BIRN Fact-check: Does North Macedonia’s Budget Merit the ‘Human Capital’ Hype?
The Social Democrat-led government in North Macedonia says it wants to invest in the labour force in order to grow the economy. But experts question the long-term value of simply hiking wages.
When lawmakers in North Macedonia endorsed the country’s budget for 2020 in late December, the Social Democrat-led government boldly declared that its focus for the year would be investment in ‘human capital’ – that is, increasing the economic value of a worker’s experience and skills.
“If we don’t continuously invest in human capital, we will not have a workforce prepared for the jobs of the future, we won’t be competitive in the global economy and we won’t be able to maintain economic growth,” Finance Minister Nina Angelovska said at the time.
The notion that North Macedonia must improve the skills of its workforce in order to boost long-term economic growth is nothing new. But to make it the centrepiece of the annual budget is a first.
A closer look at the numbers, however, show the government is looking primarily at raising salaries, pensions and social transfers. Structural reforms in education and training – widely seen as the key to developing human capital – are largely absent.
“An increase in salaries does not mean investing in human capital,” said economics professor Abdulmenaf Bexheti of the South Eastern Europe University in the western town of Tetovo.
“If we want to invest in human capital then we need to invest extensively and consistently in the education sector, from preschool to higher education.”
The opposition said the government’s spending plan was little more than a list of “populist” measures to put more money in the pockets of voters ahead a parliamentary election on April 12.
Biggest budget since independence
The 2020 budget is the country’s largest in almost three decades of independence, with projected expenditures of 3.9 billion euros, five per cent more than in 2019, and revenues of 3.6 billion, or 5.6 per cent up on last year.
Most of the outgoings – 2.5 billion euros – are earmarked for salaries, pensions and other social transfers. That’s 162 million euros, or six per cent, more than last year.
The health sector, which has struggled for years with retaining doctors and nurses due to poor working conditions and low salaries, will see the largest increase: nurses will receive a 10 per cent pay rise, general practitioners 15 per cent and medical professors 20 per cent.
Specialist doctors can expect to receive up to 25 per cent more money, taking their average pay to more than 1,600 euros net per month, well above the country’s average wage of just over 420 euros.
Starting this month, pensions will see an average increase of up to 15 euros, with the average pensioner currently receiving a meagre 240 euros per month.
Teachers will also receive a pay rise of 10 per cent, but higher salaries, said Bexheti, are no substitute for the kind of systemic reforms and major investment required to provide a long-term qualitative improvement of the workforce.
Higher salaries will boost the local economy only in the short-term, experts argue.
Education sector worse off
A closer look at education spending shows that, while the sector will receive 11 million euros more than last year – or 434 million euros – over 60 per cent will be spent on wages including the planned wage increase.
Actual investment in education will fall from 16 million euros to 13 million, of which 8.4 million will be spent on sports facilities in schools and just 2.8 million on building new schools and renovating old ones.
Science will also be one million euros worse off compared to 2019 with just 5.6 million euros of government spending. Universities, too, see their slice of the pie falling some four million euros to roughly 100 million.
Spending on “student’s standard”, meaning on dormitories, as well on primary education will also fall slightly on last year, while high schools will receive slightly more.
North Macedonia’s deputy prime minister in charge of economy, Koco Angjushev, said on several occasions last year that the government recognised the importance of education and threats posed by an unproductive education sector to the economy’s future development.
The government therefore unveiled a plan last year for the speedier introduction of so-called dual education, which includes budget help for students in all technical [applied sciences] high-schools to gain paid work experience while still studying.
The costs of project, however, have yet to be worked out in full and are not part of the 2020 budget.
https://balkaninsight.com/2020/01/13/birn-fact-check-does-north-macedonias-budget-merit-the-human-capital-hype/
There it is in a nutshell.
This type of thing has been happening in Macedonia since independence. Money gets thrown around in a short sighted fashion to basically buy votes. Even when they claim they are "investing" in something its always shallow and wasteful. The part about education spending is quite telling.
Bigger budgets, more waste, a population that is ill educated and ill prepared for the present and the future. If you want to know what Macedonia will be like in 20 years, there it is right there, it will be exactly the same if not worse because the investments and changes that need to be made today in order to improve things in the future are not happening.
Its painful to say but I'm starting to think Macedonia was better run institutionally when it was part of Yugoslavia.