• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Predictions on the upcoming elections

Gocka

New member
So as you all know on March 24th local elections will be held in The Republic of Macedonia. The significance of this election is quite large because the full implementation of decentralization has finished and this throws the Kicevo municipality into doubt.
What are some of your thoughts and predictions as to the outcomes and repercussions of the elections.
In my opinion Kicevo will be key and if it is lost to the albanians then I fear they will soon start laying the ground work to annex western Macedonia, and I don't think there will be much we can do about it because as far as I know they still have the backing of the USA.
I feel there is a high probability that we may see some type of manipulation, intimidation, or outright fraud.
I also think if somehow by an act of god that the Macedonians are able to keep Kicevo and take back Struga that we will see violent outburst from the albanians.
So what are your thoughts on the subject?
 
So as you all know on March 24th local elections will be held in The Republic of Macedonia. The significance of this election is quite large because the full implementation of decentralization has finished and this throws the Kicevo municipality into doubt.
What are some of your thoughts and predictions as to the outcomes and repercussions of the elections.
In my opinion Kicevo will be key and if it is lost to the albanians then I fear they will soon start laying the ground work to annex western Macedonia, and I don't think there will be much we can do about it because as far as I know they still have the backing of the USA.
I feel there is a high probability that we may see some type of manipulation, intimidation, or outright fraud.
I also think if somehow by an act of god that the Macedonians are able to keep Kicevo and take back Struga that we will see violent outburst from the albanians.
So what are your thoughts on the subject?

Here is an interesting article on this issue from Biljana Vankovska:

Битката за Кичево
Нели е спротивно на филозофијата на човековите права да се бара од кандидатите уште пред изборите да ја декларираат етничката припадност (поради Бадинтер)? Но еднакво лицемерно е сега, по 12 години уставно втемелена поделба, која се третира како светиња, да се кука поради преседанот кај Македонците за она што кај Албанците е одамна практика....

.....Мнозина ќе го осудат овој став како дефетистички и немакедонски, ама битката за Кичево е задоцнета, па и бесмислена. Од моментот на исцртување на општинските граници по етнички клуч, секоја изборна битка на локално ниво престана да има врска со демократијата, уште помалку со селекција на поквалитетен градоначалник и советници. „Од кал да е, ама наш да е“ е парола на денот. Бидејќи мнозина страдаат од кратко помнење, да се потсетиме: Струга и Кичево беа клучните точки околу кои цели 40 дена зад затворени врати преговараа СДСМ и ДУИ во 2004 година, и тоа како партнери во владина коалиција. На крајот Бучковски со спортски жаргон соопшти (ние, Македонците) „изгубивме со 3:0“. Прашан да дообјасни зошто натпреварот бил предаден, претседателот Црвенковски рече „да се боревме, ќе изгубевме со 5:0“......

....Тогашната опозиција [DPMNE na Gruevski] реагираше, ама млако. Кога дојде на власт со истиот коалициски партнер (бидејќи ДУИ е константата, а со партиите од македонскиот блок игра симултанка и ги менува) - не само што не се ни обиде да направи измени на законот, кој предвидуваше стапување во сила на новите граници на Кичево токму од 2013-та, туку уште и се согласи на проширена амнестија, која ги опфати и осомничените/обвинетите за воени злосторства.

Откако почна да се шушка за можна етничка коалиција, ама кај Македонците, духовите се вознемирија, особено кај оние што се беа заиграле „фашисти“ и „отпораши“. Да, спасот за оваа држава лежи во граѓански опции и листи, на кои нема да биде важно кој со какво етничко потекло е, ама... Ама, тоа е невозможно во постохридска Македонија! Навистина е трагикомично да се гледаат оваа непринципиелна коалиција и примирјето по етничка основа, на оние што два месеца нѐ држеа во заложништво.

Трагикомично е што во сојуз влегуваат партиите што овозможија Кичево и Струга да станат доминантно албански општини. Од граѓански аспект, ужасна е помислата дека ги спојува заедничкиот страв од Албанците или можеби само заедничката желба да се прикажат како големи Македонци пред гласачите....."

