• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Hellenic religion

In your view, abstract objects and other immaterial things don’t exist without a brain thrown into the mix. A person calls it into existence physically in their brain each time. After this, it ceases to exist when the person is no longer thinking about it - Immaterial things such as abstract objects and laws do not exist until someone, somewhere is thinking about it. This is obviously wrong.
First, if a natural disaster manages to wipe out humanity, does the law of gravity cease to exist? Again, if there is no one around to read about it, does the second law of thermodynamics cease to exist? If no one is around to observe it, is the universe no longer ordered in such a way that it can be expressed mathematically? If a new advanced species evolves on the earth some time after our extinction, although they may not write 7 the way we write it, and although they may not use the decimal system like we choose to, do the mathematical properties of the universe no longer exist? Do “numbers” no longer exist for them to discover? Would they be unable to count the 7 continents of the earth because numbers were buried with us? The answer is no…
Yes the things that carry the information are physical, and offcourse if you damage the brain, the information carrier will cease to exist, but that is not an argument to say that two things are the same thing. That’s like saying the meaning of the writing is the same as the page and the ink. And that is absurd nonsense.

The laws of Gravity and other nature laws are not abstract as you call it. They are very actual and Physical.

The laws of nature are described by Mathematic, which is a language in its own. That is the actual abstraction. The language is learned and imprinted in the neurons of the brain. It exist as physical matter and when electric current flows through it, we see the number 7!

Your notion about other species. They will sure be able to describe actual laws of nature, but with their own abstraction. To that comes, which senses and sensors they have to make observations, so it will be either more accurate or more inaccurate abstracted definition.

So the carrier is gone, what is left are actual laws nature with no abstraction of it, cause there is no one there to abstract them in Ideas and thoughts.

Till the next time another one comes and do the same thing in different way.

I hope you can respond to the comments I made previously. First, presupposing that God exists, why would it be an issue for God to add to himself human nature? Second, why would we have to step outside the bounds of the universe in order to know of Gods existence? If it is no longer a problem for you let me know.


About the form. God can't enter the form. That much is sure, it is like you wearing shoes of 8 size but your foot is of 12 size, even though it is dumb to compare both phenomenons.

He will blow out the rack or bounds of universe, which will destroy Universe ultimately. We are told, that God is born like Human. And we are still there!

Thinkable are proxies, but they should somehow delegate information from this universe to outside and vice versa. Proxy ain't the actual God or Thing, it just delegates information.

But in Gods case, this information he tries to delegate should be somehow transformed into limited Ideas and Images which still ain't God and we can't prove that they come from him!

We can't observe or prove the process, thus it is again only our assumption that those are his words and Ideas. We have to take the so called proxy for his word!

About the second one.

Because it is only a assumption if we don't exit the limited universe, which we can't cause we will cease existing. Until that not happen it is a belief, but not actual knowledge. To know something is to actually observe it, and than make an abstraction or idea to explain it, and since he is out of the universe, we can't observe him, thus everything what we know about him is a belief, Idea, assumption, but in no case knowledge.


Bottom line:

In the science, first is the observation, than it comes the abstraction in form of Mathematical description and model, which not necessary reflects the whole things. There are models which are observed isolated from the world, an idealized form or idea to help us describe things.

In the Religion, we have the abstraction with out actual observation.
 
Last edited:
The language is learned and imprinted in the neurons of the brain. It exist as physical matter and when electric current flows through it, we see the number 7!
Makedonin, it seems you haven’t a clue in the slightest of what you are talking about. Why can’t you understand that I agree with you; The numeral 7 is of the English language and it is learned. But what you cannot seem to grasp is the following analogy - the meaning of the writing is NOT the same as the page and the ink. In the same way, the number is not the same as the language “imprinted on the neurons”. Again, if humanity became extinct and another relatively advanced species evolved, would there no longer be any mathematical laws for them to discover since as you ignorantly believe, they ceased to exist with our physical brains? The language that we have learned would die with us, but the mathematical laws would not cease to exist. The number 7 and the numeral 7 are not the same thing, please grasp this. Again, abstract objects, by definition are actual objects that do not exist at any particular time and place! By definition! That’s why we class them as abstract as opposed to concrete. If by definition they do not exist at any particular time or place, then why would they cease to exist when the human brain is not around to talk about them?
They are very actual and Physical.
As for the law of gravity being physical - You are just speaking nonsense now. The law of gravity is immaterial but for some reason you personally just can’t seem to think past its physical effect.

About the form. God can't enter the form. That much is sure, it is like you wearing shoes of 8 size but your foot is of 12 size, even though it is dumb to compare both phenomenons.
Im sorry Makedonin, that is not an answer. You are speculating to know the mind, ability and power of God. I see no reason here to think that God, The being that supposedly brought all matter, time, space and energy into existence, is somehow unable to, in part, take on human nature. It is not the subtraction of his divine nature, it is the addition of a new nature which he can create.
I completely agree that if in some way God subtracted his infinite nature, added finite nature, and then somehow the man Jesus was able to subtract his finite nature and make himself God again, then this would have been an embarrassment for Christianity for it seems impossible. Just because we cannot add to ourselves the nature of God, or any other nature for that matter, why would this rule apply to God. Being God, Why would it be a problem for him?
Frankly it is not an answer to just say “God can’t enter the form. That much is sure..” without any argument. You have gone from posting page length dribble to worse.

