• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Hellenic religion

Bratot,

If you see someone jumping off a cliff in a movie, would you try it in real life? If TV influences your morality that much, then perhaps its not for you.


If you are impotent than watching Baywatch will not stimulate your immagination at all.

I'm curious how Vangelovski's childhood looked liked.

Explain to me with law forces you to disobey the commandments? As an Australian citizen and a Christian, I'm genuinely interested in this area.

Do you want me to study specifically Australian law or the examples I already gave which are pretty general does not meet your requirements?
 
Last edited:
If you are impotent than watching Baywatch will not stimulate your immagination at all.




Do you want me to study specifically Australian law or the examples I already gave which are pretty general does not meet your requirements?

The actual temptation is not a sin - acting on that temptation is. Again, if you saw someone in a movie jumping off a cliff, would you do the same? Or maybe I can put it this way - if you watched a movie in which someone committed adultary, would you then go out and commit adultary as well? The television itself has no moral value. The programming may be morally abhorent, but at the end of the day, it is up to you to CHOOSE to obey the commandments. Further, if you found the programme unsuitable for your viewing, you can change the channel.

The examples you provided (with regard to law) do not compel you to break the commandments. If you think they do, please explain how.
 
Last edited:
The actual temptation is not a sin
Un pure thoughts is not a sin? Thats the problem with us christians, we pick and choose. I know what you will use as defence "the flesh is weak". Lets get serious and admit its a sin and we always must ask for forgivness and not hide behing scriptures.
How does that scripture go about removing an eye, its better to go to heavan with one eye, than to not go to heavan at all.
obviously its not literal but there is some meaning to it basicly if you perv.

Again, if you saw someone in a movie jumping off a cliff, would you do the same? Or maybe I can put it this way - if you watched a movie in which someone committed adultary, would you then go out and commit adultary as well?
I am not sure where you are going with this, but you are kidding if you think television does not influence us and we should be able to decern. The biggest problem is the damage gets done from a young age when we are most vulnerable.

if i am way off what you are trying to say, then i apologize for the mis understanding.
 
Last edited:
Makedonin,

If you are going to throw in a red-herring and then an answer is provided, can you at least attempt a rebuttal before you throw in your next red-herring, pretending as if neither question was asked nor answer provided?

There are many reasons why I would not enter in discussing your question. Some of them are:

1. Are laughable cause they are based on "rational" belief! And you dare present them as absolute fact! I can predict where they are headed to, and I see it as pulling red-herring, as you use to say!
2. Are something that will need writting essey and cost me time!
3. You want me to enter speculations which are based on your "rational" belief!
4. Or I have an not ripe understanding of it, but still expressed it, cause the idea just struck me when I read your nonsense!

You've done nothing but throw around some pretty lame assumptions and random "facts" that you have invented yourself and when they are shown for what they are, you pretend as if it never happened and you continue merrily along.

There are no greater assumption than your belief dude. You leck humility when presenting your beliefs based on some shaky book! You preassume it is whole and absolute, but no book is such! You assume that those "saints" were of noble spirit who had only one thing in their mind, helping you understand God!

Rember they were also sinful! The one has disavow his Master (Peter) the other did not believe in him (Tomas) the third has betray him (Judas), from the others we don't even have any record, but by some "miracle", there we go again, they all changed, and became some obedient servants of God.

Maybe they did not perpetuate their belief after the resurrection (which remains in realm of faith) cause they saw something supernatural, but out of remorse betrying their master! Strange are the ways of a religious man.

Their statements about the resurrection contradict and exclude one another in wierd way, so that they can't make any case of being seen as true, but you perpetuate that! You base your whole belief on a shaky stories which contradict one another!


Short overview:
Matthew 28
1. Magdalene and Mary are the first to find him
2. Angel opened the Tomb
3. Angel said go to Galilee you will meet him there
4. Magdalene and Mary meet Jesus on the road back to desciples
5. Desciples go to Galilee to the mountain where Jesus had told them to go. There they saw Jesus, but not all believed that he was really Jesus

http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Matthew+28&version=NCV

Mark 16
1. Mary Magdalene and the other Mary go to tomb
2. The stone had already been rolled away
3. The women entered the tomb and saw a young man wearing a white robe and sitting on the right side
4. Jesus is going into Galilee ahead of you, they are told
5. Jesus showed himself first to Mary Magdalene
6. Later, Jesus showed himself to two of his followers while they were walking in the country, but he did not look the same as before.
7.Later Jesus showed himself to the eleven apostles while they were eating

http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Mark+16&version=NCV

Luke 24

1. The women came to the tomb, It was Mary Magdalene, Joanna, Mary the mother of James
2. While they were wondering about this, two men in shining clothes suddenly stood beside them.5 The women were very afraid and bowed their heads to the ground.
3. The women told the apostles everything that had happened at the tomb. But they did not believe the women, because it sounded like nonsense.
4. That same day two of Jesus' followers were going to a town , he walked and talked to them
5. They said, "About Jesus of Nazareth. He was a prophet who said and did many powerful things before God and all the people.
6. They went back to Jerusalem, and told the apostels.
7. They were fearful and terrified and thought they were seeing a ghost. 38 But Jesus said, "Why are you troubled? Why do you doubt what you see? 39 Look at my hands and my feet. It is I myself! Touch me and see, because a ghost does not have a living body as you see I have."
8 Then Jesus opened their minds so they could understand the Scriptures
http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Luke+24&version=NCV

Did Jesus opened your mind too! Did it hurt...:rolleyes1: Why those two did not use the word Mesiah, but Prohet, describing Jesus!?

John 21
1. Mary Magdalene went to the tomb
2 When she saw that the large stone had been moved away from the tomb, she ran to Simon Peter and the follower whom Jesus loved.
3. So Peter and the other follower started for the tomb
4. All went into the tomb and wondered about the empty clothes
5. Then the followers went back home only Magdalene was crying on the tomb. She saw two angels dressed in white, sitting where Jesus' body had been
6. she turned around and saw Jesus standing there, but she did not know it was Jesus.
7. She was thinking he was the gardener
8. Jesus said to her, "Mary" and and Mary turned toward Jesus and said in the Hebrew language
9.Mary Magdalene went and said to the followers
10. After that on another evening he appeared in the middle of them in a locked room.
11. Thomas was not with them when Jesus came, and wanted to put his finger on the nail mark.
12. A week later Thomas could put his finger in where it does not belong!
13. Later he showed him self at the Galilee-Lake
14. Jesus talks to Peter
http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=John 21&version=NCV

Is that accurate Mr. Red-Herring? Is that what you believe in?

