I was thinking if I should reply and waste my time once more, but hey I could not let it go, not yet.
I have the same view but there is a need for clarification and thus I will answer, or point out, what I think needs to be said and you can go scratch your head if you don't like that!
The following is the core issue regarding the flag and how it was imposed:
They signed under duress (as well as stupidity), it is not enforceable.
I doubt that there was ANY DURESS for SDSM but rather it was their PLAN and COMMITMENT to their "IC" backers for turning a blind eye to (and ENDOREMENT of) all the electoral FRAUD in the RIGGED 1994 elections. What was the benefit for SDSM, one might ask? I would answer that one should imagine a morally and politically corrupt regime having total political control of a state in the early stages of economic transition from a socialist economy to a capitalist one, where privatisation of all the state and commonly owned assets is about to go full-throttle mode.
Monument to Crvenkovski's (corruption) achievments - Oktopod!
19.10.94
Do
Pretsedatelot na Sobranieto na Republika Makedonija
Поради масовното и драстично кршење на изборната постапка и директната инволвиараност на државата во многубројните извршени повреди на законите и процедурата, кои што се образложени во приговорите на кандидатите за пратеници и во приговорите на Демократската партија и ВМРО-ДПМНЕ.
БАРАМЕ
1. Поништување на Изборите `94;
2. Обезбедување на сите потребни услови за одржување на законски и фер избори;
3. Оставка на Владата и формирање на чиновничка Влада, која ќе спроведе регуларни избори;
4. Оставка на Државната изборна комисија;
5. Одвојување на претседателските од парламентарните избори.
Доколку овие барања не бидат исполнети до 22 Октомври (сабота), до 19 часот, не гледаме причина за наше учество на вториот круг на Изборите `94.
ВМРО – Демократска партија за
македонско национално единство
Претседател
Љупчо Георгиевски
Демократска партија (ДА)
Претседател
Петар Гошев
факсимил копија на оргиналниот документ во формат на слика (image file) тука
Za Potsetuvanje - Razno
M., care to tell us if you were at least 18 years old and was interested in the politics of the day in 1994?
Main point that you have NOT, or have not wanted to be, addressed is THE FACT THAT the 1994 ELECTIONS WERE FRAUDULENT AND RIGGED and that SDSM + ALLIES RULED SOLO from 1994 to 1998! Thus, in the main, DPMNE and Democratic Party (led by Petar Goshev) members and supporters saw that "Government" as ILLIGITAMATE and they numbered in the tens and hundreds of thousands!!! They immediately collected over 150,000 signatures in support of a REFERENDUM calling for new elections and a technical provisional government to implement them. These calls were ignored and every element of the state machinery was used to undermine and suppress any effective opposition. At that time the VENTILATOR was opposed and denigrated by the DPMNE and DP supporters.
Therefore any political capitulations committed by this ILLEGITIMATE REGIME of 1994-1998 can RIGHTFULLY be claimed to be ILLEGAL and should be declared null and void.
----------
„Вентилаторот“ и грее и лади
А политичките околности беа повеќе од сложени. Знамето беше сменето две години по прифаќањето на референцата БЈРМ и само два дена по атентатот врз претседателот Киро Глигоров, кога целата јавност беше окупирана со тој немил настан. На 5 октомври 1995 година Собранието го изгласа новиот закон за знамето со консензус, но тоа беше парламентарен состав без опозиција, во кој членуваа само пратеници од тогашниот Сојуз за Македонија (СДСМ, Либерална партија и Социјалистичка партија) и претставници на Албанците во земјава. Притисокот за промена, секако, доаѓаше од Грција.
[...]
Тито Петковски е еден од тројцата пратеници што беа членови на Собранието и во 1995 година и денес.
Според него, треба сé уште да се работи, особено со младите генерации, за новото знаме да биде целосно прифатено.
- На јавните манифестации често се сретнува ѕвездата од Вергина, а најмногу ја користат млади луѓе. Нивните мотиви главно се националистички. Кога се промени знамето, тоа беше направено за да се покаже конструктивност кон јужниот сосед, за односите да ни станат попријателски. Затоа треба образовните установи, но и политичките партии, да поработат со своите подмладоци за ова прашање - додава Петковски.
Еден од ретките политичари што активно се залагаат за да се врати старото знаме е Тодор Петров, лидерот на Светскиот македонски конгрес, организација што најмногу комуницира со нашинците во светот.
- Речиси сите македонски организации во соседството и во далечните земји како свој симбол го користат 16-кракото сонце. Новото знаме не го признаваа ниту тогаш ниту денес. Има голем број иницијативи да се напуштат преговорите со Грција и да се укине Привремената спогодба, а со тоа и да се врати старото знаме - рече Петров.
Тој раскажува како тогашните политичари тврделе дека го трампаат знамето за меѓународното признавање на уставното име, но останале без двете.
[…]
Неодамна шпанскиот весник „20 минутос“ спроведе гласање за најубаво знаме, на кое победи Мексико, а Македонија никаде ја немаше. Од првите десет на тој список, дури осум се земји од шпанското говорно подрачје.
Автор: Гоце Трпковски Фотографија: Маја Јаневска - Илиева
------------
коментари
Македонче
Новото знаме не побудува никакви чуства во мене. Не го прифаќам, но едноставно е, не се бунам затоа што за тоа не е дојдено врeме . А Денот ќе дојде . За знамето од Кутлеш негувам уште посилни чуства затоа што е прво знаме со кое повторно ја изразивме слободата и независноста на Македонија . За мене ова знаме остана како наше државното знаме , иако привремено го променија пред неколку години . Од тие причини знамето од Кутлеш станува како знаме со кое историски државата Македонија и народот Македонски се самоидентификуваат во континиум .
строиник
Единствено македонското знаме со Златно-Жолта 16-зрачна Ѕвезда на Црвена основа ( "Сонцето од Кутлеш-Вергина"), e СИМ(В)БОЛ за слобода, континуитет, иднина, безвремена потврда за идентитетот на Македонецот. Тоа е моето знаме, тоа е знамето на Македонија и така ќе остане засекогаш. Сегашното пак "официјално" знаме, претставува сончев ЗНАК и такви знаци ги има на секаде низ светот, да, ги има и во Македонија, да, ние сме деца на светлината, поклоници на сончевината, но сепак тоа е САМО знак, претставен пред 15 години како знаме, усвоено ПОД ПРИТИСОК, не со СЛОБОДНА ВОЛЈА и ентузијазам како што го усвоивме Вечното ни знаме со 16-зрачната златно-жолта ѕвезда на црвена основа, кое како симбол го наоѓаме, не само во Кут-Леш, туку и во охридско, гевгелиско...на секаде низ Македонија....Има огромна разлика меѓу симб(в)ол и знак. Во симболот ја наоѓаме сопствената срж, си им-аме во-(и)-лја своја, сме ја пронашле нашата смисла на земјата во име на светлината. Симболот истакнува повеќе зборови, дела, слики, времиња, мистика ако сакете препознатлива за носителот на сим(в)болот..., додека знакот е менлив, разбирлив само во одредено време и дури и да опстои низ годините тој многу лесно може да го смени изворното значење. Па нели, сегашново "сонце", може да е и вентилатор, ветерница, развиен занк за нуклеарен отпад итн, итн....Македонија ќе ја зачне слободата, кога на скопската тврдина ќе се вее нашето знаме со 16-зрачна златно-жолта ѕвезда на црвена основа. Единствениот МАКЕДОНСКИ СИМБОЛ за сите времиња
Стеф
Вентилаторот е знаме на Македонија. А од друга страна го мразам зошто не е го осеќам како свое. Не ги сакам од СДСМ поради знаме и мал милион други причини. Јас би сакал да се смени знамето на Македонија ова не го сакам наметнато е со сила и вештачко е.
