One example I gave was a natural right to own private property. Communism seeks to violate this right.
Communism does intrude on that natural right, but capitalism isn't exactly encouraging all rights either. What about social equity?
Owners are “overpaid”? Are you for real? The owners of the business will do with their profits as they see fit. Who are you to tell them how to use their own money? Come on mate, you are starting to sound like you’ve never even held a job or had money of your own.
They are perfectly in their right to do so, provided the money has come from ethical and legal means. Doesn't necessarily mean that they are also in the right to exploit workers. Every organisation has a corporate social responsibility, to give something back to the community, who essentially acted as a catalyst for their success.
Further, you seem to think that employees cannot find other work and that consumers have to purchase the relevant products/services.
Somehow I doubt it is as easy as you point out. A lot of brands make similar products under different names, adopting a ploy to suck in all different 'types' of consumers. It's a great business strategy, but not all consumers are aware of the consequences. Dick Pratt is a good example of fixing prices, what option do consumers have under these circumstances? You underestimate the potential burden of finding a new job. If it were that easy to replace years of reputation and work, we'd have a swarm of people quitting for a more 'optimistic' future job. The trend is changing, but perhaps it isn't as easy as A-B-C.
I’ve already made this clear – go back a few posts.
I'm talking about Andrew Demetriou specifically. Top bloke?
As CEO, he heads industrial relations disputes such as the Qantas one we were talking about. And as CEO, HR decisions ultimately rest with him. Much like many decisions ultimately rest with your state’s Minister for Education.
I doubt it. Maybe he plays a direct role in large scale disputes such as this, but you will most likely find that he delegates such tasks to the Human Resources department. They specialise in that particular function and would ultimately be responsible for the management of employees. By the looks of it, Alan Joyce doesn't know the first thing about 'connecting' with employees.
Yes you are, but I don’t think you realise to what extent you are.
Wrong. I prefer our capitalist system because it is more effective. What I don't like is the direction it is heading. So I guess your exempt from 'presumptions' with that statement?
I haven’t tried to justify it at all. I have had a grandfather and close friend die from asbestos, one in Macedonia, the other here in Australia. My point was that asbestos has been used and continues to be used around the world since ROMAN TIMES, REGARDLESS of the economic system in place. You are trying to make it out like its some sort of capitalist problem.
I'm sorry to hear that, but it reiterates my point that corporations need to take more responsibility for their actions and need to be held accountable. If anything, this type of negligence should not be occurring in an ideal system, but every political system has its downfalls.
This one nearly made me fall off my chair laughing. Do you know who appoints High Court judges? Do you know who enacts the laws within which they are able to make decisions one?
Yes, parliament created the courts through legislation, but the High Court was formed by the constitution. That's irrelevant though, the High Court is primarily designed to deal with disputes regarding the constitution. The James Hardie asbestos case was hear in a Supreme Court. Ever heard of judge-made law? You do know that they are not completely restricted by parliament legislation when deciding on a case before them? Have a read into statutory interpretation and precedent, or are you going to dismiss this as irrelevant since you're incorrect?
I never stated that. But you claim that the US state is making money of war. Can you provide any evidence? Can you explain why it is in so much debt? Surely if it makes so much money off war, the US state would have the cash rolling in by now wouldn’t it?
No, you missed my point altogether. My point was that the west does not need to go to war in order for western oil companies to have a massive stake in Middle East oil and that is because Middle East oil companies don’t have the technology or resources to drill on their own. They need western help. So the idea that the west goes into the Middle East in order to gain lucrative oil contracts is just naive.
Perhaps they aren't making a profit currently, but the deals that eventuate will see to that. Have a look at the Gadaffi thread in regards to America's willingness to get involved in their business at any cost. It wouldn't surprise me if corporations made money off of war. You stated before that whether there is war or not it is necessary for America to involve themselves in foreign business. War does not justify exploiting the resources of a foreign country.
No, that is just your presumption.
I'm a bit tired of this phrase. Like I said, are you exempt from these so called 'presumptions?'
What on earth is “moderate” and “extreme” capitalism?
I support a degree of privatisation, but under the current trend most essential services are being sold off to private companies. I don't believe this is right, especially at the expense of public essential services.