The one saw an Angel, the other saw some dudes, than Jesus. Were there one or two dudes apearing to the same Mary? Which will it be? Was it in Galilee on the Mountain, or was it in the Galilee-Lake? Many did not believe it was him even after seeing him, others put his finger in his woulnds! Man, what a wild ride!

Similar to the game Operator (Gluf telefon).

The credibility is astonishing! And you dare talking about "hard facts"! Did you puled that out of your "opened mind"?

Turn it on the one or the other, your facts leck any reason, but you still speak of them in a high manner, as absolute truth!

Even if the Apostel did see Jesus, which they did not believe them self, the whole matter is wrong and does not fit the Just God. They had their empirical evidence, they saw what they saw, and we have to believe in non credible stories.

They are saved based on knowledge, they observed, saw him, one should even have put his finger in his would, Jesus should have opened their heads so that they understand!
We should be saved based on belief.

How Just is that? Nada!


By the way, you are the first one who proved my theory stands!
 
Last edited:
Television, Internet and mass Media are shaping the Human mind in that amount that no book has done before.

Mr. Red-Herring would only dream of such shaping impact of the Bible on the modern man brain!
 
The actual temptation is not a sin - acting on that temptation is.

Again, if you saw someone in a movie jumping off a cliff, would you do the same?

The first thing is called - hypocrisy or being a mental virgin.

The second thing is measured individualy as we have seen few examples of video games becoming reality by shooting in the schools around the world.

Or maybe I can put it this way - if you watched a movie in which someone committed adultary, would you then go out and commit adultary as well?

But it does shape your sense, it can ewoke such feelings to come on surface and to actualy start thinking of it more often.

I don't need a movie to commit adultary, I make my own home videos.


The television itself has no moral value.

How come you aply double standards on the TV when a book can have the same content presented on a TV screen?

Or maybe a TV station called Religion Tv or Vatican Tv makes no difference?

You just oppose without any logic and against yourself you have the whole human psychology and marketing techniques, but I wont even considering goin into that "forbiden" area.


The programming may be morally abhorent, but at the end of the day, it is up to you to CHOOSE to obey the commandments. Further, if you found the programme unsuitable for your viewing, you can change the channel.

Ok, tell me what was or is your favorite TV show, commedy or a movie?

Do you know that according to the church teaching having an erection not for your wife is a sin?



Another absurd.
2352 By masturbation is to be understood the deliberate stimulation of the genital organs in order to derive sexual pleasure. "Both the Magisterium of the Church, in the course of a constant tradition, and the moral sense of the faithful have been in no doubt and have firmly maintained that masturbation is an intrinsically and gravely disordered action."

Medicine says the regular masturbating protects agaist the cancer of the prostate.

The semen cannot remain in the seminal vesicles. When the semen builds up to a certain level, your body will release semen of its own accord. It usually happens at night while you are dreaming. You become aroused and your penis becomes erect. The glans at the end of your penis becomes very sensitive to any contact, causing your body to tense with pleasure (this is known as orgasm). Suddenly, there is a release and the semen squirts out of your penis. The tension leaves your body leaving you feeling satisfied and very relaxed.

If you held the end of your penis closed just before ejaculating, the semen will be forced backwards through the prostate and into your bladder. This stretches your prostate, causing extreme discomfort, if not down right pain. For a few days you will experience pain when urinating and your urine will have a cloudy look. If the discomfort does not begin to go away in a few days, your inflamed organs may have picked up an infection. See your doctor immediately for treatment.


Bur according to the church ejaculating outside the wife's vagina not for the purpose of having a child is always a sin.

Can you count? :)

Not even mentioning the Banks of Sperm.

The examples you provided (with regard to law) do not compel you to break the commandments. If you think they do, please explain how.

Yes they do and I already explained.
 
I wonder which event made him so strong believer! What lead him to his strong faith, that can't move Mountain!

i am also kind of strong believer. specialy after my acident. if we follow the laws of physics and logic, i should be dead now, or sitting in wheel-chair / be tied to bed for rest of my life.

i think some Angel saved my life.

also my healing process... all the doctors and nurses were simply astonished how fast i recovered from injuries that were dangerous for my life.

if i post here pictures how did i looked 4-5 weeks ago, and how i looked 2 weeks ago, and how i look today, and what i am able to do with my injured hand, you will start believe in something "super-natural" too :D

what the "hard core believers" don´t understand, is that me and people like me do NOT question the existence of God.

i am sure God exist.

i question the "doctrines" implanted in the institutionalized form of Religion (Churches and etc), by greedy, power-hungry (and blinded by satan) people who were "smart" enough to twist, turn and mis-interprate the basics of the Religions.

for examples, this hard core believers on this forum did not even ASKED what am i talking about, mentioning "Makedonianstvo". they claim they are Macedonians and Christians, but dont even bother to ask what is ment with a religious terminology containing the Name of our Nation - Country?

i ask myself, does some of them have any idea to explain to the people how we reproduced after Adam and Eva?

or it´s "taboo" ???

or how come they ask such un-logic questions about "God of Muslims, God of Jews"?

who mentiones "God of Muslims" and "God of Jews", CAN NOT CALL - CONCIDER HIMSELF CHRISTIAN;

Couse one of the postaments of the Christianity is:

there is ONLY ONE GOD.

should i write it again? :)

or it ring´s a bell already?
 
Here is John Calvin's commentary on the so called contradictions of the Resurrection Accounts:

There certainly was nothing more of earthly grandeur in the disciples than in the women who followed Christ; but as Christ was pleased to reckon them the principal witnesses of his resurrection, on this single ground their testimony is entitled to the greatest deference, and is not liable to any objection. As to the priests, and scribes, and the whole people, and even Pilate, nothing but gross and wilful blindness prevented them from firmly believing that Christ was risen. All of them, therefore, deserved that seeing they should not see; yet Christ revealed himself to the little flock.

