Bratot
New member
This is true Bratot, that is why subsequent factors need to be considered to make more specific determinations regarding who these traits originally derived from. Let's compare the Macedonians and the Bulgars. The latter solemnly believe that their nation arrived from somewhere other than the Balkans, and for all intents and purposes, this is what they claim as their historical narrative. The Macedonians didn't originate from somewhere outside of the Balkans, nor do they harbour such fantastic theories. Using these two nations alone to draw a comparison in relation to this particular matter, I would say that the traditional use of the bagpipe would find an older history among the Macedonians than the Bulgars. Same applies for the kolo/oro dances. Of course, today, after centuries of use, it has become a part of Bulgar culture, and, while indigenous to the region in which they now live and the Thracian people they assimilated, it was not indigenous to the people they claim to have primarily descended from, who were the progenitors of their nation.
I agree, blood purity is nonsense, however, DNA research does have its benefits.
There is an arousin question in your comparison, the term - Bulgarian was not indigenous endonym* on the Balkans, so if the nowadays Bulgarians identify with it they could or could not be the true hereditary people of it's terminology. So what were the 'Bulgarians' before they adopted this exonym** ?
*A name used by a people to refer to themselves or their language, as opposed to a name given to them by other groups. For example, Deutschen is the endonym of a people known in English as German.
**a name given to a group or category of people by a secondary person or persons other than the people it refers to.
Exonyms form a typical (but very useful) example of cultural chauvinism.
The Bulgarian identification with this exonym or precizelly exo-ethnonym is a politically occured geographical paradox which forced the Bulgarian national-chauvinist to seek 'historical' justification of providing some sort of 'superiority' of their nation in more directions, but this national complex produced only numerous historical distorsions and identity crisis.
I don't think we can really compare to their case.
Last edited: