• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Proposed Constitutional Changes

There is a sense of duality.Society has morals regarding sexuality but moral sexual behaviour has to be made into a law .Originally religion dictated how man was to behave .So laws were passed around.Can people think of the ten commandments covering all sorts of human behaviour.Codification of laws ,you break the law the law breaks you.
 
We can judge, every person judges for themselves and in our societies as a whole it is judged to be wrong. You talk to much from an absolute point of view.

Even something that is an absolute truth only becomes absolute truth when a consensus of people agree that it is absolutely true.

For example Newtons laws or accepted as absolute truth in science, but they originated as Newtons subjective opinions about gravity and energy, then the scientific community after rationalizing his opinions also came to the conclusion that these opinions are absolute facts. Today our entire society deems them absolute facts. This is how human morals originate. Ideas are put forth and the collective decides whether or not they accept it. One persons acceptance or denial is meaningless on its own merits, but in combination with the society in which he lives it is relevant. Things don't need to come from a higher power in order to have meaning or validity, they don't need to and they can't start as absolutely true, they become absolutely true when an overwhelming majority of society accepts something as absolutely true.

Within social behavior how many absolute truths are there anyway? The only absolute truths I know of are scientific because they can be proven through experimentation.

Back to your favorite example of pedophilia. The age at which it is considered ok to have sexual activity with someone has changed throughout the ages. At one point it may have been 10 yeas old, the bible may say 12, but today in our society 12 would seem disgusting and morally wrong.

God, has not shed light on every topic or controversy ever know to man, so how do we solve all our social problems based on one set of fixed moral values that are very outdated?

We live in a world where there are many social tiers. Towns, Cities, States, Provinces, Regions, Countries, Continents, the Plant. An example: In Utah in the USA, polygamy was widely practiced, the majority of the USA was against this practice and so it became officially illegal under Federal law. In the Utah society it was deemed OK, so was marrying of under aged girls. In the end their state of Utah is part a bigger society which found their practices wrong.

Lets say an entire Country on this planet was for the raping of babies. They considered it some kind of right of passage. That country is not alone on this planet, what do you think the reaction globally would be to a group of people who thought baby raping was good? The rest of the world would deem it wrong, then they rest of the world would decide what to do about it, sanctions, intervention, isolation?

It is all very simple and is how the world currently functions. In Macedonia I am positive a majority of people are against gay marriage since a majority of people are against homosexuality in general. Now if the rest of the world chooses to punish us for this point of view is their choice. One day should the majority of people be OK with gay marriage the laws will change and life will go on.

Why is this all such a big debate?
I couldn't see your answer in all of that.

P.S. You need to read up on what absolute truth is. You can't change the definition just to suit your argument. You have so thoroughly confused absolute truth with non-absolute truth its become ridiculous.
 
I'm still waiting for your views on this one Gocka...with the actual meaning of ABSOLUTE and TRUTH in mind

The other problem with denying objective moral values is that you automatically deny absolute truth. But by denying the existence of absolute truth you are contradicting yourself. The statement that absolute truth does not exist is an absolutist claim in and of itself - something that supposedly does not exist and yet you're making your entire case based on it.
 
How do you know? Seeing as you have admitted on previous occasions that you have never attempted a serious study of the Bible, how can you be so definitive about it?
I know they (the majority of Chinese) have not attempted even a cursory study of the bible. Which is the point that seems to evade you. The point being that God is not embraced by the majority of them yet the values seem to exist. You can call the objective ones God given, but they flat out reject Him and yet still largely subscribe to these values. Technically, I would imagine they should all go to hell or at least never get to heaven.I find them a good example simply because of the sheer number of Godless Chinese. My attempts with the bible are irrelevant.

I think a serious study of the bible can be done from differing perspectives. A serious study performed by you will see shadows and lights and remarkable insights. But these are stemming from a position of unquestionable faith. You still need it (faith) to take the book seriously. Without it, it is another story. You have it. Enjoy it.

Separate question, would you embrace a Christian enemy of Macedonia more than a non-Christian Macedonian?
 
I'm still waiting for your views on this one Gocka...with the actual meaning of ABSOLUTE and TRUTH i mind

You know we are getting close to the end of this discussion when Tom brings out the "definitions"

You will not accept an answer that is not theological in nature. The more we got into this the more it becomes a debate about God.

I reject your reality you reject mine.

Your view of the world, society, and everything else folds together nicely with your faith in God. I do not have such a strong faith in God so my point of view is very different. I cant accept the foundation for your argument, you cant accept the foundation for mine.

To answer your question I don't believe in absolute truth when it relates to anything but science and mathematics. 1 +1 is always 2, this is an absolute truth, in social situations it is always relative and never absolute. Murder is not absolutely wrong, what if it is in self defense, or in defense of another?