Jordan-Lerin
Ventilatorot nikogash nema da go prifatime kako nacionalno zname na Makedonskiot narod.
smislov
Ako Тито Петкостки е македонец и добро го владее својот мајцин македонски јазик, ке знае дека "ѕвездата од Вергина" е од Кутлеш.
ЗНАМЕТО ОД КУТЛЕШ
Симболот на сонцето е македонски од Македонија. Грција го поседува само 100 години. Секогаш со гордост ке го носам. Едноставно е симбол на Македонија. А Македонија не е грчка.
veta
nemase ocenka 0 pa zatoa stavivn 1 ovaa zname nikoj ne go saka ama go prfativme zatoa sto ni bese naredeno da ne se vrakame vo nasata anticka istoria,za da gi zadovolime grcite i nasite domasni kodosi ipredavnici.
http://novamakedonija.com.mk/NewsDetal.asp?vest=10510958239&id=9&prilog=0&setIzdanie=22100
For fair use only.
Previous extensive discussion at this thread: ventilator
http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=3315&page=2
-----------
The only thing that Macedonians with some basic self-respect are morally obliged to do is to reject the VENTILATOR because it represents national shame and capitulation. The same applies to the UCK constitution and "Ramkoven dogovor", the "Temporary Reference" and the "Interim Accord".
----------
First of all, I still see the Republic of Macedonia being existent. It may be not perfect, it may be not as we would wish it, and yet it prevailed. It is a starting point. But you are starting on the wrong end. As long as the people are disapointed and hungry, they won't bother with your Idealogy, however this may be good or perfect.
I don't know about that analysis? Was it not said that "seeds germinate best on rotten ground" and were the Macedonians better of economically during WWII and in 1903 when they rose up in arms? There is no need for anyone to starve in Macedonia as the country is capable of growing enough food to feed itself and then some more.
Compare Macedonia to Slovenia and Croatia and see who is better off and figure out why! As for the republic, it basically has its name for home use and even there it has been renamed from Macedonia/Makedonija to Republika Makedonija and the people to "Citizens" (Gragjani).
Secondly, Macedonia CEASED to be a MACEDONIAN NATIONAL STATE IN 2001 and anyone who thinks otherwise is in a SERIOUS DELUSIONAL STATE OF MIND.
Second, yes we were forced to change the Flag.
You did NOT answer WHY SDSM and allies voted for it in 1992 whilst and embargo was imposed. Why was this the case?
Once you figure this out, you might realise that we were not "forced to change the flag" at all but that it was part of a scheme to other ends! I STRONGLY SUGGEST YOU CHEW OVER THIS PUZZLE if you want to come to the "truth"!
What I wonder is, if it wasn't for that and instead we chose another flag from the beginning of the indepenence, what would have been your argument? What would have been complaining.
It has been clearly stated in the "VENTILATOR" thread relating to this topic by the likes of Vangelovski and Aleksandrov, amongst others, that a freely chosen flag would not have been objectionable even if something else was preferable and would be accepted as a legitimate state symbol, much like the "Denar" currency is. The objections are twofold, it was imposed by an ILLEGITIMATE REGIME and REPRESENTS CAPITULATION.
Macedonians have used many flags through out the history and I don't see you slandering them one by one.
See above.
When someone from the Republic of Macedonia hear you about what you are babbling, he will nod his head and say "who the fuck are you to tell me what to do".
It depends who they are as I can read many Macedonian commentators who share (some of) my views but may be a bit more guarded in what they say, which is understandable. Secondly, I don't think I am babbling about anything but stating my views on MTO. I am also pretty sure that most Macedonians know that the 2001 Ramkoven Dogovor was a capitulation and what the consequences of that were and will continue to be. What is you take on the Ramkoven?
Second thing he will laugh you out for your bad Macedonian language.
