• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Is Macedonia Important?

Vangelovski,

The elephant in the room isn't the shiptari nor Macedonian incompetence...it's the USA.
You're far too dismissive of the role the US has played in the destabilisation of Macedonia since independence.

I agree, but I would not single out only the USA.
 
As i said before the timing and events passed are more then coincidences (in my opinion). Viktor Orban from Hungary being attacked by the Western Union and USA for 'poor human rights' and being called 'mini-putin', the unrest in Macedonia and smear campaign towards the current government.

In a Euronews article, the European Commission President called Orban a dictator.

Hello, Dictator! That was the greeting Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban received on Friday from none other than the President of the European Commission, Jean-Claude Juncker.

The lack of respect for a head of state is conspicuous. But this does not surprise me or you. Western Europe has no respect for the other half of Europe.

Big Bad Sven said:
Or the fact that The west pressured Bulgaria out of South Stream and now is doing the same to Greece and Hungary. We dont know what is happening in macedonia and who is behind it but it wouldn't be far fetched this is another method the west is using to force macedonia out of the turkish-stream.

But on the Albanians to be honest it was american support that one them the Kosovo war, and it was american support that won them the macedonian 'civil war' in 2001. Why did the the US help buss of the terrorists to safety in 2001 when they close to being defeated by the Macedonian army? Why did the USA do everything they could to make the referendum of 2004 fail?

Why does the west still refer to albanian terrorists as 'armed men' but not terrorists? Why does western media still continue the lie of poor oppressed albanians? Why do they push for a 'switzerland of the balkans"?

Maybe im too cynical but i have lost faith in Western Europe and the USA. It seems they have already made their plans for the Balkans and macedonia is either the 'bad guy' of simply something that is annoying and needs to be disposed of.

Good comments.

What is clear is that without outside intervention, Kosovo would not exist and Albanian ambitions would be null and void.

I think the trap many of us fall for is to analyze world politics purely in black and white terms. Macedonians have fallen for this time and again.

The Macedonian people are divided between the West and the East. Some are pro-West and some are pro-Russia.

This is silly.

Neither side cares for Macedonia. The idea that Russia is our friend because they speak a Slavic language is a serious error in judgment.

Where was Russia when Serbia was being bombed by NATO?

Russia is not our friend and neither is the USA.
 
I stumbled across these photos on a social media site. Photos of the recent incident in Kumanovo. They were taken by an Albanian....alleged to be "A Drug Dealer" and "untouchable"
This Albanian commented on his own photo....calling these Macedonian police "weasels" where one of his Albanian mates label them "kafsht" Google translate from Albanian to English is "Beasts" most likely meaning Animals. Let's not forget.....these so called "Weasels" and "animals" ......took measures (which cost police lives) inorder for no civilian get hurt or killed. Civilians that were if not all, large majority of his kin....Ethnic Albanians








In this next photo, we can see how close he was to where the terrorists were hiding. Now im speculating....but if true this Albanian taking these photos is someone with a dark history and lived so close to the heart of the action....I would not be surprised one bit if he previously knew about these terrorists or even housed some of them leading up to the incident.





As I looked further into his photo collection.....I almost fell off my chair when I stumbled across this one. He him self together with............





Zaev is nothing but a opportunistic dangerous man, who needs to be locked up permanently or driven out of Macedonia for good. I would love to wish him assassinated.....but the Christian in me stops me from going that far. Looks like he needs the Albanians on his side....Albanians are more than happy to use him temporarily.

Tom.......did the American's make Zaev promise Albanian language classes for all students?
With Soros funding the opposition demonstration, and Zaev leading this destabilisation anti government movement....it's highly likely Zaev the puppet is following some kind of orders from the west. How does he benefit? A) he benefits financially B) This opportunistic traitor will become a proxy leader (which I'm sure he wouldn't mind that) of a country.
 
Last edited:
What is clear is that without outside intervention, Kosovo would not exist and Albanian ambitions would be null and void.
Kosovo might not have existed without NATO intervention, but Albanian ambitions would not have ended there. The West didn't create Albanian extremism and they certainly don't control it either.

Western and Russian interests may try and push circumstances one way or another in the Balkans when they see an opportunity, but its really not something we can influence directly. If we take care of our Albanian problem and our slave mentality, then we will have a lot less that foreign powers can work with. And I think the ones we really have to worry about are not the US/Europe or Russia, but our more immediate neighbours.
 
Kosovo might not have existed without NATO intervention, but Albanian ambitions would not have ended there. The West didn't create Albanian extremism and they certainly don't control it either.

I think you missed the point. I'm not arguing Albanian ambitions would not exist; they would. What I'm arguing is that Albanian ambitions would not amount to anything, much like Kosovo would never have existed as a separate state apart from outside intervention. In order for either or both to succeed, outside intervention is required.

Vangelovski said:
Western and Russian interests may try and push circumstances one way or another in the Balkans when they see an opportunity, but its really not something we can influence directly. If we take care of our Albanian problem and our slave mentality, then we will have a lot less that foreign powers can work with. And I think the ones we really have to worry about are not the US/Europe or Russia, but our more immediate neighbours.

The problem with your analysis (in my opinion) is that you are analyzing the present problems in Macedonia in a vacuum. All you see are Albanians and Macedonians. There is no real room for outside intervention in your mind. You should not preclude the idea of outside intervention.

You say we should take care of our Albanian problem, but how? You do realize that what Macedonia does will be published all over the world? What do you propose? Banning the Albanian language, expelling Albanians from Macedonia, and asserting our national identity? If we did these things, we would be accused of ethnic cleansing. Then what? You really think our immediate neighbours should be our concern?

Macedonia is a small inconsequential country with a disputed name and with limited resources. Do you think the media will be pro-Macedonia or pro-Albania? You really think the US and the EU would not intervene?
 
Last edited:
I think you missed the point. I'm not arguing Albanian ambitions would not exist; they would. What I'm arguing is that Albanian ambitions would not amount to anything, much like Kosovo would never have existed as a separate state apart from outside intervention. In order for either or both to succeed, outside intervention is required.
I don't think we could say definitively whether Kosovo would or would not have existed without outside intervention. But that's a whole different topic.

The problem with your analysis (in my opinion) is that you are analyzing the present problems in Macedonia in a vacuum. All you see are Albanians and Macedonians. There is no real room for outside intervention in your mind. You should not preclude the idea of outside intervention.