We can file this one away with the rest of the debates that devolved into debates about theology and philosophy.
 
Add in the Indians and you've got almost 40% of the worlds population.

Morality is a social construct not a divine one. Humans who have evolved realize that a safer, freer, fairer society is better for everyone, that is why we hold basic morals because it has been built into our biology over the many millenniums of evolution. Of course this point of view requires you to accept evolutionism over creationism. Which is really what we are talking about this whole time while beating around the bush. Its a debate with no right or wrong and no end because neither side will accept the foundation of the others argument as true thus not accepting anything after that.


I know they (the majority of Chinese) have not attempted even a cursory study of the bible. Which is the point that seems to evade you. The point being that God is not embraced by the majority of them yet the values seem to exist. You can call the objective ones God given, but they flat out reject Him and yet still largely subscribe to these values. Technically, I would imagine they should all go to hell or at least never get to heaven.I find them a good example simply because of the sheer number of Godless Chinese. My attempts with the bible are irrelevant.

I think a serious study of the bible can be done from differing perspectives. A serious study performed by you will see shadows and lights and remarkable insights. But these are stemming from a position of unquestionable faith. You still need it (faith) to take the book seriously. Without it, it is another story. You have it. Enjoy it.

Separate question, would you embrace a Christian enemy of Macedonia more than a non-Christian Macedonian?
 
Same sex marriage is sooooo gay….

As for the philosophical debate, I’m just waiting for the arguments to inevitably turn to consciousness and reality… objective?, subjective?, or is dualism the key? Are we an objective consciousness in a subjective reality?, or a subjective consciousness in an objective reality?... we’re knocking on the door to the theory of everything here people… that’s some pretty heavy stuff if I must say so myself.

:40:yep, some pretty heavy stuff…

The Doors - Riders On the Storm (Remastered HD) - YouTube
 
You know we are getting close to the end of this discussion when Tom brings out the "definitions"

You will not accept an answer that is not theological in nature. The more we got into this the more it becomes a debate about God.

I reject your reality you reject mine.

Your view of the world, society, and everything else folds together nicely with your faith in God. I do not have such a strong faith in God so my point of view is very different. I cant accept the foundation for your argument, you cant accept the foundation for mine.

To answer your question I don't believe in absolute truth when it relates to anything but science and mathematics. 1 +1 is always 2, this is an absolute truth, in social situations it is always relative and never absolute. Murder is not absolutely wrong, what if it is in self defense, or in defense of another?

We can file this one away with the rest of the debates that devolved into debates about theology and philosophy.
leaving aside your absolute logical inconsistencies on absolute truth for a moment, I take it you would accept the proposition that it would be morally good for someone to torture a baby purely for personal pleasure if society (or a majority of it) accepts it as morally good?
 
I know they (the majority of Chinese) have not attempted even a cursory study of the bible. Which is the point that seems to evade you. The point being that God is not embraced by the majority of them yet the values seem to exist. You can call the objective ones God given, but they flat out reject Him and yet still largely subscribe to these values. Technically, I would imagine they should all go to hell or at least never get to heaven.I find them a good example simply because of the sheer number of Godless Chinese. My attempts with the bible are irrelevant.

I think a serious study of the bible can be done from differing perspectives. A serious study performed by you will see shadows and lights and remarkable insights. But these are stemming from a position of unquestionable faith. You still need it (faith) to take the book seriously. Without it, it is another story. You have it. Enjoy it.

Separate question, would you embrace a Christian enemy of Macedonia more than a non-Christian Macedonian?
Are you playing the game where you pretend to forget everything I've ever said on the topic so that you can just rehash the same old arguments that I've already addressed dozens of times?

Seriously Chris, no one said you have to agree with me or even like what I'm saying, but don't treat me like a fool.
 
Are you playing the game where you pretend to forget everything I've ever said on the topic so that you can just rehash the same old arguments that I've already addressed dozens of times?

Seriously Chris, no one said you have to agree with me or even like what I'm saying, but don't treat me like a fool.

You mean like you have done numerous times to me in this thread? Where you keep asking the same question with a progressively more obscene examples? Pretty soon you will be hashing out full plot lines, "raping, then killing the baby and then chopping it into pieces and eating it" is what you will ask me next.
 
You mean like you have done numerous times to me in this thread? Where you keep asking the same question with a progressively more obscene examples? Pretty soon you will be hashing out full plot lines, "raping, then killing the baby and then chopping it into pieces and eating it" is what you will ask me next.
The difference between you and me is that I have the courage to plainly state what I stand for. You don't want to actually answer the question, rather you skim around the edges trying to justify your position that objective moral values (and absolute truth) do not exist.

