• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Todor Petrov

Finally, up until now you were making excuses for them, implying they were not aware of what the ventilator is. Lets see what you have further below.

Where do I “discount” Macedonian children as not being important to Macedonia’s future? Can you cite it? Or is that just another presumption?

Your constant use of 'adult Macedonians' shows you are making separations between the Macedonian people. Why is this necessary? Is this because only 'adult Macedonians' seem to be fully informed of the implications of the ventilator as you like to argue? Most likely yes, because such logic would not apply to the 'young Macedonians' who didn't have first hand experience of the IA being implemented. Sure they are witnesses to the after-effects, but are they well and truly informed of such an issue?

What of them? Are you now going to claim that they are mentally retarded? Are you now going to claim that children that grow up in Macedonia since the ventilator will not know what it is?

What does being mentally retarded have to do with anything? If they haven't been educated then how can you expect them to know? I'm confident that many are informed but you continue to insist that 'adult' Macedonians are fully aware of the Interim Accord. I'll use one of my 'famous presumptions' and assume that such awareness arises from the fact that these people were alive when the drastic and criminal change occurred. So I'll ask again, what of the 'young' Macedonians? If the country is currently held hostage by a 'slave mentality,' do you expect all these 'kids' to be educated thoroughly without a first-hand experience?

Where have I applied a blanket label of ‘traitor’ anywhere? Can you cite it? Or is this yet another presumption?

You seem to be an expert of presumptions, so I'm sure your capable of answering such questions. I'm confident in your ability to interpret your own posts, let alone mine.

Are you saying that no one can have an understanding of what has happened before they are born? Are you saying that we can only know what has happened within living memory? This may be the case with you, but you should not presume that everybody else has been living in a cave.

Yes, unless they are actively educated. I wasn't alive to see Hawthorn win the 91 premiership, but can you guess how I learnt that such an event took place. Surprisingly I was informed. But if someone came up to me as a kid and said "Your not a true supporter because you have no idea what happened in 1991 to the football club," I'd not only be confused, but also very discouraged. That highlights your forceful approach. my cave has a bookshelf full of educational books, does yours?
I’ve made this very clear. But seeing as you insist to be treated as an adult, I will begin to hold you to the same standard.

Is this another presumption? Who was calling for children to be treated as morally culpable and who was arguing that only adults should be placed in that category?

Suit yourself. Are you going off on that tangent of yours?

Which Macedonians? Those living in the republic? I think you will find that they have a much better understanding of what the ventilator is than you give them credit for. But again, weren’t you just saying that they can think independently? Why would you contradict yourself (again) by implying they need to be ‘educated’?

Well obviously they aren't in the right state of mind in regards to acting against capitulation. They may be informed, but reinforcing such knowledge is far more powerful than forcing them to agree with you, or risk being labelled as acting against the Macedonian cause. How can you expect the new generation of Macedonians to act independently if they aren't provided with the appropriate tools to do so. United MKD's post in the other thread shows that there is either little knowledge and/or little concern amongst 'younger' Macedonians. So should we encourage them to fight for their rights, or should we criticise them and attack them for their passiveness and inability to act or acknowledge the detrimental effects of the ventilator?

Yet another presumption! I have only commented on the views that you have provided on this forum. Nothing else. If you feel that I have ‘hit the nail on the head’ in relation to you more broadly, then perhaps that’s something for you to consider.

Presumptions hey...that's why you assume I won't be taken seriously in real life, that's why you assume I act as a kid, that's why you assume I am ideologically flawed. Please stop using this excuse, for it makes you look like an absolute hypocrite and ultimately detracts from your arguments.

Again, you should try to read my posts carefully. My comment was in relation to being taken seriously in Macedonian affairs, not “real life”. But the remedies I have suggested would help you more broadly as well.

You stated that you are under 18 years old. You are a kid.

That was not directed at you personally.

Another presumption! You seem entirely comfortable with dishing out presumptions yet can't handle them yourself. Your attitude of trying to prove yourself as some how 'superior' reminds me of a kid, something reserved for primary school.