Before proceeding farther, however, it is necessary to show how the Evangelists agree with each other; for, at first sight, there appears to be some contradiction in their words. John mentions but one woman, Mary Magdalene; Matthew 28:1 mentions two, Mary Magdalene, and the other Mary; Mark 16:1 mentions three, Mary Magdalene, and Mary (the mother) of James, and Salome; Luke 24:10, 22 does not fix the number, but only relates that women came, who had followed Christ from Galilee. But the difficulty is easily solved in this manner.

As Matthew inserts the names of two women who were best known, and had the highest reputation among the disciples, so John satisfies himself with mentioning the name of Mary Magdalene alone, but yet does not exclude the others; and, indeed, it is evident, from viewing his words in their connection, that she was not alone, for, shortly afterwards, Mary Magdalene says, in the plural number, WE know not where they have laid him. Although, therefore, John says nothing about her companions, yet the other Evangelists, who relate that there were many along with her, say nothing that is contradicted by John’s narrative.

The discrepancy as to the time may be easily solved. When John says that they came before daybreak, we must understand, that they had set out on their journey during the darkness of the night; that, before they came to the sepulcher, the day had dawned; and that in the evening, after sunset, when the Sabbath was ended, they had bought the spices; and thus the narrative of the other Evangelists must be reconciled.

It may be thought that there is another appearance of contradiction in its being stated by John, that Mary spoke to none but himself and Peter, while Luke 24:10, 11 relates, that she came to the eleven Apostles, and that her words appeared to them to be idle tales. But this is easily explained, for John intentionally passed by the rest of the Apostles, because it was only himself and Peter that came to the sepulcher. As to Luke mentioning Peter alone, it is for the same reason as we have just now assigned in reference to Mary Megdalene and the rest of the women. It is also probable, that the other nine disciples were restrained by fear, lest they should be too easily observed if they went in a body. Nor is this inconsistent with what Luke appears to suggest, that they despised Mary’s words; for immediately afterwards he adds, that Peter ran, (Luke 24:12.) He therefore means simply that, when they first heard it, they appeared to be astonished, but that at length Peter took courage, and followed her for the purpose of seeing.
When Luke relates that Christ appeared to Mary before that she had informed the disciples that the grave was empty, the order of the narrative is inverted. This is evident from the context, for he adds what, John tells us, happened before she saw Jesus; nor is there any thing strange in this, for the Hebrew writers frequently relate first what is later in the order of time.
 
Here is John Gill's Exposition on the Resurrection Accounts:

Ver. 1. In the end of the sabbath,.... This clause is by some joined to the last verse of the preceding chapter, but stands better here, as appears from Mr 16:1, and intends not what the Jews call the sabbath eve, for that began the sabbath; but what they call
tbv yauwm, "the goings out of the sabbath"; and as Mark says,
Mr 16:1, "when the sabbath was past": that is, when the sun was set, and any stars appeared. The Vulgate Latin, Arabic, and Ethiopic versions, and Munster's Hebrew Gospel render it, "the evening of the sabbath"; and the Persic version, "the night of the sabbath"; but must mean, not the evening and night, which preceded the sabbath, and was a part of it, but what followed it, and belonged to the first day.

As it began to dawn; not the day, but the night; a way of speaking used by the Jews, who call the night, rwa, "light": thus they say {y}, rve hebral rwa, "on the light, or night of the fourteenth" (of the month Nisan) "they search for leavened bread", &c. And so the word is used, in Lu 23:54, of the eve of the sabbath, or the beginning of it, as here of the going out of it;

towards the first day of the week, or "sabbaths"; so the Jews used to call the days of the week, the first day of the sabbath, the second day of the sabbath, &c. take an instance or two {z}

"The stationary men fast four days in the week, from the second day to the fifth day; and they do not fast on the sabbath eve (so they sometimes call the sixth day), because of the glory of the sabbath; nor tbvb dxab, "on the first day of the sabbath", or week, that they may not go from rest and delight, to labour and fasting, and die.''

On which the Gemara has these words {a};

"the stationary men go into the synagogue, and sit four fastings; tbvb ynvb, "on the second of the sabbath", or "week": on the third, and on the fourth, and on the fifth.''

Came Mary Magdalene, and the other Mary, the wife of Cleophas, and mother of James and Joses, with whom also was Salome, the mother of Zebedee's children, Mr 16:1. There seems to be some difference between the evangelists about the time of the women's coming to the sepulchre. Matthew says, it was "at the end of the sabbath, when it began to dawn; towards the first day of the week". John says, that "Mary Magdalene" came "when it was yet dark", Joh 20:1, and yet Mark says, that they came "at the rising of the sun", Mr 16:2. Though they all agree it was early in the morning: all they say is no doubt true, and may be reconciled thus. As soon as the sabbath was ended, the women set out on their journey, and as they went, bought spices and ointment to anoint the body with: they passed through the gates of the city before they were shut, and might stay some time in the suburbs; when Mary Magdalene, eager to be at the sepulchre, set out first, whilst it was dark, and came back and reported to Peter what she had seen, and returned again by such time the other women came, which was at sunrising. From all the accounts it is clear, that he rose, as is expressly said, Mr 16:9, on the first day of the week, and which was the third from his death: on the sixth day, which was Friday, he was crucified, and buried that evening; he lay in the grave all sabbath day, or Saturday; and rose early on the first day of the week, before the women got to the sepulchre; who came thither, as it is here said,

to see the sepulchre: not merely to see it, for they had seen it before, and where, and how the body of Christ was laid in it; but to see whether they could enter into it, and anoint the body with the spices and ointments, which they had prepared and brought with them for that purpose.

{y} Misn. Pesachim, c. 1. sect. 1. Vid. Maimon. & Bartenora in ib. {z} Misn. Taanilh, c. 4. sect. 3. {a} T. Bab. Taanith, fol. 27. 2. Vid. T. Bab. Nidda, fol. 4. 2. & 11. 1. & 67. 2.


Matthew 28:2

Ver. 2. And behold there was a great earthquake,.... Or "there had been one"; which, how far it reached, and whether further than the spot of ground in which the sepulchre was, is not certain: it was an emblem of the shaking of the earth by the preaching of the Gospel, the sound of which was now to go after Christ's resurrection to the ends of the world; and a prelude of the general resurrection, when the earth shall be shaken, and the graves opened, and the dead come forth; and was a symbol and token of the presence and majesty of Christ, at whose rising, as at his death, the earth shook and trembled. Think whether the watch could now be asleep, as they afterwards gave out, Mt 28:13. The Persic version renders it very wrongly; "and there was great consternation and fear"; which was the consequence of the earthquake, and the descent of the angel, and was so great that it was not possible for the keepers to sleep, if ever so much inclined:

for the angel of the Lord descended from heaven; perhaps Gabriel, who brought the news of the conception of Christ to the virgin, and of his incarnation to the shepherds, and might be the same angel that strengthened him in the garden: nor is this any contradiction to the other evangelists, which speak of two angels, Lu 24:4, for Matthew does not say there were no more than one, though he makes mention but of one.

