The Multilingual Experience in Egypt, from the Ptolemies to the 'Abbasids
The Multilingual Experience in Egypt, from the Ptolemies to the 'Abbasids
Papaconstantinou, Arietta, ed. <i>The Multilingual Experience in
Egypt, from the Ptolemies to the 'Abbasids</i>. Burlington, VT:
Ashgate, 2010. Pp. x, 240. $114.95. ISBN: 9780754665366.
Reviewed by Janet Timbie
Catholic University of America
jtimbie@att.net
This collection of essays adds to the growing field of study of
language change and language interaction in Egypt. The impetus for
the publication came from lectures given by Willy Clarysse and Sofia
Torallas Tovar in 2005, and from seminar presentations by Sarah J.
Clackson. Essays were added in order to present evidence for
multilingualism over the entire period in question. The quality of
research and analysis presented in these essays is generally very
high, though some aspects of the publication format make the volume a
bit hard to use. All essays but one are written in English, though
this is not the first language of certain contributors, and thus some
editorial polishing would have been helpful. But these details do not
seriously detract from the overall quality of this collection.
Important work in this field has been published in the last decade,
and the pace of research is increasing. J. N. Adams, <i>Bilingualism
and the Latin Language</i> (2003), set a standard for research in this
area and is frequently cited in the essays in this collection, as are
the reference works, <i>The Oxford Handbook of Papyrology</i> (2009)
and <i>Egypt in the Byzantine World</i> (2007), both edited by Roger
Bagnall. Both reference works have chapters dealing with language
usage in Egypt. Another recently published collection of essays,
<i>From Hellenism to Islam: Cultural and Linguistic Change in the
Roman Near East</i>, edited by H. Cotton et al. (2009), is similar in
scope to the collection reviewed here, and has some of the same
contributors.
The volume is divided into three parts. An introductory essay by the
editor, Arietta Papaconstantinou, and a somewhat different
introduction to the topic, by Sofia Torallas Tovar, lead off. Part
One, Evidence for a Multilingual Society: Documents and Archives,
follows with three essays (Clarysse, Clackson, and Sijpesteijn). Part
Two, Case Studies in Language Use in a Multilingual Society (Dieleman,
Choat, Boud'hors, Richter, Cromwell) closes the collection. When the
reader carefully studies individual essays, there is much valuable
information and analysis, as well as interesting pointers to the
direction of future research. As Papaconstantinou says in the
introduction, "The approach taken here is broadly socio-historical,
and focuses in great part on making the rich source material and its
potential better known. If anything, this collection demonstrates the
necessity for further work in this field with a full theoretical
framework to support it" (4). Due to the great advantages offered by
the preservation of evidence on papyri, multilingualism in Egypt from
300 B.C.E. to 700 C.E. can be studied over a "wider range of social
strata and language registers" (3). She then reviews topics that need
study, including separation between Greek and Egyptian cultures,
interference, bilingual scribes, education, group language use,
bilingual archives, gender, and public use of language, and points out
how each essay advances research. Torallas follows with a historical
survey of the evidence, and the questions that it raises, in
"Linguistic Identity in Graeco-Roman Egypt." She offers a useful
review of the Greek presence in Egypt before Alexander, based on both
literary and documentary evidence. Then, after an overview of changes
in Egyptian written language, Torallas turns to bilingualism and notes
that the "level of language mixing and of bilingualism among the
speakers was as heterogeneous as the population" (28), yet researchers
can only approach this problem by means of written evidence from the
Graeco-Roman period.
From this point on, the essays describe and analyze specific bodies of
evidence for multilingualism in Egypt. In Part One (Documents and
Archives), Willy Clarysse, "Bilingual Papyrological Archives," begins
with useful links to on-line databases for papyri and ostraca and
defines an archive as "a group of several texts that were brought
together <i>in Antiquity</i> by an institution or person" (48). After
discussing aspects of the relationship between archives and
archaeology, Clarysse turns to bilingual Greek-Demotic archives and
presents the evidence with an effective combination of graphs and
text. The late Sarah J. Clackson, whose essay "Coptic or Greek?
Bilingualism in the Papyri" was posthumously edited by
Papaconstantinou from two conference papers, provides an excellent
introduction to the relationship between written Coptic and Greek in
the fourth to seventh centuries. Beginning students of Coptic,
papyrology, and related fields would get a good orientation from this
essay, since the author aims to dismantle the "dichotomy between
'Greek-speaking culture' and 'Coptic-speaking culture'" (73).