Who said they did? I was making a valid comparison to make my point – that capitalism is a BETTER system than any other. Not that its ok if its not perfect because no other system is. There is a distinct difference between those two points.
The comparison is invalid unless you are trying to justify that because it happens in a communist system, it is perfectly normal for it to occur in a capitalist system. Capitalism is better than any other current system, but a balance needs be be struck in the centre.
I know much more about propaganda than you could ever dream of. I can see from your comments that you are not very well informed on Cuba and should make an better effort to look at it critically if you are going to use it as an example.
I'm merely referring to their improved public healthcare system and education system under communist rule. It doesn't make Cuba a paradise, but it certainly refutes your view that communism is absolutely 'evil.'
That's a bit of an obnoxious statement to make. You're starting to sound like a Republican, a bit like your mate vojnik over here.
Take care to read my comments without adding your presumptions in there. I said that it is much better than any other system at controlling greed.
Maybe so, but since you insist on me proving everything with hard evidence, what do you base such views upon? Greed seems to be more widespread, since the opportunity is there for the everyday person, an opportunity that does not exist for the people under communist rule; only the 'leaders.'
The vast majority of mothers are ready to go home either the same day or the very next day. You should look into this more and stop relying on sensationalist media.
Where are they going to stay until then? The emergency area of a public hospital should be used only for absolute emergencies. The only answer to this is a lack of beds, which is to blame on a lack of funding.
Have you worked out the funding figures for health in Australia yet? Or are you still relying on what your mate said?
How about you provide me with the figures, after all you're the one disagreeing. I've looked around for stats to no avail, so until then, I find personal accounts much more reliable than what a bunch of 'calculated' figures imply.
Money does not necessarily equate quality. Swiss cheese? You need to get out more.
It sure helps though. Better equipment, improved training of staff, higher salaries. Have a look at a few motivational theories, namely Maslow's and Herzberg. Then you might understand that for an employee to truly provide a 'great' service and be motivated, they require the essential needs first, namely job security, adequate salary, etc. Only then are they inclined to have a stronger work ethic and improve productivity, thus improving the quality of a service such as education and healthcare.
You are the one calling for more funding for health and education. Where do you think the money is going to come from? Greece?
Perhaps the subsequent governments could recognise that these two areas are crucial to the progress of Australia. There is always 'more' money to inject in these areas, yet bad allocation of resources does not help in any way. What about the Mining tax? I think that was a great idea. The mining companies started to whinge and cry, despite already making billions upon billions of dollars. BHP recently recorded their largest ever profit. They are using the resources of Australia, so don't you think the people have a right to see some of this money? Or would you rather see it go back oversees to their owners?
I support a capitalist, free market system with a minimum safety net. I support individual natural rights and responsibilities and absolute minimum state interference in the lives of individuals, the economy and society at large. Ultimately, I am a Christian and my worldview stems from there.
I feel sorry if you live in Victoria, a future nanny state. I generally agree with this stance, but I can assure you that society is not heading this way. 'Absolute minimum state interference in the lives of individuals?' I don't think any of us are still safe even in our 'private' property. Privacy has become a blurred concept, especially with the ongoing advancement of technology.
Some very good points in that article. I couldn't agree more with this statement:
In the past, many of us acquiesced in discomfiting levels of inequality because we perceived a tradeoff between equity and economic growth. But there’s evidence that the levels of inequality we’ve now reached may actually suppress growth. A drop of inequality lubricates economic growth, but too much may gum it up.
Neither am I, but nor I am convinced that capitalism has all of the answers. That is why I think a form of centrism could probably be a workable formula.
Exactly, finding a balance is most likely the best solution.
LOL! I don't think understand how much money the workers are already receiving, in my view that was a great choice grounded the airline. The workers and unions demands are ridiculous. This is all thanks to Labours socialist policies....
Can't say the Liberal party are much better to be perfectly honest. The way I see it is the Labour party are apparently a 'working class' party, whethers the Liberals are 'business and corporate' orientated. The Liberals have certainly lived up to that assumption, especially under the Howard Government, but Labour is creeping more and more to the right as I see it.