So you may think that but, in the main, I got praise for how well I could speak Macedonian given the fact that I spent several decades (from early childhood) living and working in an English language environment.
I am born there, lived almost my whole life there except for the last seven years or so, have my whole extended family there and have my Macedonian citizenship and no other. I go there on regular bases and plan to return when I see it right for my family.
Being Macedonian is NOT a prerequisite to where you are born, what your surname, religion (or if you have one at all) or political preference is and what language you are fluent in. Nor does one need to have a deep knowledge and understanding of traditional Macedonian folk culture in order to be a Macedonian and it is simply enough to have Macedonian ancestry and be proud of your identity. A person of Macedonian ancestry anywhere in the world is entitled to defend his Macedonian identity and all that it encompasses against anyone who undermines it regardless where they may be from.
I was born there too and have some extended family living there, similar to many others. There is a difference between the emigrants to Europe and those that went to Australia in that the first lot were able to return for summer holidays and keep in good repair their homes and, more than not, they had their families back home whilst the second lot left for good with the whole family and many of their homes fell into disrepair, making it harder to return even for holidays as it would be expensive to live in hotels for several months with the family and therefore visit much less frequently. Thus those from Europe have their homes in Macedonia to return to during summer holidays or when they retire whilst many migrants from rural villages that ended up in Australia in the 1960s and 1970s are unable to do the same as their former homes have fallen into disrepair and ruin.
Lastly, if I have citizenship or not is of little importance as I do not want to recognise a Ramkovist Macedonia as legitimate.
So I am bound to Macedonia more than you ever will be. I and my whole family will be effected if anything will get started there.
You may be a bit more bound than I (as your whole family lives there) but that does not give you or anyone else the right to sell out, DESTROY or UNDERMINE the MACEDONIAN INHERITANCE of EVERY MACEDONIAN LIVING or DEAD!
Secondly, what is the effect of the RAMKOVEN DOGOVOR for the Macedonians under UCK RULE? Did those that "bought" the temporary appeasement of UCK FACISTS do it at the expense of other Macedonians left behind enemy lines in the 25-33% of Macedonia under what is effectively foreign occupation and rule?
Escaping in numbers again. Who are this thousands of Macedonians! Those who don't live in R. of Macedonia?
See above!
You not being in the R. of Macedonia would know that not everyone have seen the events like I say?
We had the
spokesperson for VMRO-DPMNE give us weekly reports on radio here in Sydney (and Australia) during this period and he surely knew more than you did. The presenter of that program that ran from 1993 through to 1995 is another MTO member and he had regular interviews with other leading opposition political figures who were informing and enlightening us here much more than you were able to be because of the media monopoly of the ILLEGITIMATE SDSM REGIME! Some of us were also subscribed to opposition magazines plus our local media carried much more info from the opposition as well. Thus I can easily say that we had more insight into what politics were at play than those in RoM watching MTV or reading Nova Makedonija and the like.
And the flag is still there.
The hard reality!
And you have VASSALS running a country which they turned from a MACEDONIAN NATIONAL STATE into a RAMKOVIST NON-MACEDONIAN ONE! That is the "reality" you are cheering for!
Still there were Macedonians who fought under that Flag, who died under that Flag.
Another one of those EMOTIONAL MYTHS used to justify use of SYMBOLS of CAPITULATION! I am not going to argue it here as it has already been covered previously in the "VENTILATOR" thread but will keep it in mind for inclusion in a myth-busting thread that should be raised sooner or later here on MTO. What excuse did you use for period of 1995-2000 then? I can tell you because I heard it many times from the SDSM supporters and apologists - it is the state flag and we must respect the state. What respect did they show the state when they sold us out in 1993 and 1995 and gave away our only democratically chosen state flag of a sovereign and independent Macedonian state - the 16-ray Kutlesh (Macedonian) Sun Flag together with our indigenous heritage and name?
Only for that reason I would shit you out for slandering the Flag.