Авторката е универзитетска професорка
Автор: Билјана Ванковска
http://www.novamakedonija.com.mk/NewsDetal.asp?vest=3111394626&id=13&prilog=0&setIzdanie=22826
 
So as you all know on March 24th local elections will be held in The Republic of Macedonia. The significance of this election is quite large because the full implementation of decentralization has finished and this throws the Kicevo municipality into doubt.
What are some of your thoughts and predictions as to the outcomes and repercussions of the elections.
In my opinion Kicevo will be key and if it is lost to the albanians then I fear they will soon start laying the ground work to annex western Macedonia, and I don't think there will be much we can do about it because as far as I know they still have the backing of the USA.
I feel there is a high probability that we may see some type of manipulation, intimidation, or outright fraud.
I also think if somehow by an act of god that the Macedonians are able to keep Kicevo and take back Struga that we will see violent outburst from the albanians.
So what are your thoughts on the subject?

"....Трагикомично е што во сојуз влегуваат партиите што овозможија Кичево и Струга да станат доминантно албански општини. Од граѓански аспект, ужасна е помислата дека ги спојува заедничкиот страв од Албанците или можеби само заедничката желба да се прикажат како големи Македонци пред гласачите....."

Авторката е универзитетска професорка
Автор: Билјана Ванковска
http://www.novamakedonija.com.mk/New...tIzdanie=22826

The reality is that the new (planned long ago and signed in 2004) administrative local government territorial borders that will apply to Kichevo in 2013 (100th Anniversary of the Balkan Wars and the Division of Macedonia in 1913) are designed to favour the Ghegs/Shiptars/UCK and their domination of the whole area. The extra villages (predominantly, if not all, Gheg) added to the administrative unit of Kichevo will tilt power in the the UCK/Gheg favour no matter if Macedonians are 100% united and this will be much more pronounced (and absolute) in the years to come.

The FA and its implementation allows for the following (i.e. Struga and Kichevo to become predominantly Gheg local area administrative units):
"овозможија Кичево и Струга да станат доминантно албански општини"

---------------
In my opinion Kicevo will be key and if it is lost to the albanians then I fear they will soon start laying the ground work to annex western Macedonia
Gocka, can you please clearly explain to me (or to forum readers) what you envisage when you use the term "annex western Macedonia"? Do you mean annex to Kosovo or Albania or something else?
 
Last edited:
"....Трагикомично е што во сојуз влегуваат партиите што овозможија Кичево и Струга да станат доминантно албански општини. Од граѓански аспект, ужасна е помислата дека ги спојува заедничкиот страв од Албанците или можеби само заедничката желба да се прикажат како големи Македонци пред гласачите....."

Авторката е универзитетска професорка
Автор: Билјана Ванковска
http://www.novamakedonija.com.mk/New...tIzdanie=22826

The reality is that the new (planned long ago and signed in 2004) administrative local government territorial borders that will apply to Kichevo in 2013 (100th Anniversary of the Balkan Wars and the Division of Macedonia in 1913) are designed to favour the Ghegs/Shiptars/UCK and their domination of the whole area. The extra villages (predominantly, if not all, Gheg) added to the administrative unit of Kichevo will tilt power in the the UCK/Gheg favour no matter if Macedonians are 100% united and this will be much more pronounced (and absolute) in the years to come.

The FA and its implementation allows for the following (i.e. Struga and Kichevo to become predominantly Gheg local area administrative units):


---------------

Gocka, can you please clearly explain to me (or to forum readers) what you envisage when you use the term "annex western Macedonia"? Do you mean annex to Kosovo or Albania or something else?

My personal opinion is that there may be a push to unite with Kosovo. I think ideologically and culturally the albanians in Macedonia have more in common with kosovo albanians then with albania. I think another small random country in the balkans would be overkill so western powers may just let it happen, but unification with albania will one day happen in my opinion but not for a long time until the claims for former lands recede. Of course another tiny random country may also be what happens but who really knows right?

I just wanted to hear other peoples thoughts on the matter.

Do you disagree that some sort of separation will happen or were you just curious as to what type of separation I was referring to?

In all honesty does it really matter? Once our lands are separated good luck getting them back. How can you ever make a case to get back land that is completely populated by another ethnicity, its impossible if you ask me.

Your thoughts Pelagon? Thanks for the articles.
 
The battle for Kicevo

Is it not contrary to the philosophy of human rights to require candidates even before the elections to declare their ethnicity (according to Badinter)? But equally hypocritical is now, after 12 years of constitutionally based division, which is treated as something sacred, to moan because of the precedent of the Macedonians for what the Albanians is a long time practice ....