You say we should take care of our Albanian problem, but how? You do realize that what Macedonia does will be published all over the world? What do you propose? Banning the Albanian language, expelling Albanians from Macedonia, and asserting our national identity? If we did these things, we would be accused of ethnic cleansing. Then what? You really think our immediate neighbours should be our concern?

Macedonia is a small inconsequential country with a disputed name and with limited resources. Do you think the media will be pro-Macedonia or pro-Albania? You really think the US and the EU would not intervene?
I don't think you've read many of my thousands of posts relating to the Albanians. Certainly I'm not going to try and summarise them all here.

If you are afraid of great power intervention, then why not just give up? Why even bother? If they pull all the strings like puppet masters, then what they want will happen and the poor little Macedonians will be victims of their power games (again?). No need to do anything, or even concern ourselves with Macedonian affairs on an intellectual level, as its all been planned out by our masters in Washington, Brussels and Moscow. Lets just shrug our shoulders and hope some bread scraps are thrown our way. After all, were just "a small inconsequential country with a disputed name and with limited resources".

When I asked the question 'Is Macedonia important?', it was in a geo-strategic sense looking at the US, Europe and Russia and if so, to what extent. Just as a side note, I do not categorise the US and Europe as one behemoth "west" as their interests don't really correspond. I would also not categories Europe as one behemoth mass as there are many competing interests within it.

But is Macedonia important enough to the US, Europe and Russia for one or more of them to orchestrate the phone taps and Kumanovo, forgetting the fact that events such as these have happened dozens of times (hundreds if you count all the bombings) without the need for foreign interference? The majority of opinion here seems to be yes. The only reason provided is Turkish stream. Tomche Makedonche made a very good point on this thread but it was ignored by everyone. I wanted to see whether anyone would actually do the research that he suggested (which is required in order to produce a semi-intelligent analysis of whether Turkish stream really does fit in with the thinking that Macedonia has stepped into a US/Russia dispute). Doesn't seem like anyone took up the task.

Seems like the consensus on here is that Turkish stream is a purely (evil) Russian operation to force (evil) Europe to buy gas it doesn't want to buy and the (evil) Americans are doing everything they can to stop the (evil) Russians like manipulating poor Zaev and the highly misunderstood Albanians to destabalise a country which has never actually been stable. To say the least, this idea is missing a few details, has obvious logical and factual problems and doesn't quite fit the reality on the ground.

Might be time for some on here to actually take a trip to Macedonia. Go this northern summer. But don't just hang out in cafe's with your relo's. Get into the thick of things. Go to Struga, Gostivar, Tetovo, Skopje and Kumanovo. Check out some of their villages - Albanian ones. Talk to the people there. Speak to the local officials. Talk to DUI/DPA party officials. Chat to the Imams. Speak to the local police. Read some books - preferably non-fiction. Talk to some of the guys with the long beards, white robes and funny hats. Dig, prod and challenge. Ask them how much of a F**k they give about what Washington or Moscow think they should do or how they should live.
 
You mentioned what you believed the "general consensus to be, and to be honest I'm a bit baffled how you got to that conclusion. There are only 2 or 3 commentators who really fit into your generalization. The other 2 or 3 including myself are much closer to your own view than the opposite. If you want to address someone specific than just go ahead and do it, no need to lump everyone in.

I happen to agree with you for the most part except I'm a little more open minded to alternative explanation but if I had to pick one and only one explanation I'd say:

The Albanian problem in the Balkans is more than a 100 years old, anyone who cant admit that is just ignorant. Yes they have had heavy support from the US in the last 20-30 years, and maybe the only reason they have a Kosovo is because of US/NATO intervention, but had there no been intervention they would probably still be at war to this day and thus there would still be a problem. So you right that regardless of outside support, the agenda is the same, they are militant by nature, and don't need any help. It might be harder for them but they will still rebel. The reason they don't fit in anywhere and the reason they are militant is because they are Muslim and we are not. This fact alone would be enough to cause tension. There language and culture is very different from ours, so again, we have almost nothing in common.

The USA or anyone else for that matter can meddle only to a certain degree, the best they can do is exploit and play both sides of a conflict. Usually they cant just create a conflict out of thin air. The Albanians who attacked Kumanovo had probably wanted to and planned to on their on, the only way the US could have gotten involved is to give them through third parties weapons and gear. No one goes into a mini war which is highly likely to get them killed for any other reason, other than if they want to. You cant pay people to go and die, you cant force them into it.

Where I think we see outside meddling is where Zaev is concerned. He is corrupt and dumb all on his own, but I think he is being egged on with promises of Western support if he makes it to the top. I think they are giving him advice, and maybe favorable press, and maybe even some money to organize better protests, but he is still corrupt and stupid by his own free will and any idiotic idea he says could just as easily be his own. This type of meddling is normal I would think. At the end of the day Zaev still has to win an election with the approval of Macedonians. The USA cant force that, they can support and prop up any which candidate they want but at the end of the day its still up to the citizens of Macedonia to decide.

I also agree that it is kind of slavish and defeatist to say that the "great powers" control everything, if that was the case then like you said, why bother? And like I said, if they were so powerful and controlling then a tiny shit hole like Macedonia would cease to exist if we got in their way, which is what many are saying we are doing by opposing the Albanians and by supporting the Russian pipeline.

If one thing you said is 100% true then it was that if Macedonia got its shit together then there would be less for the larger players to exploit. They can only exert pressure if there is leverage.


I don't think we could say definitively whether Kosovo would or would not have existed without outside intervention. But that's a whole different topic.

I don't think you've read many of my thousands of posts relating to the Albanians. Certainly I'm not going to try and summarise them all here.

If you are afraid of great power intervention, then why not just give up? Why even bother? If they pull all the strings like puppet masters, then what they want will happen and the poor little Macedonians will be victims of their power games (again?). No need to do anything, or even concern ourselves with Macedonian affairs on an intellectual level, as its all been planned out by our masters in Washington, Brussels and Moscow. Lets just shrug our shoulders and hope some bread scraps are thrown our way. After all, were just "a small inconsequential country with a disputed name and with limited resources".

When I asked the question 'Is Macedonia important?', it was in a geo-strategic sense looking at the US, Europe and Russia and if so, to what extent. Just as a side note, I do not categorise the US and Europe as one behemoth "west" as their interests don't really correspond. I would also not categories Europe as one behemoth mass as there are many competing interests within it.