The children in Africa are completely irrelevant, but they have a much better grasp of what freedom is than most Macedonians. As for my charitable donations and how much I have donated over my lifetime, that is quite frankly none of your business. I thought you wanted to be treated like an adult? You should start acting like one and not prying into the personal finances of others.

Well, if you read my post clearly you would realise I never asked about your charitable donations or personal finances, and to be honest I don't really care about your generous acts of humanity. Stop trying to find attacks which do not exist, it only acts as further proof of your extremely negative attitude. (sorry, another presumption!!:44:)

Yes you are. You claim they need to be educated. That implies that they are not responsible for themselves and the circumstances that they are now in because they are somehow unaware of their decisions/actions and/or the meaning of their decisions/actions.
Your point? Some would be unaware of their decisions and actions, and they need to be educated appropriately. You cannot generalise all Macedonians as being 'informed,' because that is an absolute overstatement to be frank.

You’re basing your entire view on a false premise.

Is that so? Care to explain why? Already a few people have shared and acknowledged the approach I propose, so unless your prepared to dismiss any view other than your own, it cannot be categorised as a false premise. However that seems to be the case, so I'll leave you to bathe in your golden shower of self righteousness.

Emotionalism is what plays a big part in this issue so it must be noted. I am afraid people are now emotionally attached to the current flag and negativity towards it would offend many people emotionally.

Ok, the changing of the original Macedonian flag was forced on us, the Macedonian government shit them selves and changed it which was weak, but, is it possible to find anything good about the fact that the current flag was designed and chosen by a Macedonian? if Greece said "here, use this flag for now on" that would be a whole different story. I think the issue with the flag has caused alot of unnecessary division amongst Macedonians which non-Macedonians would find amusing all at the same time we are arguing.

Exactly. Such an important stakeholder in the issues that face Macedonia cannot be ignored. Emotionalism exists, and if the likes of Vangelovski do not see this factor as influencing their approach, then their results will be short-lived. Even if emotionalism hinders ones ability to think and act clearly, it exists, and therefore must be dealt with appropriately.

It certainly has created a lot of unnecessary division between individuals who share identical goals, yet different methods of approach. A hybrid of these methods would likely be the most successful, however unfortunately some individuals are too stubborn to acknowledge the ideas and proposals of others as valid.
 
Last edited:
Makedonin, if we have no emotions we would be dead.
Agreed.
If the new flag adoption represents a logical departure from sovereignty, I am against it. I can get emotional when it occurs to me that other people do not value sovereignty as highly as me.
I am against it too, although I don't need for it to be called "logical" and than to be against it.

The thing is that this "logical" argument is only facade of the same reason I reject it, and this is exactly the same that you mentioned further down:
We must look at the nature of the original event which compelled Macedonia to give up one of its own symbols.
That in it self is the core of the whole emotion (meaning literally to be in-motion) and this emotion is the fuel to the so called "logical" argument.
The name "logical" is dry word to clothe the initial animalistic emotion as something more superior than it is. And the reason for the masquerade is to give the user of this facade the appearance of knowledgeable, therefore he must be the authority on the field, therefore others must follow.

But what kind of emotion is this all about? Isn't it that the initial event make us realize what we all hate, that being, we are not in control? It is the feeling uncertainty of being dependent and not able to take care of your own needs? Of course it is, and that is why we all struggle to have control. You can call it sovereignty or what ever, but basically we don't like the idea of not being in control and live in uncertainty .

Therefore, what we do is the most easiest and most common human response to this kind of challenge, that is being aggressive about it, to project the appearance that we are still in charge and in control.

That is what was happening here the past few months, and will continue happening.

Now comes the tricky part.

People tend to pursue things that give them pleasure and gratification, things that are palatable to them, things that are actual and acute to their perception.
This are all sorts of things from daily life.
Humans also tend to blend out everything that is inconvenient and not actual to their daily needs.