..... Many will condemn this attitude as defeatist and Un-Macedonian, but the battle for Kicevo is much too late, also pointless. From the moment of the redrawing of boundaries along an ethnic key, each local election battle stopped having anything to do with democracy, even less with the selection of a better quality mayor and councilors. "He can be made of mud, as long as he is one of ours" is the slogan of the day. Because so many people suffer from short memory to recall: Struga and Kicevo were key points around which a whole 40 days was spent behind closed doors negotiating, between SDSM and DUI in 2004, and as partners in the coalition government. In the end Buckovski with sports jargon said (we Macedonians) "we lost 3-0." When asked to elaborate why the game was given away, the President said "if we fought, we would have lost 5:0" ......

.... The then opposition [DPMNE of Gruevski] reacted, but tepidly. When it came to power with the same coalition partner (because DUI is a constant, it plays simultaneously with the parties of the Macedonian block and rotates them) - not only did they not even try to make changes to the law, which foresaw going into force the new boundaries of Kicevo starting from 2013, but even agreed to extend amnesty, which includes suspects / defendants of war crimes.

Since the whispers started about a possible ethnic coalition, but a Macedonian one, spirits are upset, especially those who had played "fascists" and "the resistance". Yes salvation for this country lies in civil options and lists, on which it wouldn’t matter who is from what ethnic background... But this is impossible in Post-Ohridska Macedonia! It is really tragicomic to see this unprincipled coalition truce on ethnic grounds, from those who for two months held us hostage.

It is tragicomic that the alliance includes parties that made it possible for Kicevo and Struga to become predominantly Albanian municipalities. From a civil aspect, it is a horrible thought that what unites them is a common fear of Albanians or maybe just common desire to show how Macedonian they are before the voters ..... "

The author is a university professor
Author: Biljana Vankovska

I translated the article for those who do not understand Cyrillic
 
Last edited:
I translated the article for those who do not understand Cyrillic
You must have used Google (?) because it is a poor translation and very misleading, IMHO.
.....Мнозина ќе го осудат овој став како дефетистички и немакедонски, ама битката за Кичево е задоцнета, па и бесмислена.
..... Many will condemn this attitude as defeatist and Un-Macedonian, but the battle for Kicevo is overdue, also senseless
Zadoncneta in this context above means much too late (or too little, too late).
 
You must have used Google (?) because it is a poor translation and very misleading, IMHO.

Zadoncneta in this context above means much too late (or too little, too late).

Yes I did use gooogle translate to translate it quickly, I skimmed it over to see if anything was way off but looks like I missed that. Thank you.

I made the suggested change but I dont see it is being so bad that it is misleading, why do you believe that, am I missing some glaring mistake?

In summary what she is trying to say is that it is a bit late for all the hoopla and a little comical but also tragic that the same two parties who are supposedly uniting to save us from Albanian domination in Struga and Kicevo are the same parties who made it possible for such a situation to exist in the first place. She also gives a few examples of how both parties had a hand in the mess at different times and how they never fought for the Macedonians before.
 
Last edited:
My personal opinion is that there may be a push to unite with Kosovo. I think ideologically and culturally the albanians in Macedonia have more in common with kosovo albanians than with albania.
I don't think the Ghegs in Macedonia will genuinely push for a pan-Siptar political union of any kind in the context of changing borders before 2050, at the earliest (unless some unforeseen political events occur that could unravel the whole Balkans and they have good opportunities to grab what they want or are forced to get what they can), as they have a lot more territory on their agenda to consolidate/appropriate. But you are right in saying that they have closer ethnic ties to Kosovo Ghegs (many having origins from there).

I think another small random country in the balkans would be overkill so western powers may just let it happen,
As it is, Macedonia now is a de facto bi-national state in all but name and they could by 2025 formalise that reality on the ground in a FA Mark II.

I just wanted to hear other peoples thoughts on the matter.

Do you disagree that some sort of separation will happen or were you just curious as to what type of separation I was referring to?
I basically reacted to your claim about "western Macedonia" (which could mean Tetovo, Debar, Gostivar, Struga and Kicevo) wanting to "split" and "join" another "Albanian" state. This is an idea ("fear") based on old-school Yugo ideology that fails to take into account today's reality that the Ghegs are in a very,very good position to take the WHOLE of Macedonia by 2050 and are NOT politically stupid do what you "feared"/suggested. Skopje, Kumanovo and their surrounds are NOT exactly "western" Macedonia and can any sane person see that the Ghegs would freely give up on their claims to them, especially when they are heavily investing in them and aiming for eventual takeover there?

In all honesty does it really matter? Once our lands are separated good luck getting them back. How can you ever make a case to get back land that is completely populated by another ethnicity, its impossible if you ask me.

