are Greeks to you mostly because of church affiliations. I am bored with your pet project here.

- The usage of French in Greece and in Russia: You are conveniently missing a very important point. In both cases of Greece and Russia, we know that their own languages were spoken by anybody else then aristocrats or elite. (or whover wanted to pass as such)
In the case of Macedonians, we have no clue what that mysterious language sounded like, how it is written, ... nothing. I claim that in those days (the glory days of Macedonians) that is impossible.
It is impossible to simply lose a complete language even of we buy your theory that their 'elite' communicated in another than their own. So I do not accept that example: from my point of view it is disqualified.
We know that the Macedonians spoke in a language different to the Hellenes. We know they did it 1000 years before a written language that the entire slavic world used was developed. Are you saying the Russians did not exist until those little monks from Macedonia gave them a written language? Whatever the language the Ancient Macedonians spoke in was, it does not look like it was a written language. Very hard to comprehend in today's day and age, but not 2000 years ago.


- You confusing story about Turks, Germans, and Italian mass.... Again a lot of ' If's and but's '.

No one will say that Germans were Italians because the Roman Catholic part of the German population held masses in Latin 50 years ago, here you go again drifting away with fantastic claims.
Half of today's Germany was atheist 50 years ago Risto, when they were called the DDR. I believe that only in Yuguslavia churches were founded by atheists, the others did their best to suppress them. Then you forget that actually many Germans are not Roman Catholic but Protestant which originated in Germany. But never mind, let's not go into details, you are making a point. And my point is that again we see a lot of speculation from your side instead of looking at the obvious that is right in front of you.You are not short of imagination. Trust me, no one will say they were Italian because of the Roman Catholic masses. (like the will not think that in any of the other countries where they held masses in Latin. Latin is no Italian and Turks will not take over Germany, even if they have a large population. here you go again ...
It was a silly example. I should have used a Turkish population that spoke Turkish every day but went to the church and listened to sermons in Koine. Who then move to Greece and became Greeks. Totally confusing ... lots of ifs and buts.


The Turks in Germany will eventually lose links with their homeland, and the 2nd generation is already losing the ability to speak correct Turkish
Imagine if half of Germany's population was Turkish. One wonders how different things would become in Germany. We can draw obvious parallels but the difference is that the people that were imported into Macedonia from Turkey were different races that could not even be grouped into a singular category. The best way for them to survive was to learn the language and ways of their new master ... Mother Ellada.
 
- I am glad you understood your own post. Your theories are not what I asked then. I asked whether you could back it up, and we specifically talked about figures. Do you know what the population was before we ethincally cleansed you as you claim? And do you know the population now?

- Hellinism: We are running around in circles here and you deny so it seems things that are right in front of you. I am not talking about vague unsubstantiated theories à la Risto but facts. Now you want me to define Hellinism ...
We've been through this but ok, I will repeat it again:
In short, I define Hellism as spreading Greek / Hellenic culture and civilization. I have broken it down above into different aspects in the previous messages. Feel free to read back. And I have given perfectly ligitimate examples in my previous messages. I can accept the obvious, namely that you hate anything to do with Greece, but what you are trying to do here compromises your crediblity. You might not like it but fact is that Macedonians did spread Hellinism. (Greek / Hellenic culture and civilization)

- Koine: I have never said that Koine and Greek is the same. Greek ( or modern Greek if you want) happens to be a language that we can trace back easily in all it's different forms, regardless whether we talk about Koine, Attic, Doric etc. Like all languages, Modern Greek has (even recently) gone through changes and this is what we call continuity. What exactly is your problem with all this and what are you exactly suggesting here?

- You are right, the subject to this thread had nothing to do with the improper use of the term ' Christian Turks'. Fact remain that you brought up antiquity when discussing with me. So complain to the Great Risto.

- You seem to know that Macedonians spoke a different language then Hellenes. That is interesting, since (as you admit) there is no record of that at all. A handful of comments that can be interpreted any way one likes are hardly proof of an existance of a spoken language. So we do not know that at all for sure what you claim.
Admitting the obvious, that it seems not to have been a written language will not save you on that one. ..

- I am not saying Russian is not a language because they had no script to write it in.
On the contrary, the language is alive and kicking today. There is no comparison. I did not say that that Macedonian could never have been a language because there is no written evidence. There is no evidence at all, neither written nor spoken. Period. It's wishful thinking from your side. If you have evidence, please bring it forward.

- Ah, the Christian Turks theory revived now in your last paragraph....

