• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

The Theory of Evolution

Philosopher

New member
44 Reasons Why Evolution Is Just A Fairy Tale For Adults

By Michael Snyder, on January 8th, 2014

The theory of evolution is false. It is simply not true.* Actually, it is just a fairy tale for adults based on ancient pagan religious philosophy that hundreds of millions of people around the world choose to believe with blind faith.* When asked to produce evidence for the theory of evolution, most adults in the western world come up totally blank.* When pressed, most people will mumble something about how “most scientists believe it” and how that is good enough for them.* This kind of anti-intellectualism even runs rampant on our college campuses.* If you doubt this, just go to a college campus some time and start asking students why they believe in evolution.* Very few of them will actually be able to give you any real reasons why they believe it.* Most of them just have blind faith in the priest class in our society (“the scientists”).* But is what our priest class telling us actually true?* When Charles Darwin popularized the theory of evolution, he didn’t actually have any evidence that it was true.* And since then the missing evidence has still not materialized.* Most Americans would be absolutely shocked to learn that most of what is taught as “truth” about evolution is actually the product of the overactive imaginations of members of the scientific community.* They so badly want to believe that it is true that they will go to extraordinary lengths to defend their fairy tale.* They keep insisting that the theory of evolution has been “proven” and that it is beyond debate.* Meanwhile, most average people are intimidated into accepting the “truth” about evolution because they don’t want to appear to be “stupid” to everyone else.

In this day and age, it is imperative that we all learn to think for ourselves.* Don’t let me tell you what to think, and don’t let anyone else tell you what to think either.* Do your own research and come to your own conclusions.* The following are 44 reasons why evolution is just a fairy tale for adults…

#1 If the theory of evolution was true, we should have discovered millions upon millions of transitional fossils that show the development of one species into another species. Instead, we have zero.

#2 When Charles Darwin came up with his theory, he admitted that no transitional forms had been found at that time, but he believed that huge numbers certainly existed and would eventually be discovered…

“Lastly, looking not to any one time, but to all time, if my theory be true, numberless intermediate varieties, linking closely together all the species of the same group, must assuredly have existed. But, as by this theory, innumerable transitional forms must have existed, why do we not find them embedded in countless numbers in the crust of the earth?”

#3 Even some of the most famous evolutionists in the world acknowledge the complete absence of transitional fossils in the fossil record. For example, Dr. Colin Patterson, former senior paleontologist of the British Museum of Natural History and author of “Evolution” once wrote the following…

“I fully agree with your comments about the lack of direct illustration of evolutionary transitions in my book. If I knew of any, fossil or living, I would certainly have included them …. I will lay it on the line – there is not one such fossil for which one could make a watertight argument.”

#4 Stephen Jay Gould, Professor of Geology and Paleontology at Harvard University, once wrote the following about the lack of transitional forms…

“The absence of fossil evidence for intermediary stages between major transitions in organic design, indeed our inability, even in our imagination, to construct functional intermediates in many cases, has been a persistent and nagging problem for gradualistic accounts of evolution.”

#5 Evolutionist Stephen M. Stanley of Johns Hopkins University has also commented on the stunning lack of transitional forms in the fossil record…

“In fact, the fossil record does not convincingly document a single transition from one species to another.”

#6 If “evolution” was happening right now, there would be millions of creatures out there with partially developed features and organs.* But instead there are none.

#7 If the theory of evolution was true, we should not see a sudden explosion of fully formed complex life in the fossil record. Instead, that is precisely what we find.

#8 Paleontologist Mark Czarnecki, an evolutionist, once commented on the fact that complex life appears very suddenly in the fossil record…

“A major problem in proving the theory has been the fossil record; the imprints of vanished species preserved in the Earth’s geological formations. This record has never revealed traces of Darwin’s hypothetical intermediate variants – instead species appear and disappear abruptly, and this anomaly has fueled the creationist argument that each species was created by God.”

#9 The sudden appearance of complex life in the fossil record is so undeniable that even Richard Dawkins has been forced to admit it…
“It is as though they [fossils] were just planted there, without any evolutionary history. Needless to say this appearance of sudden planting has delighted creationists. Both schools of thought (Punctuationists and Gradualists) despise so-called scientific creationists equally, and both agree that the major gaps are real, that they are true imperfections in the fossil record. The only alternative explanation of the sudden appearance of so many complex animal types in the Cambrian era is divine creation and both reject this alternative.”

#10 Nobody has ever observed macroevolution take place in the laboratory or in nature.* In other words, nobody has ever observed one kind of creature turn into another kind of creature.* The entire theory of evolution is based on blind faith.

#11 Evolutionist Jeffrey Schwartz, a professor of anthropology at the University of Pittsburgh, openly admits that “the formation of a new species, by any mechanism, has never been observed.”

#12 Even evolutionist Stephen J. Gould of Harvard University has admitted that the record shows that species do not change. The following is how he put it during a lecture at Hobart & William Smith College…

“Every paleontologist knows that most species don’t change. That’s bothersome….brings terrible distress. ….They may get a little bigger or bumpier but they remain the same species and that’s not due to imperfection and gaps but stasis. And yet this remarkable stasis has generally been ignored as no data. If they don’t change, its not evolution so you don’t talk about it.”

#13 Anyone that believes that the theory of evolution has “scientific origins” is fooling themselves.* It is actually a deeply pagan religious philosophy that can be traced back for thousands of years.

#14 Anything that we dig up that is supposedly more than 250,000 years old should have absolutely no radiocarbon in it whatsoever.* But instead, we find it in everything that we dig up – even dinosaur bones.* This is clear evidence that the “millions of years” theory is simply a bunch of nonsense…

It’s long been known that radiocarbon (which should disappear in only a few tens of thousands of years at the most) keeps popping up reliably in samples (like coal, oil, gas, etc.) which are supposed to be ‘millions of years’ old. For instance, CMI has over the years commissioned and funded the radiocarbon testing of a number of wood samples from ‘old’ sites (e.g. with Jurassic fossils, inside Triassic sandstone, burnt by Tertiary basalt) and these were published (by then staff geologist Dr Andrew Snelling) in Creation magazine and Journal of Creation. In each case, with contamination eliminated, the result has been in the thousands of years, i.e. C-14 was present when it ‘shouldn’t have been’. These results encouraged the rest of the RATE team to investigate C-14 further, building on the literature reviews of creationist M.D. Dr Paul Giem.

In another very important paper presented at this year’s ICC, scientists from the RATE group summarized the pertinent facts and presented further experimental data. The bottom line is that virtually all biological specimens, no matter how ‘old’ they are supposed to be, show measurable C-14 levels. This effectively limits the age of all buried biota to less than (at most) 250,000 years.

#15 The odds of even a single sell “assembling itself” by chance are so low that they aren’t even worth talking about.* The following is an excerpt from Jonathan Gray’s book entitled “The Forbidden Secret“…

Even the simplest cell you can conceive of would require no less than 100,000 DNA base pairs and a minimum of about 10,000 amino acids, to form the essential protein chain. Not to mention the other things that would also be necessary for the first cell.

Bear in mind that every single base pair in the DNA chain has to have the same molecular orientation (“left-hand” or “right hand”)? As well as that, virtually all the amino acids must have the opposite orientation. And every one must be without
error.

“Now,” explained Larry, “to randomly obtain those correct orientations, do you know your chances? It would be 1 chance in 2110,000, or 1 chance in 1033,113!
“To put it another way, if you attempted a trillion, trillion, trillion combinations every second for 15 billion years, the odds you would achieve all the correct orientations would still only be one chance in a trillion, trillion, trillion, trillion … and the trillions would continue 2755 times!

“It would be like winning more than 4700 state lotteries in a row with a single ticket purchased for each. In other words…impossible.”

#16 How did life learn to reproduce itself?* This is a question that evolutionists do not have an answer for.

#17 In 2007, fishermen caught a very rare creature known as a Coelacanth.* Evolutionists originally told us that this “living fossil” had gone extinct 70 million years ago.* It turns out that they were only off by 70 million years.

#18 According to evolutionists, the Ancient Greenling Damselfly last showed up in the fossil record about 300 million years ago.* But it still exists today.* So why hasn’t it evolved at all over the time frame?

#19 Darwinists believe that the human brain developed without the assistance of any designer.* This is so laughable it is amazing that there are any people out there that still believe this stuff.* The truth is that the human brain is amazingly complex.* The following is how a PBS documentary described the complexity of the human brain: “It contains over 100 billion cells, each with over 50,000 neuron connections to other brain cells.”

#20 The following is how one evolutionist pessimistically assessed the lack of evidence for the evolution of humanity…

“Even with DNA sequence data, we have no direct access to the processes of evolution, so objective reconstruction of the vanished past can be achieved only by creative imagination.”

#21 Perhaps the most famous fossil in the history of the theory of evolution, “Piltdown Man”, turned out to be a giant hoax.

#22 If the neutron were not about 1.001 times the mass of the proton, all protons would have decayed into neutrons or all neutrons would have decayed into protons, and therefore life would not be possible. How can we account for this?

#23 If gravity was stronger or weaker by the slimmest of margins, then life sustaining stars like the sun could not exist. This would also make life impossible. How can we account for this?

#24 Why did evolutionist Dr. Lyall Watson make the following statement?…
“The fossils that decorate our family tree are so scarce that there are still more scientists than specimens. The remarkable fact is that all of the physical evidence we have for human evolution can still be placed, with room to spare, inside a single coffin!”