Those in Macedonia for example have blended out the whole incident long time ago, it is not present in their daily life.
What happens, is that they don't really care for what the diaspora says. Actually they don't even see it, much less they remember the event that causes you all those emotions.

And they will be emotional when you try to bring the snow from last year into their daily life and focus. They will try to avoid it by all means because it brings inconvenience to them, the initial reason why they blended it out at the first place, all under the pretext "we can't do anything about it". Than if you press them to bother with it they will most probably become aggressive about it.
You can get emotional and aggressive about their reaction, call them all sorts of things and than they will get more aggressive about your reaction, and hoopla, there is the same old circle made so obvious here.

By this time, communication has already ceased.

And than you think that you have the blue print and the "logical" construct and try to reduce them to a PC processor by expecting them to follow instructions and adopt your rhetoric, and than black mail them with the condition of your acceptance of their persona, or even worse, you indicate that they will lose the right to be Macedonians, at least not so great as you are! And they will go along the lines "who the fuck is this guy to tell me what I should or should not do?" and so on and so on.

Congratulation, you have managed to become their number one enemy, and instead of winning them over to support the whole initial cause, the whole emotionalism bounced us up into whole different direction.

Why? Because everyone wants to be in control, therefore wants to have the big say, not to follow, that being when ever one see it is possible, by all means.

Because it is basic fear that by backing off and accepting the opponents stand point, you understand that you are 'standing under' the law of restriction and are not master of your environment, which in turn means you are not in control, therefore you get aggressive again. People will only than back off, when they think the opponent is way powerful than they are. Basic animalistic drive.

It is the great circle of life and daily relationship of humans.

So do with this what you will, you either understand or get angry with me.

Macedonians have not torn themselves apart due to this issue.
Well I have witnessed different picture here.
Unless you can show me how this issue has caused division in Macedonia, I would say your negativity on this revolution of the mind is not helping Macedonia.
But by reducing it only to Macedonia, you can claim that I don't have a point and am negative about what ever you think you have on going here.

It is your right to think so.

I decide to step out of that circle, and am not going to reduce my self to your measuring standards.

If you really think that this was my intention, Vangel can give you crash course how to delete posts and close threads that are not palatable for your taste.

And just a friendly advice, use it as you please.

This word "revolution" won't bring the result you like to see.

It is not palatable for most of the people, because it implies change, which means leaving that which is known, and that breaths unconscious fear. Therefore it is a bad marketing for the product you want to sell.

But do with it what you please, I don't care.
Why is it senseless? Because there are some people who aren't willing to compromise on their integrity? Or because some people still haven't grasped what the ventilator represents in terms of our capitulation?
Neither of your reasons.

It appears senseless to me, because it is lacking sensitivity and understanding of each party involved in it, therefore fails to achieve the purpose of gathering all Macedonians under one umbrella.

Of course you can and most probably will disagree with that, and it is your right to do so.

So carry on with it and ignore my comments, or better yet, delete it as inappropriate.

No, its not. The drive against the ventilator is a rational drive seeking to restore our national sovereignty, it has nothing to do with the flag itself.

Still in denial of your human nature Mr. Spock? You can masquarade it as you please, at the end of the day it is all the same thing, only different package.
 
Last edited:
EM,

You're starting to contradict yourself quite drastically. Maybe its time to restate what exactly your point is before you confuse yourself even further.

One thing I do want you to do is cite where I have used a blanket label of 'traitor'? Or are you now resorting to lies?
 
Makedonin,

You are a useless waste of space. What brought you back? Did they get sick of your BS on the other forums? Did you try and convince them that the correct spelling of Macedonia in Macedonian is "Маќедониа" or "Мќедониа?
 
Makedonin,
You are a useless waste of space.
You know what to do about it, don't you? You have performed good job previously.

What brought you back?
Never was away anyways! I was even asked why I don't participate. So I thought I might drop a line or two. But not too much, we don't want to ruin MTO financially, don't we? Web space is costly thing.
Did they get sick of your BS on the other forums?
Whats up, could not be more creative than that? I see you still fart along the lines.
Did you try and convince them that the correct spelling of Macedonia in Macedonian is "Маќедониа" or "Мќедониа?