But is Macedonia important enough to the US, Europe and Russia for one or more of them to orchestrate the phone taps and Kumanovo, forgetting the fact that events such as these have happened dozens of times (hundreds if you count all the bombings) without the need for foreign interference? The majority of opinion here seems to be yes. The only reason provided is Turkish stream. Tomche Makedonche made a very good point on this thread but it was ignored by everyone. I wanted to see whether anyone would actually do the research that he suggested (which is required in order to produce a semi-intelligent analysis of whether Turkish stream really does fit in with the thinking that Macedonia has stepped into a US/Russia dispute). Doesn't seem like anyone took up the task.

Seems like the consensus on here is that Turkish stream is a purely (evil) Russian operation to force (evil) Europe to buy gas it doesn't want to buy and the (evil) Americans are doing everything they can to stop the (evil) Russians like manipulating poor Zaev and the highly misunderstood Albanians to destabalise a country which has never actually been stable. To say the least, this idea is missing a few details, has obvious logical and factual problems and doesn't quite fit the reality on the ground.

Might be time for some on here to actually take a trip to Macedonia. Go this northern summer. But don't just hang out in cafe's with your relo's. Get into the thick of things. Go to Struga, Gostivar, Tetovo, Skopje and Kumanovo. Check out some of their villages - Albanian ones. Talk to the people there. Speak to the local officials. Talk to DUI/DPA party officials. Chat to the Imams. Speak to the local police. Read some books - preferably non-fiction. Talk to some of the guys with the long beards, white robes and funny hats. Dig, prod and challenge. Ask them how much of a F**k they give about what Washington or Moscow think they should do or how they should live.
 
That proves no one from Russia or the us cares enough to commit to anything in Macedonia.We are virtually irrelevant.The fact that there is aname dispute with the neighbours does not bother anyone else.Yes we are irrelevant I'm sure they don't want to commit their troops for us.
 
You mentioned what you believed the "general consensus to be, and to be honest I'm a bit baffled how you got to that conclusion. There are only 2 or 3 commentators who really fit into your generalization. The other 2 or 3 including myself are much closer to your own view than the opposite. If you want to address someone specific than just go ahead and do it, no need to lump everyone in.
By general consensus I mean most, not all. I certainly wouldn't lump you into that category either. And I'm looking at all the threads on here, not just this one.

The USA or anyone else for that matter can meddle only to a certain degree, the best they can do is exploit and play both sides of a conflict. Usually they cant just create a conflict out of thin air. The Albanians who attacked Kumanovo had probably wanted to and planned to on their on, the only way the US could have gotten involved is to give them through third parties weapons and gear. No one goes into a mini war which is highly likely to get them killed for any other reason, other than if they want to. You cant pay people to go and die, you cant force them into it.
I agree. With regards to Kumanovo, I think the only outside support they got was from Kosovo-based paramilitaries and at most, the Kosovo Government, but I highly doubt the latter.

Where I think we see outside meddling is where Zaev is concerned. He is corrupt and dumb all on his own, but I think he is being egged on with promises of Western support if he makes it to the top. I think they are giving him advice, and maybe favorable press, and maybe even some money to organize better protests, but he is still corrupt and stupid by his own free will and any idiotic idea he says could just as easily be his own. This type of meddling is normal I would think. At the end of the day Zaev still has to win an election with the approval of Macedonians. The USA cant force that, they can support and prop up any which candidate they want but at the end of the day its still up to the citizens of Macedonia to decide.
I agree. I'm pretty sure that Zaev is accepting American advice and is probably grateful enough to make some promises. Where he sourced the phone taps and whether they are genuine is an open question as far as I'm concerned.

Its quite possible, considering that most of Macedonian intelligence is left over from the UDBa days many of them are still linked to SDSM and their old CPM comrades. Gligorov and Crvenkovski controlled the intelligence services, even during the 1998-2002 DPMNE Government. Since Gruevski came to power and Mijalkov's accession to Director of Intelligence, DPMNE gained some control over them, but the old networks between comrades in SDSM and the intelligence services no doubt remained and its possible that they continued to run their own show, as they did during the Georgievski Government.

If one thing you said is 100% true then it was that if Macedonia got its shit together then there would be less for the larger players to exploit. They can only exert pressure if there is leverage.
This is the one thing Macedonians can try to change and have a chance of success. Even if the most outlandish conspiracy theories were true, we would have little hope of making a difference in the thinking/planning in Washington, Brussels or Moscow.
 
The international community typically doesn't start these problems; certain governments just do their best to capitalize on them, and usually not to the benefit of the Macedonians when Macedonians are involved. Some political tension and a day long fight with terrorists, and now most every Western commentator is calling for some sort of intervention -- be it political or more -- in Macedonia to "save it from falling apart." NATO is still seeking to expand; the EU wants to feel important and credible; and Russia is sick of being "2nd" to the US. I don't know how all this plays into the specifics of the current Macedonian situation. I am pretty confident, though, that these countries' involvement -- to whatever extent it is at now and will be in the future -- is more about financial and political goals than it is about democracy, freedom and equality in Macedonia.
 
Vangelovsk said:
I don't think we could say definitively whether Kosovo would or would not have existed without outside intervention.

Definitive may be too strong a word, but the creation of a Kosovo state without outside intervention is fairly close to definitive.

Vangelovski said:
But that's a whole different topic.

Not necessarily.

Let me ask you something.

Do you believe NATO intervened in regard to the Kosovors because their cause was just? Was this a principled stand of the United States and Europe against Milosevic and the evil Serbs?

Or do you believe NATO intervened because there was geopolitical reasons involved?

Vangelovski said:
I don't think you've read many of my thousands of posts relating to the Albanians. Certainly I'm not going to try and summarise them all here.

Obviously not.

But maybe you can briefly summarize them?

Vangelovski said:
If you are afraid of great power intervention, then why not just give up? Why even bother? If they pull all the strings like puppet masters, then what they want will happen and the poor little Macedonians will be victims of their power games (again?). No need to do anything, or even concern ourselves with Macedonian affairs on an intellectual level, as its all been planned out by our masters in Washington, Brussels and Moscow. Lets just shrug our shoulders and hope some bread scraps are thrown our way. After all, were just "a small inconsequential country with a disputed name and with limited resources".

I find these statements a distortion of what I and others have been writing. No one is saying that Macedonia should not deal with the Albanian problem. It should. All I am saying is that whatever actions the Macedonian government makes on this issue will not be in a vacuum. You cannot seriously think Macedonia can do what it wants and not face repercussions, which can include economic sanctions and war.

