• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Macedonia & Greece: Name Issue

Macedonia & Greece: Name Issue

  • .

    Votes: 5 62.5%
  • .

    Votes: 3 37.5%

  • Total voters
    8
Its hard to deny that it would likely be seen as an enormous relief to the nation, as though a great weight has finally been lifted off their shoulders.

Unfortunately I feel that many RoMacedonians have finally found the ultimate scapegoat in Zaev, their Martyr in Zaev, I dare say they view Zaev as a Godsend for their abysmal predicament and you will be hard to find many who will actually move to stand against him, including politically in parliament
And then the wait for the German river of gold begins. I can see Zaev pulling out promissory notes from a bag and throwing them into the crowds, "you get a pension, and you get a pension, we all get a pension".
 
Seven in 10 Greeks against use of 'Macedonia' in name solution, poll shows

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-g...-idUSKBN1F30M1

Doesn't this just highlight Greek chauvinism? Especially being more prominent in the younger crowds within a financially crippled state. Seriously, you'd think this younger generation would be more engrossed in investing in themselves through education rather than following futile politics.

I don't know who looks more ridiculous in the dispute, whether it's us trying to give up everything to get into some international organisation or if it's the Greeks with their blatant chauvinism.
 
While the Greeks continue to be bailed out to the tune of $8.4 billion Euros by the European authorities, there is no reason for them but to show their chauvinism towards the name.
 
I think Zaev will try for a composite name first, but ultimately I wouldn't be surprised if he agrees to a complete change. I don't see any real threat from a long-enslaved and compliant people. I can't think of anyone in Macedonia that actually gives a f*ck anymore. I'm quite convinced that they will be glad to "solve" the name issue.
Its hard to deny that it would likely be seen as an enormous relief to the nation, as though a great weight has finally been lifted off their shoulders.

Unfortunately I feel that many RoMacedonians have finally found the ultimate scapegoat in Zaev, their Martyr in Zaev, I dare say they view Zaev as a Godsend for their abysmal predicament and you will be hard to find many who will actually move to stand against him, including politically in parliament

And then the wait for the German river of gold begins. I can see Zaev pulling out promissory notes from a bag and throwing them into the crowds, "you get a pension, and you get a pension, we all get a pension".

po nacionalnost sum siromav_00.jpg

If this piece of graffiti is not the ultimate shared sentiment of the nation, I don't know what is - "My Nationality is Poor". It screams:

Fuck Macedonia and Fuck all Macedonian patriots...Just show me the money & Long Live Makebanija!!!
 
https://www.rferl.org/a/macedonia-name-dispute-greece-skopje-alexander/28979309.html

In 'Macedonia' Name Dispute, Optimism In The Air

It will not happen tomorrow, but a cloud hanging over neighbors Greece and Macedonia for more than two decades might soon be lifted.

Delegations from the two states, headed by their respective negotiators, Adamantios Vassilakis and Vasko Naumovski, are due to meet with UN mediator Matthew Nimetz in New York on January 17 to resume talks over Macedonia's official name, frozen since 2014.

Greece has objected to Macedonia's use of that name -- also a region of northern Greece -- since the former Yugoslav republic's declaration of independence in 1991. Unlike some, Macedonia did not have to fight a war to secure its statehood; but it has been engaged in a diplomatic struggle to keep its name for 26 years.

As a constituent part of Yugoslavia, it had been known as the "Socialist Republic of Macedonia," but its bid to simply drop the Socialist designation and become the sovereign "Republic of Macedonia" was repeatedly thwarted by EU member Greece.

At the forthcoming meeting, Nimetz is expected once again to present the parties with a list of names that have been under discussion before, with only minor changes.

So no one is expected to pull a rabbit out of a hat.

But the meeting could be a major step in the right direction.

'Positive Momentum'

Driving from Thessaloniki toward the Macedonian border, one will not come across any road signs for the state of Macedonia. There is a sign indicating an international border crossing, and the direction of the Macedonian capital, Skopje, is indicated.

Nimetz is nevertheless optimistic about resolving the dispute. He told Greek state television this week that there was "positive momentum" in both countries: "I think the people in both countries are maybe ready to hear some solutions that are consistent with national interests but also have some element of compromise that would resolve the problem."

So far Greece would only countenance referring to its neighbor by the acronym FYROM (Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia). The country was admitted to the United Nations under that name in 1993, and that designation is used by the EU among others. (Others, including the United States, China, and Russia, routinely use the name Republic of Macedonia in communications with Skopje.)

A compromise solution could involve substituting a new qualifier, such as "Upper," "Northern" or "New Macedonia."

But for many Greeks, even this might be unacceptable. According to a recent poll, more than two-thirds of Greeks are opposed to any mention of "Macedonia," and there are rallies planned in Athens and northern Greece in the weeks ahead.

Reportedly in order to avoid tensions, the Greek prime minister has called on the influential Orthodox Church to refrain from commenting on the Macedonian question.