Still lacking of real arguments I see. Androids don't have the potential to change their programming, I understand.

OK, it is enough. Too many bytes may short circuit your poor processor, and you are waste of time and energy anyways.
 
Last edited:
Great to see you back in action Makedonin!
How have you been?
Dobro doijde! :macedonia

PS. the Androids are taking over the market :)
 
Great to see you back in action Makedonin!
How have you been?
Dobro doijde! :macedonia

Zdravo Daskale,

been doing great, family, work and enjoyed real life, you know stuff like that.

Hope everything is the best with you.
PS. the Androids are taking over the market :)

Yep, they are good for given purposes (I mean the real androids, not the wannabe above), but don't rely on their GPS ;) Most probably you will fail to reach your goal for at least few miles. I have experienced it first hand, trust me it ain't good.
Pozdrav :macedonia
 
Last edited:
Makedonin,

I know you're desperate to go through all your usual excuses as to why we should accept the ventilator, so you might as well start (again). Then you can crawl back into your hole..or other forums until they give you a good slapping and you finally come back here again, just to do the same old.
 
Agreed.

I am against it too, although I don't need for it to be called "logical" and than to be against it.

The thing is that this "logical" argument is only facade of the same reason I reject it, and this is exactly the same that you mentioned further down:

That in it self is the core of the whole emotion (meaning literally to be in-motion) and this emotion is the fuel to the so called "logical" argument.
The name "logical" is dry word to clothe the initial animalistic emotion as something more superior than it is. And the reason for the masquerade is to give the user of this facade the appearance of knowledgeable, therefore he must be the authority on the field, therefore others must follow.

But what kind of emotion is this all about? Isn't it that the initial event make us realize what we all hate, that being, we are not in control? It is the feeling uncertainty of being dependent and not able to take care of your own needs? Of course it is, and that is why we all struggle to have control. You can call it sovereignty or what ever, but basically we don't like the idea of not being in control and live in uncertainty .

Therefore, what we do is the most easiest and most common human response to this kind of challenge, that is being aggressive about it, to project the appearance that we are still in charge and in control.

That is what was happening here the past few months, and will continue happening.

Now comes the tricky part.

People tend to pursue things that give them pleasure and gratification, things that are palatable to them, things that are actual and acute to their perception.
This are all sorts of things from daily life.
Humans also tend to blend out everything that is inconvenient and not actual to their daily needs.

Those in Macedonia for example have blended out the whole incident long time ago, it is not present in their daily life.
What happens, is that they don't really care for what the diaspora says. Actually they don't even see it, much less they remember the event that causes you all those emotions.

And they will be emotional when you try to bring the snow from last year into their daily life and focus. They will try to avoid it by all means because it brings inconvenience to them, the initial reason why they blended it out at the first place, all under the pretext "we can't do anything about it". Than if you press them to bother with it they will most probably become aggressive about it.
You can get emotional and aggressive about their reaction, call them all sorts of things and than they will get more aggressive about your reaction, and hoopla, there is the same old circle made so obvious here.

By this time, communication has already ceased.

And than you think that you have the blue print and the "logical" construct and try to reduce them to a PC processor by expecting them to follow instructions and adopt your rhetoric, and than black mail them with the condition of your acceptance of their persona, or even worse, you indicate that they will lose the right to be Macedonians, at least not so great as you are! And they will go along the lines "who the fuck is this guy to tell me what I should or should not do?" and so on and so on.

Congratulation, you have managed to become their number one enemy, and instead of winning them over to support the whole initial cause, the whole emotionalism bounced us up into whole different direction.

Why? Because everyone wants to be in control, therefore wants to have the big say, not to follow, that being when ever one see it is possible, by all means.

Because it is basic fear that by backing off and accepting the opponents stand point, you understand that you are 'standing under' the law of restriction and are not master of your environment, which in turn means you are not in control, therefore you get aggressive again. People will only than back off, when they think the opponent is way powerful than they are. Basic animalistic drive.