I will again bring out the example of the creation of a Kosovo state.

Vangelovski said:
But is Macedonia important enough to the US, Europe and Russia for one or more of them to orchestrate the phone taps and Kumanovo, forgetting the fact that events such as these have happened dozens of times (hundreds if you count all the bombings) without the need for foreign interference? The majority of opinion here seems to be yes. The only reason provided is Turkish stream. Tomche Makedonche made a very good point on this thread but it was ignored by everyone. I wanted to see whether anyone would actually do the research that he suggested (which is required in order to produce a semi-intelligent analysis of whether Turkish stream really does fit in with the thinking that Macedonia has stepped into a US/Russia dispute). Doesn't seem like anyone took up the task.

Whether or not the Macedonian government illegally intercepted the communications of Macedonians is not the central issue here. I do not deny that governments do this. The issue here is Zoran Zaev. Zaev is backed by George Soros, a man whose philanthropic work is (among other things) in promoting color revolutions. He openly admitted it as much on CNN in regard to Ukraine. Soros' Open Society works closely with the CIA. That America would finance and foment Albanian terrorists and work to overthrew a government that is pro Turkish Stream and pro-Russia in favor of a government pro-West and anti-Turkish Stream is not inconsistent with American history.

Why was Mosaddeg overthrown in 1953? Why would America, England, and other Western powers overthrow a democratically elected government and install an Islamic dictator? Geopolitical interests?

Was Iran important enough?

If so, what commonality is there between Iran and Macedonia? Oil? Geopolitics?

Vangelovski said:
Seems like the consensus on here is that Turkish stream is a purely (evil) Russian operation to force (evil) Europe to buy gas it doesn't want to buy and the (evil) Americans are doing everything they can to stop the (evil) Russians like manipulating poor Zaev and the highly misunderstood Albanians to destabalise a country which has never actually been stable. To say the least, this idea is missing a few details, has obvious logical and factual problems and doesn't quite fit the reality on the ground.

I don't recall anyone speaking of evil Russian forces. America has interests and those interests include isolating Russia. America has its own pipeline ambitions and those do not include Russia. This makes sense from a military, economic, and geopolitical sense. This is why South Stream failed. For America to sabotage Turkish Stream is not inconsistent with American vital interests in the region.
 
Do you believe NATO intervened in regard to the Kosovors because their cause was just? Was this a principled stand of the United States and Europe against Milosevic and the evil Serbs?

Or do you believe NATO intervened because there was geopolitical reasons involved?
I think the Balkan wars were a big headache for the West in general. While everyone complains because they intervene, there is always an expectation that they do intervene and "fix" things. The Croats and Bosnian Muslims were calling for intervention the entire time. When Kosovo opened up, not only did the Albanians want intervention, but there was a large part of the public within western countries that wanted intervention because nothing was done in relation to the chaos and destruction during the Bosnian and Croat wars.

I do think that there was a geo-strategic element to it as well, though as time goes on I'm more and more hard-pressed to work out exactly what that was. Many jump up and down claiming it was to stop Russia from gaining a foothold through Serbia, but Russia has never helped or used Serbia in any meaningful way since the first world war. So I don't really buy that.

Then there is the issue of camp Bondsteel. They can station up to 7,000 soldiers there. They haven't really used it for anything other than its official purpose - to support KFOR. The camp itself is built mainly of wooden, semi permanent SEA (South East Asia) huts. Nothing too flash. Obviously its not deterring anyone from signing up to Russian pipelines either. Nor is it stopping Albanian paramilitaries from operating in the region - nor do they need the camp to enable Albanian paramilitaries from operating in the region.

Maybe you know more about what exactly the west got out of their Kosovo adventure.

Obviously not.

But maybe you can briefly summarize them?
No, not really. Its not a matter of just a few paragraphs. Its much better (for me) if you read what I've already spent hundreds of hours writing up.

You cannot seriously think Macedonia can do what it wants and not face repercussions, which can include economic sanctions and war.
No, I don't. But because you haven't read any of what I have written about our Albanian problem, you've made irrelevant assertions. You've automatically gone to economic sanctions and war without even having the slightest idea of what I have proposed in the past.

However, even if it were to come to economic sanctions and war, that's the problem with freedom. It doesn't come cheap or easy. At some point, a free people need to decide whether they will defend and exercise their freedom or just pack it in. Macedonians have already packed it in, so the discussion is quite mute.

The issue here is Zoran Zaev. Zaev is backed by George Soros, a man whose philanthropic work is (among other things) in promoting color revolutions. He openly admitted it as much on CNN in regard to Ukraine. Soros' Open Society works closely with the CIA. That America would finance and foment Albanian terrorists and work to overthrew a government that is pro Turkish Stream and pro-Russia in favor of a government pro-West and anti-Turkish Stream is not inconsistent with American history.
It might not be inconsistent with American history, but it is inconsistent with Albanian extremism in Macedonia.

Why was Mosaddeg overthrown in 1953? Why would America, England, and other Western powers overthrow a democratically elected government and install an Islamic dictator? Geopolitical interests?

Was Iran important enough?

If so, what commonality is there between Iran and Macedonia? Oil? Geopolitics?
Comparing Macedonia with Iran won't help with a clinical analysis of the situation.

I don't recall anyone speaking of evil Russian forces. America has interests and those interests include isolating Russia. America has its own pipeline ambitions and those do not include Russia. This makes sense from a military, economic, and geopolitical sense. This is why South Stream failed. For America to sabotage Turkish Stream is not inconsistent with American vital interests in the region.
It wouldn't be the first pipeline that has been sabotaged and certainly not the first that the US has sabotaged. But the question is, was there anything to even sabotage with Turkish Stream? If there is, has it really been sabotaged? That pipeline is so far out from development, that Zaev could conceivably run two terms and still miss out on having the opportunity to stop it from going through Macedonia. The Turkish stream proposal was only announced six months ago. Nothing has been agreed to and the technical planning hasn't even begun. So I'm not sure what, if anything, has been sabotaged yet.

What I am fairly confident about is that Kumanovo was not American planned and sponsored. Its typical Albanian. Its not even the first time its happened. Gun battles and bombings in Macedonia are actually quite common. Its just not often that they are so widely reported. Names such as Gostivar, Kale, Vevcani/Struga, Smilkovo, Kondovo and Brodec to name a few should be familiar (and they weren't even during 2001).
 
