Soldier of Macedon
Senior Member
Living in the same geographical region ensures an avenue for commonality in terms of culture and language to be developed and sustained between peoples of the same ethnic origin. That cannot be disputed. The reference to a 'cultural/political' identity, on the other hand, can quite easily be perceived as an oxymoron, as the two are not necessarily congruent with each other (today's Greeks are an obvious example of a single political identity consisting of multiple cultural and linguistic identities). As for political identities pertinent to today's ethnic groups in the Balkans, I don't believe there were any of great significance or impact within the Ottoman Empire prior to the late 18th century.Vangelovski said:Using the argument that the Macedonians were confined to a specific region suggests a ‘geographic’ identity rather than a cultural/political identity, and therefore I don’t think it resolves the problem of how a Macedonian is defined.
Those Macedonians all live in the Diaspora, and descend from Macedonian-speaking ancestors from Macedonia or the greater region. That they (or their parents) didn't take enough measures to ensure that the language survived in their own families does not exclude them from being Macedonians, nor does it exclude the fact that their ancestors were indeed Macedonian-speakers.This does not resolve the issue of thousands (perhaps tens of thousands) of Macedonians who do not speak Macedonian at all, standard or dialect.
I don't see a problem there, intra-cultural diversity is to be expected in a historically and culturally rich land like Macedonia. India is another good example. Therefore, I am not at all suprised that some customs in Struga may not be familiar in Bitola; that still doesn't exclude one or the other from being Macedonian.I was married in the Struga region and many of the customs were, quite frankly, alien to my relatives from Bitola. In fact, many of the traditional wedding customs that are practiced by the people in Misleso/Moroista are different to those practiced by people in Struga, which is literally 1-2 km away. How do we account for this? We cannot say that all Macedonians practice the same traditions and customs, nor can we say one group is Macedonian and the other not.
Assimilated to what degree? You will have to be more specific, because I have met few Macedonians that were completely unaware of their own heritage.Further, what can we say about Macedonians living in the diaspora who do not meaningfully practice Macedonian customs and are culturally assimilated into their host societies? Are they Macedonian?
I don't agree with that argument, but you're entitled to your opinion. Even if the language and/or culture isn't a strong element in their everyday life, it was for their ancestors, from whom they derive their heritage.Neither language nor culture can account for what it means to be a Macedonian (or any other ethnonationality for that matter).
They are flawed only to those that don't understand the argument and aren't able to argue conclusively in favour of their own views. If you accept what I have suggested, then the flaw disappears.But how can we account for our forefathers being ‘Macedonian’ on the basis of language and culture when those two ‘indicators’ are flawed themselves.......
How much do you know about the relationship between Paleo-Balkan and Balto-Slavic langauges? I respect your knowledge regarding matters pertaining to religion, for example, but I think you are outside of your element in this instance (like most other Macedonians on this forum) and would suggest that you look into the matter a little more if you want to make an informed statement regarding the ancient Macedonian language.......and have been shown not to be an indicator of identity for even ancient Macedonians on this forum?
That would be true if only the (secondary) geographical indicator was to be accepted into the equation. When the other indicators (particularly the primary indicators) are taken into consideration the answer is more definitive.Living in close geographic proximity does not in of itself resolve the issue of different cultural traits among Macedonians or cultural traits that we share with other people. It only suggests a ‘geographic’ identity, and this is incorrect.
How would you define a Macedonian?