It is the great circle of life and daily relationship of humans.

So do with this what you will, you either understand or get angry with me.


Well I have witnessed different picture here.

But by reducing it only to Macedonia, you can claim that I don't have a point and am negative about what ever you think you have on going here.

It is your right to think so.

I decide to step out of that circle, and am not going to reduce my self to your measuring standards.

If you really think that this was my intention, Vangel can give you crash course how to delete posts and close threads that are not palatable for your taste.

And just a friendly advice, use it as you please.

This word "revolution" won't bring the result you like to see.

It is not palatable for most of the people, because it implies change, which means leaving that which is known, and that breaths unconscious fear. Therefore it is a bad marketing for the product you want to sell.

But do with it what you please, I don't care.

Neither of your reasons.

It appears senseless to me, because it is lacking sensitivity and understanding of each party involved in it, therefore fails to achieve the purpose of gathering all Macedonians under one umbrella.

Of course you can and most probably will disagree with that, and it is your right to do so.

So carry on with it and ignore my comments, or better yet, delete it as inappropriate.



Still in denial of your human nature Mr. Spock? You can masquarade it as you please, at the end of the day it is all the same thing, only different package.

Great post! really delves into the core issues and approaches in regards to the issues at hand. I couldn't have put it in better words, and if people still do not recognise or understand this point of view, I don't know what can possibly make it any clearer.

EM,

You're starting to contradict yourself quite drastically. Maybe its time to restate what exactly your point is before you confuse yourself even further.

One thing I do want you to do is cite where I have used a blanket label of 'traitor'? Or are you now resorting to lies?

I'm not sure whether you don't have the time to respond properly or simply cannot be bothered. Are you out of excuses for denying any other views other than your own?

It does not look upon you favourably when I spend my time to reply in detail, and in reply you throw around some half-arsed questions that have already been debated over and over again.

Makedonin,

You are a useless waste of space. What brought you back? Did they get sick of your BS on the other forums? Did you try and convince them that the correct spelling of Macedonia in Macedonian is "Маќедониа" or "Мќедониа?

This is the kind of bullshit I'm talking about. "What brought you back?" The words of an individual who will definitely get all Macedonians on his side. His reply was well constructed and thought through, and in reply you ask him 'why he is here.' Very poor attitude, and if you expect to adopt the same principle for heightening the Macedonian cause, I'll wish you luck in advance.
 
I'm not sure whether you don't have the time to respond properly or simply cannot be bothered.
A bit of both. But mostly because you are starting to contradict yourself and the point you are trying to make has ceased to be obvious.

It does not look upon you favourably when I spend my time to reply in detail, and in reply you throw around some half-arsed questions that have already been debated over and over again.
Show me exactly where I have used a blanket 'traitor' label or I will begin calling you a liar on top of a kid (who has potential but still needs time to ripen).

This is the kind of bullshit I'm talking about. "What brought you back?" The words of an individual who will definitely get all Macedonians on his side. His reply was well constructed and thought through, and in reply you ask him 'why he is here.' Very poor attitude, and if you expect to adopt the same principle for heightening the Macedonian cause, I'll wish you luck in advance.
You should familiarise yourself with who Makedonin is and what views he holds before you back the wrong horse. This is one of the pieces of advice I provided you with earlier, but it seems that you continue to ignore it.

P.S. If it is not bleeding obvious to you yet, I'm not interested in getting ALL Macedonians on "my side". That is neither possible nor desirable. Do you need me to spoon feed you the reasons why or are you able to think that through independently?
 
A bit of both. But mostly because you are starting to contradict yourself and the point you are trying to make has ceased to be obvious.

I guess your exempt from this then.

Show me exactly where I have used a blanket 'traitor' label or I will begin calling you a liar on top of a kid (who has potential but still needs time to ripen).

You have stated multiple times that those who embrace the ventilator would essentially be actively working against the Macedonian cause. Such a confident statement shows they do not appreciate the values or history of Macedonia, and thus do not care about the nation or the people. From my interpretation, this is essentially calling them traitors to their own people. Perhaps a hyberbole in some senses, but very relevant to your perceived stance on those who may have differing views to you in this regard.