Last edited:
This might be hard for people who have not lived in the USA to understand but there are two elements to American society, and all these theories focus only on one. Everyone assumes that Americans are greedy and are always driven by economic interests, this is partly true, Americans are pretty greedy, and corporations in the US have a fair amount of influence and through lobbying sometimes get outlandish things to happen. No one really remembers the other part of American society which is that they are incredibly arrogant.

When anyone is in a position of power sooner or later it goes to their head. The US as a nation is no different. The people as a whole have enjoyed the benefits of being at the top for so long that they eventually form a disregard, and a dismissal of anything differing from their own. The average American and probably most of the political establishment cant point to Macedonia or Albania on a map if you gave them 10 chances to do it, yet if you give them a brief explanation of a current event I guarantee you they will have an opinion one way or another. There is a reason that only the US is obsessed with super hero movies. They have this good verse evil type of view toward life, toward the world. Some of it is religiously inspired, but a lot of it has to do with this good an evil world view, where of course the US is good. In fact the term "American Exceptionalism" is quite often used in an official capacity to describe the idea that American are an exception, that what they do is exceptional and that they are unique int he world. I've heard political candidates even criticize their opponents for not being believing that Americans are "exceptional"

Once you understand this mindset, a lot of the things they do around the world begin to make a little more sense. The American people actually put a fair amount of pressure on their political establishment to intervene in certain cases. The questions "should we help" comes of often and during almost every world event. Basically the American public and political establishment feel the need to always pick a side, and this is based on who they deem to be good and evil. There is rarely a middle ground for them. Why do you think the Albanians try so had to present sob stories to western cameras? Because they know that the west eats it up. What Macedonian and Serbs fail to understand is that its not some large conspiracy to "keep us down" or "geopolitical" interests. Americans genuinely believe that we are the bad guys. They genuinely believe that Albanians are oppressed, and that we are the oppressor.

Americans see themselves as the "beacon of light" in a dark world. They have little regard for other people and at the same times feel the need to "help" those in need. Because the US is a mixed nation where all sorts of colors and creeds live together in relative harmony, its impossible for them to fathom what Albanian expansionism is, or the Greek genocide of our identity. Americans don't even understand the concept of ethnicity, they think that nationality and ethnicity are one int he same. They also think that the American way of living is the best way and that it would be best if everyone in the world did the same. Where the arrogance plays a role is that Americans believe that they have a right to intervene in a two party affair. You're walking down the street and you see two people you've never met fighting, how the hell do you know who is the aggressor? Do you know what human nature is? You go and help the underdog. This is America. They truly see themselves as the world police, and they pick sides in conflicts they know nothing about, and they don't care.

Ask an American why "terrorists" want to attack hem. Do you know what the most common answer is? "they attack us because they hate our freedom". This statement in a nutshell describes exactly who Americans are and how they see the rest of the world. Once you understand that statement, you understand what the fuck it is that they do all of the world, the play captain America.
 
Vangelovski said:
I think the Balkan wars were a big headache for the West in general. While everyone complains because they intervene, there is always an expectation that they do intervene and "fix" things. The Croats and Bosnian Muslims were calling for intervention the entire time. When Kosovo opened up, not only did the Albanians want intervention, but there was a large part of the public within western countries that wanted intervention because nothing was done in relation to the chaos and destruction during the Bosnian and Croat wars.

The West wanted that war, and they intervened accordingly. America's humanitarian wars are very selective, and the selection process is rooted in US vital interests. The breakup of Yugoslavia was one of those.

Kosovo is actually rich in natural resources (the fifth largest in lignite in the world). And is instrumental in the US led smuggling of drugs and organized crime in Europe. Not to mention that very large embassy...and military base, the largest US military base outside of the United States since Vietnam, often called Little Guantanamo.

Vangelovski said:
No, not really. Its not a matter of just a few paragraphs. Its much better (for me) if you read what I've already spent hundreds of hours writing up.

Can you cite links to your works?

Vangelovski said:
No, I don't. But because you haven't read any of what I have written about our Albanian problem, you've made irrelevant assertions. You've automatically gone to economic sanctions and war without even having the slightest idea of what I have proposed in the past.

They are not irrelevant assertions. And regardless of what you have proposed, sanctions and war is possible in Macedonia.

Vangelovski said:
However, even if it were to come to economic sanctions and war, that's the problem with freedom. It doesn't come cheap or easy. At some point, a free people need to decide whether they will defend and exercise their freedom or just pack it in. Macedonians have already packed it in, so the discussion is quite mute.

I'm not against a struggle for freedom, but that freedom will come at a price, a price which Macedonians in the Republic may not be willing to make. Economic sanctions will cripple the country even more, and a war will lead to a greater Albania. Even if Macedonia could defeat Albania militarily, it would matter little, as NATO would intervene, and destroy Macedonia, and UN resolutions will carve up Macedonia. Now this does not spell the end, but for a landlocked country with limited resources surrounded by wolves at all sides it is all but the end.

Vangelovski said:
It might not be inconsistent with American history, but it is inconsistent with Albanian extremism in Macedonia.

I do not deny Albanians have ambitions. I do not deny some Albanians are terrorists. But you are mistaken if you believe Albanians act alone. The are funded and armed by Saudi Arabia and the United States and other powers.

Vangelovski said:
Comparing Macedonia with Iran won't help with a clinical analysis of the situation.

What is being discussed here is that oil is a vital interest to America. Macedonia may not have any, but the Turkish Stream will transport oil into Europe through Macedonia. US wants less European dependence on Russian gas. Russia's reserves extends Russia's influence in Europe and America does not want that. Note it is not that Europe does not need Russia's oil and gas; of course it does. But there are those in Europe and America who do not want reliance on Russian reserves. This is why South Stream was killed. And this is why the United States is officially against Turkish Stream.

Vangelovski said:
It wouldn't be the first pipeline that has been sabotaged and certainly not the first that the US has sabotaged. But the question is, was there anything to even sabotage with Turkish Stream? If there is, has it really been sabotaged? That pipeline is so far out from development, that Zaev could conceivably run two terms and still miss out on having the opportunity to stop it from going through Macedonia. The Turkish stream proposal was only announced six months ago. Nothing has been agreed to and the technical planning hasn't even begun. So I'm not sure what, if anything, has been sabotaged yet.

Not true.

The first stage of Russia's Turkish Stream pipeline will be ready by December 2016, state gas giant Gazprom's press office announced

http://www.themoscowtimes.com/busin...peline-to-be-partly-ready-by-2016/520368.html

The Turkish Stream is a continuation of South Stream. In both instances, the pipeline will go under the Black Sea. The idea that this a long time off, like decades or something, is not accurate.