If you are so confident in your position - that objective moral values do not exist - then you would be able to explicitly accept the example I provided as morally good (or at least neutral) if society accepted it as such. That fact that you cannot even accept the less obscene examples tells me that you are not confident in your position.

The fact that you even call it obscene betrays you're commitment to that position. If there are no objective moral values, then those examples cannot be obscene - not objectively - and you would have to accept that it is morally good for those that believe it is morally good or as you put it, it would be morally good if society agrees that it is morally good. At best you would have to accept that it is morally neutral, but you could never really call it obscene because there would be no objective way of judging whether it was really obscene or you just think its obscene.
 
leaving aside your absolute logical inconsistencies on absolute truth for a moment, I take it you would accept the proposition that it would be morally good for someone to torture a baby purely for personal pleasure if society (or a majority of it) accepts it as morally good?

I would not accept it as "normally good" because my subjective morals make me believe it is "normally bad". The individual doesn't have to share the morals of the majority. The individual only to accept that he lives in a society that does has certain morals. I would not torture babies because I find it wrong. real

Again you are searching for absolution. I contend that it is always relative. If we all grew up in a society where killing babies was normal then I don't think we would inherently find it wrong.

The same applies to people in North Korea who live in a totally manipulated reality where their thoughts are all relative to what they know. Kids who grew up in polygamist compounds and had no contact with the outside world did not find pedophilia wrong, neither did the parents of those kids. If pedophilia was naturally wrong, the parents of these kids wouldn't have allowed it to happen, but as I've been saying its all relative.

The Spartans threw the "weak" babies into the gorge, this was socially acceptable and normal, today this would be considered cruel and gruesome murder.

You are so rigid man, you insist that terms can be used in only a certain way, you insist that philosophical concepts that can be argued every which way can only be one way, you seem to always insist conveniently that only your understanding and your definition of things is correct. You naturally seem to always want to impose your beliefs on others and classify any opposition as lacking validity. You enter into a discussion not to discuss but to prove that you are right, you come into every discussion positive that you are right, so really its not a discussion but a lecture wrapped in smugness.
 
No Tom I would only have to accept that in your head, and in your convoluted justification system. I have stood by what I stand for, no one is going around the edges of anything. I gave you my answer you refuse to accept it because its not what you want the answer to be.

All you do is ask questions but you never answer any. Oh I forgot everyone else's questions are objectively invalid thus no need to answer them right?? While your questions are objectively valid so we have to answer them or else we are doubly invalid.

I'm done,

The difference between you and me is that I have the courage to plainly state what I stand for. You don't want to actually answer the question, rather you skim around the edges trying to justify your position that objective moral values (and absolute truth) do not exist.

If you are so confident in your position - that objective moral values do not exist - then you would be able to explicitly accept the example I provided as morally good (or at least neutral) if society accepted it as such. That fact that you cannot even accept the less obscene examples tells me that you are not confident in your position.

The fact that you even call it obscene betrays you're commitment to that position. If there are no objective moral values, then those examples cannot be obscene - not objectively - and you would have to accept that it is morally good for those that believe it is morally good or as you put it, it would be morally good if society agrees that it is morally good. At best you would have to accept that it is morally neutral, but you could never really call it obscene because there would be no objective way of judging whether it was really obscene or you just think its obscene.
 
Last edited:
You are so rigid man, you insist that terms can be used in only a certain way, you insist that philosophical concepts that can be argued every which way can only be one way, you seem to always insist conveniently that only your understanding and your definition of things is correct.
That's what language and communication is - words and concepts have to have meaning otherwise noone would know what anyone else was talking about. Black has to be black in order for it to be understood. You cannot redefine it to mean white just to suit your argument. If you want to say white, then say white, there is no need to redefine the meaning of black and it only serves to confuse. Your confusion of absolute with non-absolute is one striking example.

What you are proposing, yet fail to actually see let alone respond to is that your stance, that there are no objective moral values and we must live by subjective moral values as determined by individuals and society (as vaguely as you have explained it) actually proposes the “right” moral scheme—the one we all ought to follow. But this itself is absolutism.

Some of what I’ve written below comes from other sources, but for the sake of brevity, I’ve only cited a few of them.

One needs to recognize the difference between beliefs and truths. What people believe is not what is important. People have different beliefs about things all the time, but what matters is which beliefs are true. For example, if two people have opposing views about life on Mars – one believes there is life on Mars while the other does not believe there is life on Mars. Both people cannot be right. Either there is life on Mars or there is not. Those are two different beliefs, but only one is true. The same argument applies to cultural relativism (or society determining what is right/wrong and good/evil and true/false). While different cultures believe different things, the fact that they have these beliefs does not result in truth. Either one is and the other is not, or they both are not true.