Maybe I'm a fruit that's ripe all year around. :001_smile:

You should familiarise yourself with who Makedonin is and what views he holds before you back the wrong horse. This is one of the pieces of advice I provided you with earlier, but it seems that you continue to ignore it.

No, I prefer to judge on his current position and his post in isolation. I agreed with his views, and thus have every right to back his ideas. If we continuely judged on peoples past mishaps, then this world would cease to be productive. For example, if he happened to kill someone, hypothetically, despite being against the values of society, it should have no bearing on how I perceive him on this particular issue in isolation. If we held grudges with everyone who has ever shared a differing view to us, then it is almost certain we'd all be alone and enemies of one another.

P.S. If it is not bleeding obvious to you yet, I'm not interested in getting ALL Macedonians on "my side". That is neither possible nor desirable. Do you need me to spoon feed you the reasons why or are you able to think that through independently?

How many Macedonians do you realistically want to 'convert' to your side? How many would allow us to achieve the goals outlined in the Macedonian cause? Certainly a majority.
 
Last edited:
Makedonin,
I know you're desperate to go through all your usual excuses as to why we should accept the ventilator, so you might as well start (again).
Sorry Vangel but you are the apologist. I don't make any excuse about anything.

Unlikely you, I go and try make sense and understand the complexity and work around so that Macedonians start to communicate instead of just revolving around in some emotional circle of aggression and offense.

But you could not understand such thing, it is not your capacity anyway.
Then you can crawl back into your hole..or other forums until they give you a good slapping and you finally come back here again, just to do the same old.

I think you are really handicapped when it comes to communication :) All you can do is go around in circles and attempts to provoke people, because you basically feel threatened by every thought that goes out of your usual narrow line.

I am beginning to pity you.
 
You have stated multiple times that those who embrace the ventilator would essentially be actively working against the Macedonian cause. Such a confident statement shows they do not appreciate the values or history of Macedonia, and thus do not care about the nation or the people. From my interpretation, this is essentially calling them traitors to their own people. Perhaps a hyberbole in some senses, but very relevant to your perceived stance on those who may have differing views to you in this regard.
Can you cite a blanket use of traitor or not?

Wasn't it you that was claiming that they need to be "educated"? Now you are suggesting that they are aware of the "values" and "history" of Macedonia!?

No, I prefer to judge on his current position and his post in isolation. I agreed with his views, and thus have every right to back his ideas. If we continuely judged on peoples past mishaps, then this world would cease to be productive. For example, if he happened to kill someone, hypothetically, despite being against the values of society, it should have no baring on how I perceive him on this particular issue in isolation. If we held grudges with everyone who has ever shared a differing view to us, then it is almost certain we'd all be alone and enemies of one another.
Wait for a few more posts, he'll let loose soon. Or will you then judge him in isolation again, five minutes later?

How many Macedonians do you realistically want to 'convert' to your side? How many would allow us to achieve the goals outlined in the Macedonian cause? Certainly a majority.
A majority is not ALL Macedonians.
 
Sorry Vangel but you are the apologist. I don't make any excuse about anything.

Unlikely you, I go and try make sense and understand the complexity and work around so that Macedonians start to communicate instead of just revolving around in some emotional circle of aggression and offense.

But you could not understand such thing, it is not your capacity anyway.

I think you are really handicapped when it comes to communication :) All you can do is go around in circles and attempts to provoke people, because you basically feel threatened by every thought that goes out of your usual narrow line.

I am beginning to pity you.
Makedonin, how's your mate's promotion of the ventilator campaign going?
 
I have no clue where are you trying to get with this. Who is this mate, and what campaign?

I have got this hunch you are getting confused again!
No, you're the one that has selective memory. Eddie Rebel and his use of the ventilator to "promote" Macedonia. Surely you remember that, that is where you spent nearly 30 pages defending the use of the ventilator and then trying to convince us that Македонија is really spelt Маќедониа or just plain Мќедониа, all the while claiming that one cannot be a "real" Macedonian unless they speak Macedonian!
 
