Bij
New member
Interesting thread, and great contributions Vic!!
I am planning a wedding right now, and am finding it incredibly difficult to control anything, much less the music that's requested by guests! If I was in charge of the whole day without input it would all run perfectly, but damn frigging fiance and family on both sides are all meddling and shit. To be fair, his parents are much better than mine (my dad suggested a soccer field for our venue and a few spit roasts.. ugh dad!). Anyway I digress.
I suppose you could ask the band not to play any serb songs, but I've heard people requesting certain songs not be played at events and the band forgetting about it and playing it anyway when someone requested it. It's not like they deal with one wedding at a time, and it would be VERY hard to say "no, can't play that song" to my drunk uncles at 11.30pm on the wedding night. So If I do require the band play no serb songs and then someone requests plava ciganka and they play it, would guests think of me as less of a Macedonian??
I suppose I'm not a good example as I am always breaking the Macedonian rules, like dating non Macedonians and stuff.
So where do we draw the line? The Ottomans pounded us for 550 years, should we stop eating baklava and tulumbi and lokumi and halva even though most of us grew up with these things?
I think (to an extent) we need to acknowledge that Yugoslavia was part of our history, and our parents generation grew up in a time where they were listening to Yugoslavian music and this is part of their youth. My dad worked in Belgrade with Serbs and served in an army with Croats, Bosnians and Serbs too. Does this make him a traitor or a victim of his time?
And to stop going off on tangents, I think it's nice when all other nationalities take an interest and celebrate Macedonian music (and subsequently culture). Whether they're arabs or serbs or asians. So long as they acknowledge it's Macedonian, it's fine by me!
I am planning a wedding right now, and am finding it incredibly difficult to control anything, much less the music that's requested by guests! If I was in charge of the whole day without input it would all run perfectly, but damn frigging fiance and family on both sides are all meddling and shit. To be fair, his parents are much better than mine (my dad suggested a soccer field for our venue and a few spit roasts.. ugh dad!). Anyway I digress.
I suppose you could ask the band not to play any serb songs, but I've heard people requesting certain songs not be played at events and the band forgetting about it and playing it anyway when someone requested it. It's not like they deal with one wedding at a time, and it would be VERY hard to say "no, can't play that song" to my drunk uncles at 11.30pm on the wedding night. So If I do require the band play no serb songs and then someone requests plava ciganka and they play it, would guests think of me as less of a Macedonian??
I suppose I'm not a good example as I am always breaking the Macedonian rules, like dating non Macedonians and stuff.
So where do we draw the line? The Ottomans pounded us for 550 years, should we stop eating baklava and tulumbi and lokumi and halva even though most of us grew up with these things?
I think (to an extent) we need to acknowledge that Yugoslavia was part of our history, and our parents generation grew up in a time where they were listening to Yugoslavian music and this is part of their youth. My dad worked in Belgrade with Serbs and served in an army with Croats, Bosnians and Serbs too. Does this make him a traitor or a victim of his time?
And to stop going off on tangents, I think it's nice when all other nationalities take an interest and celebrate Macedonian music (and subsequently culture). Whether they're arabs or serbs or asians. So long as they acknowledge it's Macedonian, it's fine by me!