Your thoughts Pelagon? Thanks for the articles.
Well, apart from the example set by the Ghegs in taking over lands in which they had little to no presence less than 50 or 100 years ago, one can also learn from the examples set by the Israelis in the West Bank (and Israel itself). If one has the military power and the will to fight for and reclaim what is their ancestral land, it is doable and there are many examples in recent world history of this happening.
 
Yes I did use gooogle translate to translate it quickly, I skimmed it over to see if anything was way off but looks like I missed that. Thank you.

I made the suggested change but I dont see it is being so bad that it is misleading, why do you believe that, am I missing some glaring mistake?

In summary what she is trying to say is that it is a bit late for all the hoopla and a little comical but also tragic that the same two parties who are supposedly uniting to save us from Albanian domination in Struga and Kicevo are the same parties who made it possible for such a situation to exist in the first place. She also gives a few examples of how both parties had a hand in the mess at different times and how they never fought for the Macedonians before.


I made the suggested change but I dont see it is being so bad that it is misleading, why do you believe that, am I missing some glaring mistake?


The FA and the subsequent territorial division for local administration make it impossible to really avoid Gheg domination in Struga, Kicevo and the rest of the designated areas the UCK asked for. Absolute Macedonian solidarity (even via SDSM-DPMNE) will only treat the symptom and NOT the CAUSE and maybe somewhat delay the terminal illness of Gheg TOTAL domination but death (domination) in that set-up is guaranteed. Thus it is the case of much too little, too late and NOT "overdue", i.e. we needed action to oppose the treasonous FA in the first place and not jump with joy when the traitors that sold us out unite and present themselves as the "saviours" ("our" saviours).
 
I don't think the Ghegs in Macedonia will genuinely push for a pan-Siptar political union of any kind in the context of changing borders before 2050, at the earliest (unless some unforeseen political events occur that could unravel the whole Balkans and they have good opportunities to grab what they want or are forced to get what they can), as they have a lot more territory on their agenda to consolidate/appropriate. But you are right in saying that they have closer ethnic ties to Kosovo Ghegs (many having origins from there).

I think the shiptars are very greedy(lakumi) and cocky because of recent history in both kosovo and Macedonia and I think they will make a push much sooner than that, maybe not a full hearted push but a kind of lets test the waters push. More and more moderate shiptari are turning into extremist ones because they are being empowered by a sense of invincibility because everything of late has been going their way. With no pressure or opposition it's not hard to see why they feel so powerful and cocky

As it is, Macedonia now is a de facto bi-national state in all but name and they could by 2025 formalise that reality on the ground in a FA Mark II.

I'm surprised that you think it will take almost 40 years for them to ask for that, I think if they pushed for it tomorrow they may very well get what they want. I think the longer they wait the less likely they will succeed. Macedonians are very weak right now and do not have enough unity to put up a good fight. If I were them I would strike now and that is why I fear the upcoming elections might just be the tipping point. Call me an optimist but I think 40 years from now Macedonians will have changed and will be better equipped to defend themselves.

I basically reacted to your claim about "western Macedonia" (which could mean Tetovo, Debar, Gostivar, Struga and Kicevo) wanting to "split" and "join" another "Albanian" state. This is an idea ("fear") based on old-school Yugo ideology that fails to take into account today's reality that the Ghegs are in a very,very good position to take the WHOLE of Macedonia by 2050 and are NOT politically stupid do what you "feared"/suggested. Skopje, Kumanovo and their surrounds are NOT exactly "western" Macedonia and can any sane person see that the Ghegs would freely give up on their claims to them, especially when they are heavily investing in them and aiming for eventual takeover there?

You make a good point here. I agree that other parts of Macedonia are not exactly safe or exempt and I agree that they are not politically stupid. Politically they are much smarter than we are. I can't foresee them taking the whole of Macedonia only because in my head it sounds so absurd that I refuse to accept it (doesn't mean you're not right) , I just won't let myself believe that. I think Macedonians wouldn't let it come to that point, even the most timid of people will fight to the bitter end if you try and take everything that they have away from them. Then again who knows, I feel like if tomorrow Tetovo, Debar, and Gostivar were on the chopping block, most Macedonians wouldn't bat an eye and just let it happen.

Well, apart from the example set by the Ghegs in taking over lands in which they had little to no presence less than 50 or 100 years ago, one can also learn from the examples set by the Israelis in the West Bank (and Israel itself). If one has the military power and the will to fight for and reclaim what is their ancestral land, it is doable and there are many examples in recent world history of this happening.

