• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Macedonian Nationalism

Originally Posted by Indigen
I consider myself as a DIRECT DESCENDANT (i.e. blood, however pure) and inherit (evolving, without excluding other external inputs over time) cultural continuity from the same forbears!

Indigen, in the above quote you consider yourself to be an inheritor or 'external inputs', which indicates a mixture of foreign elements (at least to a certain degree) in the evolution of Macedonians.

I am not excluding external blood inputs somewhere in the past but I am not claiming any either. My parents, grandparents and great grandparents (Father's and mother's paternal line only) are ALL Macedonians. The reference to external input/s is in relation to culture as applies to the base evolving indigenous MACEDONIAN CULTURE. The discovery of America by Columbus and the introduction of various new foods into Europe, amongst other places, would be one major import. The chilli - PIPERKA as a staple food of the Macedonian peasant is but one example.

MONGREL-BREED FRUIT SALAD
What exactly do you mean by 'mongrel-breed fruit salad'?
Some of the proponents of the "Slav Macedonian" theory (i.e. the mass invasion of "Slavs" into Macedonia, amongst other areas), unable to sustain such a bogus claim, are now retouching it by presenting in a modified form whereby they may now include ancient Macedonians/indigenous elements in a mix with "Slavs" and a whole bunch of others (fruit salad) who have equal or greater importance than the indigenous element. These same proponents generally will imply that the incoming "Slavs" encountered the "Latinised remnants" of the indigenous (ancient) Macedonians - THE VLACHS and thereby implying the Macedonians are a new creation - Fruit SALAD of "Slavs", Vlachs, and etc.!


----------------
m-r Pandil Kosturski: KOGA "IZUMREA " ANTICKITE MAKEDONCI? [NM, 1992]


A. Donski - Koj saka da im ja amputira antichkata istorija i poteklo na Makedoncite?
 
“.....The terms “Slav Macedonian” has not been and never will be accepted by the Macedonian community in Australia and abroad as it is a vilification and denial of Macedonians’ cultural, ethnic and national identity.

The term “Slav Macedonian” is an offensive slogan of propaganda used by Greek and other oppressors of the Macedonian people in order to usurp the heritage, suppress the identity and deny the existence of the indigenous Macedonians....”

The above two paragraphs are excerpted from the media release and public statement “The National Position of the Macedonian-Australian Community against the Slav-Prefix directive”, issued March 1994 and ENDORSED BY ALL MACEDONIAN ORGANISATIONS IN AUSTRALIA...
I think I remember writing and advocating those paragraphs (as a co-author of the media release) at the age of 20. 16 years later, I have changed my outlook on many things, but not on that. The only thing I would probably change is the use of the term 'vilification' in that way. It kind of implies that being a "Slav" is something evil, yet I don't really know what it is.

Good to know that you uphold the principles of our community of that time! IMO, there is no need to change a thing as you got it right the first time. There is NO SUCH THING AS A "SLAV" and being called one IS A VILIFICATION and denial of Macedonians’ cultural, ethnic and national identity.
 
It's a biological law Aleksandrov, every single genetic anylise so far have provided clear genetical diversity in every single human being, which is pretty much logical....

To avoid giving you more opportunities for convoluting the discussion or engaging red herring, I will deal with one point at a time from here:

I asked you for evidence of your claims about our mixed ETHNIC genes, in the same way you asked me for evidence of genetic continuity of my ethnic genes since ancient time.

If there is as much evidence around as you claim, you should be able to cite it. If you can't, be intelligent and honorable enough to admit that you have no evidence, just like I have admitted that I have no evidence of my ethnic continuity of my genes since ancient times.
 
Not wanting to steal DimkoPiperkatas thunder from the thread

Macedonian Truth Forum > Macedonian Truth Forum > General Discussions
Why do we post so many topics about Greeks?


I have posted here as the name of the above thread doesn’t seem quite right.

I just wanted to ask one question.

If as RTG says
Macedonian Truth Forum > Macedonian Truth Forum > General Discussions
Why do we post so many topics about Greeks?
Greece represents our biggest threat to maintaining our identity in the world arena.
Greece does this by attempting to trivialise and denigrate our identity.


And SoM says
Macedonian Truth Forum > Macedonian Truth Forum > General Discussions
Why do we post so many topics about Greeks?
In answer to the original question, the quantity of topics about Greeks is a direct response to the quantity of propaganda that they criminally spread against the Macedonians to their own people and the rest of the world. We must respond to their stupidity and lies, and we will meet them at every challenge, and win this fight.