And came and rolled back the stone from the door; of the sepulchre, which by Joseph, or his orders, was put there, and was sealed by the Jews. This might be done, that way might be made for the risen body of Christ to pass out of the sepulchre; for to suppose, as some do, that he penetrated through this stone with his risen body, is not to be credited: it is true, he could have caused the stone to have given way, or removed it himself, and put it in the place again; as he caused the doors of the house in which the disciples were, to open and shut so quick, that they could not discern it when he appeared in the midst of them, Joh 20:19; see Ac 12:10, but he might choose to do it by the ministry of an angel, which is no ways derogatory to his power and majesty, but rather agreeable. Moreover, this might be done, that the women might have access to the sepulchre, and enter into it, which was the thing they were concerned about by the way, who should roll away the stone for them. Besides, this the angel did, as a token that Christ was risen, and to let the guard know as much, who, if they thought fit, might come and see what was done; but chiefly the stone was rolled away by the angel, as an emblem of the acquittance and discharge of Christ, as the surety of his people. He had taken upon him their sins; he had bore them in his body on the tree; he had suffered and died for them, and was laid as a prisoner in the grave; and now full satisfaction being made, an angel is sent from heaven to roll away the stone; thereby signifying, that the debt was fully paid, and he was now legally discharged. It is added,

and sat upon it; thereby showing who it was that rolled it away; that it was done by him, not by the earthquake, nor by any human power: he sat there defying the guard of soldiers to come nigh; and waiting for the coming of the women, to tell them the good news, that their Lord was risen; and as the keeper of the sepulchre, that no corpse might be brought and laid in the room of Christ, and it be said that he was not risen. This posture of the angel does not contradict what other evangelists say of this, and the other angel, that they stood by the women, and also were sitting in the sepulchre, Mr 16:5, for each was true: when the women first came, the angel sat upon the stone; after that, with the other, stood by them; when having invited them to the grave, placed themselves, sitting the one at the head, and the other at the feet, where the body of Christ had lain.


Matthew 28:3

Ver. 3. His countenance was like lightning,.... There was such a lustre and brightness in his face, that it glittered like lightning: such a description is in Da 10:6,

and his raiment white as snow: the word "white" is left out in the Vulgate Latin, and in Munster's Hebrew Gospel: the angel appeared clad in white, as a token of the purity and innocence of his nature; and because of the victory and triumph of Christ over death and the grave; and that he might be known and taken by the women for a good angel, it being a commonly received notion of the Jews, that ministering angels were clothed in white {b}.

"Said R. Ame to R. Levi, show me the Persians; he said to him, they are like to the mighty men of the house of David: show me the Chaberin, (another nation near the Persians,) they are like to destroying angels: show me the Ishmaelites, they are like to devils of the house of Hacsa: show me the disciples of the wise men in Babylon, they are like to the ministering angels.''

Upon which the gloss says,

""to the devils", because they are clothed in black, and are like to devils; to "the ministering angels", Mynbl
yvwbl, "they are clothed in white", and veiled like the ministering angels; as it is written in Eze 9:2, "and the man was clothed with linen": and it is said {c} of R. Judah, that he was veiled, and sat in fine linen fringed, and was like to an angel of the Lord of hosts: and elsewhere {d} it is said, who are the ministering angels? the Rabbins: and why are they called ministering angels? because they are fringed, as the ministering angels, in beautiful garments.''

{b} T. Bab. Kiddushin, fol. 72. 1. {c} T. Bab. Sabbat, fol. 25. 2. {d} T. Bab. Nedarim, fol. 20. 2.


Matthew 28:4

Ver. 4. And for fear of him the keepers did shake,.... Though they were soldiers, Roman soldiers and veterans, who had been used to terrible sights in the field of battle; were men of courage, and fearless of danger; and yet were seized with a panic, and every limb of them shook and trembled at the sight of the angel, for fear he was come as an executioner of divine vengeance upon them; who had been concerned in the crucifixion of Christ, had watched him as he hung upon the cross, and now his body in the sepulchre: and even supposing no consciousness of guilt in them, or dread of punishment from him; yet such was the glory and majesty in which he appeared, of which they had never seen the like before, that it had this effect upon them:

and became as dead men: they turned pale, as dead men, and had scarce any life, or spirit, left in them.


Matthew 28:5

Ver. 5. And the angel answered and said unto the women,.... Who being come up, were also affrighted at the sight of the angel. The Arabic version leaves out the first part, "and the angel answered": which is a Jewish way of speaking, when nothing goes before, to which it is a reply; and renders the other part thus, "and said to the two women": but from the other evangelists it appears, that there were more women than two; see Mr 16:1,

fear not ye; some put an emphasis upon the word "ye", as if used in opposition to the keepers, who had reason to be afraid, but not these good women. It was very common with gracious persons to be filled with fear at the sight of an angel, as Zacharias, and the shepherds; but without reason; they are their friends, their fellow servants, and ministering spirits to them. The Persic version adds, "but come near before, for ye are his familiars": the reason alleged, by the angel, why they had no reason to fear, is,

for I know that ye seek Jesus, which was crucified: the knowledge which angels have of saints is very considerable, and which arises from their frequent embassies to them, care and guardianship of them, the good offices they perform, and their several ministrations to them; and the knowledge which the angel had of these good women, might not be from immediate revelation, but from the observations he had made of them: they had followed Jesus from Galilee, they had attended him all the while he was on the cross, and were now come to his grave to anoint him; and from their words and gestures, the angel might know that they were the disciples of Christ, and now sought him; and therefore had no reason to fear, as those who were his adversaries: and indeed, such as seek a crucified Christ, and life and salvation by him, have no reason to be afraid of any thing; not of sin, and its damning power, since Christ saves, his blood cleanses, and his righteousness justifies from all sin; nor of the law, its menaces, curses, and condemnation, for Christ has redeemed them from it; nor of Satan, and his principalities and powers, who are spoiled by Christ, and out of whose hands he has ransomed his people; nor of the world, since Christ has overcome it, and delivered his people from it; nor of death, whose sting is taken away, and that abolished as a penal evil; nor of hell, and wrath to come, from which he has saved them; and much less of good angels, who are kindly disposed to them: and such are they that seek a crucified Christ, whom Christ has first sought, and looked up, and found in redemption and the effectual calling; who are made sensible of their lost and dangerous state by nature, to whom Christ has been manifested; and who see both their need of him, and his worth and value: these seek to him in the first place, and with all their hearts, for cleansing, pardon, righteousness, rest, food, salvation, and eternal life: they seek for him where he is, and is revealed, in the Scriptures, in the Gospel, in the ordinances, and at the Father's right hand.