Clash Of Identities

In Macedonia itself, opinion is divided.

An informal poll conducted by RFE/RL's Balkan Service on January 11 on the streets of Skopje found that many people would like to see the issue resolved one way or another. Yet others are firmly against any concessions, convinced that Macedonia has the right to its own choice of name.

Behind the dispute over the name is a deeper clash of identities. Among other things, there is a tug-of-war over the figure of Alexander the Great -- claimed by Macedonians as an important part of their national identity. The Greeks, meanwhile, argue that their own ancient heritage is being hijacked by their Slavic-speaking neighbors.

"The hardest part of the bargain is that we have to renounce our mythology in order to allow Greek nationalism to incorporate the newly created Greek-Macedonian identity into Ancient Greek mythology," Denko Maleski a professor at the Skopje University Law School, told RFE/RL.

However, Maleski, who was Macedonia's first foreign minister following independence, is optimistic.

"A solution to the name issue is both possible [and desirable], as it would improve [Macedonia's] chances of getting NATO membership," Maleski added.

Indeed, the day before the New York meeting, NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg was due to visit Skopje in what was being seen as a clear show of support for Macedonia's Euro-Atlantic integration, including NATO membership.

Ismet Ramadani, head of the Macedonian Euro Atlantic Council and adviser to Macedonian Prime Minister Zoran Zaev, spoke of "a decisive week" ahead and a "historical moment."

But he also cautioned that optimism and good intentions alone were not enough, telling regional news agency IBNA that "there must be concrete results in reaching an acceptable compromises [sic] on the name dispute."

Having just emerged from a prolonged internal political crisis, the new Macedonian government may be keen to resolve a longstanding dispute with its neighbor -- particularly as it may smooth the way to EU and NATO membership.

'Historic Chance'

Greece, too, has an interest in shoring up regional stability.

According to Macedonian Foreign Minister Nikola Dimitrov, both sides are obliged to seize the "historic chance" following a turbulent few months in the wider Balkan region.

"I think the public can be very happy that now someone is raising the name issue as it indicates that the country's stability has returned," said Skopje professor Toni Deskoski.

The focus on EU and NATO integration, and better relations among neighbors, appear to contrast with the policy of the previous Macedonian government. The government has shown a willingness to compromise, for instance by agreeing to become a NATO member as "FYROM" rather than Macedonia -- even if this is unpopular at home.

But political analyst Albert Musliu suggests that this flexibility could strengthen Macedonia's hand in future negotiations.

"We had to change the narrative while resolving the name issue, because we cannot box with Greece while negotiating, and I think that is exactly the strategy of the new government," Musliu said. "Let's not forget that Greece is a full member of NATO, and it's a voice we depend on for gaining membership in European institutions. I believe that the strategy now is improving and softening the relations with our neighbors, especially Greece, but it is for our partners to also help for Athens to understand Macedonia's position."

For most Macedonians, nomen est omen. But there appears to be a recognition on someone's part that short-term compromises on the name issue may benefit their country over the long term.
 
President Kiro Gligorov's son advocates for our identity to be "New Macedonians". LOMA sent him a response. Here Gligorov's article, then our response:

https://wiiw.ac.at/n-276.html

Greece and Macedonia edge towards solution to name dispute

16 January 2018

If an agreement is reached, the Macedonian government is in a strong position to approve it. From the Greek side it could be more challenging.

By Vladimir Gligorov

An agreement between Greece and Macedonia on the latter’s name is apparently at hand. According to reports, the agreement between the two countries has three key elements:

Issue No. 1: The name of the state. Provisionally, and only in international institutions, the name is currently the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia (or FYROM). Greece cannot accept just Macedonia, while Macedonians cannot accept no mention of Macedonia in the name. The new agreement appears to pave the way for a permanent name: New Macedonia, a solution potentially acceptable to both sides.
Issue No. 2: Citizenship. For Macedonia, citizens of the state will be 'Macedonian', whereas for Greece they will be 'New Macedonian'. Internationally, there may be a split between the multilateral institutions (using the Greek version) and bilateral relations (using either one).
Issue No. 3: National identity. For Macedonians it will be Macedonian (there are also Albanians and a number of minorities). For Greece it will be 'Slavo-Macedonian'. Greece can also call its citizens Macedonian, if they so desire. The latter is probably irrelevant because of the strong preference within the country to use only Greek as a nationality, although it is possible that some will refer to themselves as Greek Macedonian.

Macedonian perspective: positive

The key tenets of the agreement, or a variant thereof, seem reasonable. Politically, the Macedonian government will face little opposition to this agreement. Macedonian identity, when it comes to the name, is not ethnic but regional - somebody living in the region of Macedonia. The nationalists (VMRO party) attempted to connect the identity to Alexander the Great and ancient Macedonians, which is unfounded and unreasonable (this is putting it mildly). In that context, New Macedonian is more accurate. The identity is really based on the political history of the independence movement in that particular region and on that territory and on the Macedonian language. It is not an ethnic thing (or racial, which is what the Slavic characterisation implies).