Because it is only a assumption if we don't exit the limited universe, it is a belief, but not actual knowledge. To know something is to actually observe it, and since he is out of the universe, we can't observe him, thus everything what we know about him is a assumption, not knowledge.
Im sorry I have to repeat myself. Why would we have to step outside the bounds of the universe in order to know of Gods existence? Natural theology is an entire branch of theology which is based on reason and ordinary experience. That is from inside our universe. But if God does exist and is interested in us, there is still the possibility that god would reveal himself to us. This is revealed theology which is based on scripture and religious experiences.

A final point, the idea that theism and science are mutually exclusive is terribly mistaken. In fact it is really materialism and science that don’t gel, since materialism undermines science.

Makedonin, when I first engaged with you on this forum I hoped that I would be able to have a stimulating conversation with you. I have quickly lost heart after some of your ignorant responses. I try to anticipate what would be a good objection to something I post, and where the conversation might lead, but with you I find that I simply cannot anticipate the irrational, ignorant and absurd responses.
 
If you are disappointed, it is your problem.

I have been writing so long that I have already lost interest in discussing things with others.

I already saw that you have agreed on some points with me. Should I always tell you that, so that you can feel better?

You have asked questions, I have given some quick response. You are not satisfied? Not my problem.

I don't have time to go on you. I have spent already too much time on this senseless topic anyway!

PS. before you ask question like "Why would we have to step outside the bounds of the universe in order to know of Gods existence?" you first define what you understand under "know".

For me knowledge starts with observation. Can you observe God? Don't think so. In that manner, you can't know God.
 
Last edited:
If you are disappointed, it is your problem.
However frustrating it is dealing with dripple, it is not my problem at the end of the day, it is your world view that is seriously flawed and has crumbled under fire in one short lived interaction...

I don't have time to go on you. I have spent already too much time on this senseless topic anyway!
What could be more important than the topic of God?

For me knowledge starts with observation. Can you observe God? Don't think so. In that manner, you can't know God.
Well known theist and philosopher William Lane Craig humiliates outspoken atheist Peter Atkins, Professor of chemistry at Oxford, in front of an audience of thousands when Atkins raises fallacious/childish arguments like the objection you have raised above - that in order to rationally accept something you must be able to observe it...

YouTube - Dr. William Lane Craig humiliates Dr. Peter Atkins

Do not be afraid of truth as unpopular it might be. Beware that you are not allowing emotionalism to determine your world view.
 
Last edited:
Makedonin,

This is the promised response to your last red-herring.

When I look at the Bible, I don't presuppose that it is the word of God! I look at it as what it is, a compilation of different Books written by different Authors in different Centuries!

I’m not saying scepticism is a bad thing – many Christians began as sceptics and after researching the topic of whether the Bible is the word of God became believers.

The Bible indeed is a compilation of 66 books written by about 40 authors over a period of 1,500 years. The authors were kings, fishermen, priests, government officials, farmers, shepherds, and doctors. We agree on that.

What we disagree on is whether it was inspired by God – to be inspired by God, I mean that the human authors wrote exactly what God wanted them to write, and the result was the perfect and holy Word of God.

The fact that so many people were involved in writing the Bible over such a long period of time and were able to produce the story about God without contradiction indicates that God himself was the real author behind it. Also, the fact that I can cross reference between books written hundreds of years apart and demonstrate how prophecy has been fulfilled also indicates that there was divine authorship.

I think you raise a number of points (among others that I have already responded to):

1. Is there any evidence for the existence of Jesus?

2. The accuracy of the New Testament

3. How can one prove that prophecies from the Bible came true?

Evidence for the existence of Jesus (Biblical and non-Biblical)

To begin with, the vast majority of scholars (Christian and non-Christian) will grant that the Epistles of Paul (at least some of them) were in fact written by Paul in the middle of the first century A.D., less than 40 years after Jesus' death. In terms of ancient manuscript evidence, this is extraordinarily strong proof of the existence of a man named Jesus in Israel in the early first century A.D.

The first-century Roman Tacitus mentioned superstitious “Christians” (from Christus, which is Latin for Christ), who suffered under Pontius Pilate during the reign of Tiberius. Suetonius, chief secretary to Emperor Hadrian, wrote that there was a man named Chrestus (or Christ) who lived during the first century (Annals 15.44).

Flavius Josephus is the most famous Jewish historian. In his Antiquities he refers to James, “the brother of Jesus, who was called Christ.” There is a controversial verse (18:3) that says, “Now there was about this time Jesus, a wise man, if it be lawful to call him a man. For he was one who wrought surprising feats....He was [the] Christ...he appeared to them alive again the third day, as the divine prophets had foretold these and ten thousand other wonderful things concerning him.” One version reads, “At this time there was a wise man named Jesus. His conduct was good and [he] was known to be virtuous. And many people from among the Jews and the other nations became his disciples. Pilate condemned him to be crucified and to die. But those who became his disciples did not abandon his discipleship. They reported that he had appeared to them three days after his crucifixion, and that he was alive; accordingly he was perhaps the Messiah, concerning whom the prophets have recounted wonders.”