#25 Apes and humans are very different genetically.* As DarwinConspiracy.com explains, “the human Y chromosome has twice as many genes as the chimpanzee Y chromosome and the chromosome structures are not at all similar.”

#26 How can we explain the creation of new information that is required for one animal to turn into another animal?* No evolutionary process has ever been shown to be able to create new biological information.* One scientist described the incredible amount of new information that would be required to transform microbes into men this way…

“The key issue is the type of change required — to change microbes into men requires changes that increase the genetic information content, from over half a million DNA ‘letters’ of even the ‘simplest’ self-reproducing organism to three billion ‘letters’ (stored in each human cell nucleus).”

#27 Evolutionists would have us believe that there are nice, neat fossil layers with older fossils being found in the deepest layers and newer fossils being found in the newest layers.* This simply is not true at all…
The fossil layers are not found in the ground in the nice neat clean order that evolutionists illustrate them to be in their textbooks. There is not one place on the surface of the earth where you may dig straight down and pass through the fossil layers in the order shown in the textbooks. The neat order of one layer upon another does not exist in nature. The fossil bearing layers are actually found out of order, upside down (backwards according to evolutionary theory), missing (from where evolutionists would expect them to be) or interlaced (“younger” and “older” layers found in repeating sequences). “Out of place” fossils are the rule and not the exception throughout the fossil record.

#28 Evolutionists believe that the ancestors of birds developed hollow bones over thousands of generations so that they would eventually be light enough to fly.* This makes absolutely no sense and is beyond ridiculous.

#29 If dinosaurs really are tens of millions of years old, why have scientists found dinosaur bones with soft tissue still in them?* The following is from an NBC News report about one of these discoveries…

For more than a century, the study of dinosaurs has been limited to fossilized bones. Now, researchers have recovered 70 million-year-old soft tissue, including what may be blood vessels and cells, from a Tyrannosaurus rex.

#30 Which evolved first: blood, the heart, or the blood vessels for the blood to travel through?

#31 Which evolved first: the mouth, the stomach, the digestive fluids, or the ability to poop?

#32 Which evolved first: the windpipe, the lungs, or the ability of the body to use oxygen?

#33 Which evolved first: the bones, ligaments, tendons, blood supply, or the muscles to move the bones?

#34 In order for blood to clot, more than 20 complex steps need to successfully be completed. How in the world did that process possibly evolve?

#35 DNA is so incredibly complex that it is absolutely absurd to suggest that such a language system could have “evolved” all by itself by accident…

When it comes to storing massive amounts of information, nothing comes close to the efficiency of DNA. A single strand of DNA is thousands of times thinner than a strand of human hair. One pinhead of DNA could hold enough information to fill a stack of books stretching from the earth to the moon 500 times.

Although DNA is wound into tight coils, your cells can quickly access, copy, and translate the information stored in DNA. DNA even has a built-in proofreader and spell-checker that ensure precise copying. Only about one mistake slips through for every 10 billion nucleotides that are copied.

#36 Can you solve the following riddle by Perry Marshall?…
1) DNA is not merely a molecule with a pattern; it is a code, a language, and an information storage mechanism.
2) All codes are created by a conscious mind; there is no natural process known to science that creates coded information.
3) Therefore DNA was designed by a mind.
If you can provide an empirical example of a code or language that occurs naturally, you’ve toppled my proof. All you need is one.

#37 Evolutionists simply cannot explain why our planet is so perfectly suited to support life.

#38 Shells from living snails have been “carbon dated” to be 27,000 years old.

#39 If humans have been around for so long, where are all of the bones and all of the graves?* The following is an excerpt from an article by Don Batten…
Evolutionists also claim there was a ‘Stone Age’ of about 100,000 years when between one million and 10 million people lived on Earth. Fossil evidence shows that people buried their dead, often with artefacts—cremation was not practised until relatively recent times (in evolutionary thinking). If there were just one million people alive during that time, with an average generation time of 25 years, they should have buried 4 billion bodies, and many artefacts. If there were 10 million people, it would mean 40 billion bodies buried in the earth. If the evolutionary timescale were correct, then we would expect the skeletons of the buried bodies to be largely still present after 100,000 years, because many ordinary bones claimed to be much older have been found. However, even if the bodies had disintegrated, lots of artefacts should still be found.

#40 Evolutionists claim that just because it looks like we were designed that does not mean that we actually were.* They often speak of the “illusion of design”, but that is kind of like saying that it is an “illusion” that a 747 airplane or an Apple iPhone were designed.* And of course the human body is far more complex that a 747 or an iPhone.

#41 If you want to be part of the “scientific community” today, you must accept the theory of evolution no matter how absurd it may seem to you.* Richard Lewontin of Harvard once made the following comment regarding this harsh reality…

We take the side of science in spite of the patent absurdity of some of its constructs, . . . in spite of the tolerance of the scientific community for unsubstantiated commitment to materialism. . . . we are forced by our a priori adherence to material causes to create an apparatus of investigation and set of concepts that produce material explanations, no matter how counterintuitive, no matter how mystifying to the uninitiated. Moreover, that materialism is absolute, for we cannot allow a Divine Foot in the door.

#42 Time Magazine once made the following statement about the lack of evidence for the theory of evolution…

“Yet despite more than a century of digging, the fossil record remains maddeningly sparse. With so few clues, even a single bone that doesn’t fit into the picture can upset everything. Virtually every major discovery has put deep cracks in the conventional wisdom and forced scientists to concoct new theories, amid furious debate.”

#43 Malcolm Muggeridge, the world famous journalist and philosopher, once made the following statement about the absurdity of the theory of evolution…

“I myself am convinced that the theory of evolution, especially the extent to which it’s been applied, will be one of the great jokes in the history books of the future. Posterity will marvel that so very flimsy and dubious an hypothesis could be accepted with the incredible credulity that it has.”

#44 In order to believe the theory of evolution, you must have enough blind faith to believe that life just popped into existence from nonlife, and that such life just happened to have the ability to take in the nourishment it needed, to expel waste, and to reproduce itself, all the while having everything it needed to survive in the environment in which it suddenly found itself. Do you have that much blind faith?

For years, I have been looking for someone that can explain to me the very best evidence for the theory of evolution in a systematic way.* My challenge has been for someone to lay out for me a basic outline of the facts that “prove” that evolution is true.

Perhaps you believe that you are up to the challenge.

http://thetruthwins.com/archives/44-reasons-why-evolution-is-just-a-fairy-tale-for-adults
 
Last edited:
I find it cool how you're creating topics I have degrees in. But I doubt you want to discuss the issue or really read what I post...your mind is made up.


In response to some of the lies and misleading statements in the article you posted:


#1 If the theory of evolution was true, we should have discovered millions upon millions of transitional fossils that show the development of one species into another species. Instead, we have zero.

"At least hundreds, possibly thousands, of transitional fossils have been found so far by researchers. The exact count is unclear because some lineages of organisms are continuously evolving."

http://www.livescience.com/3306-fossils-reveal-truth-darwin-theory.html



Stephen Jay Gould, Professor of Geology and Paleontology at Harvard University, once wrote the following about the lack of transitional forms…

“The absence of fossil evidence for intermediary stages between major transitions in organic design, indeed our inability, even in our imagination, to construct functional intermediates in many cases, has been a persistent and nagging problem for gradualistic accounts of evolution.”

This definitely shows a lack of understanding of science. Gould is referring to gradualism evolution. It's probably because he is a bigger fan of punctuated equilibrium or macro-mutation. I think all processes have happened, based on the evidence.

If “evolution” was happening right now, there would be millions of creatures out there with partially developed features and organs.

This is up there with one of the most idiotic statements I've read about evolution. A complete misunderstanding of genes and how mutations lead to evolution.

If the theory of evolution was true, we should not see a sudden explosion of fully formed complex life in the fossil record. Instead, that is precisely what we find.


Again, idiotic. Evolution happens in several ways, not just gradual.


Realizing this is pointless, I'll just point to an article that speaks fact and addresses the central lies and misrepresentations in your article.

A large part of the reason why Creationist arguments against evolution can sound so persuasive is because they don't address evolution, but rather argue against a set of misunderstandings that people are right to consider ludicrous. The Creationists wrongly believe that their understanding of evolution is what the theory of evolution really says, and declare evolution banished. In fact, they haven't even addressed the topic of evolution. (The situation isn't helped by poor science education generally. Even most beginning college biology students don't understand the theory of evolution.)

The five propositions below seem to be the most common misconceptions based on a Creationist straw-man version of evolution. If you hear anyone making any of them, chances are excellent that they don't know enough about the real theory of evolution to make informed opinions about it.

Evolution has never been observed.
Evolution violates the 2nd law of thermodynamics.
There are no transitional fossils.
The theory of evolution says that life originated, and evolution proceeds, by random chance.
Evolution is only a theory; it hasn't been proved.

Explanations of why these statements are wrong are given below. They are brief and therefore somewhat simplified; consult the references at the end for more thorough explanations.


"Evolution has never been observed."

Biologists define evolution as a change in the gene pool of a population over time. One example is insects developing a resistance to pesticides over the period of a few years. Even most Creationists recognize that evolution at this level is a fact. What they don't appreciate is that this rate of evolution is all that is required to produce the diversity of all living things from a common ancestor.