The problem for the moral relativist is they have no good answer to the two-part question: Is there anything wrong with anything, and why? A proper answer to the question necessitates that an individual have: (1) an unchanging standard they can turn to, and (2) an absolute authority that has the right to impose moral obligation. Absent these two things, and morals or ethics simply become emotive. Rape, for example, could never be deemed wrong; the strongest statement that could be made about rape would be, "I don't like it."

The idea of cultural relativism – or that society determines what moral values are – is absurd. Firstly, you would have to definitively define what society is (and I’ve never seen this done). Then you would have to determine who within society has authority to represent the defining moral values of the culture – is it a majority view, consensus, or political leadership?

If what is right is just, good, right and true is defined as whatever the cultural majority believes is right, then a reformer (one who disagrees with the culture and seeks to reform it—e.g. Martin Luther King) is – by definition – morally wrong . This leaves no room for any kind of moral or cultural reform because that implies that something needed changing with the culture in the first place. However, your saying that society determines what is right and therefore there is no need to change what is already right.

This means that Martin Luther King in trying to change dominant racism in American society was morally wrong; abolitionists who tried to end slavery were morally reprehensible; Gandhi and those who worked against apartheid for decades – the very people who are generally viewed as moral heroes, who stood up against a deeply immoral system –turn out to be the only ones who were immoral – and the ones who acquiesced, who perpetuated the system, were the moral ideals.

If cultural relativism were true, one would have to change the way he viewed the moral reformers who went again cultural norms to change the way of society. Instead of viewing these people as heroes, one would have to view them as violating the already culturally determined standards of right and wrong. This is absurd.

Claiming that morality is what the majority decides it to be shifts an unjustified opinion from one person to a group of people; it is arbitrary and leads to absurd conclusions. Hitler was able to convince a majority of his people that his actions were right, but that does not really make them right.

Without the biblical God and literal Genesis, right and wrong become personal preferences such that “murder is wrong” is equivalent to “blue is my favorite color.” Both are personal opinions and provide no basis for arguing with someone who has a different opinion. But the question, logically speaking, is how the moral relativist can make sense of taking evil seriously – not simply as something inconvenient, or unpleasant, or contrary to his or her desires. What philosophy of value or morality can the moral relativist offer which will render it meaningful to condemn some atrocity as objectively evil? The moral indignation which is expressed by the moral relativist when they encounter the wicked things which transpire in this world does not comport with theories of ethics which moral relativists espouse, theories which prove to be arbitrary or subjective or merely utilitarian or relativistic in character.

On the moral relativists’ worldview, there is no good reason for saying that anything is evil in nature, but only by personal choice or feeling. Thus, when evolutionists talk about morality as if it is a real standard, they are being inconsistent with their own worldview.

Going back to your claim that Macedonians would have rights if they determined they have rights. The reality is that the vast majority of Macedonians have determined that they do not have rights (and this clearly stems from their nihilistic worldview which seems to predominate even on this forum). This means that as Macedonians, we have long ago determined that we do not have rights – the right to national self-determination or even individual rights of self-identification. Because Macedonian society has determined this we are now, according to your relativist logic, morally wrong in thinking that we do have rights and in trying to convince the Macedonian people that they not only have rights, but that they should exercise them. According to your moral relativism, we are an abomination because the decision has been made by the society that we claim to belong do.

You stated that you only believe in scientific absolutes. What you are basically saying is that you only believe something is absolutely true if it can be tested empirically. But I think that you also believe that emotions like love exist and that their existence is absolutely true. The problem you have is that emotions cannot be empirically tested and yet they exist

I think you also wrote that morality has evolved through human evolution, implying that we have developed an awareness of right or wrong and moral obligation to help us survive/reproduce.

If human beings are simply the product of naturalistic evolution, then we have no foundation for moral obligation and human dignity.

If human beings are merely the inevitable result of the laws of physics and chemistry acting over time, then how can people have any genuine choice in what they do? If the decisions people make are simply the deterministic outworking of electrochemical reactions in a brain – which is itself allegedly the mindless outworking of billions of random chance copying errors in our DNA – then how would it make sense to hold people responsible for their “decisions”?

After all, we do not attempt to punish the planet Venus for spinning backwards. And we do not get angry at baking soda for reacting with vinegar. This is just what necessarily happens in the universe given the laws of nature. So why would an evolutionist be angry at anything one human being does to another, if we are all nothing more than complex chemical reactions? If we are simply evolved animals, why should we hold to a code of conduct in this “dog-eat-dog” world? After all, what one animal does to another is morally irrelevant.