No, you're the one that has selective memory. Eddie Rebel and his use of the ventilator to "promote" Macedonia. Surely you remember that, that is where you spent nearly 30 pages defending the use of the ventilator and then trying to convince us that Македонија is really spelt Маќедониа or just plain Мќедона, all the while claiming that one cannot be a "real" Macedonian unless they speak Macedonian!

I guess the Bozo is waiting for you Vangel. You are jumping around like one already.

Eddie Rebel is not a friend of mine, I happened to support his initiative and his proposal to send the petition with out the Ventilator(by the way will support it any time when needed), or tried to make it obvious to the others why people cling to the Ventilator, but that does not make him my friend, only Macedonian compatriot. And I will say Маќедониа anytime I like, because I speak my own dialect. You can clap that all you like, you only show that you lack any real argument.

Of course you can try to put the twist of your finger on the whole issue, but thanks God, your opinion is worth next to nothing. Laughing stock, that is what you are becoming.

I guess I better stop replying to your petty provocations and spare MTO some money.
 
Last edited:
I guess the Bozo is waiting for you Vangel. You are jumping around like one already.

Eddie Rebel is not a friend of mine, I happened to support his initiative and his proposal to send the petition with out the Ventilator, or tried to make it obvious to the others why people cling to the Ventilator, but that does not make him my friend, only Macedonian compatriot.

Of course you can try to put the twist of your finger on the whole issue, but thanks God, your opinion is worth next to nothing.

I guess I better stop replying to your petty provocations and spare MTO some money.
I think you are lying Makedonin..you see, contrary to your previous lie (that we delete posts), we actually keep them all. Anyone can go into that thread and read the multiple posts from you, with all of your multiple excuses for the ventilator.

Further, it was fairly obvious from that thread that you and Eddie are much more than just "compatriots"...
 
Can you cite a blanket use of traitor or not?

There are plenty of examples where you imply such a point, it does not need to be said word for word to be implied.

Are they helping the cause of Macedonian freedom? No, they're not. Every time they use the ventilator, its another nail in the coffin of Macedonian freedom because it is an act of obedience to an oppressor. Patriots who work for freedom do not obey oppressors, they resist them.

Since you enjoy comprehending information word for word, let's have a look at this statement of yours briefly. If they are hammering another nail in the coffin of Macedonian freedom due to their actions, that is essentially implying a traitor, in a more subtle approach. Why would a person bury the values of their own nation, isn't this working against the Macedonian cause as you suggest?

I could provide several instances where you have used phrases of a similar nature, but since you avoid my questions and 'can't be bothered,' then I don't see why I should have to.

Wasn't it you that was claiming that they need to be "educated"? Now you are suggesting that they are aware of the "values" and "history" of Macedonia!?

Wait for a few more posts, he'll let loose soon. Or will you then judge him in isolation again, five minutes later?

A majority is not ALL Macedonians.

This probably explains your inability to extract ones views from a post. You bolded the first five words in my sentence so I'm surprised that you fail to recognise that this is my perceived belief of YOUR views. Your confidence in your posts is definitely admirable, yet I worry that it is adding to your stubbornness and issuing you a thicker pair of blinkers every time this discussion seemingly persists in the right direction.

So your not even going to attempt to convince all Macedonians in the first place? Have you already established specific targets?

The crap attitude you direct at a number of forum members ensures that there won't be a 'few more posts.' So on your behalf, no need to worry there.
 
Last edited:
I am against it too, although I don't need for it to be called "logical" and than to be against it.
If someone forces me to abandon something I love and replace it with something else .... logically I would be mental if I embrace the new thing and don't fight for what I have had taken away from me. Why make excuses for such a piss weak perspective? It is absolutely logical that the replacement cannot be more significant than what what was given up in the first instance.