Greek population may be more resistant

The Greek government will have more of a problem selling the agreement domestically. This is because of the detour that the Conservatives took after the end of the Simitis-Papandreou government. The latter was close to an agreement essentially indistinguishable from the one which is being discussed now. However, for domestic reasons, Greece’s then-Conservative government needed to revive nationalism (as did VMRO), and subsequently stepped back from the agreement.

As a result, Prime Minister Tsipras may face a hostile public reaction. The argument he is making is the same one employed previously by Papandreou: that the agreement provides Greece with a leadership position in the Balkans and thus strengthens its influence in the EU. And the latter, Greece needs badly.


LOMA response:


https://www.leagueofmacedonians.org/letters-and-writings

January 16, 2018

Dear Mr. Vladimir Gligorov,

The League of Macedonian-Americans (LOMA) is disappointed with your inaccurate portrayal of Greece’s dispute with Macedonia’s name. While your commentary is short, it disseminates many misconceptions about the ethnic Macedonian identity, negates and belittles the Macedonian perspective on identity, and ignores the importance and relevance of internationally accepted principles and values enshrined in the Charter of the United Nations.

First, it was not VMRO-DPMNE nationalists who first began to connect the ethnic Macedonian identity to Alexander the Great and the ancient Macedonians. The following observations are just a few from 19th and 20th century authors (not affiliated with VMRO-DPMNE of the 21st century) who acknowledged that the Macedonians believed that they were related to the ancient Macedonians, regardless of whether you or others actually think this to be the case:

We have many times heard from the Macedonists that they are not Bulgarians but Macedonians, descendants of the Ancient Macedonians.
-Petko Slaveykov, 1871

Our dear Macedonia, our dear homeland is calling: You, who are my faithful children; you, who like Aristotle and Alexander the Great, are my heirs; you, in whose veins Macedonian blood flows, do not leave me to die, help me. What a sad sight, real Macedonians, it would be if you were to witness my burial.
-Macedonian Provisional Government, March 23, 1881

Our fatherland Macedonia has her own history about her past, where one can see her might, glory, as well as her political subjugation under the rule of the then mighty Turkish Empire…Today, every Macedonian, when he mentions the name Aleksandar Makedonski, says: We once had King Alexander the Great. With those words he reminds oneself of the brightest period and glory of the Macedonian State. Aleksandar Makedonski stands before every Macedonian as national pride.
-Kosta Shahov, circa 1900

Macedonians! Remember the world's winner, the great glory of Macedonia, the great Alexander of Macedon; remember for the brave King Samoil, the Macedonian giant, for the marvelous Marko Kral, the Slavic glory, that Macedonian blood flowed through them; those of heavenly heights watch and bless our initiated work. To show worthy descendants of their descendants: to preserve their glorious names and to amaze the world with our courage, dexterity and self-sacrifice; to cut off from us the shameful yoke that suffocates us for five centuries.
-Anastas Jankov, 1902

In their proclamations the leaders of the Slavo-Macedonian Committee appeal to Alexander the Great as a national hero.
- George F. Abbott, The Tale of a Tour in Macedonia, 1903, Pg. 278

There are still those of today's inhabitants of Macedonia that do not consider themselves as Serbs or Bulgarians, but a separate ethnicity, probably descendants of the ancient Macedonians.
-Slishkovikj Jakov, Albania and Macedonia, 1904, Pg. 160

Poor Georgie! He spoke a Slav dialect, and was possibly a mixture of all the races that have ever ruled the peninsula, and all he had gained was a Mauser ball through his right hand in the name of Alexander the Great… A song was sung during the late Macedonian insurrection in which an eagle, who is soaring over the land, asks what is the cause of so much excitement, and is told that the sons of Alexander are rising.
--Mary Durham, The Burden of the Balkans, 1905, Pg. 6

King Marko is the son and pride of Macedonia and one of the three great conquerors who spread the name of their land far beyond its territories: (1) Alexander of Macedon spread the glory of Macedonia as far as the Central Asian rivers of Amu Darya [Oxus] and Syr Darya [Jaxartes], and also to India and the Indian Ocean; (2) The holy Cyril and Methodius spread the Macedonian word and script among all the Slavic peoples, and (3) King Marko placed under his authority and under that of the Macedonian muse all popular singers and peoples on the Balkan Peninsula, including you, the descendants of his sworn enemies.
-Krste Misirkov, 1923


Thus, you can read for yourself that the Macedonians’ belief in their connection to ancient Macedonia and the ancient Macedonians is not a modern-day concoction; the modern-day interpretation is an affirmation and expansion of thought rooted in both Macedonian intellectuals and peasants in centuries past.