The origin of new species by evolution has also been observed, both in the laboratory and in the wild. See, for example, (Weinberg, J.R., V.R. Starczak, and D. Jorg, 1992, "Evidence for rapid speciation following a founder event in the laboratory." Evolution 46: 1214-1220). The "Observed Instances of Speciation" FAQ in the talk.origins archives gives several additional examples.

Even without these direct observations, it would be wrong to say that evolution hasn't been observed. Evidence isn't limited to seeing something happen before your eyes. Evolution makes predictions about what we would expect to see in the fossil record, comparative anatomy, genetic sequences, geographical distribution of species, etc., and these predictions have been verified many times over. The number of observations supporting evolution is overwhelming.

What hasn't been observed is one animal abruptly changing into a radically different one, such as a frog changing into a cow. This is not a problem for evolution because evolution doesn't propose occurrences even remotely like that. In fact, if we ever observed a frog turn into a cow, it would be very strong evidence against evolution.


"Evolution violates the 2nd law of thermodynamics."

This shows more a misconception about thermodynamics than about evolution. The second law of thermodynamics says, "No process is possible in which the sole result is the transfer of energy from a cooler to a hotter body." [Atkins, 1984, The Second Law, pg. 25] Now you may be scratching your head wondering what this has to do with evolution. The confusion arises when the 2nd law is phrased in another equivalent way, "The entropy of a closed system cannot decrease." Entropy is an indication of unusable energy and often (but not always!) corresponds to intuitive notions of disorder or randomness. Creationists thus misinterpret the 2nd law to say that things invariably progress from order to disorder.

However, they neglect the fact that life is not a closed system. The sun provides more than enough energy to drive things. If a mature tomato plant can have more usable energy than the seed it grew from, why should anyone expect that the next generation of tomatoes can't have more usable energy still? Creationists sometimes try to get around this by claiming that the information carried by living things lets them create order. However, not only is life irrelevant to the 2nd law, but order from disorder is common in nonliving systems, too. Snowflakes, sand dunes, tornadoes, stalactites, graded river beds, and lightning are just a few examples of order coming from disorder in nature; none require an intelligent program to achieve that order. In any nontrivial system with lots of energy flowing through it, you are almost certain to find order arising somewhere in the system. If order from disorder is supposed to violate the 2nd law of thermodynamics, why is it ubiquitous in nature?

The thermodynamics argument against evolution displays a misconception about evolution as well as about thermodynamics, since a clear understanding of how evolution works should reveal major flaws in the argument. Evolution says that organisms reproduce with only small changes between generations (after their own kind, so to speak). For example, animals might have appendages which are longer or shorter, thicker or flatter, lighter or darker than their parents. Occasionally, a change might be on the order of having four or six fingers instead of five. Once the differences appear, the theory of evolution calls for differential reproductive success. For example, maybe the animals with longer appendages survive to have more offspring than short-appendaged ones. All of these processes can be observed today. They obviously don't violate any physical laws.


"There are no transitional fossils."

A transitional fossil is one that looks like it's from an organism intermediate between two lineages, meaning it has some characteristics of lineage A, some characteristics of lineage B, and probably some characteristics part way between the two. Transitional fossils can occur between groups of any taxonomic level, such as between species, between orders, etc. Ideally, the transitional fossil should be found stratigraphically between the first occurrence of the ancestral lineage and the first occurrence of the descendent lineage, but evolution also predicts the occurrence of some fossils with transitional morphology that occur after both lineages. There's nothing in the theory of evolution which says an intermediate form (or any organism, for that matter) can have only one line of descendents, or that the intermediate form itself has to go extinct when a line of descendents evolves.

To say there are no transitional fossils is simply false. Paleontology has progressed a bit since Origin of Species was published, uncovering thousands of transitional fossils, by both the temporally restrictive and the less restrictive definitions. The fossil record is still spotty and always will be; erosion and the rarity of conditions favorable to fossilization make that inevitable. Also, transitions may occur in a small population, in a small area, and/or in a relatively short amount of time; when any of these conditions hold, the chances of finding the transitional fossils goes down. Still, there are still many instances where excellent sequences of transitional fossils exist. Some notable examples are the transitions from reptile to mammal, from land animal to early whale, and from early ape to human. For many more examples, see the transitional fossils FAQ in the talk.origins archive, and see http://www.geo.ucalgary.ca/~macrae/talk_origins.html for sample images for some invertebrate groups.

The misconception about the lack of transitional fossils is perpetuated in part by a common way of thinking about categories. When people think about a category like "dog" or "ant," they often subconsciously believe that there is a well-defined boundary around the category, or that there is some eternal ideal form (for philosophers, the Platonic idea) which defines the category. This kind of thinking leads people to declare that Archaeopteryx is "100% bird," when it is clearly a mix of bird and reptile features (with more reptile than bird features, in fact). In truth, categories are man-made and artificial. Nature is not constrained to follow them, and it doesn't.

Some Creationists claim that the hypothesis of punctuated equilibrium was proposed (by Eldredge and Gould) to explain gaps in the fossil record. Actually, it was proposed to explain the relative rarity of transitional forms, not their total absence, and to explain why speciation appears to happen relatively quickly in some cases, gradually in others, and not at all during some periods for some species. In no way does it deny that transitional sequences exist. In fact, both Gould and Eldredge are outspoken opponents of Creationism.

"But paleontologists have discovered several superb examples of intermediary forms and sequences, more than enough to convince any fair-minded skeptic about the reality of life's physical genealogy." - Stephen Jay Gould, Natural History, May 1994


"The theory of evolution says that life originated, and evolution proceeds, by random chance."

There is probably no other statement which is a better indication that the arguer doesn't understand evolution. Chance certainly plays a large part in evolution, but this argument completely ignores the fundamental role of natural selection, and selection is the very opposite of chance. Chance, in the form of mutations, provides genetic variation, which is the raw material that natural selection has to work with. From there, natural selection sorts out certain variations. Those variations which give greater reproductive success to their possessors (and chance ensures that such beneficial mutations will be inevitable) are retained, and less successful variations are weeded out. When the environment changes, or when organisms move to a different environment, different variations are selected, leading eventually to different species. Harmful mutations usually die out quickly, so they don't interfere with the process of beneficial mutations accumulating.

Nor is abiogenesis (the origin of the first life) due purely to chance. Atoms and molecules arrange themselves not purely randomly, but according to their chemical properties. In the case of carbon atoms especially, this means complex molecules are sure to form spontaneously, and these complex molecules can influence each other to create even more complex molecules. Once a molecule forms that is approximately self-replicating, natural selection will guide the formation of ever more efficient replicators. The first self-replicating object didn't need to be as complex as a modern cell or even a strand of DNA. Some self-replicating molecules are not really all that complex (as organic molecules go).

Some people still argue that it is wildly improbable for a given self-replicating molecule to form at a given point (although they usually don't state the "givens," but leave them implicit in their calculations). This is true, but there were oceans of molecules working on the problem, and no one knows how many possible self-replicating molecules could have served as the first one. A calculation of the odds of abiogenesis is worthless unless it recognizes the immense range of starting materials that the first replicator might have formed from, the probably innumerable different forms that the first replicator might have taken, and the fact that much of the construction of the replicating molecule would have been non-random to start with.

(One should also note that the theory of evolution doesn't depend on how the first life began. The truth or falsity of any theory of abiogenesis wouldn't affect evolution in the least.)


"Evolution is only a theory; it hasn't been proved."

First, we should clarify what "evolution" means. Like so many other words, it has more than one meaning. Its strict biological definition is "a change in allele frequencies over time." By that definition, evolution is an indisputable fact. Most people seem to associate the word "evolution" mainly with common descent, the theory that all life arose from one common ancestor. Many people believe that there is enough evidence to call this a fact, too. However, common descent is still not the theory of evolution, but just a fraction of it (and a part of several quite different theories as well). The theory of evolution not only says that life evolved, it also includes mechanisms, like mutations, natural selection, and genetic drift, which go a long way towards explaining how life evolved.

Calling the theory of evolution "only a theory" is, strictly speaking, true, but the idea it tries to convey is completely wrong. The argument rests on a confusion between what "theory" means in informal usage and in a scientific context. A theory, in the scientific sense, is "a coherent group of general propositions used as principles of explanation for a class of phenomena" [Random House American College Dictionary]. The term does not imply tentativeness or lack of certainty. Generally speaking, scientific theories differ from scientific laws only in that laws can be expressed more tersely. Being a theory implies self-consistency, agreement with observations, and usefulness. (Creationism fails to be a theory mainly because of the last point; it makes few or no specific claims about what we would expect to find, so it can't be used for anything. When it does make falsifiable predictions, they prove to be false.)

Lack of proof isn't a weakness, either. On the contrary, claiming infallibility for one's conclusions is a sign of hubris. Nothing in the real world has ever been rigorously proved, or ever will be. Proof, in the mathematical sense, is possible only if you have the luxury of defining the universe you're operating in. In the real world, we must deal with levels of certainty based on observed evidence. The more and better evidence we have for something, the more certainty we assign to it; when there is enough evidence, we label the something a fact, even though it still isn't 100% certain.

What evolution has is what any good scientific claim has--evidence, and lots of it. Evolution is supported by a wide range of observations throughout the fields of genetics, anatomy, ecology, animal behavior, paleontology, and others. If you wish to challenge the theory of evolution, you must address that evidence. You must show that the evidence is either wrong or irrelevant or that it fits another theory better. Of course, to do this, you must know both the theory and the evidence.