Clackson believed that this dichotomy did not exist, but was an
artifact of the separation of Greek studies and Egyptian studies in
museums, libraries, and universities. More advanced students and
scholars will learn from the examples presented of interference
between Greek and Coptic at the level of lexicons and syntax, and from
the discussion of bilingual Coptic-Greek archives, "focusing on who
was writing what and why" (88). The last essay in Part 1 is
"Multilingual Archives and Documents in Post-Conquest Egypt" by Petra
Sijpesteijn, who carries the subject into and beyond the seventh
century through analysis of the use of Greek, Coptic, and Arabic in
public and private archives. Her conclusion highlights the
significant increase in the use of written Arabic in archives from the
seventh to the eighth centuries, but also underlines the difficulty in
understanding how Egypt eventually "became an entirely Arabic-speaking
country" (123). Sijpesteijn's more speculative ideas about this,
related to changes in low-level administration and religious
conversion, point the direction to further research.
Part Two (Case Studies in Language Use in a Multilingual Society) is
longer, with five essays in rough chronological order by date of
texts. Jacco Dieleman, in "What's in a Sign? Translating Filiation
in the Demotic Magical Papyri," examines the relationship between
written Egyptian (Demotic), spoken Egyptian, and Greek through the
evidence of bilingual magical manuscripts in which a Greek
abbreviation sign is used in the Demotic font. Dieleman then asks,
"Are there any indications that the foreign loan sign articulates a
particular sentiment on the part of the editors within its new
linguistic and scriptural environment?" (129). After a very careful
and clearly written analysis, Dieleman ends by saying that "it remains
unclear to me what these sections have in common that could explain
the loan sign's occurrence" (151). Yet the reader will not be
disappointed with this modest conclusion because the analysis has been
so careful and has set a standard for future research. Malcolm Choat,
"Early Coptic Epistolography," shifts the discussion into the Coptic
period of written Egyptian, looks at formulae in early Coptic letters,
and "assesses the relative influence of Graeco-Roman patterns, the
letters of Paul, and earlier Egyptian precursors" (153). He concludes
that all three elements influenced Coptic practice, and therefore that
the knowledge of "the last guardians of Demotic" (178), namely the
Egyptian priestly class, contributed to Coptic in a way that must be
studied further.
Another type of multilingualism is explored by Anne Boud'hors in
"Toujours honneur au grec? À propos d'un papyrus gréco-copte de la
region thébaine." Some liturgical manuscripts from the seventh
century have Greek and Coptic versions of the same text on facing
pages. Her analysis demonstrates that the Greek version had a place
of honor, but probably was not read in services, thus forecasting the
relationship between Coptic and Arabic versions in eleventh-century
liturgical manuscripts. Tonio Sebastian Richter, in "Language Change
in the Qurra Dossier," adds to the study of written Arabic in Egypt
with an exploration of a trilingual collection of texts related to
taxation and dated to the early eighth century. His essay begins with
a statement of principle regarding language choice in written versus
spoken communication, continues with background on Umayyad
administration in Egypt, and then delves into the details of the Qurra
dossier, leading to some suggestions about the usage of both spoken
and written Coptic in the public domain. Finally, Jennifer Cromwell
offers a case study of the work of an eighth-century scribe who wrote
both Coptic and Greek texts, "Aristophanes Son of Johannes: An Eighth-
Century Bilingual Scribe? A Study of Graphic Bilingualism."
Aristophanes clearly used different Coptic and Greek hands for texts
in each language and the illustrations and analysis in Cromwell's
essay are very clear and helpful. It seems that there were multiple
schools for scribal training and Aristophanes was the product of one
that taught two different styles. But the relationship between this
graphic bilingualism and true bilingualism, as in the famous case of
Dioscorus of Aphrodito, remains to be explored.
The reader will have some problems in using this volume. On occasion,
poor choices in English lead to confusion. See, for example, "did not
go wasted on administrators" (8) and "a man invested in Christ" (40 n.
98); other instances could be cited. The table of contents omits the
headings Part One and Part Two. There are no bibliographies, either
at the end of each essay or in the volume as a whole, although there
is an index. The publisher should have corrected these problems, yet
they do not negate the value of the collection. The essays by
Torallas, Clarysse, Clackson, Sijpesteijn, and Richter combine
background material that would be very helpful to both beginners and
advanced students with expert analysis of a specific problem. The
entire case study section (Part Two) offers material from the cutting
edge of multilingual studies, where technical command of the material
is combined with understanding of the theoretical framework.