Matthew 28:6

Ver. 6. He is not here,.... In the grave, where he was laid, and these women saw him laid: he was dead, but is now alive; he was laid in the grave, but God would not leave him there, nor suffer him to see corruption:

for he is risen, as he said; not stolen away, as the chief priests hired the soldiers to say he was; nor removed to another place, as Mary Magdalene first thought, when she found him gone; but he was risen from the dead, by the power of his Father, and by his own power, as he had before said he should. In one of Beza's exemplars it is added, "to you"; for the words that Christ said in Galilee, that he should be delivered into the hands of sinful men, and be crucified, and rise again, the third day, were said in the presence and hearing of these women, and to them, as well as to the disciples; see Luke 24:6. This clause is left out in the Persic version: it follows,

come see the place where the Lord lay; the Lord both of angels and men: the Syriac and Persic versions read, "our Lord". The Arabic and Ethiopic versions leave out the word "Lord", and only read "he". Christ, as the Son of God, lay in the bosom of his Father, and in the arms of his love, from all eternity; as mediator, he lay in the womb of God's purposes and decrees, being his elect, in whom his soul delighted; as man, he lay in the womb of the virgin; and, as an example to his people, he lay, when baptized, in the waters of Jordan; and as the language of the ordinance of the Lord's supper is, "come see my hands, and my feet"; that of baptism is, "come see the place where the Lord lay": but here it regards the grave, in which the body of Christ had been laid; and the women are invited by the angel to go along with him, into the sepulchre, to see the place where he had lain; to assure them the more of the truth of his resurrection, that they might, with their own eyes, see that he was gone, who before had beheld where, and how he was laid; as also to affect them with the condescending grace of Christ, in making his grave with the wicked, and with the rich in his death; as well as to strengthen their faith in their discharge from sin and condemnation by Christ, who was risen for their justification; as also to let them see that the grave was perfumed and sanctified by him; and he was risen as the first fruits and pledge of them that slept.


Matthew 28:7

Ver. 7. And go quickly and tell his disciples,.... Who were mourning and weeping for the death of Christ; despairing of his resurrection, of which, at least, they had but little hope, nor indeed much thought, though Christ had so often told them of it; and therefore a quick dispatch was necessary to remove their sorrow, revive their faith, and relieve their souls, to which the errand these women were sent upon, and the news they were to bring, had a tendency; namely,

that he is risen from the dead: than which nothing could be more joyful news unto them, as it is to all believers; for on this depend the justification and salvation of God's elect; their security from condemnation, and their resurrection from the dead. This news was first brought to the apostles by women, who were greatly honoured hereby; that as the woman was first in the transgression, and the cause of death, so the first news of the resurrection of Christ to life, and of life and immortality being by him, who was first showed the path of life, were brought by women; and to a woman it was that Christ first appeared after his resurrection, Mr 16:9. The Vulgate Latin only reads, "that he is risen", as in the former verse.

And behold he goeth before you into Galilee. These are still the words of the angel to the women, telling them what they should say to the apostles, that he should go before them into Galilee; and which might serve to confirm the resurrection to them, and to give the greater credit to the report of the women, since this very thing Christ had promised them before; see Mt 26:32, though it was also true, that he should go before these women into Galilee, and who also should see him there: for the next words,

there shall ye see him; though they may chiefly design the apostles, who should have a sight of Christ in Galilee, yet may include these women also:

lo! I have told you; I "Gabriel", who am an angel of the Lord, sent by him to inform you of these things; and you may depend upon the truth of them, that Jesus is risen, and that he is about, in a very little time, to go before his disciples into Galilee, where they shall see him with their bodily eyes, and have a free and familiar conversation with him. The reasons why this place was pitched upon for Christ and his apostles to meet in, were, because here he first preached, and chiefly conversed, and had the largest number of disciples there, to whom he meant to show himself, as he did,
1Co 15:6, as well as to his apostles: moreover, the apostles were of Galilee, and so were these women; and to go into their own country, and there meet with Jesus, must be very agreeable; and besides, there they would be safer and freer from the molestations and persecutions of the Jews; and might follow their former calling, as they did, until the time they were to be further employed in preaching the Gospel.


Matthew 28:8

Ver. 8. And they departed quickly from the sepulchre,.... Or "they went out from it", as it may be rendered, and as it is in Mr 16:8, which shows, that they went into the sepulchre upon the invitation of the angel, and saw the place where the Lord lay; and here it was the angel gave them their instructions, and errand to the disciples; which as soon as they received, they quitted the sepulchre in all haste, partly in obedience to the angel's orders, and partly through surprise and fear; for Mark says, "they fled from the sepulchre",
Mr 16:8, as persons terrified and affrighted: and it is added here,

with fear and great joy: a mixture of both these; with fear and dread, because of the vision they had seen, and with joy at the news of Christ's resurrection; and yet in this their faith might not be so confirmed, as to have no doubt about it: they might fear the body was taken away, and removed to some other place, and that this they had seen might be a deception and a delusion. However, between both joy and fear, they set out,

and did run to bring his disciples word; as Mary Magdalene ran to Peter, Joh 20:2, nor is running unusual for women, or unbecoming them on certain occasions; see Ge 24:20. Their fright, as well as their joy, and their regard to the angel's order, might cause them to run, and make the quicker dispatch.