Vangelovski said:
What I am fairly confident about is that Kumanovo was not American planned and sponsored. Its typical Albanian. Its not even the first time its happened. Gun battles and bombings in Macedonia are actually quite common. Its just not often that they are so widely reported. Names such as Gostivar, Kale, Vevcani/Struga, Smilkovo, Kondovo and Brodec to name a few should be familiar (and they weren't even during 2001).

Maybe it was an Albanian operation alone, though I'm not sure whether this matters. We already know Saudi Arabia has been funding the Islamists of the Balkans for years, as have the United States. The problem is that the Albanian operation in Kumanovo is very close to a whole host of scandals in Macedonia, and the Turkish Stream. Maybe some Albanians decided to take up arms. Or maybe someone from Western intelligence fomented them.
 
Wasn't the Kosovo meant to be turned into cantons .This was one proposal and weren't the serbs mean't to be returning. to Kosovo??I'm sure the KLA or UCK would welcome them with open arms.The KLA is rearming and remassing for another war with Macedonia..Instability breeds instability.Anyone thinking that the us or nato will come to our aid has got rocks in their head.Nobody gives a shit re Macedonia.The terrorists want a war and Macedonia is just ripe for the takings.
 
Philosopher,

I think you need to do a lot more research on Macedonia. At this point there are so many inaccuracies in your posts and assumptions based on I'm not sure what, that I don't think there's any point in continuing. For starters, you might want to decide whether Turkish Stream is an oil or gas pipeline.
 
Philosopher,

I think you need to do a lot more research on Macedonia. At this point there are so many inaccuracies in your posts and assumptions based on I'm not sure what, that I don't think there's any point in continuing. For starters, you might want to decide whether Turkish Stream is an oil or gas pipeline.

Not sure of the errors you speak of, but I am sure you will correct them in the spirit of charity.

Gas is produced from crude oil, as is petroleum gas, kerosene, and etc.
 
Assumptions and inaccuracies:

Gas is produced from crude oil, as is petroleum gas, kerosene, and etc.
No, its not. It shares some chemical elements, but natural gas is mostly methane. You might be thinking about American “gas”, which is not the same as natural gas.

The West wanted that war, and they intervened accordingly.
How do you know the “west” wanted the war? Why did they want that war? What did they have to gain from it? What exactly were its ‘vital’ interests in a war in Kosovo? Who exactly do you mean by the “west”? You can’t just say it wanted that war and ignore the detail.

The breakup of Yugoslavia was one of those.
Again, who, why, how, what?

Kosovo is actually rich in natural resources (the fifth largest in lignite in the world).
Its hardly “rich” in natural resources other than lignite – also known as brown coal. And so what? Its main trading partners are Italy, Albania and Macedonia. The rest barely rate a few percentage points of its total exports which are only worth about $400 million – hardly a gold mine so to speak. Are these three countries the “west” exploiting Kosovo?

And is instrumental in the US led smuggling of drugs and organized crime in Europe. Not to mention that very large embassy...and military base, the largest US military base outside of the United States since Vietnam, often called Little Guantanamo.
US led smuggling of drugs? Do you have actual evidence? Or is it just mere speculation and conspiracy theories? You didn’t address anything I wrote about Camp Bondsteel? What exactly is its purpose and how has it been used? If its all that its made out to be by people like Michael Chossudovsky, then the US wouldn’t have to worry about Turkish stream or Russia because it already dominates the region through this base. And I don’t know why people on here keep quoting Chossudovsky!?

Can you cite links to your works?
Of my 7,500 posts on here, I’d say probably around 5,000 are related to the Albanians in Macedonia. As a start, you might want to look at the cause as defined by MTO. As I helped shape it, you’ll find some of my ideas in there about minorities. Other than that, its just gonna have to be the hard slog cause I really can’t be bothered with a that at the moment.

They are not irrelevant assertions. And regardless of what you have proposed, sanctions and war is possible in Macedonia.
You still don’t know what my thinking is, but you’re adamant that your comments are not irrelevant.

I'm not against a struggle for freedom, but that freedom will come at a price, a price which Macedonians in the Republic may not be willing to make. Economic sanctions will cripple the country even more, and a war will lead to a greater Albania. Even if Macedonia could defeat Albania militarily, it would matter little, as NATO would intervene, and destroy Macedonia, and UN resolutions will carve up Macedonia. Now this does not spell the end, but for a landlocked country with limited resources surrounded by wolves at all sides it is all but the end.
You make so many assumptions here and then pass them off as absolute fact that I really don’t know where to begin. But like I said before, the Macedonians have already given up on freedom, so its really a mute point.

I do not deny Albanians have ambitions. I do not deny some Albanians are terrorists. But you are mistaken if you believe Albanians act alone. The are funded and armed by Saudi Arabia and the United States and other powers.
More assumptions passed off as fact. Its known that Saudi Arabia funds some radical Islamists in Macedonia, but I wouldn’t put their number beyond more than a few hundred at most. As for the US, its possible (though I don’t have any actual evidence other than some vague reports) that it provided the NLA with some funds and weapons during 2001. Other than that, I haven’t seen anything concrete other than pure speculation. Other powers? Who are they and what have they done exactly? Who have they funded? What evidence do you actually have or is it all just hearsay and speculation?

What is being discussed here is that oil is a vital interest to America. Macedonia may not have any, but the Turkish Stream will transport oil into Europe through Macedonia. US wants less European dependence on Russian gas. Russia's reserves extends Russia's influence in Europe and America does not want that. Note it is not that Europe does not need Russia's oil and gas; of course it does. But there are those in Europe and America who do not want reliance on Russian reserves. This is why South Stream was killed. And this is why the United States is officially against Turkish Stream.
Does it really extend Russian influence? What has Russia actually gain in terms of policy making from Europe that was a direct or indirect result of their gas supplies? Some leniency? Maybe, but would that have been any different if Europe wasn’t buying any gas from Russia? Given Russia has a considerable nuclear weapons stockpile, I don’t think so.

No one is making Europe buy Russian gas. Europe has the option to build its own pipelines, such as Nabucco, bringing natural gas from the middle east and central asia. I’ve seen other proposed pipelines from Africa. You and everyone else have failed to address these key points. I’ll put them down again:

1. Nobody is forcing Europe to buy Russian gas. Europe can allow Russia to waste its time and money building pipelines and it does not have to buy the additional gas.