Conclusion

These are not the only misconceptions about evolution by any means. Other common misunderstandings include how geological dating techniques work, implications to morality and religion, the meaning of "uniformitarianism," and many more. To address all these objections here would be impossible.

But consider: About a hundred years ago, scientists, who were then mostly creationists, looked at the world to figure out how God did things. These creationists came to the conclusions of an old earth and species originating by evolution. Since then, thousands of scientists have been studying evolution with increasingly more sophisticated tools. Many of these scientists have excellent understandings of the laws of thermodynamics, how fossil finds are interpreted, etc., and finding a better alternative to evolution would win them fame and fortune. Sometimes their work has changed our understanding of significant details of how evolution operates, but the theory of evolution still has essentially unanimous agreement from the people who work on it.

http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-misconceptions.html
 
Let's examine Michael Snyder, the author of the article Philosopher posted:

Michael T. Snyder is a fundamentalist Christian crank who has started numerous blogs as a testament to his raging insane belief that the world is about to end.

Huh, Philosopher, it seems you're quick to downplay experts who say that doom and gloom from overpopulation and climate change will occur, but not ones who associate end times with Christianity? Interesting. I like the logic.

He started with The Economic Collapse Blog in 2007, with constant articles stating how the world is going to hell every single day since the meltdown started in 2007.

Yes, the world has clearly gone to Hell.

It seems as though Snyder blames the government for every ill in the world, because without it everything would be great.

Ahh, now I see. Global warming isn't true because it's a conspiracy to create a world government; evolution isn't true because it's a conspiracy to create a world government...I get your drift.

Like most doom-sayers, it doesn't seem to faze Snyder one bit that every one of his past predictions of economic collapse were dead wrong.

Yet, Philosopher believes in his ability to be right just enough to post an article by him.

He also states very clearly, "I am a Christian, but I believe that most of the churches in America have gotten way off track." Snyder has recently posted a statement of faith[1] in which he states that he believes that the Bible is literally true and that Jesus is coming down in person soon to start the end times to punish all the non-believers.[2] After which Jesus will start his thousand year reign over Earth.

I wonder if he hangs out with Philosopher and Vangelovski? (Unnecessary, but so necessary.)

The only ones who will survive are the ones believing in the mantra of 3 G's (Gold, Guns, and God). If you don't have enough of the products to survive the shit hitting the fan, you can always click any of the links at the top of the main page to buy it!

Hehehe...I like it, the 3 G's. Nice. Profitting off of people's religious beliefs and ignorance with regards to science and history. What's new?

http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Michael_T._Snyder

I wonder what else is out there about this guy?

If you're going to dispute evolution, use science to dispute it, not religion and psychological disorders. Am I going too far, or not far enough?
 
Let's examine Michael Snyder, the author of the article Philosopher posted:

Huh, Philosopher, it seems you're quick to downplay experts who say that doom and gloom from overpopulation and climate change will occur, but not ones who associate end times with Christianity? Interesting. I like the logic.



Yes, the world has clearly gone to Hell.



Ahh, now I see. Global warming isn't true because it's a conspiracy to create a world government; evolution isn't true because it's a conspiracy to create a world government...I get your drift.



Yet, Philosopher believes in his ability to be right just enough to post an article by him.



I wonder if he hangs out with Philosopher and Vangelovski? (Unnecessary, but so necessary.)



Hehehe...I like it, the 3 G's. Nice. Profitting off of people's religious beliefs and ignorance with regards to science and history. What's new?

http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Michael_T._Snyder

I wonder what else is out there about this guy?

If you're going to dispute evolution, use science to dispute it, not religion and psychological disorders. Am I going too far, or not far enough?

I do not agree with everything Mr. Snyder writes. In fact, I have strong disagreements with him on a number of issues.

The article was posted to galvanize discussion on this issue. You are free to attack him and it.

I have noticed that every time some author is referenced or quoted you feel the need to research him and then attack him.

You are free to do this of course. But I think it preferable if you would dissect his statements (which you did in your earlier post).

Also, if I may make a suggestion, you should learn to act more civil and present yourself more civil, as your puerile, if not downright obnoxious manners, are evident to all.
 
Last edited:
Here is a article by Babu G. Ranganatham

June 7, RUSSIA (PRAVDA) — Millions of people are taught that the fossil record furnishes proof of evolution. But, where are there fossils of half-evolved dinosaurs or other creatures?

The fossil record contains fossils of only complete and fully-formed species. There are no fossils of partially-evolved species to indicate that a gradual process of evolution ever occurred. Even among evolutionists there are diametrically different interpretations and reconstructions of the fossils used to support human evolution from a supposed ape-like ancestry.

Even if evolution takes millions and millions of years, we should still be able to see some stages of its process. But, we simply don't observe any partially-evolved fish, frogs, lizards, birds, dogs, cats among us. Every species of plant and animal is complete and fully-formed.

Another problem is how could partially-evolved plant and animal species survive over millions of years when their basic organs and tissues were still in the process of evolving? How, for example, were animals breathing, eating, and reproducing if there respiratory, digestive, and reproductive organs were still evolving?

In fact, precisely because of this problem more and more modern evolutionists are adopting a new theory known as Punctuated Equilibrium which says that plant and animal species evolved suddenly from one kind to another and that is why we don't see evidence of partially-evolved species in the fossil record. Of course, we have to accept their word on blind faith because there is no way to prove or disprove what they are saying. These evolutionists claim that something like massive bombardment of radiation resulted in mega mutations in species which produced "instantaneous" changes from one life form to another. The nature and issue of mutations will be discussed later and the reader will see why such an argument is not viable.

The fact that animal and plant species are found fully formed and complete in the fossil record is powerful evidence (although not proof) for creation because it is evidence that they came into existence as fully formed and complete which is possible only by creation.

Evolutionists claim that the genetic and biological similarities between species is evidence of common ancestry. However, that is only one interpretation of the evidence. Another possibility is that the comparative similarities are due to a common Designer who designed similar functions for similar purposes in all the various forms of life. Neither position can be scientifically proved.

Although Darwin was partially correct by showing that natural selection occurs in nature, the problem is that natural selection itself is not a creative force. Natural selection can only work with those biological variations that are possible. The evidence from genetics supports only the possibility for horizontal evolution (i.e. varieties of dogs, cats, horses, cows, etc.) but not vertical evolution (i.e. from fish to human). Unless Nature has the ability to perform genetic engineering vertical evolution will not be possible.

The early grooves in the human embryo that appear to look like gills are really the early stages in the formation of the face, throat, and neck regions. The so-called "tailbone" is the early formation of the coccyx and spinal column which, because of the rate of growth being faster than the rest of the body during this stage, appears to look like a tail. The coccyx has already been proven to be useful in providing support for the pelvic muscles.

Modern science has shown that there are genetic limits to evolution or biological change in nature. Again, all biological variations, whether they are beneficial to survival or not, are possible only within the genetic potential and limits of a biological kind such as the varieties among dogs, cats, horses, cows, etc.

Variations across biological kinds such as humans evolving from ape-like creatures and apes, in turn, evolving from dog-like creatures and so on, as Darwinian evolutionary theory teaches, are not possible unless Nature has the capability of performing genetic engineering.

Biological variations are determined by the DNA or genetic code of species. The DNA molecule is actually a molecular string of various nucleic acids which are arranged in a sequence just like the letters in a sentence. It is this sequence in DNA that tells cells in the body how to construct various tissues and organs.

The common belief among evolutionists is that random mutations in the genetic code over time will produce entirely new sequences for new traits and characteristics which natural selection can then act upon resulting in entirely new species. Evolutionists consider mutations to be a form of natural genetic engineering.

However, the very nature of mutations precludes such a possibility. Mutations are accidental changes in the sequential structure of the genetic code caused by various random environmental forces such as radiation and toxic chemicals.

Almost all true mutations are harmful, which is what one would normally expect from accidents. Even if a good mutation occurred for every good one there will be thousands of harmful ones with the net result over time being disastrous for the species.

Most biological variations, however, are the result of new combinations of previously existing genes - not because of mutations.

Furthermore, mutations simply produce new varieties of already existing traits. For example, mutations in the gene for human hair may change the gene so that another type of human hair develops, but the mutations won't change the gene so that feathers or wings develop.

Sometimes mutations may trigger the duplication of already existing traits (i.e. an extra finger, toe, or even an entire head, even in another area of the body!). But mutations have no ability to produce entirely new traits or characteristics.

Young people, and even adults, often wonder how all the varieties and races of people could have descended from Adam and Eve as the Bible teaches. Well, in principle, that's no different than asking how children with different color hair (i.e., blond, brunette, brown, red ) can come from the same parents who both have black hair.

Just as some individuals today carry genes to produce descendants with different color hair and eyes, our first parents, Adam and Eve, possessed genes to produce all the varieties and races of men. You and I today may not carry the genes to produce every variety or race of humans, but Adam and Eve did possess such genes.

All varieties of humans carry the genes for the same basic traits, but not all humans carry every possible variation of those genes. For example, one person may be carrying several variations of the gene for eye color (i.e., brown, green, blue) , but someone else may be carrying only one variation of the gene for eye color (i.e., brown). Thus, both will have different abilities to affect the eye color of their offspring.

