Vangelovski
New member
Makedonin,
Its hard to determine what you consider an appropriate methodology or what you consider evidence with all of your backfliping and contradictions. On the one hand, you claim that the Gospels themselves and the extra-Biblical sources cannot be taken as evidence because somehow are they are invalid. On the other hand, you use gnostic gospels in an attempt to argue that the Biblical Gospels are innacurate.
As for the disingenuous arguments provided for in your links about the recorded material involving Jesus, if you accepted those arguments in relation to Jesus, then you would have to accept them for any number of historical figures, events and documents. The Gospels themselves are by far more historically realiable than the great majority of secular texts we have because: a) they were written by eyewitnesses; and b) we have literally thousands of copies. This is not the case for many of the secular documents we have in our possession today yet we accept their reliability.
More importantly, (while ignoring both internal and external tests) what you are suggesting is that the Gospels were in fact conspired - that the authors came together and conspired to invent a story about Jesus and write the same account from four different viewpoints. Why would they do that? They had absolutely nothing to gain. The Apostles lived a life of suffering for their faith, taking beatings, humiliation, persecution and eventually dying for their faith. People die for what they believe to be true, they do not die for what they know to be a lie. Then there is the case of Paul, a powerful and influential Jew who persecuted and killed Christians. Why would he all of a sudden change his faith, give up his power and prestige and risk his life for something he knew was a lie?
Another absurdity is your claim that archaeology does not prove the existence of Jesus. Archaeology has in fact confirmed the accuracy of the Gospels by discovering a number of sites mentioned in them and affirming many other details relating to historical figures and events. Further, archaeology has never contradicted the Bible. So, you would have us believe that the Gospels contain verifiable facts about people, places and events and yet the central character was some sort of forgery...that is until you use the gnostic gospels to contradictorily argue that Jesus did exist after all, but not as described in the Gospels.
As for you wasting your time and money, noone has a gun to your head. Noone is forcing you to continually respond with more contradictions and blatant falsehoods about what constitutes evidence in the various fields, while at the same time using the very methodologies and principles for evidence that you claim are invalid to agrue in favour of your perspective.
Its hard to determine what you consider an appropriate methodology or what you consider evidence with all of your backfliping and contradictions. On the one hand, you claim that the Gospels themselves and the extra-Biblical sources cannot be taken as evidence because somehow are they are invalid. On the other hand, you use gnostic gospels in an attempt to argue that the Biblical Gospels are innacurate.
As for the disingenuous arguments provided for in your links about the recorded material involving Jesus, if you accepted those arguments in relation to Jesus, then you would have to accept them for any number of historical figures, events and documents. The Gospels themselves are by far more historically realiable than the great majority of secular texts we have because: a) they were written by eyewitnesses; and b) we have literally thousands of copies. This is not the case for many of the secular documents we have in our possession today yet we accept their reliability.
More importantly, (while ignoring both internal and external tests) what you are suggesting is that the Gospels were in fact conspired - that the authors came together and conspired to invent a story about Jesus and write the same account from four different viewpoints. Why would they do that? They had absolutely nothing to gain. The Apostles lived a life of suffering for their faith, taking beatings, humiliation, persecution and eventually dying for their faith. People die for what they believe to be true, they do not die for what they know to be a lie. Then there is the case of Paul, a powerful and influential Jew who persecuted and killed Christians. Why would he all of a sudden change his faith, give up his power and prestige and risk his life for something he knew was a lie?
Another absurdity is your claim that archaeology does not prove the existence of Jesus. Archaeology has in fact confirmed the accuracy of the Gospels by discovering a number of sites mentioned in them and affirming many other details relating to historical figures and events. Further, archaeology has never contradicted the Bible. So, you would have us believe that the Gospels contain verifiable facts about people, places and events and yet the central character was some sort of forgery...that is until you use the gnostic gospels to contradictorily argue that Jesus did exist after all, but not as described in the Gospels.
As for you wasting your time and money, noone has a gun to your head. Noone is forcing you to continually respond with more contradictions and blatant falsehoods about what constitutes evidence in the various fields, while at the same time using the very methodologies and principles for evidence that you claim are invalid to agrue in favour of your perspective.
Last edited: