Makedonin,
I don't think you have understood the arguments Craig has put forward, so I'm not sure how to debate this with you any further.
I perfectly understand the argument that Craig puts. It is the usual oversimplified and isolated argument you or Craig use.
I also understand the underlining agenda and zeal of Craig.
For the sake of the argument let us say I agree with Craig that God is needed to have objective morals and that he somehow instilled us with the sense of what is good or wrong. So objective morals come from God.
In the videos you provide he is pulling the tongue of the other dude to say the above, so I have said it.
The next thing I would be hearing is that the God of the Bible is the one that is postulating this objective morals.
But that instilled sense of moral tells me exactly that the God of the Bible is bending the moral values how he prefers or needs. He is also cruel and selfish God that I with my instilled moral values can't say that he is a moral being.
That is my problem with the whole under cover semi philosophical argument you and Craig are giving.
When Craig's argument is taken out of it's isolation, the next question that will be asked is whose version of God is the real one that postulates the objective morals. Is it the Christianity and which brand and flavor of it. Or maybe the Jewish or Muslem God?
You see, Craig's argument is only than valid when hiding in isolation and taken over simplistic. Once facing reality of religion of human kind, it fails short of convincing.
But even if we go and say his argument is somehow valid, and God is the measurement of the objective morals and this is God of the Bible, than this is only another subjective moral value, namely
GODS SUBJECTIVE MORALS, and
objectivity per definition means not to be bound to any subject or bias, but be valid in any circumstance and independent of any observer or subject.
He knows that and that is why he is arguing and preassigning that God in his essence is good, benevolent etc.
BUT taken in the light of the Bible that he set off to defend with the given argument, this obviously becomes a gullible argument, cause the Bible God is proven not to be per default good, benevolent etc. Instead he is jealous God per his definition:
Do not follow other gods, the gods of the peoples around you; for the LORD your God, who is among you,
is a jealous God and his anger will burn against you, and he will destroy you from the face of the land.
Deuteronomy 6:15
The God of the bible is a selfish God, and selfishness is subjective which makes Craig's presumption false.
So, Craig's argument and his hidden agenda are contradicting presumptions that does not serve his cause and are semi philosophy and science.
Further, this very refutation is more accurate for atheism than theism, and one of the obvious examples is the begining of the universe.
Atheists would have us believe that this mind-blowingly massive and complex universe came out of nothing! But how reasonable is it to believe that assumption as opposed to believing it was created by God?
Scientific theories change each day with each new observation or disapproval of given theories and hypothesis.
It is work in progress which will never cease.
What you have to make your mind boggling is your own flawed universe creation theory which can't stand the critical eye of science, which being such as light existing before the sun was created!
Common every elementary kid would know it better, and you want to sell this as some fact.
The moon being source of light! What a fucking laughable proposition.
The casual argument used from creationists such as Craig to explain the creation of the universe is flawed and bases on axioms:
- Reality and Universe are Causal chain is the first postulate.
This much any human can figure out. But it is a axiom since there is no direct prove of it. It bases only on limited human experience therefore subjective. A objective proof is still not found.
- Causality is time in order.
There are quite excellent physical experimental to support the relativity theory which lead us to believe that this is not true and in fact causality as expressed in physics law is time symmetric, and the direction is given by the relative entropy.
- Causality is ontologically ordered. (Craig's argument, comes from Hellenistic philosophy)
This is a argument from philosophy which tells us that ones own cause must be "greater than one self'', God being the ultimate greater cause. Therefore fundamentalists are speaking of ontological reality.
How do you define proper ontological system and what does mean "greater" in comparison to entities such as human being and God?
There is no way to define such thing other than make another assumption.
- The last argument of theological philosophers such as Craig argue that the termination of an ontological chain of causality (ever-greater) must end with God.
This is something that again theologists want to presume. Someone will rightly ask why we presume that this is so?
Specially in relation to creation it can be argued as many physicist argue that the universe as well can be seen as Perpetuum mobile which can self sustain and does not need greater cause. Other have argued that this universe is part of a greater Multiversum and the the primary cause of this universe is only part of a expanding Multiversum.
What ever being the case, one can't argue for the one or the other, cause both are unproved presumption and can be considered Prime Axiom.
The burden of proof still is to be found on the part of the theistic argument, which has to provide valid argument why chain of ever-greater causality ends with God. They have to prove this, but naturally can't, Craig have admitted in the previous video.
He can only argue with another presumptions.
Looking at that, I will argue that God is a mystery, that religions are human creation and that we can't know the personal mind of God nor can thoroughly understand universe and it's creation.
As Pascal have put it:
If there is a god, He is infinitely incomprehensible, since, having neither parts nor limits, He has no affinity to us. We are then incapable of knowing either what He is or if He is....
Pascal's Wager
In other words, we can not know God and his personal mind as long as we remain persons, which will render the presumption that God is giving the objective morals as false.
Some world philosophies have argued that human beings can cease to exist as personality, which should transcend the boundary between infinite God and limited human mind.
But that is another story which has to be discussed.
You definately have not understood Bible passages (or you just don't want to, preferring to take them out of their textual, linguistic, historic, cultural and political context), so I'm not sure how one is to debate those with you any further either.
Tell me how did I take any passage out of any context?
How does the context helps you with the problem of the light with out source.
The fundamentalist are jumping form the Genesis to Revelation and give cross references of passages that does not have anything to do with one another just to prove that the light can exist also with out light source.
What is the context when fundamentalist are doing such things?
Also by jumping from Genesis to Revelation they only indulge into a circular argument by using the Bible to prove the Bible! That is hardly any real argument!
One example Makedonin provides is the following:
This is ridiculous! Why? Because the Bible is not meant to classify animals according to modern biological categories. If it did so, how on earth would the people at the time understand what it was about?
The Bible is supposed to be the word of God. It yet has lack of objective knowledge.
Fundamentalists are selling the Bible as scientific book. They are those such as your self who point to the science and say "science is wrong in this and that, the bible says that God has created the world with out light source but than he divided the light in to day and night."
Bible has been posed as some kind of supernatural scientific knowledge.
It is used as measurement to bash science as invalid, so it deserves to be put under the same scientific scrutiny.
That is why it can't say that bats are not mammals but some kind of a bird. Omniscient all knowing God would have known to write this in a universal manner so that in all times it will be valid, yet he fails to do so and "restricts" it to the understanding of nomadic people, while he is asking us the modern people to use "church exegesis" to understand what is he talking about. That is of course absurd.
But let us say for the argument sake you are right about the passage above.
If really understanding was in question, than it could just say don't eat bats. But it goes on and uses classifications. Classification is a scientific method, thus when the Bible classify bats under birds and it previously was sold out as a scientific book, than it can only be found errant. That is really scientific, exactly as the fundamentalists science.
How about the grasshoppers having four legs and not six?
That wouldn't have been hard for any Israelite of the time to understand? Still the Bible gives errant account on how many legs this insects have!
Show me the context and explain me how the context changes this errant account?
Show me how the context changes when the bible sells the moon as source of light. Show me how the context changes the passage where the stars are falling on earth!
It is science and fundamentalists sell the Bible as scientific book knowing how the universe have been created, so it should also know what a source of light is or what is not!
No mercy there!
But using EXEGESIS we can understand what it means today by looking at it logically and within context.
Paul have told you that he is writing so that fools can understand him.
Exegesis is only a tool for the Modern man to cover the holes in indefensible.
Apart from the above said, here are you where you use Job 26:7 out of the context in your zealous attempt to defend the Biblical flat earth subscription:
It wasn't the Church that developed the theory of a flat earth or the sun revolving around the earth, it was the scientists of the day. In fact,
Isaiah 40:21-22, refers to the 'circle of the earth' and
Job 26:7 refers to the earth as being suspended over empty space.
If you were clever enough you would have practice what you preach and seen that it is Job that was talking, not God as shown in context:
And Job answereth and saith: -- ...Stretching out the north over desolation,
Hanging the earth upon nothing,
Job 26:1,7
BUT if you have read further, you would have seen that God has actually refuted Jobs argument by saying:
Then the LORD spoke to Job out of the storm. He said: “
Who is this that obscures my plans with words without knowledge? Brace yourself like a man; I will question you, and you shall answer me.
“Where were you when I laid the earth’s foundation? Tell me, if you understand. ...
“Have you ever given orders to the morning,
or shown the dawn its place,
that it might take the earth by the edges and shake the wicked out of it? ...
“
Have you entered the storehouses of the snow or seen the storehouses of the hail,[/B]
Job 38:1-4,12-13,22
In actuality the quote that you taken out of the context(the same context you accuse me of not including) shows that in your fundamentalist zeal to prove that the Bible has any scientific values is proving the opposite.
It is obvious that the Bible is flat earth subscribers, since you can take the earth on it's edge and shake off the wicked out of it Also the earth has foundation. Apart from the flat earth thing, you see many other pseudo scientific nonsense, such as store house of snow, hail etc. etc.
Tell me about the context and about how exegesis will tun the above into a scientific truth.
If you say that it is written only for the understanding of the nomadic people of Israel of the time, than why is Genesis to be taken literally exactly as you have proposed?
The rest of Makedonin's "examples" suffer from the same problem and that is why I have ignored them - because they are so mind-blowingly stupid!
You have ignored them because you can't really cover the holes and errors disposed.
Ad hominem fallacy won't help your case. Taking the time to counter the alleged "flawed" arguments may will.
In fact, debating this whole topic with you is like debating the Interim Accord with Buktop, Volk or the UMD. Its impossible when the other side is being intellectually dishonest or just does not have the intellectual capacity to understand the issues in front of them.
You are over simplistic, there is nothing mind boggling to understand about anything you say.
You escape in the over simplicity to avoid real arguments that will refute your position.
Ad hominem fallacy won't help your case.
but I highly doubt you can be intellectually honest in your response. You copied and pasted the following claim:
Ad hominem fallacy won't help your case.
The problem with this refutation is that it pretends we need to rely on "assumption" when we do not. We don't need to assume anything (I don't) and we can independently check whether it is reasonable to believe a biblical passage is 'true' or not by using various faculties.
That is flawed argument out of few reasons:
- It does assume that it is the word of God therefore it is argued that it contains no contradictions thus is inerrant.
- According to you, the Bible is truly interpreted only when it aligns with your interpretation.
As soon as someone comes and argues that it does not say what you think it say, you are swinging the exegesis card. Paul have given his reason why no one needs exegesis, it is written for fools to understand.
- The assumption that the bible is inerrant and the inspired word of God comes from passages as this:
All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness,
2 Timothy 3:16
were by All Scripture it is meant the Old and New Testament i.e. Christian Bible.
- The above passage that is wrongly interpreted that the Bible is God inspired fails short of convincing when reading Paul's own commentary:
and to the married I announce --
not I, but the Lord -- let not a wife separate from a husband: ... And to the rest
I speak -- not the Lord -- if any brother hath a wife unbelieving, and she is pleased to dwell with him, let him not send her away;
1 Corinthians 7:10,12
So Paul was not always giving the inspiration of God, but rather his own interpretation.
That which I speak,
I speak not according to the Lord, but as in foolishness, in this the confidence of boasting;
2 Corinthians 11:17
Here Paul admits that he is not speaking by inspiration, but by his foolishness.
or Jeremiah accusation:
At that time, declares the LORD, the bones of the
kings and officials of Judah, the bones of the priests and prophets, and the bones of the people of Jerusalem will be removed from their graves. ...
Even the stork in the sky knows her appointed seasons,
and the dove, the swift and the thrush observe the time of their migration.
But my people do not know the requirements of the LORD. “‘How can you say, “We are wise, for we have the law of the LORD,” when actually the lying pen of the scribes has handled it falsely? The wise will be put to shame; they will be dismayed and trapped.
Since they have rejected the word of the LORD, what kind of wisdom do they have?
Jeremiah 8:1,7-9
Jeremiah tells us that the law of the Jews (his own people) are flawed cause they were corrupted by the lying pen of the scribes.
Conclusion would be that just because someone was “inspired” or "God-breathed" by something to write does not mean that that which caused the inspiration wrote it directly verbatim, but maybe by his own agenda and boasting or by the lying pen of the scribes.