Social Darwinism claims that all the behaviours we do, we do because they provide some selective advantage to the individual or the species. For example, evolutionists can explain reciprocal altruism ("I scratch your back, you scratch mine"), but have had difficulty explaining altruistic acts done by humans that are not likely to be returned by the recipient.

In a recent book, A Natural History of Rape: Biological Bases of Sexual Coercion, authors Randy Thornhill and Craig T. Palmer claim that rape is "a natural, biological phenomenon that is a product of the human evolutionary heritage," just like "the leopard's spots and the giraffe's elongated neck." In other words, rape is a biological "adaptation" that allows undesirable males the opportunity to pass on their genes. According to Randy Thornhill, "Every feature of every living thing, including human beings, has an underlying evolutionary background. That's not a debatable matter." According to the anthropology department at the University of California Santa Barbara, "That rape might be an adaptation is a reasonable hypothesis to pursue, and the proper framework is intersexual conflict." If rape is just an evolutionary adaptation, then how can it be immoral, regardless of what you or anyone else may think about it?

My next point goes more toward RtG, even though I’ve made this point to him multiple times already.

Humans do not have to find out what is moral by reading the Bible such knowledge is available to all people. They have God's general revelation of his basic moral law in their conscience. People (including atheists and Chinese) have the same sorts of moral instincts as Christians – that torturing babies for fun (along with rape or adultery) is wrong, and kindness is good.

When a person says, "Maybe murder or rape isn't really wrong," he does not need an argument. He is self-deceived. If he really believes this, he needs spiritual or psychological help because he is just not functioning properly. Even relativists who claim that someone's values may be true for him but not for others are likely those who say, "I have rights" or "You ought to be tolerant." But rights and tolerance do not make any sense if relativism is correct. Rather, they entail that objective moral values exist.

Moral principles are discovered, not invented. Moral reforms (abolishing slavery, advocating a woman's right to vote, promoting civil rights for blacks) make no sense unless objective moral values exists. Even if creating the atmosphere for reform may take time (even centuries), this does not imply that morality just evolves during human history and is just a human invention. Rather, it more readily suggests that moral principles can be discovered and are worth pursuing, even at great cost.

Even if relativists are right in that cultures differ radically in their basic moral values, so what? The observation in itself proves nothing, because no conclusion about morality follows. Just because cultures differ on moral viewpoints doesn't mean that objective moral truth is a fiction. In logic this is called a non-sequitur; the conclusion doesn't follow from the premises.

Observations about the practices of groups of people, even if accurate, don't translate into valid conclusions about the true nature of morality per se. How does it follow that because each group thinks it's right, therefore no group is correct? The simple fact of disagreement on morality doesn't lead to the conclusion there is no moral truth. This confuses the epistemological question (the accurate knowledge of objective values) with the ontological question (the existence of objective values).

Let the moral relativist be lied to, be the victim of false advertising, uncover the fact that their spouse has been relatively faithful to them, and they instantly become a moral absolutist. A person's reaction to what they consider unfair ethical treatment always betrays their true feelings on the matter of relative vs. objective moral laws – something that both Gocka and RtG have done repeatedly in their posts!

 
Are you playing the game where you pretend to forget everything I've ever said on the topic so that you can just rehash the same old arguments that I've already addressed dozens of times?

Seriously Chris, no one said you have to agree with me or even like what I'm saying, but don't treat me like a fool.

I would suggest you give a genuine attempt at an answer on these issues one in every hundred attempts. The rest of the time you basically say "because of God" and wrap it up in a nice bundle of smug. Many are reluctant to tell you if they disagree because they fear they will spend an eternity in hell or, worse yet, suffer an eternity of abuse from you.

I note you gave me an answer above about the Chinese or Indians or whoever, .... because God made them. It is painfully fundamental for you and you are a painful fundamentalist in this regard. I can see you have no choice but to argue from this perspective. And it is wonderfully convenient. Not everyone is on the same page. Those people on different pages have been known to be wonderful human beings on occasions. No doubt through the glory of God (even if they don't know him).

Anyway, are you actually saying homosexuality is objectively morally wrong based upon God's will? And, as a consequence, support the ban on homosexual marriage? Should the constitution of a nation limit itself to objective moral values?

How do nations fit within your concept of objective morality?

Vangelovski said:
Humans do not have to find out what is moral by reading the Bible such knowledge is available to all people. They have God's general revelation of his basic moral law in their conscience. People (including atheists and Chinese) have the same sorts of moral instincts as Christians – that torturing babies for fun (along with rape or adultery) is wrong, and kindness is good.
So God is playing a game with the people who do not worship him. He instils these moral "instincts" in all humans but only lets the ones who worship him in heaven. This kind of feeds the "smug" in my opinion.
 