But what kind of emotion is this all about? Isn't it that the initial event make us realize what we all hate, that being, we are not in control? It is the feeling uncertainty of being dependent and not able to take care of your own needs? Of course it is, and that is why we all struggle to have control. You can call it sovereignty or what ever, but basically we don't like the idea of not being in control and live in uncertainty .

Therefore, what we do is the most easiest and most common human response to this kind of challenge, that is being aggressive about it, to project the appearance that we are still in charge and in control.
Well done. You have solved all the world's problems Makedonin. No more wars and world peace and harmony. How much are you realistically prepared to lose with your frame of mind? No point getting angry about losing Macedonia as the homeland of Macedonians either. What is so bad about learning another language like Albanian. It would be great to learn another language. All is good.

People tend to pursue things that give them pleasure and gratification, things that are palatable to them, things that are actual and acute to their perception.
This are all sorts of things from daily life.
Humans also tend to blend out everything that is inconvenient and not actual to their daily needs.

Those in Macedonia for example have blended out the whole incident long time ago, it is not present in their daily life.
What happens, is that they don't really care for what the diaspora says. Actually they don't even see it, much less they remember the event that causes you all those emotions.

And they will be emotional when you try to bring the snow from last year into their daily life and focus. They will try to avoid it by all means because it brings inconvenience to them, the initial reason why they blended it out at the first place, all under the pretext "we can't do anything about it". Than if you press them to bother with it they will most probably become aggressive about it.
You can get emotional and aggressive about their reaction, call them all sorts of things and than they will get more aggressive about your reaction, and hoopla, there is the same old circle made so obvious here.

By this time, communication has already ceased.

And than you think that you have the blue print and the "logical" construct and try to reduce them to a PC processor by expecting them to follow instructions and adopt your rhetoric, and than black mail them with the condition of your acceptance of their persona, or even worse, you indicate that they will lose the right to be Macedonians, at least not so great as you are! And they will go along the lines "who the fuck is this guy to tell me what I should or should not do?" and so on and so on.

Congratulation, you have managed to become their number one enemy, and instead of winning them over to support the whole initial cause, the whole emotionalism bounced us up into whole different direction.

Why? Because everyone wants to be in control, therefore wants to have the big say, not to follow, that being when ever one see it is possible, by all means.

Because it is basic fear that by backing off and accepting the opponents stand point, you understand that you are 'standing under' the law of restriction and are not master of your environment, which in turn means you are not in control, therefore you get aggressive again. People will only than back off, when they think the opponent is way powerful than they are. Basic animalistic drive.

It is the great circle of life and daily relationship of humans.

So do with this what you will, you either understand or get angry with me.
No, you have a point. What you are saying is the Diaspora is useless and there is no point whatsoever in reminding Macedonians in Macedonia about what they continue to give up. They are doing so well without us anyway .... can you speak Albanian Makedonin?



But by reducing it only to Macedonia, you can claim that I don't have a point and am negative about what ever you think you have on going here.
Why would I extend it beyond Macedonia?

This word "revolution" won't bring the result you like to see.

It is not palatable for most of the people, because it implies change, which means leaving that which is known, and that breaths unconscious fear. Therefore it is a bad marketing for the product you want to sell.

But do with it what you please, I don't care.
The idea of revolution worked for a while in Delcev's era. Macedonians used to be quite fierce once upon a time. But I get your point, you don't want to upset anyone in Macedonia and hope that through a process of gentle coaxing that somehow the Macedonians will gently move towards something better. Nobody knows what your version of "better" will be because you won't be telling anyone. It might upset them.

Actually, you seem to know the Macedonian psyche very well. You should then accept that the status quo will only end up causing further erosion to Macedonia's sovereignty.

We are all allowed to have opinions. My opinion is that I don't want any maggots destroying the Macedonian identity. Right now there are way too many enemies of Macedonia who live in Macedonia. Much more than anywhere else.

Sometimes I just think that everyone is feeling bitter about how hapless and spineless Macedonians really are and argue amongst themselves because of this anger. Other times I just think there are hapless and spineless Macedonians.
 
Back
Top