Then isn’t the core question with regards to our identity are we

1. direct decedents of the Macedonians of Alexanders time or

2. were the Macedonians of Alexanders time originally something different to us and our ancestors were newcomers who either mixed with these ancient Macedonians to produce us and if so when and if they were something different then who were they kin to or

3. were superseded by our ancestors and if so when. Was this action complete or did it force the ancient Macedonians south or out.

These are pretty much the only options.

In general the Greeks assert
1. the ancient Macedonians were something different to our ancestors and that they were kin to the ancient Greeks.

2. They further assert that they are the direct decedents of the ancient Greeks and as the ancient Macedonians were there kin then they also are the decedents of the ancient Macedonians.

3. The so called concession they are making is to acknowledge that our ancestors may have mix with some of the ancient Macedonians to produce us and as such we are a kind of Macedonian or

4. Our ancestors have been there so long we have become a kind of Macedonian with minimal mixing in either case we are a kind of Macedonian hence the demand for a qualifier beit Northern ect.

Does it not seem obvious that to conclusively answer these questions a timeline needs to be established with evidence we are Macedonians beginning with modern times working backwards to Alexanders ancient Macedonians whom both sides seem to agree were Macedonians. A shorter answer would be to establish the ancient Macedonians were not kin to the Greeks. The obvious dilemma to this is the lack of physical written evidence due to the supposed no written Macedonian alphabet but nonetheless as can be found on MTO there is much evidence to support the Macedonian case.

It seems to me that the Greeks have been able to peddle their lies unabated because the Macedonians have never been free to counter until now and also because the west has been in cahoots with the Greeks. Is it not possible to collate and present another inconvenient truth to the world. When they have no answer to the truth it defeats any name negotiations and posses at least a serious question about the rights of Macedonians in the occupied lands if not further as to what is to be done to land that is clearly foreign occupied.

Some have questioned do we need to prove a link to Alexanders day. This is the only accepted by all time that the people were Macedonians.
Very good take, given the doubts I had/have about your genuinity as an Ozi Mak!
 
Aleksandrov,

I hold no animosity for anyone but don't underestimate me and trying to be Indigen rescuer when he repeatedly confirmed his racistic claim about the how he comprehend the "continuity".
I don't need anyone to be my defense attorney but I have NO INTENTION of WASTING TIME ON YOUR INCOMPREHENSIBLE RAMBLINGS! Thus if you try to use anything I post in order to make some point with Aleksandrov, Vangelovski, or others, they should be able to challenge your claims.

He doesn't have to use the exact term 'purity' in order to qualify his claim of 'genetical continuity' opposite from the "salad" in order to be "direct" descendant.
Blah, blah, blah...you are a CONFUSED MALAKA, IMO!

What could "salad" means if not some proportion of foreign genes and than logically it's about being 'pure', hmm? Or you will continue ignoring the sane logic?
You are insane!

Well... according to Indigen we are 'direct' descedants.
YES! Anti-Macedonians find it such an evil thought - tought titties then! :-)

But you should ask your self what is such absurdal claim suggesting in line with the "clean" genetical continuity?
Where did anybody mention "clean"? We are in the main INDIGENOUS MACEDONIAN IN BLOOD AND CULTURE and, IMHO, whoever does not like that, can burn in hell for eternity!

So, talking about such 'genetic continuity' and holding so tightly about it, in order to provide some imagined condition to prove our indigenous existance can be very easy harmful to the clear meaning of being a Macedonian today.
KE?
FYI: Genetic=Blood! Krvta ne e voda za da ispari!

When I said that we shouldn't get into the Greek trap of " proving the direct ancestry " if we want to be called Macedonians I had on mind exactly what Indigen is doing.
You are acting as TM's advocate and are posting contradictory claims all over the place.

We do have a genetical continuity, but it's a continuity we share with all of the populations surrounding us in a wider regional meaning.
And you know this for certain and that we share exactly the same markers with Albanians, Greeks, Bulgars, Slovenes, Hungarians, Romanians, Turks, Roms, Turks, Serbs, Croats, etc?


We are not able to define the genes of our Macedonian ancestors and even if we do, they will also show a diversity rate since the transmition of the genetical matherial is not a isolated process, and they will also share that matherial with the rest of the ancient Balkan populations as we do today.
Ancient Balkan (Macedonian Peninsula) ancestry is great for our cause, you boof-head! It completely counters aggressive Gheg and Greek claims that we are "Slav" invaders on the native "Illyrian" and "Hellenic" land!

But if we chose the path of Indigen logics, than every our neighboor will be equally or nearly genetical 'Macedonian' as we are.
NONSENSE and GIBBERISH!


Стани МАКЕДОНИЈО, крени знаме високо
сонце АЛЕКСАНДРОВО, знаме баш македонско,
Стани Македонијо, викни свои синови,
земја да се одбрани, земја баш македонска

YouTube - ‪Macedonia,Suzana Spasovska - STANI MAKEDONIJO Goce Fest 2002‬‎


Земјо МАКЕДОНИЈО ништо не те плашеше
Смело низ вековите народот те градеше.
Гордо МАКЕДОНИЈО чекори кон сонцето
Чеда АЛЕКСАНДРОВИ со вас е вистината!

Гордо МАКЕДОНИЈО чекори кон сонцето
Чеда АЛЕКСАНДРОВИ со вас е вистината!


Гордо МАКЕДОНИЈО!!!

YouTube - ‪Suzana Spasovska "GORDO MAKEDONIJO "‬‎

Nie ne sme Grci
Bugari ni Srbi
Cheda sme na Aleksandar
Gordost Makedonska


Edna misla imame
Eden zhivot zhiveeme
Makedonia cela da e
YouTube - ‪Edna misla imame | Една мисла имаме‬‎
 
When I said that we shouldn't get into the Greek trap of " proving the direct ancestry " if we want to be called Macedonians I had on mind exactly what Indigen is doing.

Who have ever seen such condition to be made in order to be fulfilled from some group of people to have the right to identify themselfs with their ancestors who lived 24 centuries ago?

It's very clear to me, what they want to achieve with this trap, since it's basicaly impossible to track such genealogy and it's biological absurd to preserve the exactly same genetic matherial with your ancient ancestors.



You are right Bratot. This is a Greek trap and it`s sad to see some people here lured with it. This is some kind of competition that you can never win because you cannot beat the Greek propaganda machine on this issue. They have 200 years of delusional material which have already been accepted as truth by many.

Also, why you should think that you have to be direct descendant of ancient Macedonians to consider yourself as indigenous here? This is also against human nature. The culture of societies evolves in time with connections of other societies. No one invents everything as their own. This idea is even against the philosophy of Alexander the Great as we knew because his Empire was multi-cultural too.







One good example can be the Hungarians who both culturally and ethnically significantly differ from their surrounding:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17632797

and tell me, in your opinion Aleksandrov, does the modern Hungarians have lost the right to be 'Hungarians' anymore since they cannot provide genetical continuity with their ancient ancestors?


Hungarians today, preserves their Eurasian roots in terms of culture, including their language but genetically, they have been mixed with the western european populations like Germans and all other people in Balkans. As far as i know, western european racial ideas didn't spread among them and today, they enjoy their Euroasian roots and they don't let it disappear.



So, according to Indigen`s philosophy, Hungarians should be "MONGREL-BREED FRUIT SALAD" too, like the Turks, hehe :)
 
Last edited:
Some of the proponents of the "Slav Macedonian" theory (i.e. the mass invasion of "Slavs" into Macedonia, amongst other areas), unable to sustain such a bogus claim, are now retouching it by presenting in a modified form whereby they may now include ancient Macedonians/indigenous elements in a mix with "Slavs" and a whole bunch of others (fruit salad) who have equal or greater importance than the indigenous element. These same proponents generally will imply that the incoming "Slavs" encountered the "Latinised remnants" of the indigenous (ancient) Macedonians - THE VLACHS and thereby implying the Macedonians are a new creation - Fruit SALAD of "Slavs", Vlachs, and etc.!

You are beyond any logic and your effort to include some "Slav" threat by admitting you share some proportion of those proposed to be "Slav" genes it goes in line with those who are trying to give greater significance to one (marked as Slav) proportion of genes in order to eliminate or neutralize the other.


First of all, it's very very easy to get in a blind debate when one doesn't possess even the basic knowledge about certain issues he makes conclussions of.

There are no "Slav" genes but a most common genetical matherial appearing in the Slav "speaking" population in Europe, nor the Ra1 marker can be accepted as one by the panslavic theories who would like to present it that way.

If you take any genetical map available on the source I recomended to you, will clearly see that the Ra1 marker appears in a varriety of geographycal regions, such as - Eastern Asia China, India, Caucasus, Central-Eastern Europe, Scandinavia and in many other places where was never recorded that the Slav migration occured (like Scottland or Crete), so the only conclussion about Ra1 is that the 10% or 15% of this genetical marker are much older and have existed before any "migration" theory was proposed to have occured in the past.

http://www.ethnoancestry.com/R1a.html

800px-GlobalR1a1a.png


Even the modern 'Slavic' peoples come from a wide variety of genetic backgrounds.