2. Europe can build its own pipelines rather than relying on Russian pipelines and already has plans in process.

It does not have to make a mess that it will inevitably have to clean up and pay for.

Not true.

http://www.themoscowtimes.com/busin...peline-to-be-partly-ready-by-2016/520368.html

The Turkish Stream is a continuation of South Stream. In both instances, the pipeline will go under the Black Sea. The idea that this a long time off, like decades or something, is not accurate.
Yes, it is true that Zaev could conceivably run two terms (8 years, not decades) and the pipeline not make it to Macedonia by then. You seem to think you can just dismiss anything you don’t like as if your position is an established fact. I’m yet to see a pipeline (or any government sponsored project) actually be built on time and on budget. That pipeline could in theory be supplying gas to Turkey by 2016. But there is yet no agreement and negotiations on technical aspects of the project are still underway. Even if they had been agreed to, actually building the pipeline “on the ground” is another story and its not unusual for large delays to occur for whatever reason.

Russia would still have to work out all the technical aspects, routes and political agreement with Greece, Macedonia, Serbia before Turkish stream actually reaches the EU. It would then have to actually make an agreement with the EU on a political level and sort through all the EU bureaucratic BS, technical aspects, tender processes etc with EU countries in order to connect up to their gas supply.

Maybe it was an Albanian operation alone, though I'm not sure whether this matters. We already know Saudi Arabia has been funding the Islamists of the Balkans for years, as have the United States. The problem is that the Albanian operation in Kumanovo is very close to a whole host of scandals in Macedonia, and the Turkish Stream. Maybe some Albanians decided to take up arms. Or maybe someone from Western intelligence fomented them.
What do you actually know about the US supposedly funding radical Islamists in Macedonia? I would be very interested in that information. Or is it just speculation?

How exactly would someone from Western intelligence foment the incident in Kumanovo? Who would that someone be? Which western intelligence agency specifically? What did it take to convince these men to move into Kumanovo, wait for the police to attack them and then surrender? Why? To what end? Why do it now and not wait until a more opportune time that would have more impact – i.e., when its being built in Greece or when negotiations start with Macedonia or something like that?

You’re not sure whether its important if the Albanian operation in Kumanovo was undertaken alone? That’s the claim of a lot of posters on here – that the west orchestrated Kumanovo in order to stop Turkish stream.
 
Vangelovski said:
Assumptions and inaccuracies:

Yes, indeed. I have noticed – and please take this in the spirit of charity – that you make many statements which are patently untrue. The reason for this (it appears) is that you are uninformed. Let me explain.

Vangelovski said:
No, its not. It shares some chemical elements, but natural gas is mostly methane. You might be thinking about American “gas”, which is not the same as natural gas.

Wrong. All gas comes from crude oil. The difference is that it takes higher heat for natural gas to naturally form, as opposed to lighter heat.

To understand the diversity contained in crude oil, and to understand why refining crude oil is so important in our society, look through the following list of products that come from crude oil:

Petroleum gas - used for heating, cooking, making plastics
commonly known by the names methane, ethane, propane, butane
http://science.howstuffworks.com/environmental/energy/oil-refining2.htm
Natural gas also comes from crude oil.
Vangelovsk said:
How do you know the “west” wanted the war? Why did they want that war? What did they have to gain from it? What exactly were its ‘vital’ interests in a war in Kosovo? Who exactly do you mean by the “west”? You can’t just say it wanted that war and ignore the detail.

First, the West is composed of NATO countries, with US and Great Britain being the principal agents. Second, NATO does not enter into wars unless there is a vital interest at stake. If you actually believe the ethnic cleansing claims made by the West and that the war in Yugoslavia was about humanitarian reasons then you are seriously misguided. The US was trying to break up Yugoslavia for years.

Vangelovski said:
Again, who, why, how, what?

NATO

Vangelovski said:
Its hardly “rich” in natural resources other than lignite – also known as brown coal.

That is not what data suggests.

Kosovo is one of the wealthiest lands in natural resources per square mile in Europe.

Albanian Minerals research as of 2015 showed that Kosovo has over $2 trillion dollars in mineral reserves.

Kosovo is very rich in minerals such as lignite, coal, zinc, gold, bauxite, silver, magnesium, lead, silver, aluminum, chrome ore and much more. Kosovo possesses around 15 billion tons of lignite in reserves,
fifth largest lignite reserves in the world. Kosovo also possesses rich reserves of asbestos, indium, germanium, thallium, and gallium, limestone, marble, quartz and other minerals.

http://friendsofkosovo.com/2015/01/26/kosovo-has-over-2-trillion-dollars-worth-of-minerals/

Again:

In Kosovo, the abundance of non-renewable natural resources is a reality—one that represents a key ingredient of, and significant risk to, Kosovo’s socio-economic development potential.
Kosovo is very rich in mineral deposits.
http://www.worldbank.org/en/news/sp...ironment-center-baker-tilly-kosovo-conference

Vangelovski said:
And so what? Its main trading partners are Italy, Albania and Macedonia. The rest barely rate a few percentage points of its total exports which are only worth about $400 million – hardly a gold mine so to speak. Are these three countries the “west” exploiting Kosovo?

You are so far off base. Do you even know how much money the architects of the war have made in Kosovo? Kosovo is the organize crime capital of Europe.

Vangelovski said:
US led smuggling of drugs? Do you have actual evidence? Or is it just mere speculation and conspiracy theories?

That the US government is the world's largest drugs smuggler is a fact.

http://www.counterpunch.org/2014/11/07/the-cia-and-drugs-inc-a-covert-history/

Than the Taliban shut down the poppy fields in Afghanistan is a fact. That opium production in Afghanistan is at record levels after the US took over Afghanistan is also a fact. That drugs are routed through the Balkans from South West Asia is also a fact. That the United States is running the show is also a fact.

Vangelovski said:
Of my 7,500 posts on here, I’d say probably around 5,000 are related to the Albanians in Macedonia. As a start, you might want to look at the cause as defined by MTO. As I helped shape it, you’ll find some of my ideas in there about minorities. Other than that, its just gonna have to be the hard slog cause I really can’t be bothered with a that at the moment.

When you have the time, please provide links or papers.

Vangelovski said:
You still don’t know what my thinking is, but you’re adamant that your comments are not irrelevant.

Absolutely.

Vangelovski said:
You make so many assumptions here and then pass them off as absolute fact that I really don’t know where to begin. But like I said before, the Macedonians have already given up on freedom, so its really a mute point.