As I said, this is another one of those MYTHS we need to bust with more elaboration and I hope the MTO team will assist and keep it in the soon to do list.
Idealogy won't help you when noone will listen to you.
The struggle belongs with the younger generation and time will tell what they will or will not listen to, act upon or actually say in leading the way forward! I am just trying to share some info on Macedonia and Macedonian issues that is not available online and that may be useful to that younger generation in the coming struggle. As well as that, yes, I will express my views that reflect my ideology and so be it if someone or noone takes notice of any of them.
Also what is debatable about the "state building". Were you there when we all called for independent Macedoni? Were you there to defend it's integrity. Are you involved in the Politics of R. of Macedonia.
I doubt it.
I was on streets of Australia calling for recognition of Macedonia by the world and defending and promoting our heritage and linking up (with their full co-operation and appreciation) with internal political forces pushing for an independent and sovereign state of Macedonia whilst those that sold us out were trying to keep us in the old federation and hence were happy to see us in the UN as former "YUGOSLAV REPUBLIC of Macedonia" as a "Temporary Reference"
for two months only! And as
Petar Goshev stated in 1994 (at the 1 year "anniversary" of the "TR"): "There is nothing more permanent than the temporary".
Why weren't you there to stop the Ramkovist agreement, a prodigy child like you should have accomplished that with out effort.
Moronic gibberish!
You made me curious about the new Macedonian state!
Tell me, do you plan building clones who will comply with your Ideology and will, who will call out "Heil Indigen!" ?
If the vast majority of Macedonian are anything like you and ideological work fails to raise their consciousness in order to restore Macedonia to being a state of Macedonians (or even parts of it), then they will either become the Shiptar's bitches, take Serbian, Bulgarian or Greek citizenship and go to those countries or high-tail it out to Europe or some other destination.
Take it from me, only a KOSOVO FUTURE awaits Ramkovist Macedonia!
And the UN ID Card is that what would Identify me!? Don't be so stupid.
Yes, you can look in the mirror and call yourself Macedonian if you like but the world will call you by the nationality derived from whatever Rep. of X will be called.
It might be annoying seeing that bullshit, maybe that battle is lost, but the war is still on going.
The WAR was lost the minute we engaged in the name game! We can only start to fight if we end (declare null and void) the capitulationist agreements relating to the name issue and fight the WAR for our national sovereignty with all our might, come what may! When Macedonia does that, call me and I will gladly go to any front-line regardless whether you go or not.
So, the war is raging and won't cease as long as there are Macedonians who will call their Country Macedonia.
Macedonia was more or less lost in 2001! You need to inform yourself what the Ramkoven means.
And yet I see you attacking the Macedonian people and their current State symbols. Symbols under which many Macedonians have lost their lifes. You show no respect of them, most likely cause you consider them brainwashed. And yet when you insult them you are just distancing them from you.
Who do I show no respect to? Do you know what symbols "DOSTOINSTVO" uses and who they represent? Maybe you need to inform yourself more by reading the "Ventilator" thread?
Go into Macedonia, get involved in the Political scene, get elected for President and start your own brainwashing!
Another idiotic mindless statement! I am having my say on an international forum with members from all around the world, including from Macedonia, and ideas and information can travel far and wide.
Can you vote in R. of Macedonia? Ooops my fault, you ain't citizent!
I may be able to but I have no intention in giving validity to the Ramkovist State.
Living in EU, I know exactly what EU is. I know exactly what for EU stands for. I know it ain't the promissing land for what the
Macedonians are holding it.
You actually do not get the point I was making in that you can NOT transform the country economically and culturally to be at the same level of that of an advanced western economy simply by entering the EU!
Yet, your Ideological Crusade won't bring them from wishing what they want.
It depends how strong and effective the campaign is in informing and convincing them that what they are chasing is a mirage and they are better off chasing realistic options. It will not be me that does that but we can all help to inform ourselves on MTO so we don't contribute to fallacies.