The genetic argumentation we need to hold on, without interfering some 'ethnic' genetical continuity, is this:

The three groups of humans had taken refuge for so long that their DNA had naturally picked up mutations, and consequently can be defined into different haplogroups. As they spread from these refuges, Haplogroups R1b, I and R1a propagated across Europe.

- Haplogroup R1b is common on the western Atlantic coast as far as Scotland.
- Haplogroup I is common across central Europe and up into Scandinavia.
- Haplogroup R1a is common in eastern Europe and has also spread across into central Asia and as far as India and Pakistan

http://www.dnaheritage.com/masterclass2.asp

europe_haplogroups_2.jpg


YHAPLOGROUP.jpg

http://www.scs.uiuc.edu/~mcdonald/WorldHaplogroupsMaps.pdf

and

nationalgeoH-Igroup.jpg


Hierarchical analysis of 28 Y-chromosome SNP’s in the
population of the Republic of Macedonia
P. Noveski
, S. Trivodalieva, G. D. Efremov, D. Plaseska-Karanfilska;

Macedonian Academy of Sciences and Arts, Research Centre for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology, Skopje,
Republic of Macedonia.
Analysis of Y-chromosome haplogroups, defined by single nucleotide
polymorphisms (SNP’s), has become a standard approach for studying the origin of human populations and measuring the variability among them.
Furthermore, Y-SNP’s represent a new forensic tool, because
their population specificity may allow to determine the origin of any
male sample of interest for forensic purposes. The aim of this study was to develop a strategy for rapid, simple and inexpensive Y-chromosome SNP’s typing in the population of R. Macedonia.
We have studied a total of 343 DNA male samples; 211 Macedonians, 111 Albanians and 21 of other ethnic origin (Roma, Serbs and Turks).
Methodology included multiplex PCR and single nucleotide extension reaction by SNaPshot multiplex kit. The set of 28 markers has been grouped in 5 multiplexes in order to determine the most frequent haplogroups using only 1 or 2 multiplexes. Twenty different Y haplogroups were determined among 343 male DNA samples.
The finding that five haplogroups (E3b1, I1b1, J2b1a, R1a and R1b) comprise more than 70% of the Y chromosomes is consistent with the typical European Y chromosome gene pool. The distribution of the Y-haplogroups differs between Macedonians and Albanians. The most common Y haplogroup among Macedonians is I1b1 (27.5%), followed by three haplogroups present with similar frequencies E3b1 (15.6%), R1a (14.2%) and R1b
(11.4%). Among Albanians the most frequent Y haplogroup is E3b1 (28.8%), followed by R1b (18.0%), J2b1a (13.5%) and R1a (12.6%).


It is very important to note that membership in a particular haplogroup does not (by itself) indicate the ethnic group from which the patrilineal line derives


And here is something for rethinking:

At the time of Ötzi 5.300 years ago,the autohtonus “Macedonians” and “Basques” shared a trade language.
To this day the features and items associated with the Iceman have similar names in Basque and in Macedonian language.

otzimk4.gif

Petr Jandáček-Prebivalstvo na tleh Srednje Evrope p.17-20
127 La Senda Rd, Los Alamos, NM 87544, USA
E-mail: jandacek@mesatop.com p.jandacek@laschools.net


GOAT-SKINS have been used in antiquity for water vessels and BELLOWS. GOAT-SKIN bellows were needed for the smelting of copper for OTZI's axe-head. OTZI had with him at least 3 parts of an ibex goat.

It is a natural step to combine a wood-wind musical instrument with goat-skin bellows and come up with a type of bag-pipes. The Basques call this instrument GAITA.
Such instrument is also used by Slovaks and their neighbors (Ruthenians, Czechs & Guralu Poles) who call it GAJDA. Creatures possessing HUMAN & GOAT CHARACTERISTICS & PLAYING WOOD-WIND INSTRUMENTS have been depicted on walls of caves more than 25.000 years ago.

http://www.laschools.net/146120827151657640/blank/browse.asp?A=383&BMDRN=2000&BCOB=0&C=54843


Well.. we have GAJDA as well the Scottish, so do we need really to invent some absurdal claims in order to satisfy the Greek propaganda?

Or this is enough to be calm and confident about our INDIGENOUS origin and culture?

If for you Indigen those 15% mean that the population in Macedonia came from behind Karpatians you have a big problem with the idea of those percentage and what they actually mean.

Since they are confirmed to exist today, it's about 14 centuries(after the 6 A.D.) when they could possibly "arrive" not related to any proposed "Slavic" migration, but recent occurance.

I wont even try to suggest how will look our genetic picture after another 14 centuries, God forbid it.