I think Israel is not a good example and I think we are kidding ourselves if we are to think that we can strive to emulate them, they are ruthless and the persistence that they have with pursuing only their best interests is unmatchable. I think if you gave us 500 years we couldn't emulate them, I don't think it's in our DNA. Is it doable sure, maybe. Is it doable with 1.5 million people most of which are depressed and unmotivated and a piss poor economy to top it off. We hold no cards and we do not posses enough man power, money, or support to flip the table and say fuck this game.
 
This is an idea ("fear") based on old-school Yugo ideology that fails to take into account today's reality that the Ghegs are in a very,very good position to take the WHOLE of Macedonia by 2050 and are NOT politically stupid do what you "feared"/suggested. Skopje, Kumanovo and their surrounds are NOT exactly "western" Macedonia and can any sane person see that the Ghegs would freely give up on their claims to them, especially when they are heavily investing in them and aiming for eventual takeover there?
I agree. I don't think the Albanians (at least Albanian political leaders) have any interest in seceding from Macedonia, now or ever. I think their long-term ambitions are to gain as much political/institutional control over the entire state as possible. In effect, I think they are pursing the complete Albanianisation of Macedonia and therefore there is no need to secede.

Well, apart from the example set by the Ghegs in taking over lands in which they had little to no presence less than 50 or 100 years ago, one can also learn from the examples set by the Israelis in the West Bank (and Israel itself). If one has the military power and the will to fight for and reclaim what is their ancestral land, it is doable and there are many examples in recent world history of this happening.
This is an interesting point of view coming from you :)
 
I agree. I don't think the Albanians (at least Albanian political leaders) have any interest in seceding from Macedonia, now or ever. I think their long-term ambitions are to gain as much political/institutional control over the entire state as possible. In effect, I think they are pursing the complete Albanianisation of Macedonia and therefore there is no need to secede.
Arben Dzhaferi stated just about the same point in 2001 when there was all the commotion about "partitioning" that Lupco Georgievski and some members of MANU were supposed to be proposing.


Well, apart from the example set by the Ghegs in taking over lands in which they had little to no presence less than 50 or 100 years ago, one can also learn from the examples set by the Israelis in the West Bank (and Israel itself).

If one has the military power and the will to fight for and reclaim what is their ancestral land, it is doable and there are many examples in recent world history of this happening.

This is an interesting point of view coming from you :)
It was not meant to appear as you may interpret (i.e. as an endorsement for "Israeli ancestral rights".) but that a previously populated (or even recently settled) place by your national enemies can be altered by the use of force and settlement. :)

The part in red was meant to be in relation to other historical events where force was (or has been) used to drive out national enemies, e.g. ethnic Germans in Poland and the Czech Republic after (or during) WWII.

------------

„Со многудетни семејства против планерите на Етничка Албанија, нема повлекување!“
Петок, 15 Март 2013 13:54
Ако ние сакаме да опстоиме на долг рок во Македонија, а не во нивната замисла да станеме Албанија, треба да имаме повеќедетни семејства. Нема да дозволиме од Струга, преку Кичево, Тетово, Скопје, Куманово да им било Албанија. Ќе одговориме и на тој начин, со многудетни семејства. Тоа нема да им биде дозволено на секој начин. Нема повлекување. Нема повлекување од Кичево, ниту од Струга, Брвеница, Долнени, ниту од Тетово, Гостивар и Куманово, ниту од Скопје. Нема повлекување!....

http://kurir.mk/makedonija/vesti/10...anerite-na-Etnicka-Albanija-nema-povlekuvanje

The above is some fresh info from a very recent campaign speech by Gruevski that is relevant to this topic. As can be seen, it is clearly mentioned that Skopje and Kumanovo are part of the "Albanian plan" and thus "western Macedonia" should not be used but rather "north-western Republic of Macedonia" when mentioning current (short-term) Gheg territorial ambitions.
 
Last edited:
I think the shiptars are very greedy(lakumi) and cocky because of recent history in both kosovo and Macedonia and I think they will make a push much sooner than that, maybe not a full hearted push but a kind of lets test the waters push. More and more moderate shiptari are turning into extremist ones because they are being empowered by a sense of invincibility because everything of late has been going their way. With no pressure or opposition it's not hard to see why they feel so powerful and cocky[
As it is, Macedonia now is a de facto bi-national state in all but name and they could by 2025 formalise that reality on the ground in a FA Mark II.