Second, all ethnic identities are modern constructions – Greek, Bulgarian, Albanian, Serb, German, French, Russian, Macedonian, and etc. The concept of ethnicity did not appear in intellectual literature in any meaningful form until the 19th century, and it did not infiltrate mainstream society until the middle of the 20th century. Further, to insist that Macedonian identity is not an “ethnic thing” because Macedonia is also a region has no logical basis. Which post-modern school of thought invented the idea that a name cannot be used in both a regional and ethnic context? It certainly is possible to have ethnic Macedonians and regional Macedonians – ask the over 2 million people who consider themselves ethnic Macedonians.

Let me put it differently. If Germany today is split into several pieces, after being conquered by its neighbors, and remains divided and occupied for several centuries, does this mean that ethnic Germans cannot exist in a region called Germany that is shared by several different countries? Or, being that Ireland is split between a country called Ireland and the United Kingdom, are the Irish of Ireland not ethnically Irish? Further, because the vast majority of Irishmen speak English, does this mean they cannot identify as Irish? Or, because the vast majority of Americans speak English, does this mean an ethnic American identity does not exist, or cannot develop? We all know that the Americans are a mish-mash of peoples from around the globe and not just from England. Therefore, is it really fair to describe the ethnic Macedonians racially as ‘Slavic’, as you implied, when ‘Slavic’ is not a racial identification but a linguistic characterization?

But I apologize for departing and return to the matter at hand. The term ‘Macedonians’ has been used throughout history to refer to the people of Macedonia no differently than ‘Bulgarians’ has been used to refer to the people of Bulgaria, ‘Serbians’ to the people of Serbia, and ‘Greeks’ to the people of Greece. That Macedonia is now located in three countries certainly gives the people who live in all three portions of Macedonia the opportunity to call themselves Macedonians; but it certainly does not imply that people in Macedonia cannot identify only as Macedonian. The ethnic Macedonian people, like neighboring Balkan ethnic groups, are a product of an amalgamation of different tribes throughout thousands of years of migrations and occupations. That the ethnic Macedonians in Macedonia choose not to affiliate with any other ethnic identity is a product not just of political aspirations, as you imply, but also of history, culture and other common bonds.

Third, putting aside historical insights and exercises in identity formation, let us turn to the mission of upholding democratic principles and values enshrined in the Charter of the United Nations. The Charter states the following as one of the UN’s purposes:

To develop friendly relations among nations based on respect for the principle of equal rights and self-determination of peoples, and to take other appropriate measures to strengthen universal peace.

In your commentary, you completely ignore the relevance of this in its application to modern day democracies. The world, as indicated by the UN Charter, is attempting to promote governing systems that respect equal rights and self-determination. Can you explain to us what is equal about letting all peoples except the Macedonians decide their country’s name and their ethnic identity? Further, can you explain why self-determination does not apply for the Macedonians, in this context, when it has applied to every other UN country?

When it comes to rights and freedoms – cherished democratic principles and values – history and social theories on identity have no place in deciding how, or to whom, to grant those rights and freedoms. The principle of equality is enshrined in the UN Charter and the name negotiations are an affront to the UN’s purpose. Macedonia has no territorial aspirations against Greece; Macedonia is not preventing Greeks from identifying as Macedonians or naming their northern province ‘Macedonia’; and Macedonia has not asked for superior treatment in the UN. Macedonia has asked for that which is automatically granted to all other UN members: the right to self-determine their own name and identity, and the right to be recognized as such by the UN. The UN should not violate one member’s rights and freedoms (Macedonia’s) simply because its name and identity annoys another member. Macedonia is not asking for preferential treatment; it’s asking for equal treatment.

In summary, your commentary has been a complete disservice to WIIW members and readers. Instead of providing a well-reasoned analysis on likely outcomes of the name negotiations and potential benefits and consequences, you strayed into repeating lousy but dangerous arguments emanating from chauvinists in Greece and Bulgaria. Identity is not a matter to be trifled with; your simplified denial of the ethnic Macedonian identity is a promotion of barbarous ideologies that brought Europe to its knees on several occasions in the 20th century. Let’s stray away from ideologies of denial and instead embrace an ideology of acceptance. It’s the only way to preserve peace in Europe.

Sincerely,
Victor Sinadinoski, Co-founder
League of Macedonian-Americans
www.leagueofmacedonians.org
 
Nice response Vic.

Macedonian identity, when it comes to the name, is not ethnic but regional
He is a chip off the old block.
Where are the protests in Macedonia?

Deep down, we know the fyromians will whore their mothers for some chance of making money. Part of me understands this, but why do they keep lubing themselves in anticipation?
 
Exhibit A = European Slav

Greece and Macedonia edge towards solution to name dispute

16 January 2018

If an agreement is reached, the Macedonian government is in a strong position to approve it. From the Greek side it could be more challenging.

