What is your opinion in this matter?
I guess everyone has his own thoughts.
Most here-as far as i know- deny that a Slavic migration ever happened.
Some believe there was no movement at all, some that there were only minor scale invasions and the ancient Macedonians were actually Slavic speaking!
The Academy of science of Skopje ,and the Macedonian national museum on the other hand do not deny the migration ,but they promote the idea of mix.
=Slavs migrated ,mixed with the ancient Macedonian (and Paeonian and Dardanian) people ,(gave their language) and the new Macedonian nation was formed so. (appeared in state's form during Samuel's era (10th cent AD)
---------------------------------------------------------------------
I will put a couple of questions on the table ..
If the Slavic migration never happened...
1)Why Slavic place names are NOT found in Macedonia (as well as in Greece) before 7th-8th century AD?...but they do in significant numbers after this time? (at which time,movement of Sclavenes is recorded in the sources)
2)Why the Slavs are described as PAGANS ?
If the slavic-speaking population was actually the descendants of ancient Macedonians...they would be already Christians.
(Remember that Apostle Paul had already started baptizing the Macedonians in the 1st cent AD. (writing letters to Thessalonians in Greek.. )
The Slavic Migration Theory is a myth. I can disprove it rather easily.
1. The ancient Macedonians, as the first Europeans to adopt Christianity, were called Christians. Only non-Christians could be slaves in the Roman Empire, since Church teaching dictated thus. However, since Rome did not become Christian until the fourth century AD, anyone could have been a slave.
Where the confusion lies is that Macedonians, in time, were called Slavs, because of their language being similar to the people of the north. Thus, those unbaptized people of the north, who spoke slavic, were called Slavs (Slaves), and then Macedonians were called slaves because their language was similar. If the Macedonians were slaves before the Christian era in Rome, then it is because they were slaves in building Rome, along with Greeks and others.
2. If the Migration theory is true, as you suggest, then surely there would be evidence of this in the DNA. If the Macedonians are the product of a migration with 15% R1a, then so is Crete with 14%-16%, southern Greeks with 12%, Greek Macedonians with 35%, Syrians and Lebanese with 10% R1a, and Albanians with 10%.
According to Oxford, "Contemporary Slavic paternal gene pool is characterized by the predominance of R1a and I1b (xM26) variants as well as the scarcity of E3b1 lineages as a result of the following prehistoric gene flows."
According to Stanford University,
"Haplogroup R1a is found today across a large swathe of Asia and Europe and may have originated in South or Central Asia. R1a is most common among Pakistanis, North Indians, Russians, Ukrainians, and the Kyrgyz and Altai peoples of Central Asia. Europe R1a is the most common in Slavic peoples and is also very common in Scandinavia. The presence of R1a in the British Isles is in the main due to Norse Viking ancestry…"
According to Oxford, R1a-M17 is found highest among:
1. Polish 56.4%
2. Ukraine 54.0%
3. Byelorussian 47.0%
In the Southern Balkans:
1. Slovenian 37.0%
2. Croatian (mainland) 34.3%
3. Bosnian 24.6%
4. Herzegovinian 12.1%
5. Serbian 15.9%
6. Macedonian 15.2%
7. Bulgarian 14.7%
What other countries have amount of R1a?
1. Romanian 20.0%
2. Hungarian 20.4%
3. Icelander 23.8%
4. Swedish 17.3%
5. Norwegian (Germanic)17.9%
6. Southern Greece 12%
7. Crete 14%-16%
8. Eastern Iran 35%
9 Syria 10%
10. Greek Macedonia 35%
Greeks apparently have something very in common with Eastern and Western Slavic people. In the measurement of I1b, Greece has 8.4%. Compare that to:
1. Czech and Slovak 11.1%
2. Hungarian (non Slavic) 7.1%
3. Polish 9.9%
However, Macedonia has 29.1% compared to Serbia’s 29.2%.
But the real data I would like to point out is: E3b1 and J2E. The National Geographic explains E3b1 thus:
Today, the E3b1 line of descent is most heavily represented in Mediterranean populations. Approximately 10 percent of the men in Spain belong to this haplogroup, as do 12 percent of the men in northern Italy, and 13 percent of the men in central and southern Italy. Roughly 20 percent of the men in Sicily belong to this group. In the Balkans and Greece, between 20 to 30 percent of the men belong to E3b1, as do nearly 75 percent of the men in North Africa. The haplogroup is rarely found in India or East Asia. Around 10 percent of all European men trace their descent to this line. For example, in Ireland, 3 to 4 percent of the men belong; in England, 4 to 5 percent; Hungary, 7 percent; and Poland, 8 to 9 percent. Nearly 25 percent of Jewish men belong to this haplogroup.
If E3B1 is characterized by Mediterranean, and it is, isn’t it odd how Balkans people, a supposedly Slavic people from Ukraine, has the highest amount of this frequency? More than Spain and Italy—not even close. And isn’t it odd that according to Oxford Slavic people are characterized by a scarcity of E3b1. And yet, who has the highest of this frequency?