Science cannot prove we're here by creation, but neither can science prove we're here by chance or macro-evolution. No one has observed either. They are both accepted on faith. The issue is which faith, Darwinian macro-evolutionary theory or creation, has better scientific support.

What we believe about life's origins does influence our philosophy and value of life as well as our view of ourselves and others. This is no small issue!

Just because the laws of science can explain how life and the universe operate and work doesn't mean there is no Maker. Would it be rational to believe that there's no designer behind airplanes because the laws of science can explain how airplanes operate and work?

Natural laws are adequate to explain how the order in life, the universe, and even a microwave oven operates, but mere undirected natural laws can never fully explain the origin of such order.

The law of entropy in science shows that the universe does not have the ability to have sustained itself from all eternity. In other words, the universe cannot be eternal and requires a beginning.

It is only fair that school students be exposed to the scientific arguments and evidence on both sides of the creation/evolution issue.
 
The article was posted to galvanize discussion on this issue.

I guess you do understand the point of posting topics in a General Discussions Forum. Or should a discussion not be had because the topic of evolution is heavily politicized?

I have noticed that every time some author is referenced or quoted you feel the need to research him and then attack him.

Do you have evidence that every time an author is reference or quoted I research him and attack him? I'll admit, I like to research.

You are free to do this of course. But I think it preferable if you would dissect his statements (which you did in your earlier post).

People's intentions can be very showing.

Also, if I may make a suggestion, you should learn to act more civil and present yourself more civil, as your puerile, if not downright obnoxious manners, are evident to all.

Ahh, lessons on civility. When you make a joke by lumping me with Eco-terrorists, it's a joke. But when I make a joke, it's childish. I believe that's hypocrisy.
 
Last edited:
If you're going to dispute evolution, use science to dispute it, not religion
lol

Ok then, if evolutionists are going to dispute creation, use the Bible to dispute it, not Science........ It's only fair.

Am I going too far, or not far enough?
just a little.

I never understand why evolutionists get so paranoid and turn unsivilised when they get challenged?
 
Bill, for all the times I have read fundamental Christians on this site becoming much more paranoid and uncivilized than I have when their beliefs are challenged, I have never seen you suggest they were being paranoid or uncivilized. If you have, I apologize. But if you want to talk about being fair...

Evolutionists wouldn't attempt to dispute creationists if creationists weren't suggesting they are using science to dispute evolution. That's the problem. Belief in creationism, go ahead. Just don't try to use science to explain it and cry foul when non-creationists refute that science.
 
Vicsinad said:
I guess you do understand the point of posting topics in a General Discussions Forum. Or should a discussion not be had because the topic of evolution is heavily politicized?

I do not consider the discussion of the theory of evolution a politicized subject, at least not in the same sense as gun control and climate change.

Vicsinad said:
Do you have evidence that every time an author is reference or quoted I research him and attack him? I'll admit, I like to research

Actually I do:

John Coleman
Ronald Bailey
Michael Snyder

Vicsinad said:
Ahh, lessons on civility. When you make a joke by lumping me with Eco-terrorists, it's a joke. But when I make a joke, it's childish. I believe that's hypocrisy.

Not accurate at all. Your behavior has been anything other than civil.
 
I do not consider the discussion of the theory of evolution a politicized subject, at least not in the same sense as gun control and climate change.



Actually I do:

John Coleman
Ronald Bailey
Michael Snyder



Not accurate at all. Your behavior has been anything other than civil.

Again, I'll ask:

Do you have evidence that every time an author is reference or quoted I research him and attack him?

Three doesn't cut it.


Please describe how my behavior has not been civil. And compare it to your comments in the topic on Climate Change. Thanks.
 
Again, I'll ask:

Do you have evidence that every time an author is reference or quoted I research him and attack him?

Three doesn't cut it.


Please describe how my behavior has not been civil. And compare it to your comments in the topic on Climate Change. Thanks.

That attention to detail problem keeps resurfacing. Naturally, the context of my statement was based on our written conversations, viz., the climate thread and now this one. Unless of course you know of another thread we have been engaging in and I have been quoting scholars from?
 
You claim I have an "attention to detail" problem. It's not true. But you do. Otherwise, you would have a valid response to why you only listed three authors after stating that every time an author is referenced or quoted I attack him. Either you're missing the details of all the instances I attacked authors, or you're not paying attention to the details in your own sentences that you're constructing.

However, it was not just the "detail" comments. It includes the eco-terrorist comment. Please compare my comments to your comments and their civility.
 
Vicsinad said:
You claim I have an "attention to detail" problem. It's not true. But you do. Otherwise, you would have a valid response to why you only listed three authors after stating that every time an author is referenced or quoted I attack him. Either you're missing the details of all the instances I attacked authors, or you're not paying attention to the details in your own sentences that you're constructing.

There appears to be a context problem. Not only did you totally ignore my previous post, you also ignored the context of my original statement.

Philosopher said:
I do not agree with everything Mr. Snyder writes. In fact, I have strong disagreements with him on a number of issues.

The article was posted to galvanize discussion on this issue. You are free to attack him and it.

I have noticed that every time some author is referenced or quoted you feel the need to research him and then attack him.

The context is clearly pertaining to our recent conversations, unless of course you are naive enough to believe I was referring to your life on this forum.
 
Last edited:
I find it cool how you're creating topics I have degrees in.
Maybe you can actually try to provide a few answers to some burning questions.

For evolution to be true, it would require the continuous creation of new genetic information. How is that even possible? How is it possible for new information to just appear?

Let me clarify here, I'm not talking about jumbling up existing information, for example (very basic example), ABC = ACB = BCA etc, or the loss of information, for example, ABC = AC. I'm talking about the addition of new information, such as ABC + D. This is what is required for evolution - the addition of new information. For example, without the addition of new genetic information, a creature would not be able to grow an eye where that genetic information did not previously exist.
 
Last edited:
Maybe you can actually try to provide a few answers to some burning questions.

For evolution to be true, it would require the continuous creation of new genetic information. How is that even possible? How is it possible for new information to just appear?

Let me clarify here, I'm not talking about jumbling up existing information, for example, ABC = ACB = BCA etc, or the loss of information, for example, ABC = AC. I'm talking about the addition of new information, such as ABC + D. This is what is required for evolution - the addition of new information. For example, without the addition of new genetic information, a creature would not be able to grow an eye where that genetic information did not previously exist.

You could start by reading and understanding the following articles:


Origins of New Genes and Pseudogenes


By: Chitra Chandrasekaran, Ph.D. (Texas Wesleyan University) & Esther Betrán, Ph.D. (Department of Biology, University of Texas, Arlington, TX) © 2008 Nature Education

The formation of new genes is a primary driving force of evolution in all organisms. How exactly do these new genes crop up in an organism’s genome and what must occur in order for them to be passed on.


New gene origination is a driving force of evolutionary innovation in all organisms. Recent research has focused on identifying the mechanisms that generate new genes, and scientists have found that these mechanisms involve a variety of molecular events, all of which must occur in the germ line to be inherited by the next generation. After the germ-line mutational event, the new gene (e.g., a new gene duplicate located on human chromosome 2) will be polymorphic in the population; in other words, not all second chromosomes in the population will carry the duplication. Subsequently, the two most likely outcomes for the new gene are fixation (i.e., the new gene will reach a frequency of 100%) or extinction (i.e., the new gene will be lost).


Current knowledge of the origin of new genes encompasses information regarding both protein-coding genes and RNA genes. All of these genes are transcribed, but only protein-coding genes are translated into proteins. The study of pseudogenes, originally defined as sequences that resemble known genes but cannot produce a functional protein, has revealed not only how often genes degenerate, but also that many sequences once believed to be degenerating protein-coding genes are in fact functional RNA genes.


Mechanisms of New Gene Generation


Over the years, scientists have proposed several mechanisms by which new genes are generated. These include gene duplication, transposable element protein domestication, lateral gene transfer, gene fusion, gene fission, and de novo origination.




Gene Duplication


Gene duplication was the first mechanism of gene generation to be suggested (Ohno, 1970), and this process does indeed appear to be the most common way of creating new genes. Duplications are typically classified according to the size of the portion of the genome that is duplicated; thus, a duplication may be described as involving an entire genome, large segments of a genome, individual genes, individual exons, or even specific parts of exons (Betrán & Long, 2002). The mechanisms that generate duplicate genes are diverse, and more details about these mechanisms are continually being discovered. These mechanisms include whole-genome duplications originating through nondisjunction, tandem duplications originating through unequal crossover, retropositions originating through the retrotranscription of an RNA intermediate, transpositions involving transposable elements (Jiang et al., 2004; Morgante et al., 2005), and duplications occurring after rearrangements and subsequent repair of staggered breaks (Ranz et al., 2007). Such duplications involve not only protein-coding genes, but also noncoding RNA genes. For example, a novel class of retroduplicates includes snoRNAs, which are a class of RNA genes that are involved in ribosomal RNA processing (Weber, 2006).