I'm surprised that you think it will take almost 40 years for them to ask for that,
2025 means within 12 years or less. :)

I think if they pushed for it tomorrow they may very well get what they want.
They probably could but they are getting a lot of concessions lately and they can afford to wait a little longer, IMO.

I think the longer they wait the less likely they will succeed.
I don't know about that. :)

They have an increasing birth-rate and Macedonians have a declining one and thus time is working in their favour. Do some research on statistics before getting into this type of assumption.

Call me an optimist but I think 40 years from now Macedonians will have changed and will be better equipped to defend themselves.
Yep, I will call you a delusional optimist. :)

You make a good point here. I agree that other parts of Macedonia are not exactly safe or exempt and I agree that they are not politically stupid. Politically they are much smarter than we are.
:)

I can't foresee them taking the whole of Macedonia only because in my head it sounds so absurd that I refuse to accept it (doesn't mean you're not right), I just won't let myself believe that.
What can I say? :)

I think Macedonians wouldn't let it come to that point, even the most timid of people will fight to the bitter end if you try and take everything that they have away from them.
They let it get this far and the road from here on is pretty easy and straightforward for the eventual Siptar political takeover. I don't see any major obstacles at this stage to what is obviously awaiting Macedonia.

Then again who knows, I feel like if tomorrow Tetovo, Debar, and Gostivar were on the chopping block, most Macedonians wouldn't bat an eye and just let it happen.
They did allow that long ago and especially in 2001 and 2004.

I think Israel is not a good example and I think we are kidding ourselves if we are to think that we can strive to emulate them, they are ruthless and the persistence that they have with pursuing only their best interests is unmatchable.
Far from it that I would believe that we can compare to the Israelis and achieve what they have but I was just giving an example of what is needed for reclaiming land overpopulated by others.

I think if you gave us 500 years we couldn't emulate them, I don't think it's in our DNA.
DNA talk is nonsense and one needs just to listen to old folk songs (or read history) about the Janicari in order to realise that it is upbringing that is the problem.

Is it doable sure, maybe. Is it doable with 1.5 million people most of which are depressed and unmotivated and a piss poor economy to top it off. We hold no cards and we do not posses enough man power, money, or support to flip the table and say fuck this game.
Do you think there is 1.5 million (Ethnic) Macedonians in the republic? If you do, you would be wrong again and should read some current statistics about demographics there.
 
Last edited:
Arben Dzhaferi stated just about the same point in 2001 when there was all the commotion about "partitioning" that Lupco Georgievski and some members of MANU were supposed to be proposing.
Menduh Tachi, Xhaferi's protoge and successor, has been calling for a new FA and basically seeking a completely consociationalist state in which ALL decisions would be made consensually (meaning they would have a veto over everything and a say in everything regardless of their numbers) and that all state resources should be divided equally (regardless of their numbers). Its a fitting next logical step for them.

In the past, they have railed against the "evils" of majoritarianism (or in other words, one citizen, one vote). Apparently this denies them their "national rights". I'm quite sure they will develop a new love for majoritarianism when they become the majority.

It was not meant to appear as you may interpret (i.e. as an endorsement for "Israeli ancestral rights".) but that a previously populated (or even recently settled) place by your national enemies can be altered by the use of force and settlement. :)
That's a shame.

The above is some fresh info from a very recent campaign speech by Gruevski that is relevant to this topic. As can be seen, it is clearly mentioned that Skopje and Kumanovo are part of the "Albanian plan" and thus "western Macedonia" should not be used but rather "north-western Republic of Macedonia" when mentioning current (short-term) Gheg territorial ambitions.
On the point that Gruevski raises, personally I think its too late for the 'demographic solution'. In my view, it would be much easier to liberate Macedonians from their slave mentality than convince them to have more children (i.e., close to impossible). Even if you could increase the Macedonian birth rate, I don't think that it would be able to compete with the Albanian rates - they are quite astronomical. Eventually, I think they will out-breed us. This is not the say that Macedonians should not have as many children as they can, but to rely on it as a solution is not, in my view, realistic.
 
Pelagon,

Valid an interesting points. The one that interests me is about demographics. Macedonians don't constitute 1.5 million exactly but in my understanding it is close I think in fact it may be a little less. Can you give me a source or at least elaborate on what you think is correct?

Both Pelagon and Tom make very good points. I guess I was too focused on the average shiptar that you meet and not giving their political elite enough credit.

Would either of you say that the majority of Albanians want separation (full on) or am I mistaken on that? This is my impression of them as a people.