Matthew 28:9

Ver. 9. And as they went to tell his disciples,.... This clause is wanting in the Vulgate Latin, Syriac, Arabic, and Persic versions, and in Beza's most ancient copy; but it stands in the Ethiopic version, and in Munster's Hebrew Gospel,

behold, Jesus met them: that they might be confirmed in what the angel had told them, and their fear might be removed, and their joy increased; and also be capable of reporting to the disciples not only what they had heard from the angel, but what they had seen themselves; they being now eyewitnesses, as well as earwitnesses of his resurrection: so souls in the way of their duty, as these women were, oftentimes meet with Jesus, and he with them, as they may expect, and indeed not otherwise:

saying, all hail; all health of soul and body, all happiness and prosperity, both temporal, spiritual, and eternal, attend you. The Syriac and Persic versions, and Munster's Hebrew Gospel render it, "peace be to you"; which, it is highly probable, was the phrase used by Christ, since it was the common form of salutation among the Jews, and what Christ made use of at other times; see Joh 20:19,

and they came; near unto him, being encouraged by the above salutation, and knowing who he was by his voice, habit, and gesture:

and held him by the feet; they threw themselves prostrate at his feet, in token of reverence and humility; and they laid hold on his feet, that they might know, and be assured that he was really risen, and that it was not a spirit, or a mere phantom and appearance; and they held him in affection to him, and as desirous of his continuance with them:

and worshipped him: with divine adoration, expressing their love to him; their faith and hope in him, owning him to be their Lord and God; he being, by his resurrection from the dead, declared to be the Son of God, with power; and so the proper object of religious worship.


Matthew 28:10

Ver. 10. Then said Jesus unto them, be not afraid,.... Of me, or what you have seen; or lest there should be any deception in the case. In other respects the saints are subject to fears; as lest they should have no share in the love of God, nor interest in Christ, or the work of God is not begun in their hearts; and by reason of sin, lest that should get the ascendant over them, and they perish by it, and so fall short of eternal glory; when it is the will of Christ to have these fears removed, by shedding abroad his love in their hearts, by affording his gracious presence, views of interest in him, and promises of his grace, by sending his Spirit, word, and ministers to comfort them, by discovering and applying pardoning grace to them, and showing his power to keep them.

Go tell my brethren; meaning not his kinsmen according to the flesh, but his disciples, who were in this relation to him, as all the elect of God are; not only through his incarnation, he being their "Goel", their near kinsman, and Redeemer, and of the same nature, flesh, and blood with them, and like unto them in all things, excepting sin; but on account of their divine adoption, to which they were predestinated, and which they received through his redemption, and under the witnessings of the Spirit: he that is his God being theirs; and he that is his Father being theirs also: and which was made manifest in their regeneration, by their faith in him; and obedience to him, and his Father; see Mt 12:49. A very considerable relation this is, that the disciples stood in to Christ, who is the eternal Son of God, and heir of all things; and wonderful grace and condescension it was in Christ to own the relation, when they had so lately forsaken him; and now he was raised from the dead, and had glory given him:

that they go into Galilee, and there shall they see me: he does not say they should not see him before: for they saw him, all but Thomas, that very evening, and all of them eight days after; and both times were before they went into Galilee: but this he said, to put them in mind of what he had promised them, Mt 26:32, and to confirm the words of the angel; and which might serve for a confirmation of the truth of these things, both to the women, and to the disciples, when they observed the exact agreement between the words of Christ, and of the angel. Moreover, it may be remarked, that wherever Christ has appointed to meet his people, they may expect, and be sure to see him at one time or another; as in his house and ordinances, where they are sometimes indulged with a sight of him by faith, which is an appropriating, assimilating, soul rejoicing, and satisfying one; when with pleasure they behold the glory of his divine person, and of his offices, the transcendent excellencies and perfections of his nature, his love and his loveliness, the beauty and amiableness of him, the fulness of grace, life, and righteousness in him, and so the suitableness of him as their Saviour and Redeemer; and when they are favoured with communion with him, and the joys of his salvation.


Matthew 28:11

Ver. 11. Now when they were going,.... Or were gone from the sepulchre: that is, the women, Mary Magdalene, and the other Mary, and their companions, when they were going, or gone, and before they could come to the disciples, to inform them of what they had seen and heard, and deliver the message both of the angel, and of Christ, unto them:

behold, some of the watch came unto the city: that is, "of Jerusalem". The word "behold" is left out in the Syriac, Persic, and Ethiopic versions; but ought to be retained as expressive of what is wonderful, and worthy of observation and attention; that the very persons who were placed to prevent every thing, that might be the foundation of a report, that Christ was risen, should be the first persons that should relate it to the chief priests and elders, that employed them: not all the watch, for some still stayed behind, till they had orders to come away; but some of them, the principal of them, or who were deputed by the rest, came. The Persic version, rather commenting than translating, has these words:

"moreover, the rulers and governors, who watched the sepulchre, coming to themselves, returned to the city with a pale and frightened countenance.''


Matthew 28:16

Ver. 16. Then the eleven disciples,.... For Judas was not only gone from them, but was dead; so that there were now but eleven of them: went

away into Galilee: not directly, as soon as the women had delivered their message; for Christ appeared to them the same day at Jerusalem; and so he did at the same place that week; see
Joh 20:19, but some time, after this they went together into Galilee, according to Christ's direction both before and after his resurrection, Mt 26:32,

into a mountain where Jesus had appointed them; either before his death, or since he was risen; and very likely at one of the above interviews he had with them. This is generally thought to be Mount Tabor; but of this there is no proof, nor certainty: it might be the mountain near Capernaum, on which he taught, Mt 5:1, or that, if not the same with the other, near the sea of Galilee, where Christ fed four thousand with seven loaves, and a few fishes, Mt 15:29. A mountain was appointed for this meeting, both for solitariness and for sight; for here it was he was seen by above five hundred brethren at once, 1Co 15:6.


Matthew 28:17

Ver. 17. And when, they saw him, they worshipped him,.... With divine adoration, as the eternal Son of God; for so he was now declared to be by his resurrection from the dead, Ro 1:4,

but some doubted; or "some of them", as the Syriac and Arabic versions render it; that is, some of the eleven disciples: not that they doubted now that Christ was risen from the dead; since he had appeared several times to them before this, and had given them all the proofs of the truth of his resurrection they could desire; but they, who worshipped him now in Galilee, had doubted before in Jerusalem; not only Thomas, but all of them: they looked upon the words of the women as idle tales; nor did the rest believe the two disciples, with whom Christ travelled to Emmaus: wherefore he upbraids them for their unbelief, Lu 24:11, or else the sense is, that some of them, though they believed Christ was risen from the dead, of which they had had the strongest assurance; yet they doubted whether what they then saw on the mountain was he, or whether it was not a spirit, or a mere phantom; and therefore, as in the next verse, he "came" nearer to them, when they knew him: or else this may be understood of some of the seventy disciples, or of the five hundred brethren, who saw him at this time, and at first had some doubts of his resurrection, but were afterwards fully satisfied.
 