Why is that so? Why didn't you learn the language properly. For a proud Macedonian I would be ashamed to admit that my language skills are insufficient.
Blah blah blah....We all have our priorities and opportunities. When I grew up there was little opportunity to learn and study Macedonian and language skills in a total foreign language environment are hard to develop unless you had them already. Being a proud Macedonian or a good patriot is not a prerequisite to being fluent in spoken and/or written literary Macedonian.
How do the others in R. of Macedonia survive? That is a interesting question.
That is their environment that they know how to get around in and most have a place to live in and many have land back in home villages plus getting some support from relatives living outside the country.
Ah OK, now you have said it, If you were rich!.
I said maybe if I were rich! I know one fellow who had a lot of trouble trying to do business there in the early 1990s because the old ruling clique did not want others to encroach on their turf.
The old good glue, the money. Well if all the Macedonians in R. of Macedonia were rich, they would have been ready for your Ideology and would have swallowed it whole heartedly.
I am not rich, as most Macedonians in Australia and around the world are surely not and there would be many who would be doing it quite tough. So stop your illusions and think about what has happened to the manufacturing industries in the western world where many Macedonians were employed and how others would be coping living on the old-aged pension as their sole income.
My parants were never rich, neither had good political connection nor were in the so called middle class, and yet they stayed there!
Were they living on the land? It was not full employment in SRM, if you did not know, and social security did not really apply if one did not have a long work contribution (raboten stazh). One needed connections to get jobs and there were not enough of them to go around. Collectivisation and other policies just about ruined village life and the consequences of that are now obvious and disastrous - ruined and abandoned villages in most cases.
I know many such cases. The only one who really leave abroad were those who either had some relatives there or wanted to go earn some money to by them self ficco or 101 car and come back.
The early migrants were poor rural unskilled peasants or semi-skilled workers who left due to few prospects at home and work opportunities in the West. Many of the older ones were born before the war and had only basic education (in Serbian for those from NRM/SRM) and may or may not have seen even electrification of their villages. Lets not compare apples to oranges.
However out of some not known reasons they stayed.
That ever.
No one likes uncertainty and being uprooted and if there is some work security or means of survival, people will stay home, especially those less adapted to living in the modern world as a migrant in a foreign land and environment.
Traitors or Vassals, to name few.
Do you know to whom that is in reference to?
You did not bothered me at first. But than you had to butt in and defend your clone brother! So now I am just questioning your integrity. I don't see much of it. What I have expecting anyways.
Anyone who states the following (as you do): "You call it capitulate, I call it reasoning and facing reality!" deserves scorn and condemnation and you should expect it from and any right-thinking Macedonian patriot!
Do you negate it that you pose like a leader. Your very tone of addressing people is arrogant. You pose like you know it all and attack others for not complying to your mindset.
There are certain things I do know about and thus, based on facts (unlike some others), I will "pose" like I do know what I am talking about.
Show me where I said that we are to change the name?
Did I say you said that?
I just expressed my confidence in the Macedonian identity and it persistence.
It may have been possible when Macedonians were the predominant population living on the land and there was no foreign church and state education and other institutions working overtime trying to eradicate their identity. As an example, check and see how the Macedonian villages around Skopje and Kumanovo are "surviving" and visit and see how Macedonian Arachinovo is today. How strong is the Macedonian identity in Seres and Kostur today and how strong will it be in Lerinsko if Macedonia disappears and there is no state to sustain the language, identity and culture of the Macedonians, even as poorly as that is the case today?
Look into the History section and prove me that I don't have right. There was no Macedonian State before 1945 and yet the Macedonian Identity prevailed.
See above and in 1945 Macedonians were mostly living on the land, more or less illiterate and having a high birth-rate. Villages today are lying in ruins and mostly abandoned and many areas taken over by the Shiptars/Ghegs.
So zdravje i teraj si go pato
Shto da se pravi so tebe koga ti go isprale mozokot od mal?