Who knows maybe when we become the minority we may be a little more aggressive in pursuing our interests (not really)

In your opinions what is the only way to save ourselves? To me it looks like eventual war is pretty much the only solution. I only say that because I think if we attempt to thwart them by any other means they will initiate it.

Also may I draw your attention to the upcoming election, I was very interested as to what you think will be the outcomes and repercussions in the short term (by the end of 2013)
 
Macedonians were a minority within Yugoslavia and were by no means 'aggressive in pursuing our interests'. The same applies for Macedonians who are now minorities within today's borders of Greece and Bulgaria.

There's very little chance and not many indicators from contemporary Macedonian history, to show that Macedonians, or at least in terms of the number of Macedonians needed to actually achieve anything, will pursue anything when it gets worse.
 
my proposal is

why predicts, if and when we could see asap what the shiptars are going to do when they are in power....


by hook or by crook to accelerate the unavoidably, we the ethnic macedonians should vote all for DUI....
 
by hook or by crook to accelerate the unavoidably, we the ethnic macedonians should vote all for DUI....
That's not as silly as it sounds. Joining these parties en mass where no veto's exist and majoritarianism is the rule would effectively render them useless. Albanian opposition to Macedonian members could be used to demonstrate their extremism and racism. But its probably too sophisticated of an operation for Macedonians to undertake.
 
Pelagon,
Valid an interesting points. The one that interests me is about demographics. Macedonians don't constitute 1.5 million exactly but in my understanding it is close I think in fact it may be a little less. Can you give me a source or at least elaborate on what you think is correct?
Your are very lazy, mate! How will you manage to do anything as an "activist" if you have (or show) no initiative? :)

http://www.google.com.au/search?client=opera&q=macedonian+census+2002+results

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_Republic_of_Macedonia
Македонија во бројки, 2012
Датум на издавање: 21.06.2012
PDF: Преземи ја публикацијата 5MB
http://www.stat.gov.mk/Publikacii/Mak_brojki_2012_M.pdf

Државен завод за статистика - публикација: Македонија во бројки

Публикација: Македонија во бројки

http://www.stat.gov.mk/PublikaciiPoOblast.aspx?id=27&rbrObl=37

Both Pelagon and Tom make very good points. I guess I was too focused on the average shiptar that you meet and not giving their political elite enough credit.

Would either of you say that the majority of Albanians want separation (full on) or am I mistaken on that? This is my impression of them as a people.
FA is what they wanted and got and now FA Mark II is on the cards (by 2025) and "Albanian" as 2nd official state language (on equal footing to Macedonian). Also, I predict Macedonians (schoolchildren) will be studying "Albanian" as a compulsory subject by 2025.

Who knows maybe when we become the minority we may be a little more aggressive in pursuing our interests (not really)
:)

In your opinions what is the only way to save ourselves? To me it looks like eventual war is pretty much the only solution. I only say that because I think if we attempt to thwart them by any other means they will initiate it.
I will let you find the solution. :)
But I think that I have already offered a few options in the other thread we had a discussion on along similar lines.

Also may I draw your attention to the upcoming election, I was very interested as to what you think will be the outcomes and repercussions in the short term (by the end of 2013)
Events (of capitulation) in 2001 and 2004 (and implementation of the same in 2013 for Kicevo) has sealed the fate of all the areas designated for Gheg control, immediate or impending (and SKOPJE is also INCLUDED in the IMPENDING!).

Census of Population, Households and Dwellings 2002, Book XIII:
Total population, households and dwellings
According to the territorial organization of The Republic of Macedonia, 2004, 2002

Page 34 - start of statistics based on ethnicity.
http://www.stat.gov.mk/Publikacii/knigaXIII.pdf


Tabela 3: Vkupno naselenie na Republika Makedonija spored izjasnuvaweto za
nacionalnata pripadnost
Tabe 3: Total population of the Republic of Macedonia according the ethnic affiliation
Vkupno Makedonci Albanci Turci Romi Vlasi Srbi Bo{waci Ostanati
Total Macedonians Albanians Turks Rhomas Vlachs Serbs Bosniaks Other
Vkupno 2022547 1,297,981 509,083 77959 53879 9695 35939 17018 20993 Total
Skopje 506926 338358 103891 8595 23475 2557 14298 7585 8167 Skopje

Skopje 2002 Census: 338,358 [Macedonians] 103,891 [Ghegs/Shiptars]
That is roughly a 3:1 ratio and bound to change in the UCK's favour at next census, which will be very crucial in understanding what has been happening over the last decade or so and what will happen in the next decade or two. By 2050 the Ghegs should gain parity or be the biggest ethnic group in Skopje municipality and you can then kiss goodbye that city as being Macedonian (and Macedonia, or whatever the name will be changed to by then, with it).