The Multilingual Experience in Egypt, from the Ptolemies to the 'Abbasids
Papaconstantinou, Arietta, ed. <i>The Multilingual Experience in
Egypt, from the Ptolemies to the 'Abbasids</i>. Burlington, VT:
Ashgate, 2010. Pp. x, 240. $114.95. ISBN: 9780754665366.
Reviewed by Janet Timbie
Catholic University of America
jtimbie@att.net
This collection of essays adds to the growing field of study of
language change and language interaction in Egypt. The impetus for
the publication came from lectures given by Willy Clarysse and Sofia
Torallas Tovar in 2005, and from seminar presentations by Sarah J.
Clackson. Essays were added in order to present evidence for
multilingualism over the entire period in question. The quality of
research and analysis presented in these essays is generally very
high, though some aspects of the publication format make the volume a
bit hard to use. All essays but one are written in English, though
this is not the first language of certain contributors, and thus some
editorial polishing would have been helpful. But these details do not
seriously detract from the overall quality of this collection.
Important work in this field has been published in the last decade,
and the pace of research is increasing. J. N. Adams, <i>Bilingualism
and the Latin Language</i> (2003), set a standard for research in this
area and is frequently cited in the essays in this collection, as are
the reference works, <i>The Oxford Handbook of Papyrology</i> (2009)
and <i>Egypt in the Byzantine World</i> (2007), both edited by Roger
Bagnall. Both reference works have chapters dealing with language
usage in Egypt. Another recently published collection of essays,
<i>From Hellenism to Islam: Cultural and Linguistic Change in the
Roman Near East</i>, edited by H. Cotton et al. (2009), is similar in
scope to the collection reviewed here, and has some of the same
contributors.
The volume is divided into three parts. An introductory essay by the
editor, Arietta Papaconstantinou, and a somewhat different
introduction to the topic, by Sofia Torallas Tovar, lead off. Part
One, Evidence for a Multilingual Society: Documents and Archives,
follows with three essays (Clarysse, Clackson, and Sijpesteijn). Part
Two, Case Studies in Language Use in a Multilingual Society (Dieleman,
Choat, Boud'hors, Richter, Cromwell) closes the collection. When the
reader carefully studies individual essays, there is much valuable
information and analysis, as well as interesting pointers to the
direction of future research. As Papaconstantinou says in the
introduction, "The approach taken here is broadly socio-historical,
and focuses in great part on making the rich source material and its
potential better known. If anything, this collection demonstrates the
necessity for further work in this field with a full theoretical
framework to support it" (4). Due to the great advantages offered by
the preservation of evidence on papyri, multilingualism in Egypt from
300 B.C.E. to 700 C.E. can be studied over a "wider range of social
strata and language registers" (3). She then reviews topics that need
study, including separation between Greek and Egyptian cultures,
interference, bilingual scribes, education, group language use,
bilingual archives, gender, and public use of language, and points out
how each essay advances research. Torallas follows with a historical
survey of the evidence, and the questions that it raises, in
"Linguistic Identity in Graeco-Roman Egypt." She offers a useful
review of the Greek presence in Egypt before Alexander, based on both
literary and documentary evidence. Then, after an overview of changes
in Egyptian written language, Torallas turns to bilingualism and notes
that the "level of language mixing and of bilingualism among the
speakers was as heterogeneous as the population" (28), yet researchers
can only approach this problem by means of written evidence from the
Graeco-Roman period.
From this point on, the essays describe and analyze specific bodies of
evidence for multilingualism in Egypt. In Part One (Documents and
Archives), Willy Clarysse, "Bilingual Papyrological Archives," begins
with useful links to on-line databases for papyri and ostraca and
defines an archive as "a group of several texts that were brought
together <i>in Antiquity</i> by an institution or person" (48). After
discussing aspects of the relationship between archives and
archaeology, Clarysse turns to bilingual Greek-Demotic archives and
presents the evidence with an effective combination of graphs and
text. The late Sarah J. Clackson, whose essay "Coptic or Greek?
Bilingualism in the Papyri" was posthumously edited by
Papaconstantinou from two conference papers, provides an excellent
introduction to the relationship between written Coptic and Greek in
the fourth to seventh centuries. Beginning students of Coptic,
papyrology, and related fields would get a good orientation from this
essay, since the author aims to dismantle the "dichotomy between
'Greek-speaking culture' and 'Coptic-speaking culture'" (73).