Makedonin,

Every red-herring you have posted has been answered. You have failed to respond to any of these answers. Instead, you just throw up new red-herrings rather than defending what you supposedly believe.

You contradict yourself in what methodologies should be used in different fields of study and then you claim that one set of evidential principles are valid when you use them but are invalid when someone else uses them.

Fortunately for Atanasovski, Philosopher and myself, anyone can go back through this thread and see that.

Bratot,

You raised the issues of technology and how it supposedly contradicts the commandments - I'm still at a loss of what you were originally trying to say. You provided the example of technology being used to bring about temptation (which nobody denies) and then you said that books do that as well. Are you now saying that technology itself is not a bad thing seeing as books have existed for centuries?

Further, none of the laws you provided compel us to disobey God's commandments.

As for your other examples, I think you are relying on Catholic "tradition".

You need to understand that the commandments tell us what is morally good and what is morally bad. Everytime a moral dilemma arises, we have a choice. God gave us free will. We have a choice as to whether we believe in Him or not. We have a choice to either obey his commandments or not.

I'm not here to claim Christians are perfect, far from it. That is the very reason we need to accept Jesus as our God and Saviour.
 
Last edited:
Un pure thoughts is not a sin? Thats the problem with us christians, we pick and choose. I know what you will use as defence "the flesh is weak". Lets get serious and admit its a sin and we always must ask for forgivness and not hide behing scriptures.

I'm not trying to justify sin, and I agree, we always need to ask for forgiveness.

How does that scripture go about removing an eye, its better to go to heavan with one eye, than to not go to heavan at all.
obviously its not literal but there is some meaning to it basicly if you perv.

Yes, it is not literal. It means to remove yourself from situations that you know will cause you to sin.

I am not sure where you are going with this, but you are kidding if you think television does not influence us and we should be able to decern. The biggest problem is the damage gets done from a young age when we are most vulnerable.

if i am way off what you are trying to say, then i apologize for the mis understanding.

Bill77,

I think a human being is more than capable of learning what is right and wrong (according to the Bible) and then applying this in his life. If what you see on TV and what you read has that much influence on you, then why arn't you doing exactly what I tell you to? I'll answer this for you - its because you are using a disengenious argument.
 
Last edited:
i question the "doctrines" implanted in the institutionalized form of Religion (Churches and etc), by greedy, power-hungry (and blinded by satan) people who were "smart" enough to twist, turn and mis-interprate the basics of the Religions.

If you are a genuine Christian, then you should question man-made doctrine and consider the Bible as the only and complete truth in relation to faith.

for examples, this hard core believers on this forum did not even ASKED what am i talking about, mentioning "Makedonianstvo". they claim they are Macedonians and Christians, but dont even bother to ask what is ment with a religious terminology containing the Name of our Nation - Country?

explain.

i ask myself, does some of them have any idea to explain to the people how we reproduced after Adam and Eva?

or it´s "taboo" ???

How do you think.


or how come they ask such un-logic questions about "God of Muslims, God of Jews"?

who mentiones "God of Muslims" and "God of Jews", CAN NOT CALL - CONCIDER HIMSELF CHRISTIAN;

Couse one of the postaments of the Christianity is:

there is ONLY ONE GOD.

should i write it again? :)

or it ring´s a bell already?

When we talk about the 'god of Islam' for example, we mean the way Muslims imagine God to be according to the Koran.
 
ok, one by one

let start with Adam and Eva :)

God created Adam , and later Eva.

They had Children.

Beside the famous Kain and Avel, they had several other children.

Avel was killed.

Kain was the killer.

He runed away with...? (one of his sisters?)

With WHOM Kain had Children? with his Sister?

incest?
 
If you are a genuine Christian, then you should question man-made doctrine and consider the Bible as the only and complete truth in relation to faith.

God is in each of us, couse we are all God´s Children. I have doubts that un-perfect, corrupted people changed the Holy Bible.

the council in Nikea was organized by corrupted people.

PEOPLE decided what Gospels will find their way to the New Testament.

They compiled it.

Why should i believe that they did not deleted or added some things in the New Testament?

I know the Bible not so bad, or to say , i know it pretty much.

There are many un-logic things in the Bible. It´s un-perfect.

Couse it is changed by people. Greedy, sinfull people. :)
 
ok, one by one

let start with Adam and Eva :)

God created Adam , and later Eva.

They had Children.

Beside the famous Kain and Avel, they had several other children.

Avel was killed.

Kain was the killer.

He runed away with...? (one of his sisters?)

With WHOM Kain had Children? with his Sister?

incest?


If we now work totally from Scripture, without any personal prejudices or other extrabiblical ideas, then back at the beginning, when there was only the first generation, brothers would have had to marry sisters or there wouldn’t have been any more generations!

We’re not told when Cain married or many of the details of other marriages and children, but we can say for certain that Cain’s wife was either his sister or a close relative.