Профил на општина Бутел

mapa-butel.jpg


Македонци 62.25%
Срби 2.86%
Албанци 25.19%
Роми 1.55%
Власи 0,33%
Турци 3.61%
Бошњаци 2.68%

http://www.opstinabutel.gov.mk/inde...rofil-opstina-butel&catid=39:profil&Itemid=88

NB: Gazi Baba and Butel are two Skopje municipalities to watch out for signs of significant Gheg expansion in as they would allow their population to link up with the outlying (surrounding) areas that are almost exclusively populated by Ghegs (e.g. Arachinovo) these days.

Also, note that a mostly rural and very large area of Saraj was attached to Skopje in 2004 as another Gheg dominated municipality and one that would allow for massive future expansion of the same population and thus facilitate the takeover of Skopje in the long run.
ЗА ГАЗИ БАБА
Број на жители:
Според пописот од 2002г. општината има 72222 жители, и според бројот на жители претставува една од поголемите општини во градот Скопје и Република Македонија.

Демографската структура на општината според етничката припадност :

Македонци 73,3%, Албанци 17,3%, Срби 2,9%, Роми 2,9%, Турци 0,8%, Власи 0,3%, и останати 1,3%.

http://www.gazibaba.gov.mk/profil-na-opstinata.html
 
Last edited:
Menduh Tachi, Xhaferi's protoge and successor, has been calling for a new FA and basically seeking a completely consociationalist state in which ALL decisions would be made consensually (meaning they would have a veto over everything and a say in everything regardless of their numbers) and that all state resources should be divided equally (regardless of their numbers). Its a fitting next logical step for them.
I am not sure they will get that but some of the talk is probably election posturing in order to appear more nationalist and militant to his electorate when in opposition. RM is in reality a USA/EU experimental political protectorate and they would have a say in such drastic changes before implementation.

In the past, they have railed against the "evils" of majoritarianism (or in other words, one citizen, one vote). Apparently this denies them their "national rights". I'm quite sure they will develop a new love for majoritarianism when they become the majority.
Exactly right and they already love "majoritarianism" in the municipalities they (i.e. Ghegs of whichever political party) politically dominate!


On the point that Gruevski raises, personally I think its too late for the 'demographic solution'. In my view, it would be much easier to liberate Macedonians from their slave mentality than convince them to have more children (i.e., close to impossible). Even if you could increase the Macedonian birth rate, I don't think that it would be able to compete with the Albanian rates - they are quite astronomical. Eventually, I think they will out-breed us. This is not the say that Macedonians should not have as many children as they can, but to rely on it as a solution is not, in my view, realistic.
I more or less agree but turning attention to fertility rates is more of a DIVERSIONARY tactic by Gruevski and DPMNE in order to avoid responsibility for allowing and sponsoring altered municipal boundaries in order to skew the numbers in favour of the Ghegs/UCk in Struga, Kicevo, Skopje and other areas.

Lastly, in the speech delivered by Gruevski in Kichevo a few days ago he is actually ATTACKING DIASPORA VOTING with similar arguments that Crvenkovski and SDSM opposed DIASPORA voting in general elections. Flip-Flop opportunism at its best. :)

Excerpt from Gruevski's speech in Kichevo: "...Ќе ги носеле со авиони, со автобуси. Ајде кичевци, овој пат да покажеме и да излеземе сите до еден и да им одговориме чие е Кичево и да го оставиме Кичево на кичевчани, а не на некој кој 20 години живее надвор од Кичево. Кичево ќе остане на луѓето кои живеат тука. Дехаровци сакаат на вештачки начин да ја сменат демографската структура со носење дијаспора. Би рекол некоректно, нечесно, нефер и неетички. Тоа не е ништо друго туку еден обичен етнонационализам. Тие луѓе не знаат за проблемите кои луѓето ги имаат тука. Затоа не смееме да му дозволиме на Дехари да ни го наруши мирот, затоа треба масовно да се излезе и да се подржи Деспотовски и советничката листа на сите политички партии кои застанаа зад него - рече Груевски...."
http://www.plusinfo.mk/vest/84548/N...Dehari-nema-nikogo-da-isplashi-so-kalashnikov
 
Back
Top