It's time we end this "genetical" paranoia and focus on some more reasonable and productive for us.
Haplogroup I1b

The undifferentiated subclade of Haplogroup I1b (or I1b*) is centered in the Balkans, where its founders may have taken refuge from the Ice Age. After the Ice Age, I1b* spread into Eastern Europe...

I1b Haplotype #2

This haplotype exhibits its highest European frequencies in Poland, Macedonia and Italy. There are also hits in Sweden and Saxony.

Enough clear?

And if any of you have any remarks about the "Slav" threat please visit this thread:

http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=4002
 
Last edited:
Tradition has played a lot in macedonian culture & there's heaps of books written on how it has evolved all on it's own.For example the customs observed in weddings,music etc etc.Also the clothes the macedonians wore there are so many things.The culture didn't just happen hokus pokus poof presto magic.It has evolved over many thousands of years passed on from mother to daughter father to son etcetc .The macedonian culture is ine evidence that can't be refuted there's ample proof of it's development & existence.
 
Indigen said:
Some of the proponents of the "Slav Macedonian" theory (i.e. the mass invasion of "Slavs" into Macedonia, amongst other areas), unable to sustain such a bogus claim, are now retouching it by presenting in a modified form whereby they may now include ancient Macedonians/indigenous elements in a mix with "Slavs" and a whole bunch of others (fruit salad) who have equal or greater importance than the indigenous element. These same proponents generally will imply that the incoming "Slavs" encountered the "Latinised remnants" of the indigenous (ancient) Macedonians - THE VLACHS and thereby implying the Macedonians are a new creation - Fruit SALAD of "Slavs", Vlachs, and etc.!
Has anybody indicated as such (in the manner you have implied, particularly the underlined) at the MTO?
 
Has anybody indicated as such (in the manner you have implied, particularly the underlined) at the MTO?
I don't keep track of many topics or posters here on MTO and thus I can't say for sure but I think there are a few who would adhere to the official RM national narrative, as taught in schools for generations since 1945. Some may post elsewhere such ideological positions whilst MTO members may (or do) hold them in high esteem in general. Some may just applaud such views when expressed by others (especially at other fora) and then completely oppose those advocating Macedonian indigenity on MTO.

To cut it short, I know of a couple of MTO members who have expressed such views in full or in part and some of that has been posted here on MTO by myself but I do not wish to escalate this issue any further at this time. So please let sleeping dogs lie as there are more important issues to focus on.
 
To avoid giving you more opportunities for convoluting the discussion or engaging red herring, I will deal with one point at a time from here:

I asked you for evidence of your claims about our mixed ETHNIC genes, in the same way you asked me for evidence of genetic continuity of my ethnic genes since ancient time.

If there is as much evidence around as you claim, you should be able to cite it. If you can't, be intelligent and honorable enough to admit that you have no evidence, just like I have admitted that I have no evidence of my ethnic continuity of my genes since ancient times.

You have lost this subject before even entered it and now you trying to save some face.

You really need and have to study a lil bit more about the genetic background and than enter such debate.

Your existence today wouldn't be possible if there was no genetical mixing. It's kind of silly what you are asking me, but I'm honourable enough not to make a fun of it.


Take account what I already posted in my previous post and add this:

Hierarchical analysis of 28 Y-chromosome SNP’s in the
population of the Republic of Macedonia
P. Noveski
, S. Trivodalieva, G. D. Efremov, D. Plaseska-Karanfilska;

Macedonian Academy of Sciences and Arts, Research Centre for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology, Skopje,
Republic of Macedonia.
Analysis of Y-chromosome haplogroups, defined by single nucleotide
polymorphisms (SNP’s), has become a standard approach for studying the origin of human populations and measuring the variability among them.
Furthermore, Y-SNP’s represent a new forensic tool, because
their population specificity may allow to determine the origin of any
male sample of interest for forensic purposes. The aim of this study was to develop a strategy for rapid, simple and inexpensive Y-chromosome SNP’s typing in the population of R. Macedonia.
We have studied a total of 343 DNA male samples; 211 Macedonians, 111 Albanians and 21 of other ethnic origin (Roma, Serbs and Turks).
Methodology included multiplex PCR and single nucleotide extension reaction by SNaPshot multiplex kit. The set of 28 markers has been grouped in 5 multiplexes in order to determine the most frequent haplogroups using only 1 or 2 multiplexes. Twenty different Y haplogroups were determined among 343 male DNA samples.
The finding that five haplogroups (E3b1, I1b1, J2b1a, R1a and R1b) comprise more than 70% of the Y chromosomes is consistent with the typical European Y chromosome gene pool. The distribution of the Y-haplogroups differs between Macedonians and Albanians. The most common Y haplogroup among Macedonians is I1b1 (27.5%), followed by three haplogroups present with similar frequencies E3b1 (15.6%), R1a (14.2%) and R1b
(11.4%). Among Albanians the most frequent Y haplogroup is E3b1 (28.8%), followed by R1b (18.0%), J2b1a (13.5%) and R1a (12.6%).