By Vladimir Gligorov

An agreement between Greece and Macedonia on the latter’s name is apparently at hand. According to reports, the agreement between the two countries has three key elements:

Issue No. 1: The name of the state. Provisionally, and only in international institutions, the name is currently the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia (or FYROM). Greece cannot accept just Macedonia, while Macedonians cannot accept no mention of Macedonia in the name. The new agreement appears to pave the way for a permanent name: New Macedonia, a solution potentially acceptable to both sides.
Issue No. 2: Citizenship. For Macedonia, citizens of the state will be 'Macedonian', whereas for Greece they will be 'New Macedonian'. Internationally, there may be a split between the multilateral institutions (using the Greek version) and bilateral relations (using either one).
Issue No. 3: National identity. For Macedonians it will be Macedonian (there are also Albanians and a number of minorities). For Greece it will be 'Slavo-Macedonian'. Greece can also call its citizens Macedonian, if they so desire. The latter is probably irrelevant because of the strong preference within the country to use only Greek as a nationality, although it is possible that some will refer to themselves as Greek Macedonian.

Macedonian perspective: positive

The key tenets of the agreement, or a variant thereof, seem reasonable. Politically, the Macedonian government will face little opposition to this agreement. Macedonian identity, when it comes to the name, is not ethnic but regional - somebody living in the region of Macedonia. The nationalists (VMRO party) attempted to connect the identity to Alexander the Great and ancient Macedonians, which is unfounded and unreasonable (this is putting it mildly). In that context, New Macedonian is more accurate. The identity is really based on the political history of the independence movement in that particular region and on that territory and on the Macedonian language. It is not an ethnic thing (or racial, which is what the Slavic characterisation implies).

Greek population may be more resistant

The Greek government will have more of a problem selling the agreement domestically. This is because of the detour that the Conservatives took after the end of the Simitis-Papandreou government. The latter was close to an agreement essentially indistinguishable from the one which is being discussed now. However, for domestic reasons, Greece’s then-Conservative government needed to revive nationalism (as did VMRO), and subsequently stepped back from the agreement.

As a result, Prime Minister Tsipras may face a hostile public reaction. The argument he is making is the same one employed previously by Papandreou: that the agreement provides Greece with a leadership position in the Balkans and thus strengthens its influence in the EU. And the latter, Greece needs badly.



Exhibit B = Indigenous Macedonian

January 16, 2018

Dear Mr. Vladimir Gligorov,

The League of Macedonian-Americans (LOMA) is disappointed with your inaccurate portrayal of Greece’s dispute with Macedonia’s name. While your commentary is short, it disseminates many misconceptions about the ethnic Macedonian identity, negates and belittles the Macedonian perspective on identity, and ignores the importance and relevance of internationally accepted principles and values enshrined in the Charter of the United Nations.

First, it was not VMRO-DPMNE nationalists who first began to connect the ethnic Macedonian identity to Alexander the Great and the ancient Macedonians. The following observations are just a few from 19th and 20th century authors (not affiliated with VMRO-DPMNE of the 21st century) who acknowledged that the Macedonians believed that they were related to the ancient Macedonians, regardless of whether you or others actually think this to be the case:

We have many times heard from the Macedonists that they are not Bulgarians but Macedonians, descendants of the Ancient Macedonians.
-Petko Slaveykov, 1871

Our dear Macedonia, our dear homeland is calling: You, who are my faithful children; you, who like Aristotle and Alexander the Great, are my heirs; you, in whose veins Macedonian blood flows, do not leave me to die, help me. What a sad sight, real Macedonians, it would be if you were to witness my burial.
-Macedonian Provisional Government, March 23, 1881

Our fatherland Macedonia has her own history about her past, where one can see her might, glory, as well as her political subjugation under the rule of the then mighty Turkish Empire…Today, every Macedonian, when he mentions the name Aleksandar Makedonski, says: We once had King Alexander the Great. With those words he reminds oneself of the brightest period and glory of the Macedonian State. Aleksandar Makedonski stands before every Macedonian as national pride.
-Kosta Shahov, circa 1900

Macedonians! Remember the world's winner, the great glory of Macedonia, the great Alexander of Macedon; remember for the brave King Samoil, the Macedonian giant, for the marvelous Marko Kral, the Slavic glory, that Macedonian blood flowed through them; those of heavenly heights watch and bless our initiated work. To show worthy descendants of their descendants: to preserve their glorious names and to amaze the world with our courage, dexterity and self-sacrifice; to cut off from us the shameful yoke that suffocates us for five centuries.
-Anastas Jankov, 1902

In their proclamations the leaders of the Slavo-Macedonian Committee appeal to Alexander the Great as a national hero.
- George F. Abbott, The Tale of a Tour in Macedonia, 1903, Pg. 278

There are still those of today's inhabitants of Macedonia that do not consider themselves as Serbs or Bulgarians, but a separate ethnicity, probably descendants of the ancient Macedonians.
-Slishkovikj Jakov, Albania and Macedonia, 1904, Pg. 160