Clackson believed that this dichotomy did not exist, but was an
artifact of the separation of Greek studies and Egyptian studies in
museums, libraries, and universities. More advanced students and
scholars will learn from the examples presented of interference
between Greek and Coptic at the level of lexicons and syntax, and from
the discussion of bilingual Coptic-Greek archives, "focusing on who
was writing what and why" (88). The last essay in Part 1 is
"Multilingual Archives and Documents in Post-Conquest Egypt" by Petra
Sijpesteijn, who carries the subject into and beyond the seventh
century through analysis of the use of Greek, Coptic, and Arabic in
public and private archives. Her conclusion highlights the
significant increase in the use of written Arabic in archives from the
seventh to the eighth centuries, but also underlines the difficulty in
understanding how Egypt eventually "became an entirely Arabic-speaking
country" (123). Sijpesteijn's more speculative ideas about this,
related to changes in low-level administration and religious
conversion, point the direction to further research.
Part Two (Case Studies in Language Use in a Multilingual Society) is
longer, with five essays in rough chronological order by date of
texts. Jacco Dieleman, in "What's in a Sign? Translating Filiation
in the Demotic Magical Papyri," examines the relationship between
written Egyptian (Demotic), spoken Egyptian, and Greek through the
evidence of bilingual magical manuscripts in which a Greek
abbreviation sign is used in the Demotic font. Dieleman then asks,
"Are there any indications that the foreign loan sign articulates a
particular sentiment on the part of the editors within its new
linguistic and scriptural environment?" (129). After a very careful
and clearly written analysis, Dieleman ends by saying that "it remains
unclear to me what these sections have in common that could explain
the loan sign's occurrence" (151). Yet the reader will not be
disappointed with this modest conclusion because the analysis has been
so careful and has set a standard for future research. Malcolm Choat,
"Early Coptic Epistolography," shifts the discussion into the Coptic
period of written Egyptian, looks at formulae in early Coptic letters,
and "assesses the relative influence of Graeco-Roman patterns, the
letters of Paul, and earlier Egyptian precursors" (153). He concludes
that all three elements influenced Coptic practice, and therefore that
the knowledge of "the last guardians of Demotic" (178), namely the
Egyptian priestly class, contributed to Coptic in a way that must be
studied further.
Another type of multilingualism is explored by Anne Boud'hors in
"Toujours honneur au grec? À propos d'un papyrus gréco-copte de la
region thébaine." Some liturgical manuscripts from the seventh
century have Greek and Coptic versions of the same text on facing
pages. Her analysis demonstrates that the Greek version had a place
of honor, but probably was not read in services, thus forecasting the
relationship between Coptic and Arabic versions in eleventh-century
liturgical manuscripts. Tonio Sebastian Richter, in "Language Change
in the Qurra Dossier," adds to the study of written Arabic in Egypt
with an exploration of a trilingual collection of texts related to
taxation and dated to the early eighth century. His essay begins with
a statement of principle regarding language choice in written versus
spoken communication, continues with background on Umayyad
administration in Egypt, and then delves into the details of the Qurra
dossier, leading to some suggestions about the usage of both spoken
and written Coptic in the public domain. Finally, Jennifer Cromwell
offers a case study of the work of an eighth-century scribe who wrote
both Coptic and Greek texts, "Aristophanes Son of Johannes: An Eighth-
Century Bilingual Scribe? A Study of Graphic Bilingualism."
Aristophanes clearly used different Coptic and Greek hands for texts
in each language and the illustrations and analysis in Cromwell's
essay are very clear and helpful. It seems that there were multiple
schools for scribal training and Aristophanes was the product of one
that taught two different styles. But the relationship between this
graphic bilingualism and true bilingualism, as in the famous case of
Dioscorus of Aphrodito, remains to be explored.
The reader will have some problems in using this volume. On occasion,
poor choices in English lead to confusion. See, for example, "did not
go wasted on administrators" (8) and "a man invested in Christ" (40 n.
98); other instances could be cited. The table of contents omits the
headings Part One and Part Two. There are no bibliographies, either
at the end of each essay or in the volume as a whole, although there
is an index. The publisher should have corrected these problems, yet
they do not negate the value of the collection. The essays by
Torallas, Clarysse, Clackson, Sijpesteijn, and Richter combine
background material that would be very helpful to both beginners and
advanced students with expert analysis of a specific problem. The
entire case study section (Part Two) offers material from the cutting
edge of multilingual studies, where technical command of the material
is combined with understanding of the theoretical framework.