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11260506?dopt=Abstract

http://www.makedonika.org/processpaid.aspcontentid=ti.2001.pdf

You have graphic presentation.

http://www.igenea.com/index.php?content=49&id=40

Y-haplogroups in Macedonia

I2a 32 %
E1b1b 25 %
J2 20 %
R1a 15 %
R1b 8 %

http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/journal/118742265/abstract?CRETRY=1&SRETRY=0
A phylogenetic tree constructed on the basis of the high-resolution data deriving from other populations revealed the clustering of Macedonians together with other Balkan populations (Greeks, Croats, Turks and Romanians) and Sardinians, close to another "European" cluster consisting of the Italian, French, Danish, Polish and Spanish populations'

http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/journal/118904328/abstract

Phylogenetic and correspondence analyses showed that Bulgarians are more closely related to Macedonians, Greeks, and Romanians than to other European populations and Middle Eastern people living near the Mediterranean

http://www.springerlink.com/content/8300nn2q37527183/

Phylogenetic analysis based on HLA allele frequencies shows that Bulgarians were characterized with closest genetic similarity to Macedonians, Greeks, Romanians, Cretans and Sardinians in comparison to the other European and Mediterranean populations.

http://www.nature.com/ejhg/journal/v11/n7/full/5200992a.html

Haplogroups R1a and R1b showed the opposite frequency distribution to I-M170 and were more common in the northwest among the mainland population and in the northern island Krk. The frequency of R1b in Croatian sample (7.9%) is comparable to some other Balkan populations, for example, Macedonian (10%),41 Greek (11%) and Yugoslavian (11%),33
The average frequency of R1a in Croatian mainland population (34%) is similar to the value of other Slavs, for example, Macedonians (35%), Czechs and Slovaks (27%).41

http://hpgl.stanford.edu/publications/Science_2000_v290_p1155.pdf

Graphics.


http://www.fsijournal.org/article/S0379-0738(04)00820-5/abstract

Observed allelic frequency distribution and locus diversity values in Macedonians correspond closer to neighboring southeastern European populations than (mostly) western European populations

Sixty-six (78.57%) haplotypes appeared in single copies in Macedonians

most frequent Macedonian haplotypes (DYS19-DYS385-DYS389I-DYS389II-DYS390-DYS391-DYS392-DYS393) 16-14/15-13-31-24-11-11-13 and 13-16/18-13-30-24-10-11-13 were found in 7 and 6 copies, respectively.

Total haplotype diversity was 0.9885±0.0058 (Macedonians)

http://kinoko.c.u-tokyo.ac.jp/~dura...ness_With_Other_Mediterranean_Populations.pdf

Palestinians are close to Egyptians, Lebanese, Iranians,
Cretans, Macedonians and Sardinians, and also to
Algerians, Spaniards, French, Italians and Basques
(Table 3, Figures 4, 5, and 6).

And Graphics.

http://e20.manu.edu.mk/prilozi/05e.pdf

The results of the comparison of the researched alleles indicate relatively
small genetic distances among the researched populations
. The obtained
dendrograms indicate a larger homogeneity in the large Balkan populations, and
a manifest trend of separating the Aromanian population of the Štip region. A
larger separation is characteristic in the Greek population of Thrace.



There was a simmilar thread on MTO:
http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=256

WorldHaplogroupsMaps1.png



And here it is how such absurdal claims produced by lack of basic knowledge have give another weapon to the Greek propaganda:
http://macedonia-evidence.org/victor-friedman.html
 
Last edited:
Bratot,

Are you going to continue patting yourself on the back indefinitely or will you start providing some direct answers to specific questions? Use a dictionary if you must.

Do you know what the word 'cite' means?

Do you know what 'evidence' means?

Do you know what the word 'ethnic' means?

What does 'ethnic genes' mean?

What does "mixed ethnic genes" mean?

What does What kind of specific evidence did I ask you to cite?
 
Last edited:
Good to know that you uphold the principles of our community of that time! IMO, there is no need to change a thing as you got it right the first time. There is NO SUCH THING AS A "SLAV" and being called one IS A VILIFICATION and denial of Macedonians’ cultural, ethnic and national identity.

I am just not sure that the 'vilification' is the most appropriate word to use to describe what you are trying to say and what I was trying to say at the time.
 