Poor Georgie! He spoke a Slav dialect, and was possibly a mixture of all the races that have ever ruled the peninsula, and all he had gained was a Mauser ball through his right hand in the name of Alexander the Great… A song was sung during the late Macedonian insurrection in which an eagle, who is soaring over the land, asks what is the cause of so much excitement, and is told that the sons of Alexander are rising.
--Mary Durham, The Burden of the Balkans, 1905, Pg. 6

King Marko is the son and pride of Macedonia and one of the three great conquerors who spread the name of their land far beyond its territories: (1) Alexander of Macedon spread the glory of Macedonia as far as the Central Asian rivers of Amu Darya [Oxus] and Syr Darya [Jaxartes], and also to India and the Indian Ocean; (2) The holy Cyril and Methodius spread the Macedonian word and script among all the Slavic peoples, and (3) King Marko placed under his authority and under that of the Macedonian muse all popular singers and peoples on the Balkan Peninsula, including you, the descendants of his sworn enemies.
-Krste Misirkov, 1923

Thus, you can read for yourself that the Macedonians’ belief in their connection to ancient Macedonia and the ancient Macedonians is not a modern-day concoction; the modern-day interpretation is an affirmation and expansion of thought rooted in both Macedonian intellectuals and peasants in centuries past.

Second, all ethnic identities are modern constructions – Greek, Bulgarian, Albanian, Serb, German, French, Russian, Macedonian, and etc. The concept of ethnicity did not appear in intellectual literature in any meaningful form until the 19th century, and it did not infiltrate mainstream society until the middle of the 20th century. Further, to insist that Macedonian identity is not an “ethnic thing” because Macedonia is also a region has no logical basis. Which post-modern school of thought invented the idea that a name cannot be used in both a regional and ethnic context? It certainly is possible to have ethnic Macedonians and regional Macedonians – ask the over 2 million people who consider themselves ethnic Macedonians.

Let me put it differently. If Germany today is split into several pieces, after being conquered by its neighbors, and remains divided and occupied for several centuries, does this mean that ethnic Germans cannot exist in a region called Germany that is shared by several different countries? Or, being that Ireland is split between a country called Ireland and the United Kingdom, are the Irish of Ireland not ethnically Irish? Further, because the vast majority of Irishmen speak English, does this mean they cannot identify as Irish? Or, because the vast majority of Americans speak English, does this mean an ethnic American identity does not exist, or cannot develop? We all know that the Americans are a mish-mash of peoples from around the globe and not just from England. Therefore, is it really fair to describe the ethnic Macedonians racially as ‘Slavic’, as you implied, when ‘Slavic’ is not a racial identification but a linguistic characterization?

But I apologize for departing and return to the matter at hand. The term ‘Macedonians’ has been used throughout history to refer to the people of Macedonia no differently than ‘Bulgarians’ has been used to refer to the people of Bulgaria, ‘Serbians’ to the people of Serbia, and ‘Greeks’ to the people of Greece. That Macedonia is now located in three countries certainly gives the people who live in all three portions of Macedonia the opportunity to call themselves Macedonians; but it certainly does not imply that people in Macedonia cannot identify only as Macedonian. The ethnic Macedonian people, like neighboring Balkan ethnic groups, are a product of an amalgamation of different tribes throughout thousands of years of migrations and occupations. That the ethnic Macedonians in Macedonia choose not to affiliate with any other ethnic identity is a product not just of political aspirations, as you imply, but also of history, culture and other common bonds.

Third, putting aside historical insights and exercises in identity formation, let us turn to the mission of upholding democratic principles and values enshrined in the Charter of the United Nations. The Charter states the following as one of the UN’s purposes:

To develop friendly relations among nations based on respect for the principle of equal rights and self-determination of peoples, and to take other appropriate measures to strengthen universal peace.

In your commentary, you completely ignore the relevance of this in its application to modern day democracies. The world, as indicated by the UN Charter, is attempting to promote governing systems that respect equal rights and self-determination. Can you explain to us what is equal about letting all peoples except the Macedonians decide their country’s name and their ethnic identity? Further, can you explain why self-determination does not apply for the Macedonians, in this context, when it has applied to every other UN country?

When it comes to rights and freedoms – cherished democratic principles and values – history and social theories on identity have no place in deciding how, or to whom, to grant those rights and freedoms. The principle of equality is enshrined in the UN Charter and the name negotiations are an affront to the UN’s purpose. Macedonia has no territorial aspirations against Greece; Macedonia is not preventing Greeks from identifying as Macedonians or naming their northern province ‘Macedonia’; and Macedonia has not asked for superior treatment in the UN. Macedonia has asked for that which is automatically granted to all other UN members: the right to self-determine their own name and identity, and the right to be recognized as such by the UN. The UN should not violate one member’s rights and freedoms (Macedonia’s) simply because its name and identity annoys another member. Macedonia is not asking for preferential treatment; it’s asking for equal treatment.

In summary, your commentary has been a complete disservice to WIIW members and readers. Instead of providing a well-reasoned analysis on likely outcomes of the name negotiations and potential benefits and consequences, you strayed into repeating lousy but dangerous arguments emanating from chauvinists in Greece and Bulgaria. Identity is not a matter to be trifled with; your simplified denial of the ethnic Macedonian identity is a promotion of barbarous ideologies that brought Europe to its knees on several occasions in the 20th century. Let’s stray away from ideologies of denial and instead embrace an ideology of acceptance. It’s the only way to preserve peace in Europe.

Sincerely,
Victor Sinadinoski, Co-founder
League of Macedonian-Americans
www.leagueofmacedonians.org

Well written Vic
 
Јас незнам оти диаспората уште си ја чyка главата за името и македонскиот идентитет кога граѓаните од република Македонија ни на умот не ги ставаат разговорите за името.

Свестете се народе македонски, еден ден ке станите од кревет со прстот в'yста и курот в'гас и ништо друго.
 
Јас незнам оти диаспората уште си ја чyка главата за името и македонскиот идентитет кога граѓаните од република Македонија ни на умот не ги ставаат разговорите за името.

Свестете се народе македонски, еден ден ке станите од кревет со прстот в'yста и курот в'гас и ништо друго.

vistina e taka?
 
vistina e taka?

Јас незнам од каде сте брат, ама во мојето искyство, зивејан во Македонија, Европа и Австралија, диаспората остана да се бори за македонизмот. Жителите од република Македонија, особено граѓаните мајките ќе си ги продаат ако можат. А за тије на село...
 
Exhibit A = European Slav
Exhibit B = Indigenous Macedonian

That right there is what is wrong with FYROM. The Gligorovs of FYROM and the rest of the Slav Macedonians. This is because the Slav Macedonian will never see Macedonia quite the same way as the Ingenious Macedonian sees Macedonia - as his natural homeland.

To the Slav Macedonian, no matter how much he professes his patriotism, the country will always be just some random region that his Russian ancestors once settled which holds no real national value or connection with him. With this mindset, is it any wonder why the Fyromian is so quick to negotiate away his national identity at the drop of a hat? He feels no affinity to the land, the history or spirit of the place. The essence of his soul is somewhere far away and not in Macedonia. That is why it is easy for him to see his country renamed to New Macedonia. In his mind, he is already a new Macedonian so it's only logical. The Slav Macedonian will tell you “we want to be a proud new and modern European nation striving forward and embracing the great European ideals and values of the 21st Century not stuck in 19th Century Balkan nationalist politics”. And who can argue with that. You couldn't even if you wanted to. The Slav Macedonian will always look down on the descendants of Alexander The Great as simple minded and uneducated peasants who are an embarrassment to the rest of the nation.
 
Tomche, I was hesitant at first to accept your "European Slav" outlook because I just didn't believe that many Macedonians felt that way. But I don't know now.

There are still indigenous Macedonians in Macedonia, and they (for the most part) are sitting by idly and saying to themselves (as Gocka has observed): "But what can I do about it?"
 
Јас незнам од каде сте брат, ама во мојето искyство, зивејан во Македонија, Европа и Австралија, диаспората остана да се бори за македонизмот. Жителите од република Македонија, особено граѓаните мајките ќе си ги продаат ако можат. А за тије на село...

Koga bev na odmor vo Makedonija pred 12 godini, i zboraa za siptarite eden (od celo) vikase “ke na zgazat” a drug “ako go sakat (del) ke si go zemat”….. opasno.
 
http://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/presents-proposals-greece-macedonia-dispute-52413341

UN presents new proposals on Greece-Macedonia name dispute

U.N. mediator Matthew Nimetz presented new proposals Wednesday to resolve a 25-year-old dispute between Greece and Macedonia over the Balkan nation's name and said he should know within two months whether progress can be made.

Nimetz told reporters after meeting with negotiators from both countries he is "very hopeful that this process is moving in a positive direction."

"I really believe that we have leadership in both Athens and Skopje that genuinely want a solution," he said. "They don't just say they want a solution. I think they believe it's in the national interest of both countries to solve this problem."

Nimetz said the negotiators are taking his ideas back to their capitals and both governments have invited him to visit, which he expects to do in "the next couple of weeks."

"I think in the next month, two months, (is) a good period in which we should know whether we can make some good, serious progress here or not," he said.

If there is a green light, Nimetz said, it's possible to solve the problem in six months.

He wouldn't comment on the ideas he presented but said "I myself don't think it's realistic to expect the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia not to have Macedonia in some form in its name."

Greece maintains its northern neighbor's name implies a territorial claim to its own adjoining province of Macedonia — home of Alexander the Great, one of the most famous ancient Greek rulers.