I would suggest you give a genuine attempt at an answer on these issues one in every hundred attempts. The rest of the time you basically say "because of God" and wrap it up in a nice bundle of smug. Many are reluctant to tell you if they disagree because they fear they will spend an eternity in hell or, worse yet, suffer an eternity of abuse from you.
Every attempt has been genuine, if you refuse to read and understand what I'm saying, then I can't make you.

Abuse, where have I abused anyone?

I note you gave me an answer above about the Chinese or Indians or whoever, .... because God made them. It is painfully fundamental for you and you are a painful fundamentalist in this regard. I can see you have no choice but to argue from this perspective. And it is wonderfully convenient. Not everyone is on the same page. Those people on different pages have been known to be wonderful human beings on occasions. No doubt through the glory of God (even if they don't know him).
You seem to think that atheism is a proven fact and that it is the default position from which all knowledge proceeds. I could say that you too are a fundamentalist in this regard and a painful one at that.

I've never said that an atheist cannot be a wonderful human being with an excellent moral value system and even live it out better than a theist can. But you don't seem interested in what I have or have not said - rather you just seem to hate the fact that I don't have enough faith to be an atheist (and yes, it takes much more faith than to be a theist and I will expand on that in a later post) and attack my theism rather than think through what I'm trying to say.

Anyway, are you actually saying homosexuality is objectively morally wrong based upon God's will? And, as a consequence, support the ban on homosexual marriage?
I believe that God created the universe and everything in it. I believe that He set down a moral law for all time and for all places. And yes, this is why I believe that homosexual acts are an abomination, just like any other sin - for example, adultery.

I believe that all people (not just homosexuals and adulterers) are depraved sinners and cannot possibly reach the standards God's moral law and that we all deserve an eternity in hell because being depraved sinners we cannot be in the presence of a holy God which demands perfection.

I believe that God (Jesus), being incredibly unfair, took the punishment for our sin and all we have to do is acknowledge Him (Jesus) and our sin and trust him with our salvation.

I believe it is our choice as to whether we go to Heaven or Hell. But you already know all of this. This is the umpteenth time I've made it perfectly clear, which is why I don't know why you continue to play that game.

Should the constitution of a nation limit itself to objective moral values?
No, I think they need to set out clear and just mechanisms of governance, inherent and inalienable individual rights and limitations on the state. But you already know this through out many discussions on the topic and through our development of the MTO's version of the cause. So again, I can't see why you keep playing this game.

How do nations fit within your concept of objective morality?
I'm not sure of what exactly what are asking here. And no, this is not me saying you are a dumb arse - this is me saying I don't understand, I need further explanation and the problem may lie with my comprehension skills.

So God is playing a game with the people who do not worship him. He instils these moral "instincts" in all humans but only lets the ones who worship him in heaven. This kind of feeds the "smug" in my opinion.
It has nothing to do with worship. I explained it above as I have many times. So again, I don't know why you continue to play this game.

Perhaps you can give me enough respect to answer that? Do you genuinely forget? Are you that disinterested in my posts that you don't even take in what I say (yet for some reason continue to respond)? Or are you just playing some sort of game?
 
I don't see ant answer in all of this. I wont even begin to answer it because it is an invalid argument. Please present a valid argument and then I will answer it. Please accept my superiority and my inherent correctness bestowed upon me by God. Thank you :) Wow this is really easy, now I get it.

In the mean time while you contemplate why every answer you give will be wrong please answer this question.

If God bestowed upon us basic morals that we are born with, then tell me why the polygamists in Utah in the 21st century practice and still practice pedophilia and polygamy, and why the parents of the children who are being abused willingly present their kids to the pedophiles. Why do they not have a basic set of morals that tell them that is wrong? Let give you a hint, it has something to do with cultural relativity, where if you are cut off from a society where pedophilia is wrong you have no relative moral against it.

Subjective morality is not absurd, it is a more commonly accepted philosophy then objective morality.

That's what language and communication is - words and concepts have to have meaning otherwise noone would know what anyone else was talking about. Black has to be black in order for it to be understood. You cannot redefine it to mean white just to suit your argument. If you want to say white, then say white, there is no need to redefine the meaning of black and it only serves to confuse. Your confusion of absolute with non-absolute is one striking example.

What you are proposing, yet fail to actually see let alone respond to is that your stance, that there are no objective moral values and we must live by subjective moral values as determined by individuals and society (as vaguely as you have explained it) actually proposes the “right” moral scheme—the one we all ought to follow. But this itself is absolutism.

Some of what I’ve written below comes from other sources, but for the sake of brevity, I’ve only cited a few of them.