Aleksandrov,

I'm done with my explanations, if your aren't still capable to comprehend it than I leave it to somebody else to help you.

Everyone has his limit of tolerance and I think you used mine totally.

Irrespective of what you will try to insinuate next, every reasonable person not tendentious will understand what I exhaustedly explained and supported myself.

If you want to go in a circle, you do it alone.

With respect,
Mihail
 
That could have been a plausible exit strategy, only if you were able to delete all the evidence of who has said what on this thread, Bratot. Would you like me to help you delete it? Is being a false 'winner' is more important to you than the truth?
 
I edited my previous post with specific cites of the links I provided, even though you barely deserve such treatman and as I said already, irrespectively of your efforts to save some face in this thread the arguments are visible to everyone.

If you want to interpret this as my 'exit strategy' than I may say you have been pretty lucky I did.

Have a nice day.
 
I'll move onto something else, since you've definitely decided not to answer my last question.

...The other absurdal dimenssion in this claim is the "ethnic" genetical continuity, which will make us not only to lose every possible credibility in our rightful cause but we will enter a contest of new racist ideology.
...

In the second paragraph after saying the above, you wrote:

We do have a genetical continuity, but it's a continuity we share with all of the populations surrounding us in a wider regional meaning.

Is this supposed to mean that it is impossible to have 'ethnic genetical' continuity, but you know that we share 'multiethnic genetical continuity'? Does anybody apart from Bratot think that this proposition makes sense?

Regarding your point about a 'continuity we share with all of the populations surrounding us in a wider regional meaning, I cite one of the articles YOU posted hyperlinks to in my question as to what EVIDENCE you have to support your claims about our mixture of ethnic genetic 'material':

HLA alleles have been determined in individuals from the Republic of Macedonia by DNA [consider the distinction between this classification and Macedonian 'ethnicity'] typing and sequencing. HLA-A, -B, -DR, -DQ allele frequencies and extended haplotypes have been for the first time determined and the results compared to those of other Mediterraneans, particularly with their neighbouring Greeks. Genetic distances, neighbor-joining dendrograms and correspondence analysis have been performed. The following conclusions have been reached: 1) Macedonians belong to the ‘‘older’’ Mediterranean substratum, like Iberians (including Basques), North Africans, Italians, French, Cretans, Jews, Lebanese, Turks (Anatolians), Armenians and Iranians, 2) Macedonians are not related with geographically close Greeks, who do not belong to the ‘‘older’’ Mediterranenan substratum, 3) Greeks are found to have a substantial relatedness to sub-Saharan (Ethiopian) people, which separate them from other Mediterranean groups. Both Greeks and Ethiopians share quasi-specific DRB1 alleles, such as *0305, *0307, *0411, *0413, *0416, *0417, *0420, *1110, *1112, *1304 and *1310. Genetic distances are closer between Greeks and Ethiopian/sub-Saharan groups than to any other Mediterranean group and finally Greeks cluster with Ethiopians/sub-Saharans in both neighbour joining dendrograms and correspondence analyses. The time period when these relationships might have occurred was ancient but uncertain and might be related to the displacement of Egyptian-Ethiopian people living in pharaonic Egypt.

Note that my citation of an article that YOU quoted in support of YOUR theories does not amount to me accepting or rejecting the citation as evidence of anything other than your self-contradictions.

I won't tell you which article it came from, in order to encourage you to actually read all of the articles you have posted hyperlinks to.
 
Last edited:
I edited my previous post with specific cites of the links I provided..

Your new 'specific cites' not only do not amount to evidence of any of your prior claims about your mixed ethnic 'genetic material', but appear to make no reference to ethnicity whatsoever.
 
On the other hand, you have shown that your lack of knowledge and inability to discuss in a diplomatic manner perfectly fit the bill of your 'avatar', which displays nothing. I don't appreciate being labelled with your bogus terminology, save it for the other juveniles, or, you can go back to Maknews from whence you came.

To begin with, it would help if you corroborated every "god damn thing" you say.

What cat? What bag? What are you talking about? Can you corroborate what you're talking about? Enough with this cloak and dagger garbage, if you have something to say, then out with it, directly, and back up your assertions.

Who is the "rest" of the peanut gallery you fruit loop? At what point exactly did you start turning into an imbecile, because you certainly weren't one when you first came here? You seem to be running around like some cheerleader, what's your purpose at the MTO? What have YOU contributed to the MTO? I asked you before, do I need to ask you the same question again?

Shaky ground for what? What are you talking about? Is my integrity as a Macedonian being questioned? If so, by whom, you?