You have a proclivity of answering posts with bland assertions of assumptions.
Vangelovski said:
More assumptions passed off as fact. Its known that Saudi Arabia funds some radical Islamists in Macedonia, but I wouldn’t put their number beyond more than a few hundred at most. As for the US, its possible (though I don’t have any actual evidence other than some vague reports) that it provided the NLA with some funds and weapons during 2001. Other than that, I haven’t seen anything concrete other than pure speculation. Other powers? Who are they and what have they done exactly? Who have they funded? What evidence do you actually have or is it all just hearsay and speculation?

They are not assumptions. Why don't you do some research.

Vangelovski said:
Does it really extend Russian influence? What has Russia actually gain in terms of policy making from Europe that was a direct or indirect result of their gas supplies? Some leniency? Maybe, but would that have been any different if Europe wasn’t buying any gas from Russia? Given Russia has a considerable nuclear weapons stockpile, I don’t think so.

Yes, it does. Vangelovski, you are making serious errors in your analysis. I suggest you do some research. Here is a Reuters article that points out the obvious:

They forgot their 1990s strategic goal to cut European dependence on Russian gas. The European Union also failed to recall Moscow’s tendency to use its gas reserves as a bargaining chip in negotiations.

http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2014/05/01/dont-cry-for-the-nabucco-pipeline/

Any student of geopolitics knows this.

Vangelovski said:
No one is making Europe buy Russian gas. Europe has the option to build its own pipelines, such as Nabucco, bringing natural gas from the middle east and central asia. I’ve seen other proposed pipelines from Africa. You and everyone else have failed to address these key points. I’ll put them down again:

The Nabucco pipeline failed. There are those who are trying to revive it, but Turkish Stream is a direct opponent to it. You can't have both. So the question is, why do the Americans and the Europeans favor the Trans-Adriatic over Turkish Stream?

Here is what Lesile Palti-Guzman, a senior global energy analyst, wrote:

But the time has come to digest the lessons of the Nabucco failure. We need a serious political and geopolitical agenda to give clout to the European Union and U.S. talk about greater European gas-supply diversification. We also need to put an end to Russia’s intimidation tactics. Many factors contributed to Nabucco’s failure, but the main reasons were political rather than commercial. The pipeline was replaced by a more modest plan to upgrade and expand the Southern Corridor, which includes the Trans-Adriatic Pipeline that will carry Azerbaijan gas from the Turkish border into Greece and Italy.

The selection of the Trans-Adriatic Pipeline in late 2013 left a bitter taste in Europeans’ mouths. The pipeline will bring Azeri gas to Italy, which already has fairly diverse energy sources, while Nabucco, even in its smaller version (known as Nabucco West), would have supplied gas to EU member states — notably Bulgaria, Hungary and Romania — largely dependent on Gazprom.
The first lesson of Nabucco’s failure is that Russia’s carrot-and-stick approach not only worked, it also exposed the lack of a common EU energy policy. Moscow was able to safeguard its dominant market share in Central and Eastern Europe, where Gazprom faces little competition. Moscow pressured most of these countries to support Gazprom’s South Stream pipeline, a rival to Nabucco. That pipeline was developed to bring Russian gas into Eastern and Southern Europe.
http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2014/05/01/dont-cry-for-the-nabucco-pipeline/

You have failed to address mostly everything put forth thus far. You have failed to understand the geopolitical and economic factors involved.

Vangelovski said:
1. Nobody is forcing Europe to buy Russian gas. Europe can allow Russia to waste its time and money building pipelines and it does not have to buy the additional gas.

2. Europe can build its own pipelines rather than relying on Russian pipelines and already has plans in process.

Really? Nobody is forcing Europe to buy Russian gas?

Europe can build its own pipelines? Why would they want to do this? If Turkey and Greece sign with Turkish Stream, how is Europe going to get their gas? How and from where?

Vangelovsk said:
Yes, it is true that Zaev could conceivably run two terms (8 years, not decades) and the pipeline not make it to Macedonia by then. You seem to think you can just dismiss anything you don’t like as if your position is an established fact. I’m yet to see a pipeline (or any government sponsored project) actually be built on time and on budget. That pipeline could in theory be supplying gas to Turkey by 2016. But there is yet no agreement and negotiations on technical aspects of the project are still underway. Even if they had been agreed to, actually building the pipeline “on the ground” is another story and its not unusual for large delays to occur for whatever reason.

Russia would still have to work out all the technical aspects, routes and political agreement with Greece, Macedonia, Serbia before Turkish stream actually reaches the EU. It would then have to actually make an agreement with the EU on a political level and sort through all the EU bureaucratic BS, technical aspects, tender processes etc with EU countries in order to connect up to their gas supply.

Nonsense. That is nonsense.

Vangelovski said:
What do you actually know about the US supposedly funding radical Islamists in Macedonia? I would be very interested in that information. Or is it just speculation?

How exactly would someone from Western intelligence foment the incident in Kumanovo? Who would that someone be? Which western intelligence agency specifically? What did it take to convince these men to move into Kumanovo, wait for the police to attack them and then surrender? Why? To what end? Why do it now and not wait until a more opportune time that would have more impact – i.e., when its being built in Greece or when negotiations start with Macedonia or something like that?

You’re not sure whether its important if the Albanian operation in Kumanovo was undertaken alone? That’s the claim of a lot of posters on here – that the west orchestrated Kumanovo in order to stop Turkish stream.

Obviously there is no “made in the USA” stamp to be found. Covert missions are covert for a reason. I cannot state with absolutely certainty that the events in Kumanovo were the result of US led black ops. No one can. It is an imperfect conclusion based on analyzing the geopolitical and economic questions involved in the Balkans today. What I do not do, however, is dismiss the idea like you do without analyzing it. I have said, and will repeat what I said, it is possible that the incident in Kumanovo was an isolated event. However, considering the many issues involved today in the Balkans – from George Soros, Zoran Zaev, and the Turkish Stream – it is not likely that it was an isolated incident.
 
Philosopher,

You had an opportunity to provide information or evidence for your claims. You haven't. You have just given more assumptions and out rightly dismissed what didn't suit you.

So at this point I will just repeat what I said previously - there are so many inaccuracies in your posts and assumptions based on I'm not sure what, that I don't think there's any point in continuing.

You're still confusing petroleum gas with natural gas. Look it up. That by far is the most striking example of your claims.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top