Much of the current excitement about gene duplication stems from the fact that with the number of sequenced genomes now available, researchers have more accurate estimates of how often genes duplicate, and these rates are extremely high. For example, more than 100 genes duplicate in the human genome per 1 million years (Hahn et al., 2007a). This means that the percentage of the genome affected by gene number differences (estimated to be 6%) contributes more to the differences between humans and chimpanzees than do single nucleotide differences between orthologous sequences (estimated to be 1.5% [Demuth et al., 2006]). High rates (17 genes per 1 million years) have also been estimated in flies (Hahn et al., 2007b). Additional excitement comes from the realization that duplications occur so often that individuals of the same species differ greatly in DNA content and gene number (i.e., many duplications are polymorphic and contribute to individual differences [Sebat et al., 2004]). It is estimated that, on average, two humans will differ by approximately 5 megabases of information.


Unexpectedly, several duplication trends have been described in genomes with respect to sex chromosome evolution. Many new male genes originate in species' Y chromosomes. Some of these male genes are organized in families that undergo gene conversion to avoid Y-chromosome degeneration. Male germ-line genes can also duplicate out of the X chromosome through retroposition (Betrán et al., 2002; Emerson et al., 2004; Lahn et al., 2001; Rozen et al., 2003). These findings reveal that genomic location and organization matter for gene origination and function.


Transposable Element Protein Domestication

Transposable elements (TEs) are so-called "selfish" segments of DNA that encode proteins that allow these segments to copy or move themselves within a genome. There are two types of TEs: DNA transposons and retrotransposons. DNA transposons are able to excise themselves out of the genome and be inserted somewhere else, whereas retrotransposons copy themselves through an RNA intermediate. Similar to viral insertions in the genome, TE insertions cause mutations and contribute to increased genome size, but they usually do not encode cellular proteins.


Interestingly, one way for a genome to acquire new genes is by recruiting transposable element proteins and using them as cellular proteins. Such events are called domestications of TE proteins. A recent review by Fechotte and Pritham (2007) compiled many examples of these events, and it revealed that some of the unexpected functions in which TE domesticated proteins play a role include functioning of the vertebrate immune system and light sensing in plants. Several examples of domestication have also been described in Drosophila (Casola et al., 2007). In one case, codomestication of the two proteins encoded by the PIF/Harbinger transposable element was observed. In this fascinating example, the two genes that the original TE contained were domesticated simultaneously; one of these genes encoded a transposase that binds and cuts DNA, while the other encoded a protein that contains a Myb/SANT domain believed to function in transcription, chromatin remodeling, and protein-protein interactions. More data are needed to reveal whether both of these proteins were domesticated to function in the same biological process.


Lateral Gene Transfer


Scientists use the term "lateral gene transfer" to refer to the case in which a gene does not have a vertical origin (i.e., direct inheritance from parent to offspring) but instead comes from an unrelated genome. It is well known that this sort of transfer occurs between bacteria, and that it also has taken place between the genomes of the cellular organelles (mitochondria and chloroplasts) and the nuclear genomes (Roger, 1999). However, more recent transfer events between organelles and/or endosymbiont bacteria continue to occur (Bergthorsson et al., 2003; Hotopp et al., 2007). For example, large-scale sequencing efforts have revealed that much of the genome of the intracellular endosymbiont Wolbachia pipentis was integrated into Drosophila species (Hotopp et al., 2007). However, the mechanism for these transfers remains largely unknown, and the functional consequences of some of these transfers have yet to be explored.


Gene Fusion and Fission


Existing genes can also fuse (i.e., two or more genes can become part of the same transcript) or undergo fission (i.e., a single transcript can break into two or more separate transcripts), thereby forming new genes. Interestingly, it has been observed that chimeric fusion genes sometimes involve two copies of the same gene (e.g., the alcohol dehydrogenase gene in Drosophila), and when that happens, the resulting genes undergo parallel evolution (Jones & Begun, 2005), in which they shift away from the functions of their parental genes.


De Novo Gene Origination


New genes can additionally originate de novo from noncoding regions of DNA. Indeed, several novel genes derived from noncoding DNA have recently been described in Drosophila (Begun et al., 2007; Levine et al., 2006). For these recently originated Drosophila genes with likely protein-coding abilities, there are no homologues in any other species. Note, however, that the de novo genes described in various species thus far include both protein-coding and noncoding genes. These new genes sometimes originate in the X chromosome, and they often have male germ-line functions.


The action of all the mechanisms described in the previous sections leads to exon shuffling (i.e., the observation that many genes share exons) (Gilbert et al., 1997; Li et al., 2001). In addition, analyses of "young" genes (genes that originated only a few million years ago) allow investigators to document all of the events that gave rise to these genes, because time has not eroded the footprints of these events. Using this approach, it has been inferred that combinations of several mechanisms and several events are often responsible for the generation of new genes (Betrán & Long, 2002). Two good examples of this are the jingwei gene (Long & Langley, 1993) and the SETMAR gene (Cordaux et al., 2006; Figure 1).


What Happens to New Genes?


All these new sequences add to the complexity and diversity of genomes. As with any mutation, when new genes become fixed in a genome, they add to the differences between species and serve as the raw material for evolution (Ohno, 1970). This is easy to see in the case of gene duplication. Gene duplication results in two or more copies of a gene: one that can maintain its original function in the organism, and other(s) that can be "played with" to take on new functions. As a consequence, new duplicates are a main source of genome innovation and often evolve under positive selection, in which rapid changes in the protein encoded by the new gene occur to gain a new function (Presgraves, 2005). This process is referred to as neofunctionalization of the new gene.


Other possible outcomes after duplication include gene loss or pseudogenization; maintenance of both genes as a way to increase expression or to maintain multiple variants within individuals (essentially "fixing" heterozygosity); or the occurrence of subfunctionalization (i.e., the occurrence of mutually complementing neutral disabling mutations such that both genes need to be kept in the genome [Lynch & Force, 2000]). Subfunctionalization is an interesting phenomenon because it begins with a partition of function but can set the grounds for specialization (Torgerson & Singh, 2004). Some mixed outcomes (such as subfunctionalization followed by neofunctionalization and subneofunctionalization) are also possible (He & Zhang, 2005).


One unanticipated consequence of gene duplication and gene loss is that these events can become the basis for some incompatibilities between species. Duplications and losses have been shown to play a role in hybrid breakdown and in the reduced fitness of the descendants of matings between genetically differentiated populations. Thus, these processes might contribute to the process of speciation (Masly et al., 2006).


The Origin and Fate of Pseudogenes


This schematic illustration depicts two mechanisms by which siRNA can be produced. A horizontal curved line separates the diagram into an upper and lower half. The upper half represents the nucleus, and the lower half represents the cytoplasm. In the nucleus, process A shows a parent gene undergoing two alternative pathways: a duplication and a retroposition. Both pathways result in the production of a pseudogene. The pseudogene has two potential fates: it can exit the nucleus and exist as an antisense transcript in the cytoplasm, or undergo a duplication and inversion inside the nucleus. If it exits the nucleus as an antisense transcript, it can base pair with normal mRNA sequences, and the protein Dicer can cut it into 21-base pair pieces that act as siRNA. If the pseudogene instead undergoes duplication and inversion, it forms a long strand of DNA with complementary sequences on each end. This can form a hairpin RNA, which is a target for the Dicer enzyme. The Dicer products then interact with the RISC complex to degrade target mRNA sequences.

As previously mentioned, pseudogenes are commonly defined as sequences that resemble known genes but cannot produce functional proteins. Pseudogenes originate through the same mechanisms as protein-coding genes, followed by the subsequent accumulation of disabling mutations (e.g., nucleotide insertions, deletions, and/or substitutions) that disrupt the reading frame or lead to the insertion of a premature stop codon. Pseudogenes can be broadly classified into two categories: processed and nonprocessed. Nonprocessed pseudogenes usually contain introns, and they are often located next to their paralogous parent gene. Processed pseudogenes are thought to originate through retrotransposition; accordingly, they lack introns and a promoter region, but they often contain a polyadenylation signal and are flanked by direct repeats. Errors in reverse transcription and the lack of an appropriate regulatory environment often lead to the degeneration of processed copies of genes (D'Errico et al., 2004).


The abundance of pseudogenes in a given genome usually depends on rates of gene duplication and loss. Mammals appear to have a high number of processed pseudogenes—approximately 8,000 (Zhang et al., 2003; Zhang et al., 2004). On the other hand, most other organisms have many fewer; for instance, in Drosophila, only 20 retropseudogenes are detectable (Harrison et al., 2003). This pattern has been explained by the deletion bias that exists in Drosophila; indeed, after studying the size distribution of deletions in Drosophila and mammals, researchers concluded that deletions in Drosophila are much bigger (Petrov & Hartl, 2000).


The most interesting pseudogene finding to date is that degenerated protein-coding genes have been proven to "live on" as RNA genes (Sasidharan & Gerstein, 2008). Although researchers had previously proven that pseudogenes could be transcribed (Harrison et al., 2005), they only recently realized that these sequences can regulate parental genes through siRNAs; evidence of this phenomenon has been found in both flies and mammals (Figure 2; Sasidharan & Gerstein, 2008). In addition, some processed pseudogenes seem to have evolved into primate microRNA genes (Devor, 2006).


Of course, genomes remain full of surprises. Additional work will continue to reveal even more about the functional potential of many new DNA sequences.

http://www.nature.com/scitable/topicpage/origins-of-new-genes-and-pseudogenes-835

New genes arise quickly


What role does the appearance of new genes, versus simple changes in old ones, play in evolution? There are two reasons why this question has recently become important.