Any fool can speak their mind and give their opinion, it takes one with principle and integrity to back up their own statements.

SoM, you are babbling in fine form and I'm not going to follow into a Buktop style line for line, tit for tat spamathon with you. I'd been through it enough times over and over and a long time ago with the 'Greeks' getting stuff like 'Who says, you?' or 'go read a book'. It's a waste of time. If you want to spam me into the backwoods go ahead. Unlike you I don't need an avatar to try and make myself something or someone I clearly am not. My name and my word are enough.

Nothing I say would get anywhere on Maknews and past the delete button. You however would do a lot better when you think that this sort of discussion will help bring us to a consensus or greater understanding. How so? On the one hand you have someone who espouses a Christian (Slav) Tradition for Macedonians beginning in the 5th century AD. On the other hand you have what Macedonians have evolved into naturally of their own determination to whom the former talks down to in the most condescending and patronizing manner possible and refuses to even call some by their chosen name. If you've been around the block yet SoM, tell us what does that remind you of? The two sides are diametrically opposed and always will be. You choose to see this as healthy discussion. I see it as agitation. I'm exposing it and agitating back. I'm not interested in contributing anything to an internet forum other than to stand up for Macedonia.

On another note, you were very quick to jump out against my recommendation that we add a specific clause to the Macedonian Cause thread to clearly indicate that we are neither 'Bulgarian', 'Greek' nor 'Serbian'. What do you see as a more significant anecdote to sum up all of our problems on a practical level than that according to what we've been through the last 100 yrs? And why do you leave certain things open to interpretation that could possibly allow Slav loonies to take over, while we're asleep again, and to negotiate our name and our identity with the West? They are the only ones now besides the government who keep telling us how important the negotiations, EU clubs and NATO are to our future. Finally, in my opinion you are leaving the door open for our name to be changed and our identity to be decided by foreigners according to their interests once again. Of coarse this all assumes that the MTO Macedonian Cause will have some significant value or relevance in the grand scheme of things somewhere down the line.

Have a nice day.
 
I'll move onto something else, since you've definitely decided not to answer my last question.



In the second paragraph after saying the above, you wrote:



Is this supposed to mean that it is impossible to have 'ethnic genetical' continuity, but you know that we share 'multiethnic genetical continuity'? Does anybody apart from Bratot think that this proposition makes sense?

Regarding your point about a 'continuity we share with all of the populations surrounding us in a wider regional meaning, I cite one of the articles YOU posted hyperlinks to in my question as to what EVIDENCE you have to support your claims about our mixture of ethnic genetic 'material':



Note that my citation of an article that YOU quoted in support of YOUR theories does not amount to me accepting or rejecting the citation as evidence of anything other than your self-contradictions.

I won't tell you which article it came from, in order to encourage you to actually read all of the articles you have posted hyperlinks to.


Drowning man will clutch at a straw!

If you read exactly as you bolded the text it says: INDIVIDUALS

The same link you think it suits to you have shown exactly the opposite of what you are trying to impose, we DO share the genetic matherial.

The selected INDIVIDUALS from our side doesn't really have to correspond to the selected INDIVIDUALS from the Greek side, we are talking about an SELECTED EXAMPLE.

You will find many other genetical analyses where the result showed close relation among Macedonians and Greeks:

4. Interestingly, the ethnic Macedonians from R. Macedonia* have an R-M458 frequency of 3.8%, barely different from that of Greeks at large, suggesting that (i) the claims of some Greek nationalists that they Macedonians of R.M.* are newcomers to the Balkans are wrong, just as (ii) the claim of some Macedonian nationalists that they are markedly different from Greeks are wrong.
The actual truth is that the ethnic Macedonians from R. of Macedonia are largely of old Balkan (pre-Slavic) stock who adopted a non-Balkan Slavic language, just as the modern Turks are largely of old Anatolian (pre-Turkish) stock who adopted a non-Anatolian Turkic language.

http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=2122

Have you ever thought what if the examined "Greeks" or "Bulgarians" were actually of Macedonian origin, or vice versa?


The links I provided have sunk your 'big hope' of a question, nevertheless how ignoranmus it was.

Now you can ignore the links I provided and desperately try to diminish your failing.



Your new 'specific cites' not only do not amount to evidence of any of your prior claims about your mixed ethnic* 'genetic material', but appear to make no reference to ethnicity whatsoever.

'Whatsoever', you still continuously humiliate yourself by thinking that you actually make any sense, 'dude', you barely understand what you are talking about, stop when it's a time, show some dignity even when you're wrong.


At least stop inventing theories to fit some of your claims*.
 
Back
Top