Honestly Risto, let it go. Tell me something, if half of the 'indiginous' slav speaking population was expelled/murdered as you say, and the other half replaced with Turkish Christian settlers, who in the name of God was around to learn the Turkish Christians Greek, and to force the 'indiginous' slav speaking population to speak Greek. Do you realise how far fetched that is? On top of that, I learned from you all that Greece (ex-Macedonia) was full of Vlach and Albanian speakers, so who the hell was teaching what to whom?
Risto, no offence, but honestly, have you never wondered whether you have not spend an hour or so too much behind your PC?
Have you not wondered whether you are trying to convince yourself most of all, since you do not seem to convince any Greeks nor the neutral reader ( who will not visit any of these sites in the first place).
 
Last edited:
i have no problem with whatever you feel you are giorikas, i am more than happy for you to be a hellene. its your right as a human being to self identify, it strikes at the most basic existential feelings of ego. to paraphrase descartes.

i think whatever i am. therefore i am.

be well giorikas and be what you think you are, thats what is most important, not what i think or what i think some historian or knowledgable person may think.

i think i am a macedonian, and if it did not affetc the human righst of some people today it would not bother me how greeks felt about my identity. my identity is mine and no one can give or take it away.

Thank you Osiris.
 
I will deal with all of your issues, but for now:

- Hellinism: We are running around in circles here and you deny so it seems things that are right in front of you. I am not talking about vague unsubstantiated theories à la Risto but facts. Now you want me to define Hellinism ...
We've been through this but ok, I will repeat it again:
In short, I define Hellism as spreading Greek / Hellenic culture and civilization. I have broken it down above into different aspects in the previous messages. Feel free to read back. And I have given perfectly ligitimate examples in my previous messages. I can accept the obvious, namely that you hate anything to do with Greece, but what you are trying to do here compromises your crediblity. You might not like it but fact is that Macedonians did spread Hellinism. (Greek / Hellenic culture and civilization)

You keep wanting to write "Greek/Hellenic". And I know you really want to say Greek = Hellenic. Surely you agree this is extremely misleading. Like saying the Saxons = English.

The "Hellenistic" period of Alexander saw the introduction of Egyptian, Syrian etc. Gods. Who were naturalised amd became part of the "Hellenic dreamtime". So, with the spread of Hellenism came an absorption of new cultures, religions etc. You don't want to hear this because the picture you are attempting to paint is one where everyone became modern Greeks 2300 years ago and abandoned their native cultures. This ability to Hellenise the most foreign of cultural practices may well be a defining characteristic of Greeks after all. We even have Greek coffee nowadays ... a new God to worship.

Hey, I bet you even feel Hellenism never stopped when Byzantium commenced (much less Roman). C'mon, give me an honest answer here. I also wonder if you could even begin to describe the impact of Western Civilisation on the world. What is it? McDonalds?

So, in conclusion to your myths presented above, the spread of Hellenism as defined by you was merely a mingling of numerous cultures. I am sure you will never accept this. But the reality and the dream that is Hellenism are two very different things.
 
I will deal with all of your issues, but for now:



You keep wanting to write "Greek/Hellenic". And I know you really want to say Greek = Hellenic. Surely you agree this is extremely misleading. Like saying the Saxons = English.

The "Hellenistic" period of Alexander saw the introduction of Egyptian, Syrian etc. Gods. Who were naturalised amd became part of the "Hellenic dreamtime". So, with the spread of Hellenism came an absorption of new cultures, religions etc. You don't want to hear this because the picture you are attempting to paint is one where everyone became modern Greeks 2300 years ago and abandoned their native cultures. This ability to Hellenise the most foreign of cultural practices may well be a defining characteristic of Greeks after all. We even have Greek coffee nowadays ... a new God to worship.

Hey, I bet you even feel Hellenism never stopped when Byzantium commenced (much less Roman). C'mon, give me an honest answer here. I also wonder if you could even begin to describe the impact of Western Civilisation on the world. What is it? McDonalds?

So, in conclusion to your myths presented above, the spread of Hellenism as defined by you was merely a mingling of numerous cultures. I am sure you will never accept this. But the reality and the dream that is Hellenism are two very different things.

Nothing of what you say makes what I say (the spread of Hellinism) less likely Risto.
It looks to me that in all these messages you are trying to say: There was no Hellinism, there were no Hellenes, and whatever they spoke, wrote, built, and thought was invented by others in the first place. And all that, that really didn't happen had nothing to do with modern Greeks who do not exist either but are really converted Turks who were converted by non Greek speaking Albanians.

Have you any idea how that sounds? You might think differently but I really hope that many will read your ideas ...
 
Ancient Hellenes or whatever, the fact still remains that your 4000 years of continuous history in the country that that you call greece is a load of shit. There has always been a Macedonia. But greece is hardly 200 years old.

Now. What part of greece are you from Gorillas?
 
Back
Top