The first involves a scientific controversy. Some researchers—the most prominent being evo-devotee Sean Carroll—maintain that most important evolutionary change, at least in body form, involves changes in regulatory sequences rather than simple changes in genes themselves, or the appearance of new genes. This question hasn’t yet been answered, since we don’t know a great deal about those mutations that have been important in creating new body plans.

The second controversy is religious. Some advocates of intelligent design (ID)—most notably Michael Behe in a recent paper—have implied not only that evolved new genes or new genetic “elements” (e.g., regulatory sequences) aren’t important in evolution, but that they play almost no role at all, especially compared to mutations that simply inactivate genes or make small changes, like single nucleotide substitutions, in existing genes. This is based on the religiously-motivated “theory” of ID, which maintains that new genetic information cannot arise by natural selection, but must installed in our genome by a magic poof from Jebus.

I’ve criticized Behe’s conclusions, which are based on laboratory studies of bacteria and viruses that virtually eliminated the possibility of seeing new genes arise, but I don’t want to reiterate my arguments here. What I want to do is point out a new paper by some Chicago colleagues that suggests that new genes, at least in the genus Drosophila (fruit fly), not only arise pretty quickly, but also diverge very quickly to become essential parts of the genome.

The paper, by Sidi Chen, Yong Zhang, and my friend Manyuan Long, appears in this week’s Science: “New genes in Drosophila quickly become essential.” It’s a clever piece of work. What the authors did was compare whole-genome sequences between various species of Drosophila (there are now many of these) to see how often new genes appeared in one lineage: the lineage that diverged from the ancestors of D. willistoni to become D. melanogaster. The divergence between these two lineages is 35 million years, but by comparing the genomes of other species that branched off these two branches, they could estimate how often new genes arise over the entire period from 3 million to 35 million years ago.

What do they mean by “new genes”? These are genes in D. melanogaster that aren’t found in D. willistoni, but have arisen since their divergence by several processes—most often the duplication of an ancestral gene or its RNA followed by extensive genetic divergence, so that the gene acquires a brand new function. (This process accounts for about 90% of the new genes. Some genes, however, are so different between the species that how they arose is a mystery.) These “new genes,” then, would qualify as what Behe calls “gain-of-FCT” adaptive mutations (“FCT” = functional coded element): the kind of mutations that Behe did not see arising in short-term lab experiments on bacteria and viruses.

Chen et al. found that a surprisingly large number of genes had arisen in the D. melanogaster lineage over this 35-myr period. Here’s a summary of their results:
◾ The authors identified 566 new genes that arose over this period. That’s about 4% of the total genes in the D. melanogaster genome. And that’s quite a few given that the divergence is only 35 myr. The genus Drosophila itself (including the scaptomyzids) diverged from its sister group about 63 million years ago, so we can estimate that, in the genus as a whole, at least 7% of the genome comprises brand new genes.
◾The authors were able to take a sample of these genes (195 of them) and knockdown their transcripts using novel RNAi technology (this involves inserting transposable genetic elements in those genes and then using those elements to kill the genes). They found that about 30% of these new genes are essential for viability—that is, the fly dies if it has no active copies. This proportion didn’t vary depending on how long ago the “new” gene had arisen. Nor did it differ much from the proportion of “old” genes (those present in both lineages) that are essential for viability, which is about 35%. It seems, then, that even if these genes arise as duplicates from pre-existing genes, they quickly assume new functions that make the fly unable to survive without them.
◾The “new function” conclusion is supported by two other pieces of data. First, the average difference in DNA sequence between the “new” genes in the D. melanogaster lineage and their parental copies (that is, the genes from which they originated, usually by duplication) is 47.3%. That’s a big difference—a change in nearly every other nucleotide. Second, there are new ways to determine what the new genes do: by estimating which proteins in the genome each new gene’s protein product interacts with. Chen et al. found that many of the products of new genes interact with proteins completely different from the ancestral genes. This implies that the new genes have evolved completely different functions. And, as theory suggests, that’s the way these genes become essential: at first they do the same thing as their ancestral genes (they’re duplicates, after all), but as they diverge they assume new functions (usually impelled by natural selection) that fit them into new developmental pathways. In this way a gene that is at first “gratuitious” can become essential. It’s nice that we can actually see this happening with protein-protein interaction data.
◾In further support of the above scenario for the evolution of new genetic information, the authors found that in young and new “essential” genes, there was a strong signature of natural selection having acted, as suggested by the high rates of DNA substitution. As the “new” essential genes become older, and assume new functions, these rates slow down. This again supports the theory of how new genes originate: when they’re formed by duplication, they are quickly eliminated from the genome (see below) unless they diverge quickly to do something new. Thus the duplicates that do survive are usually those that have diverged quickly. Once the new function has been assumed, and the gene is essential, selection then acts to preserve its new function by eliminating new mutations (“purifying selection”).
◾These results, which show that new genetic information (“FCT”s) arises quickly, don’t imply that every new gene duplication becomes a brand-new gene with a new function. That’s far from the case. We don’t know the figure in Drosophila, but in the human lineage it’s estimated that only about 5% of new duplications diverge to become new genes that do something novel. The rest are inactivated, becoming dead “pseudogenes” that don’t do anything. In Drosophila these are quickly removed from the genome, but in our own lineage many of them linger, so we can estimate the proportion of duplicated genes that don’t go on to do something new.
◾Nevertheless, genes duplicate frequently enough that they can provide sufficient raw material for genetic novelty. Estimates of how often a given gene duplicates in evolution run about one duplication event per 100 million gene copies. That seems low, but remember that there are thousands of genes in the genome, and, in many species (including Drosophila and now ours), there are hundreds of millions of individuals. That means that, in the species, there are many genes that duplicate each generation. Even if only a few percent of these survive inactivation, that’s a lot of raw material for evolutionary change.
◾The presence of frequent gene duplications is supported by an independent study: Emerson et al. (2008) found that in only fifteen lines of D. melanogaster from nature there were several hundred duplicate genes segregating as polymorphisms (that is, some individuals had one copy of a gene, some had two or more). They estimated that 2% of the genome was tied up in this copy-number variation. Clearly, there are a lot of duplicate genes variants floating around in nature.

The data of Chen et al., then, show that new genetic information can arise quickly, at least on an evolutionary timescale, and that the new genes rapidly assume new functions. (Note: I am using Behe’s characterization of “new genetic information” as involving only new FCTs. I don’t agree with this, since new genetic information can also arise when a single gene copy changes sufficiently to do something new.)

Although this doesn’t answer the question of what proportion of new evolutionary traits involve changes in gene sequence versus changes in gene regulation, it does show that a substantial part of the genome in one group of eukaryotes arises by the evolution of new FCTs that become involved in new developmental networks. In other words, Behe’s conclusion from short-term lab studies of bacteria and viruses doesn’t apply to this well-studied group of organisms—and probably not to other eukaryotes, either. All the evidence tells us that a rapid and important way to create new genetic information is through the duplication of genes and then their divergence by natural selection.


Poems are made by fools like me
But only selection makes an FCT

Now ID advocates like Behe could—and do—suggest that maybe the successfully duplicated-and-diverged genes didn’t arise by natural selection, but appeared by the instantaneous intervention of the designer (aka God/Jebus). But that idea is nixed by at least two observations. The first is the appearance in many groups of dead, nonfunctional pseudogenes that were unsuccessful duplicates. If the Great Designer made gene duplications to create genetic novelty, he surely failed in the majority of cases, and left his failures sitting around in the genome.

The second is the correlation between the age of a new gene and the type of selection acting on it. If a Great Designer created these duplicates de novo to have a new function—presumably because natural selection couldn’t take a gene to a new function by gradual stepwise evolution—they would show instantaneous changes of DNA sequence that looked like selection, and then an instantaneous cessation of that selection right after the gene got its newly created function. But that’s not what we see. What we see is not instantaneous but gradual change: the younger a gene is (as estimated by the position on the evolutionary tree where it arose), the more rapid natural selection acts. That directional selection continues to act as the gene gets older, but then slows down and finally becomes purifying selection, so that new DNA changes are eliminated. This pattern is precisely what’s predicted if duplicates arise by accident and then quickly change by selection to assume new functions.

I suppose Behe and his minions will find a way to explain these two patterns by intelligent design, but that’s because ID theory isn’t science: there is no conceivable observation that can prove it wrong. Every bit of data, no matter what it is, can always be fitted into the ID scheme, especially since its advocates allow a little bit of Darwinian evolution and posit an unpredictable and unknowable Designer. But let us not tarnish the nice results of Chen et al. by using them to cast aspersions on ID. They are a valuable contribution to the real science of evolutionary biology, showing how fast new genetic information can arise by gene duplication.

https://whyevolutionistrue.wordpress.com/2010/12/21/new-genes-arise-quickly/

It has been argued that the small, simple, everyday examples of evolution do not involve new information. This argument is sometimes correct. For example, the famous black moths did not contain new genetic information.

In order to make room for new information, there have to be types of mutation which make a genome larger. It turns out that several kinds of mutation do this, notably duplication and polyploidy.

If a bacteria becomes penicillin-resistant, it really does contain new information. We know this because researchers have now got to the point where they have read out (sequenced) every last bit of the DNA in some bacteria. This means that it's possible to do before-and-after measurements.

Here's an example. Take a nice fresh culture dish, and place a single bacteria on it. A colony will grow. This is "before".

