aleksandrov
New member
You're quoting Petar Popovski the same guy who stated that the Olympics started in Macedonia and not in the ancient Hellene city-states. Yeah I am very skeptical of what you posted from his book. ...I think you need to re-evaluate Popovski and his claims. Where is this wonderous flag Popovski claims exists?
I emphasized that I didn't intend to engage in a persuasion context with you on this sub-topic because it detracts from the fundamental issues concerning the flag. You insisted on going into historical research about the use of the Sun between antiquity and modern times, so I provided you with a reference. I also indicated quite explicitly that if you look up the book you will find references to the sources Petar Popovski relies on. There are many other sources that are relevant to answering your historical question, but they won't be relevant if you are only looking to prove your preconception (promulgated mostly by Greece) that the Sun symbol was not used by Macedonians as a cultural symbol between ancient times and modern times. While the conclusions and theories he draws from those sources might be debatable, what is less debatable is that those sources provide ample evidence that contradict your own presumption. You have come back here trying to defend an presumption that the Sun symbol wasn't used by Macedonians between antiquity and modern times without even having checked Popovski's book, let alone the sources he relies on. Your logic of trying to discredit everything he says based on something specific that he has said about an unrelated point, and which you find ridiculous, is fundamentally flawed. If I was to apply your logic, I wouldn't bother discussing anything at all with you.
You need to stop equating ignorance of the existence of something with proof that it didn't exist. I have critically evaluated Dr Petar Popovski's book just like I critically evaluate anything that I read before taking it seriously. You need to re-evaluate your own methodology of reasoning and argument, especially since you have tried to defend a modern flag by stubbornly evading and downplaying the most fundamental issues relevant to choosing a modern day national flag, while clumsily focusing on a relatively peripheral question, and doing so in a way that only reinforces the propaganda of those who question the roots of the modern Macedonian identity.
Btw, that translation of the Petar Popovski quote is terrible. I hope you don't rely on such low quality translations in your research.