One needs to recognize the difference between beliefs and truths. What people believe is not what is important. People have different beliefs about things all the time, but what matters is which beliefs are true. For example, if two people have opposing views about life on Mars – one believes there is life on Mars while the other does not believe there is life on Mars. Both people cannot be right. Either there is life on Mars or there is not. Those are two different beliefs, but only one is true. The same argument applies to cultural relativism (or society determining what is right/wrong and good/evil and true/false). While different cultures believe different things, the fact that they have these beliefs does not result in truth. Either one is and the other is not, or they both are not true.

The problem for the moral relativist is they have no good answer to the two-part question: Is there anything wrong with anything, and why? A proper answer to the question necessitates that an individual have: (1) an unchanging standard they can turn to, and (2) an absolute authority that has the right to impose moral obligation. Absent these two things, and morals or ethics simply become emotive. Rape, for example, could never be deemed wrong; the strongest statement that could be made about rape would be, "I don't like it."

The idea of cultural relativism – or that society determines what moral values are – is absurd. Firstly, you would have to definitively define what society is (and I’ve never seen this done). Then you would have to determine who within society has authority to represent the defining moral values of the culture – is it a majority view, consensus, or political leadership?

If what is right is just, good, right and true is defined as whatever the cultural majority believes is right, then a reformer (one who disagrees with the culture and seeks to reform it—e.g. Martin Luther King) is – by definition – morally wrong . This leaves no room for any kind of moral or cultural reform because that implies that something needed changing with the culture in the first place. However, your saying that society determines what is right and therefore there is no need to change what is already right.

This means that Martin Luther King in trying to change dominant racism in American society was morally wrong; abolitionists who tried to end slavery were morally reprehensible; Gandhi and those who worked against apartheid for decades – the very people who are generally viewed as moral heroes, who stood up against a deeply immoral system –turn out to be the only ones who were immoral – and the ones who acquiesced, who perpetuated the system, were the moral ideals.

If cultural relativism were true, one would have to change the way he viewed the moral reformers who went again cultural norms to change the way of society. Instead of viewing these people as heroes, one would have to view them as violating the already culturally determined standards of right and wrong. This is absurd.

Claiming that morality is what the majority decides it to be shifts an unjustified opinion from one person to a group of people; it is arbitrary and leads to absurd conclusions. Hitler was able to convince a majority of his people that his actions were right, but that does not really make them right.

Without the biblical God and literal Genesis, right and wrong become personal preferences such that “murder is wrong” is equivalent to “blue is my favorite color.” Both are personal opinions and provide no basis for arguing with someone who has a different opinion. But the question, logically speaking, is how the moral relativist can make sense of taking evil seriously – not simply as something inconvenient, or unpleasant, or contrary to his or her desires. What philosophy of value or morality can the moral relativist offer which will render it meaningful to condemn some atrocity as objectively evil? The moral indignation which is expressed by the moral relativist when they encounter the wicked things which transpire in this world does not comport with theories of ethics which moral relativists espouse, theories which prove to be arbitrary or subjective or merely utilitarian or relativistic in character.

On the moral relativists’ worldview, there is no good reason for saying that anything is evil in nature, but only by personal choice or feeling. Thus, when evolutionists talk about morality as if it is a real standard, they are being inconsistent with their own worldview.

Going back to your claim that Macedonians would have rights if they determined they have rights. The reality is that the vast majority of Macedonians have determined that they do not have rights (and this clearly stems from their nihilistic worldview which seems to predominate even on this forum). This means that as Macedonians, we have long ago determined that we do not have rights – the right to national self-determination or even individual rights of self-identification. Because Macedonian society has determined this we are now, according to your relativist logic, morally wrong in thinking that we do have rights and in trying to convince the Macedonian people that they not only have rights, but that they should exercise them. According to your moral relativism, we are an abomination because the decision has been made by the society that we claim to belong do.

You stated that you only believe in scientific absolutes. What you are basically saying is that you only believe something is absolutely true if it can be tested empirically. But I think that you also believe that emotions like love exist and that their existence is absolutely true. The problem you have is that emotions cannot be empirically tested and yet they exist

I think you also wrote that morality has evolved through human evolution, implying that we have developed an awareness of right or wrong and moral obligation to help us survive/reproduce.

If human beings are simply the product of naturalistic evolution, then we have no foundation for moral obligation and human dignity.

If human beings are merely the inevitable result of the laws of physics and chemistry acting over time, then how can people have any genuine choice in what they do? If the decisions people make are simply the deterministic outworking of electrochemical reactions in a brain – which is itself allegedly the mindless outworking of billions of random chance copying errors in our DNA – then how would it make sense to hold people responsible for their “decisions”?