Take one bacteria from "before", and start a new culture with it. After the culture is well-started, add some antibiotic. Somewhere in the culture, there may be a mutant who is resistant to the antibiotic. If there isn't such a mutant, they all die. In that case, start over. If necessary, you can encourage mutation, maybe with some radioactivity.

Eventually, you will find such a mutant. You will know it's there because it reproduces, and your culture dish will contain a living colony instead of a dead one. This is "after".

Now get the DNA sequences of "before" and "after". Several researchers have done just this, and the DNA sequences have been published. It is definitely the case that "after" can have new genetic information, which is not present in "before".

In the above example, a beneficial mutation allowed the bacteria to survive a negative thing. It is equally easy to get a mutation that allows a positive thing. For example, give your colony a huge supply of some food which they cannot eat. Eventually some mutant will be able to eat the food, and will have a great many descendants. Then wipe out the normals (by withdrawing the normal food) and you have an "after" colony. As one researcher said:

Here's a tested recipe for isolating successful mutations... Grow a batch culture of Salmonella typhimurium strain SK2979 at 37 deg. C on Neidhardt's MOPS-based minimal medium with 0.4% glycerol as the carbon source and 10 mM L-aspartate as the nitrogen source. Dilute and subculture for several days. L-aspartate fast growing mutants will take over the culture in something under 3 days. These typically have a doubling time of 60 minutes on asparate, compared to about 120 minutes for the parental, wild-type strain.
Even better, starting with the fast-growing strain, one can easily isolate secondary mutation(s) which permit growth on aspartate as the sole carbon and nitrogen source -- which the parental strain simply cannot do. This demonstrates how cumulative mutations can arise.

Basically, techniques involving the natural occurrence of spontaneous, beneficial mutations are commonly used by bacterial geneticists.

The above is from a 1995 Usenet posting by Tim Ikeda (timi@mendel.berkeley.edu), UC-Berkeley Plant Biology.

Some Creationists have argued that these beneficial mutations involve simplification of the bacteria, so that some aspect attacked by the antibiotic is no longer present. That idea would rarely explain the ability to consume a new food, since that usually requires new chemical pathways. Before-and-after genetic analysis says that the "simplification" idea is just not always the case. For example, the malaria parasite has become resistant to chloroquine, by learning to make a new protein. Other examples are known from studies of pesticide resistant insects.

It is also illogical that "simplification" always be the case. A mutation is due to a completely random malfunction of the genetic mechanisms. There is simply nothing to prevent a bacteria from occasionally acquiring increased complexity. If the more complex genetic material happens to be useful, then the bacteria has by definition acquired information. It has "learned" what works. As one scientist put it, "evolution is a transfer of information from the environment to the genome."

You might wonder how a change could fail to be damaging. If all of a bacteria's genetic information is useful, then any change must have removed something useful. This is half-true, because bacteria do indeed run a tight ship. ("Higher" creatures are different, and carry around lots of genetic junk.) However, the chemical mechanisms which use genes do not really understand the idea of dosage. That is, if a creature needs twice as much of one chemical as another, there is no way to tell the mechanism "make twice as much". (I'm simplifying. Actually, hemoglobin has "enhancers" and "promoters".) The obvious trick for solving this problem is to simply have two copies of the gene. Therefore, creatures carry around two or more copies of some genes. If one copy is changed by a mutation, the creature can get along fairly well on the other one(s).

Gene duplication is a fairly common mutation. Having an extra copy doesn't "cost" much, so a creature with such a mutation isn't at any great disadvantage. Extra copies are actually fairly common in the genetic material of "higher" creatures. And of course a mutation that changes an extra copy is not the same problem as a mutation that changes an only copy.

http://www.don-lindsay-archive.org/creation/new_info.html
 
Vicsinad said:
"At least hundreds, possibly thousands, of transitional fossils have been found so far by researchers. The exact count is unclear because some lineages of organisms are continuously evolving."

http://www.livescience.com/3306-foss...in-theory.html

False.

Anyone reading creationist literature for a few years soon becomes aware that we often use quotes by evolutionists which discredit their own belief system. This raises the ire of many in the evolutionary establishment, and often they will accuse creationists of ‘taking their remarks out of context’. This is rarely the case. However, one can imagine that the spectre of condemnation from fellow evolutionists would these days tend to limit any careless remarks from the pro-evolutionary camp.

One of the most famous and widely circulated quotes was made a couple of decades ago by the late Dr Colin Patterson, who was at the time the senior paleontologist (fossil expert) at the prestigious British Museum of Natural History.

So damning was the quote—about the scarcity of transitional forms (the ‘in-between kinds’ anticipated by evolution) in the fossil record—that one anticreationist took it upon himself to ‘right the creationists’ wrongs’. He wrote what was intended to be a major essay showing how we had ‘misquoted’ Dr Patterson.1 This accusation still appears occasionally in anticreationist circles, so it is worth revisiting in some detail.

Dr Patterson had written a book for the British Museum simply called Evolution.2 Creationist Luther Sunderland wrote to Dr Patterson inquiring why he had not shown one single photograph of a transitional fossil in his book. Patterson then wrote back with the following amazing confession which was reproduced, in its entirety, in Sunderland’s book Darwin’s Enigma:

‘I fully agree with your comments on the lack of direct illustration of evolutionary transitions in my book. If I knew of any, fossil or living, I would certainly have included them. You suggest that an artist should be used to visualise such transformations, but where would he get the information from? I could not, honestly, provide it, and if I were to leave it to artistic licence, would that not mislead the reader?’

He went on to say:

‘Yet Gould [Stephen J. Gould—the now deceased professor of paleontology from Harvard University] and the American Museum people are hard to contradict when they say there are no transitional fossils. … You say that I should at least “show a photo of the fossil from which each type of organism was derived.” I will lay it on the line—there is not one such fossil for which one could make a watertight argument.’3 [Emphasis added].

http://creation.com/that-quote-about-the-missing-transitional-fossils

And

The fossil record reflects the original diversity of life, not an evolving tree of increasing complexity. There are many examples of "living fossils," where the species is alive today and found deep in the fossil record as well.

According to evolution models for the fossil record, there are three predictions:

1. wholesale change of organisms through time
2. primitive organisms gave rise to complex organisms
3. gradual derivation of new organisms produced transitional forms.

However, these predictions are not borne out by the data from the fossil record.

Trilobites, for instance, appear suddenly in the fossil record without any transitions. There are no fossils between simple single-cell organisms, such as bacteria, and complex invertebrates, such as trilobites.

Extinct trilobites had as much organized complexity as any of today’s invertebrates. In addition to trilobites, billions of other fossils have been found that suddenly appear, fully formed, such as clams, snails, sponges, and jellyfish. Over 300 different body plans are found without any fossil transitions between them and single-cell organisms.

Fish have no ancestors or transitional forms to show how invertebrates, with their skeletons on the outside, became vertebrates with their skeletons inside.

Fossils of a wide variety of flying and crawling insects appear without any transitions. Dragonflies, for example, appear suddenly in the fossil record. The highly complex systems that enable the dragonfly's aerodynamic abilities have no ancestors in the fossil record.

In the entire fossil record, there is not a single unequivocal transition form proving a causal relationship between any two species. From the billions of fossils we have discovered, there should be thousands of clear examples if they existed.

The lack of transitions between species in the fossil record is what would be expected if life was created.

http://www.icr.org/fossils-stasis/

But then a new question arises. How complete is the fossil record? Can we legitimately expect to find these transitions?

Dr. Michael Denton, an agnostic but a decided non-evolutionist compiled a chart on "The Adequacy of the Fossil Record" in his book, Evolution: A Theory In Crisis, by comparing the number of living types to fossil types, gleaning information from Romer's classic book, Vertebrate Paleontology. He found that 97.7% of living orders of terrestrial vertebrates are found as fossils. (Orders are larger groupings of families which are larger than genera which are larger then species.) Many creationists consider the groupings family or genus to best approximates the Genesis kind. Of living families of terrestrial vertebrates, 79.1% are represented, a number which jumps to 87.8% if birds (hardly ever preserved) are excluded. Thus, the fossil record of even terrestrial vertebrates is seen to be remarkably complete.

But far less than 1% of all fossils are terrestrial vertebrates. Approximately 95% are marine invertebrates, with the rest being mostly plants, fish, and insects. Land fossils are notoriously scarce, and when found are usually fragmentary. With partial evidence an evolutionary story can sometimes be told.

When we look at the invertebrates, we see separate and distinct categories (i.e., clams, corals, trilobites, etc.) existing in the earliest strata with no hint of ancestors or of intermediates. We find clams by the trillions, with a lot of variety among them, but no evolution. Furthermore, we have no idea how vertebrate fish could have arisen from any invertebrate. Where there are good data, we see no evolution. Where the data are scanty, evolutionists can tell a story. The fossil record is voluminous and apparently substantially complete. Yet no evolution is seen.

Speaking of this issue, Darwin wrote in an 1881 letter that "the case at present must remain inexplicable and may be truly argued as a valid argument against the views here entertained." Evolution—a theory of change without any evidence of change.

http://www.icr.org/article/should-we-expect-find-transitional-forms-fossil-re/
 
You could start by reading and understanding the following articles:
lots of interesting stuff there about combining, re-configuring and losing existing information, but I missed the bit about the creation of new information. Seeing as you have a degree in evolution, can you dumb it down for me?
 
Back
Top