Officially called the Republic of Macedonia when it peacefully gained independence from Yugoslavia in 1991, the country was admitted to the United Nations in 1993 under the provisional name of The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia because of the dispute with Greece.

As a NATO member, Greece has blocked Macedonia's bid to join the alliance because of the name dispute. Athens is also angry at Macedonia's appropriation of ancient Macedonian history. Macedonia counters that it covers a region that has been known as Macedonia for a long time.

Nimetz, the personal envoy of Secretary-General Antonio Guterres, said the leaders of Greece and Macedonia "both have national interests they want to pursue ... (and) they have to make some tough choices."

"I think the people of the region are ready to solve this problem," he said. "The international community really wants it solved."

But Nimetz said there are people in Greece and Macedonia "that have a very negative attitude" and no clear solution to the problem.

"This dispute has gone on for 25 years. Should it go on for another 25 years? Is that going to be helpful to the people, to the young people, in the area? I don't think so," he said. "Each country is a democracy and they're going to work it out their way, and if they don't want an agreement there won't be an agreement."

But Nimetz said the leaders and the situation in the region are different now.

"I view this as a good set of ideas, a compromise and a package that both sides should feel comfortable with, and lead to a dignified and satisfactory solution," he said.
 
https://www.washingtonpost.com/worl...bf0da31214d_story.html?utm_term=.0069b77dd296

NATO chief due in Macedonia to discuss membership bid

SKOPJE, Macedonia — NATO's secretary-general arrived in Macedonia on Wednesday for talks on the country's renewed accession bid, a decade after a dispute with neighboring Greece halted an initial effort to join the alliance.

Jens Stoltenberg will have meetings in the capital, Skopje, on Thursday with the new left-led government, which came to power last year and has pledged to try and resolve the more than two-decade quarrel with Greece.

The two countries disagree over Macedonia's name. Greece, which as a NATO member blocked its neighbor's NATO access in 2008, says it implies territorial claims on its own northern province of Macedonia. Macedonia denies that.

The dispute dates to 1991 when Macedonia peacefully gained independence from the former Yugoslavia. Greece recognizes the country as the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia
 
Tomche, I was hesitant at first to accept your "European Slav" outlook because I just didn't believe that many Macedonians felt that way. But I don't know now.

There are still indigenous Macedonians in Macedonia, and they (for the most part) are sitting by idly and saying to themselves (as Gocka has observed): "But what can I do about it?"

We have known a difference has come to exist for a long time now within the Republic, how to accurately define it has evolved over the years and is still debatable. What can be generally accepted is that the difference has been essentially ideologically based, most likely derived from a product of Yugoslavian (perhaps even Soviet influenced) communist indoctrination. I relate it to a kind of synthetic virus, a virus which has, contrary to its original intention, found a way to adapt itself in order to survive independently after the original host died, and now seeks to mutate itself to accommodate new similar hosts.

I have mentioned this before but the question I fear we may have to start to consider asking at some point is whether this process has evolved the virus into something more than just a difference in ideology, whether it is in fact becoming a difference in identity.

I feel it is this element which makes acceptance become a complicated matter, as acceptance could see our path directed towards an alternate trajectory, one which right now may be premature to commit to as its consequences may prove to be detrimental to the cause, hence in this respect I share your hesitations.

Nevertheless, the difference exists. Its extent is what needs to be accurately determined.

Can we now confidently state there are two separate Macedonian identities existing within the Republic? (i.e. The European Slav whose Macedonian identity is derived from a regional sense similar to the “Greek” Macedonian; and The Indigenous Macedonian whose Macedonian identity is derived from an ethnic ancestral sense).

Although I've highlighted its likely existence, to be honest, I couldn’t wholly or officially commit to such a conclusion at this point, but there certainly appears to be more and more indicators that point towards that direction, a prime and convincing example being the article that you responded to.
 
Last edited:
I suppose I am. If I had no hope at all then, I would be well on my way to being good old Yankee doodle George Peterson rather than Goce Petreski. On the other hand, who am I kidding, if any of these cunts were able to reflect or had remorse, you figure it would have kicked in by now.

...lol

Gocka, it sounds like you're still hanging onto a gossamer of hope that they'll see the error in their ways, even when the end has finally come...like some deathbed confession.
 
Apparently Greece will allow a new name that contains the word Macedonia, but here's the catch, it will not allow it to be translated into English. In other words, Greece will hold a monopoly to the English word "Macedonia". Macedonia's new name will be spelled in Serbian Latinica, ex. "Severna Makedonija", and that's the name to be used in all international organizations. In the olympics we will march under the letter "S", not "M", and not even "N" for Northern Macedonia, but "S" for "Severna Makedonija".

The only other state I can think of that is not allowed to translate its name in English is Bosnia's autonomous region of "Republika Srpska" Link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republika_Srpska
 
Back
Top