According to Oxford, Macedonia has the highest amount (next to Albania) at 24.1% in all of Europe, (only Morocco has more, 27.9%) followed closely by Greece at 21.4%, and Serbia at 20.4%. Notice, however, that Croatian mainland has only 5.6%, Bosnian 10.1%, Herzegovinian at 8.5%--not even close. Not even Greek Macedonia has a lot—only 18.6%. Bulgaria only has 20.7%.
How can Macedonia and Serbia, two supposedly Slavic people from the Ukraine have the highest in all of Europe! Compare their numbers to:
1. Poland 3.6%
2. Ukraine 7.5%
Macedonians have more Mediterranean frequencies than Greek, Italians, and Spaniards! And yet, all of these countries are considered natives to the region! Strange, indeed!
The last frequency, J2E is also fascinating. J2E has its origin in the north fertile crescent—South West Asia. Who in Europe has the highest?
1. Albanian Kosovo 16.7%
2. Albanians 14.3%
3. Italian north central 9.6%
4. Macedonian 6.3% (2.8-14.0)
5. Greece 6.5% (3.1-13.5)
6. Serbian 5.3%
As for the other Slavic people or Balkans people, close to nothing!
Indeed, how can the modern day Macedonians, who exhibit the highest amounts in Mediterranean and Middle Eastern frequencies (in Europe) be a Slavic people that came in the 6th century from the Ukraine? It’s not possible in the least. If that was the case, Macedonians would resemble Ukraine, Poland, Russia, and others in the category but they don’t.
The Macedonian language is native to the Balkans. Any linguist will tell you that northern slavic is a branch of southern slavic.
According to Alinei:
I have to commence by clearing away one of the most absurd consequences of the traditional chronology, namely, that of the ‘arrival’ of the Slavs into the immense area in which they now live. The only logical conclusion can be that the southern branch of the Slavs is the oldest and that from it developed the Slavic western and eastern branches in a differing manner and perhaps at different times.
Alinei further states that:
Today only a minority of experts support the theory of a late migration for the Slavs… because none of the variant versions of such late settlement answers the question of what crucial factor could possibly have enabled the Slavs to have left their Bronze-Age firesides to become the dominant peoples of Europe. The southwestern portion of the Slavs had always bordered on the Italic people in Dalmatia, as well as in the areas of the eastern Alps and in the Po lowlands.
Alinei concludes:
The surmised ‘Slavic migration’ is full of inconsistencies. There is no ‘northern Slavic language’, it is rather only a variant of the southern Slavic… The first metallurgic cultures in the Balkans are Slavic… and connected with Anatolia… Slavic presence in the territory, nearly identical to the one occupied by them today, exists ever since the Stone Age… The Slavs have (together with the Greeks and other Balkan peoples developed agriculture… agriculturally mixed economy, typically European, which later enabled the birth of the Greek, Etruscan, and Latin urbanism. Germanic peoples adopted agriculture from the Slavs… The Balkans is one of the rare regions in which a real and true settlement of human groups coming from Anatolia is proven...
Since the Slavic language originated in the southern Balkans, and since Macedonians and Serbians can trace their descendants thousands of years ago to the southern Balkans, it is only logical to conclude that the language and people are native to the southern Balkans. Science buttresses this and any knowledgeable linguist will undergird it.
The ancient Macedonian language is mentioned as Slavic by Orbini in 1601 and the ancient Macedonian language is mentioned distinct of Greek by the ancient writers.
Even if we accept the claim that the ancient Macedonians didn’t speak Slavic, then the question is: how did almost the whole Balkans learn Slavic? If there was a Migration, as you suggest, we should surely see it in DNA studies. If the Slavs were the majority, this would be reflected in the DNA; if they were the minority, then how did they subdue the Balkans with such a diminutive number? Even if we accept this, how can we reconcile the fact that Slavic had its nascence in the south and not in the north? How could the migrants bring a language to the region, if that language has its origins in that region (the Southern Balkans)?
If the ancient Macedonians adopted Slavic, a fact which is impossible, why are modern Macedonians prohibited from claiming the ancients as their own? We already know based on science that Macedonians and Greeks are very similar in DNA; if the Macedonians are a product of a migration, then so are Greeks. If Egyptians, Lebanese, Syrians, Tunisians, and Algerians can claim the ancients as their own, even though today’s people speak a different language, have different customs, and serve different gods, why can’t the Macedonians claim the ancients as their own? And this assumes that today’s Macedonians have no connection in culture and language with the ancients on conjecture.
Were the ancient Greeks so immunable to the Slavic Migration that no Slavic presence has been left in Hellas?
How is that modern Slavic words and names, predate the Homeric poems, when the Slavic language apparently came in the 6th century AD in the Balkans? Take Vasil, for example, clearly a Slavic name that has been used before the times of Homer. And yet Vasil, unlike in Greek, does not merely mean “King.” It means a person “in power.” If you study the history of the name Vasil, and how it has been used historically, you would know that it has been used as an appellation for “king,” “potentate,” “prince,” “chieftain,” “ruler,” etc. In other words, any person in power or authority—not just a “king” as the Hellenic language has it.