A closer look at the Hebrew word for “wife” in Genesis reveals something readers may miss in translation. It was more obvious to those speaking Hebrew that Cain’s wife was likely his sister. (There is a slim possibility that she was his niece, but either way, a brother and sister would have married in the beginning.) The Hebrew word for “wife” used in Genesis 4:17 (the first mention of Cain’s wife) is ishshah, and it means “woman/wife/female.”
And Cain knew his wife [ishshah], and she conceived and bore Enoch. And he built a city, and called the name of the city after the name of his son—Enoch (Genesis 4:17).​
The word ishshah is the word for “woman,” and it means “from man.” It is a derivation of the Hebrew words ‘iysh (pronounced: eesh) and enowsh, which both mean “man.” This can be seen in Genesis 2:23 where the name “woman” (ishshah) is given to one who came from Adam.
And Adam said: “This is now bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh; She shall be called Woman [ishshah], because she was taken out of Man [iysh]” (Genesis 2:23).​
Thus, Cain’s wife is a descendant of Adam/man. Therefore, she had to be his sister (or possibly niece). Hebrew readers should be able to make this connection easier; however, much is lost when translated.
Objections

God’s Laws

Many people immediately reject the conclusion that Adam and Eve’s sons and daughters married each other by appealing to the law against brother-sister marriage. Some say that you can’t marry your relation. Actually, if you don’t marry your relation, you don’t marry a human! A wife is related to her husband before they are married because all people are descendants of Adam and Eve—all are of one blood. This law forbidding close relatives marrying was not given until the time of Moses (Leviticus 18–20). Provided marriage was one man for one woman for life (based on Genesis 1–2), there was no disobedience to God’s law originally (before the time of Moses) when close relatives (even brothers and sisters) married each other.
Remember that Abraham was married to his half-sister (Genesis 20:12). God’s law forbade such marriages, but that was some four hundred years later at the time of Moses.
Biological Deformities

Today, brothers and sisters (and half-brothers and half-sisters, etc.) are not currently permitted by law to marry and have children.

Now it is true that children produced in a union between brother and sister have a greater chance to be deformed. As a matter of fact, the closer the couple are in relationship, the more likely it is that any offspring will be deformed. It is very easy to understand this without going into all the technical details.

Each person inherits a set of genes from his or her mother and father. Unfortunately, genes today contain many mistakes (because of sin and the Curse), and these mistakes show up in a variety of ways. For instance, people let their hair grow over their ears to hide the fact that one ear is lower than the other. Or perhaps someone’s nose is not quite in the middle of his or her face, or someone’s jaw is a little out of shape. Let’s face it, the main reason we call each other normal is because of our common agreement to do so!

The more closely related two people are, the more likely it is that they will have similar mistakes in their genes, inherited from the same parents. Therefore, brother and sister are likely to have similar mistakes in their genetic material. If there were to be a union between these two that produces offspring, children would inherit one set of genes from each of their parents. Because the genes probably have similar mistakes, the mistakes pair together and result in deformities in the children.
Conversely, the further away the parents are in relationship to each other, the more likely it is that they will have different mistakes in their genes. Children, inheriting one set of genes from each parent, are likely to end up with some of the pairs of genes containing only one bad gene in each pair. The good gene tends to override the bad so that a deformity (a serious one, anyway) does not occur. Instead of having totally deformed ears, for instance, a person may have only crooked ones. (Overall, though, the human race is slowly degenerating as mistakes accumulate generation after generation.)

However, this fact of present-day life did not apply to Adam and Eve. When the first two people were created, they were perfect. Everything God made was “very good” (Genesis 1:31). That means their genes were perfect—no mistakes. But when sin entered the world because of Adam (Genesis 3:6), God cursed the world so that the perfect creation then began to degenerate, that is, suffer death and decay (Romans 8:22). Over a long period of time, this degeneration would have resulted in all sorts of mistakes occurring in the genetic material of living things.

But Cain was in the first generation of children ever born. He, as well as his brothers and sisters, would have received virtually no imperfect genes from Adam or Eve, since the effects of sin and the Curse would have been minimal to start with. In that situation, brother and sister could have married (provided it was one man for one woman, which is what marriage is all about, Matthew 19:4–6) without any potential to produce deformed offspring.

By the time of Moses (about 2,500 years later), degenerative mistakes would have accumulated to such an extent in the human race that it would have been necessary for God to bring in the laws forbidding brother-sister (and close relative) marriage (Leviticus 18–20).

(Also, there were plenty of people on the earth by now, and there was no reason for close relations to marry.)

In all, there appear to be three interrelated reasons for the introduction of laws forbidding close intermarriage:
  1. As we have already discussed, there was the need to protect against the increasing potential to produce deformed offspring.
  2. God’s laws were instrumental in keeping the Jewish nation strong, healthy, and within the purposes of God.
  3. These laws were a means of protecting the individual, the family structure, and society at large. The psychological damage caused by incestuous relationships should not be minimized.
http://www.answersingenesis.org/articles/nab/who-was-cains-wife
 
Last edited:
...
When we talk about the 'god of Islam' for example, we mean the way Muslims imagine God to be according to the Koran.

You need to spend a lot of time with Muslims, and learning about Islam, to understand how they imagine / understand God.

Honestly, i don´t think you know much about Islam or any other Religion :)

If i am wrong, pls do not take it offensive, it is simply my opinion , based on what i´ve read from you on this topic.

I will try to help you: Muslims think that "the God of the Christians, the God of the Jews, and their God" is the same God.
 
God is in each of us, couse we are all God´s Children. I have doubts that un-perfect, corrupted people changed the Holy Bible.

the council in Nikea was organized by corrupted people.

PEOPLE decided what Gospels will find their way to the New Testament.

They compiled it.

Why should i believe that they did not deleted or added some things in the New Testament?

I know the Bible not so bad, or to say , i know it pretty much.

There are many un-logic things in the Bible. It´s un-perfect.

Couse it is changed by people. Greedy, sinfull people. :)

We have literally thousands of copies of the Gospels that were made less than 100 years of them being originally written. The council of Nicea did not sit until about 325 AD. There is no way they could have added or deleted anything without scholars knowing about it. Even atheists scholars do not make this claim.

What specifically do you find "illogical" in the Bible?
 
You need to spend a lot of time with Muslims, and learning about Islam, to understand how they imagine / understand God.

Honestly, i don´t think you know much about Islam or any other Religion :)

If i am wrong, pls do not take it offensive, it is simply my opinion , based on what i´ve read from you on this topic.

I will try to help you: Muslims think that "the God of the Christians, the God of the Jews, and their God" is the same God.

I have an MA in Arab and Islamic Studies. I know what Muslims say. However, and this is the thrid time I've repeated this, Muslims do not believe in the Trinity. Christians believe God is one God in three persons - God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit. How can they be the same?
 
this is how i personaly understand that part.

Adam and Eve had their Children.

Kain married his sister. He had children with her.

Story "ends" here. With Incest. The genetic distortions are result of that incest.

Also if Adam and Eva were not a single persons, but a "serial".

It came to incest. We are best proove for that, again the mentioned genetic distortions.
--------------------

If it was right or wrong, i am not the judge to judge them.

God judged them.
 
Back
Top