After all, we do not attempt to punish the planet Venus for spinning backwards. And we do not get angry at baking soda for reacting with vinegar. This is just what necessarily happens in the universe given the laws of nature. So why would an evolutionist be angry at anything one human being does to another, if we are all nothing more than complex chemical reactions? If we are simply evolved animals, why should we hold to a code of conduct in this “dog-eat-dog” world? After all, what one animal does to another is morally irrelevant.

Social Darwinism claims that all the behaviours we do, we do because they provide some selective advantage to the individual or the species. For example, evolutionists can explain reciprocal altruism ("I scratch your back, you scratch mine"), but have had difficulty explaining altruistic acts done by humans that are not likely to be returned by the recipient.

In a recent book, A Natural History of Rape: Biological Bases of Sexual Coercion, authors Randy Thornhill and Craig T. Palmer claim that rape is "a natural, biological phenomenon that is a product of the human evolutionary heritage," just like "the leopard's spots and the giraffe's elongated neck." In other words, rape is a biological "adaptation" that allows undesirable males the opportunity to pass on their genes. According to Randy Thornhill, "Every feature of every living thing, including human beings, has an underlying evolutionary background. That's not a debatable matter." According to the anthropology department at the University of California Santa Barbara, "That rape might be an adaptation is a reasonable hypothesis to pursue, and the proper framework is intersexual conflict." If rape is just an evolutionary adaptation, then how can it be immoral, regardless of what you or anyone else may think about it?

My next point goes more toward RtG, even though I’ve made this point to him multiple times already.

Humans do not have to find out what is moral by reading the Bible such knowledge is available to all people. They have God's general revelation of his basic moral law in their conscience. People (including atheists and Chinese) have the same sorts of moral instincts as Christians – that torturing babies for fun (along with rape or adultery) is wrong, and kindness is good.

When a person says, "Maybe murder or rape isn't really wrong," he does not need an argument. He is self-deceived. If he really believes this, he needs spiritual or psychological help because he is just not functioning properly. Even relativists who claim that someone's values may be true for him but not for others are likely those who say, "I have rights" or "You ought to be tolerant." But rights and tolerance do not make any sense if relativism is correct. Rather, they entail that objective moral values exist.

Moral principles are discovered, not invented. Moral reforms (abolishing slavery, advocating a woman's right to vote, promoting civil rights for blacks) make no sense unless objective moral values exists. Even if creating the atmosphere for reform may take time (even centuries), this does not imply that morality just evolves during human history and is just a human invention. Rather, it more readily suggests that moral principles can be discovered and are worth pursuing, even at great cost.

Even if relativists are right in that cultures differ radically in their basic moral values, so what? The observation in itself proves nothing, because no conclusion about morality follows. Just because cultures differ on moral viewpoints doesn't mean that objective moral truth is a fiction. In logic this is called a non-sequitur; the conclusion doesn't follow from the premises.

Observations about the practices of groups of people, even if accurate, don't translate into valid conclusions about the true nature of morality per se. How does it follow that because each group thinks it's right, therefore no group is correct? The simple fact of disagreement on morality doesn't lead to the conclusion there is no moral truth. This confuses the epistemological question (the accurate knowledge of objective values) with the ontological question (the existence of objective values).

Let the moral relativist be lied to, be the victim of false advertising, uncover the fact that their spouse has been relatively faithful to them, and they instantly become a moral absolutist. A person's reaction to what they consider unfair ethical treatment always betrays their true feelings on the matter of relative vs. objective moral laws – something that both Gocka and RtG have done repeatedly in their posts!

 
I believe that God created the universe and everything in it. I believe that He set down a moral law for all time and for all places. And yes, this is why I believe that homosexual acts are an abomination, just like any other sin - for example, adultery.
Staying on topic as much as possible. Adultery seems well documented enough. Where are we getting the homosexuality moral law from? Is it the old testament? I have problems reconciling the old testament with a loving God at the best of times.

I'm not playing any games. I probably have forgotten because what you may have said previously didn't resonate with me. It is hard to grab any reasoned argument from you on these issues because your version of religious debate simply relies on everyone starting with the same assumption about faith.

But I get it now. God created us, we have his values, even if we don't know him. It is up to us if we choose to live in our own version of heaven or hell for eternity.

I believe it is our choice as to whether we go to Heaven or Hell. But you already know all of this.
The bible insists we must accept Jesus as our Lord and saviour before we enter the kingdom of heaven, so I will assume you mean it is our choice as to whether we accept Jesus or not. Which brings me back to the billion odd people who have no idea about him. Which is kind of like asking you to accept Lithuania's national dish as your favourite food even though you have never tasted it.
 
Back
Top