Julius Africanus quotes the historian Thallus in a discussion of the darkness which followed the crucifixion of Christ (Extant Writings, 18).

Pliny the Younger, in Letters 10:96, recorded early Christian worship practices including the fact that Christians worshiped Jesus as God and were very ethical, and he includes a reference to the love feast and Lord’s Supper.

The Babylonian Talmud (Sanhedrin 43a) confirms Jesus' crucifixion on the eve of Passover and the accusations against Christ of practicing sorcery and encouraging Jewish apostasy.

Lucian of Samosata was a second-century Greek writer who admits that Jesus was worshiped by Christians, introduced new teachings, and was crucified for them. He said that Jesus' teachings included the brotherhood of believers, the importance of conversion, and the importance of denying other gods. Christians lived according to Jesus’ laws, believed themselves to be immortal, and were characterized by contempt for death, voluntary self-devotion, and renunciation of material goods.

Mara Bar-Serapion confirms that Jesus was thought to be a wise and virtuous man, was considered by many to be the king of Israel, was put to death by the Jews, and lived on in the teachings of His followers.

Then we have all the Gnostic writings (The Gospel of Truth, The Apocryphon of John, The Gospel of Thomas, The Treatise on Resurrection, etc.) that all mention Jesus.

In fact, we can almost reconstruct the gospel just from early non-Christian sources: Jesus was called the Christ (Josephus), did “magic,” led Israel into new teachings, and was hanged on Passover for them (Babylonian Talmud) in Judea (Tacitus), but claimed to be God and would return (Eliezar), which his followers believed, worshipping Him as God (Pliny the Younger).

There is overwhelming evidence for the existence of Jesus Christ, both in secular and biblical history. Perhaps the greatest evidence that Jesus did exist is the fact that literally thousands of Christians in the first century A.D., including the twelve apostles, were willing to give their lives as martyrs for Jesus Christ. People will die for what they believe to be true, but no one will die for what they know to be a lie.

http://gotquestions.org/did-Jesus-exist.html
I want to list five reasons why I think we ought to assume that the gospels are reliable until proven wrong:

1. There was insufficient time for legendary influences to expunge the historical facts. The interval of time between the events themselves and recording of them in the gospels is too short to have allowed the memory of what had or had not actually happened to be erased.

2. The gospels are not analogous to folk tales or contemporary "urban legends." Tales like those of Paul Bunyan and Pecos Bill or contemporary urban legends like the "vanishing hitchhiker" rarely concern actual historical individuals and are thus not analogous to the gospel narratives.

3. The Jewish transmission of sacred traditions was highly developed and reliable. In an oral culture like that of first century Palestine the ability to memorize and retain large tracts of oral tradition was a highly prized and highly developed skill. From the earliest age children in the home, elementary school, and the synagogue were taught to memorize faithfully sacred tradition. The disciples would have exercised similar care with the teachings of Jesus.

4. There were significant restraints on the embellishment of traditions about Jesus, such as the presence of eyewitnesses and the apostles’ supervision. Since those who had seen and heard Jesus continued to live and the tradition about Jesus remained under the supervision of the apostles, these factors would act as a natural check on tendencies to elaborate the facts in a direction contrary to that preserved by those who had known Jesus.

5. The Gospel writers have a proven track record of historical reliability.

I don’t have enough time to talk about all of these. So let me say something about the first and the last points.

1. There was insufficient time for legendary influences to expunge the historical facts.
No modern scholar thinks of the gospels as bald-faced lies, the result of a massive conspiracy. The only place you find such conspiracy theories of history is in sensationalist, popular literature or former propaganda from behind the Iron Curtain. When you read the pages of the New Testament, there’s no doubt that these people sincerely believed in the truth of what they proclaimed. Rather ever since the time of D. F. Strauss, sceptical scholars have explained away the gospels as legends. Like the child’s game of telephone, as the stories about Jesus were passed on over the decades, they got muddled and exaggerated and mythologized until the original facts were all but lost. The Jewish peasant sage was transformed into the divine Son of God.

One of the major problems with the legend hypothesis, however, which is almost never addressed by sceptical critics, is that the time between Jesus’ death and the writing of the gospels is just too short for this to happen. This point has been well-explained by A. N. Sherwin-White in his book Roman Society and Roman Law in the New Testament.

Professor Sherwin-White is not a theologian; he is a professional historian of times prior to and contemporaneous with Jesus. According to Sherwin-White, the sources for Roman and Greek history are usually biased and removed one or two generations or even centuries from the events they record. Yet, he says, historians reconstruct with confidence the course of Roman and Greek history. For example, the two earliest biographies of Alexander the Great were written by Arrian and Plutarch more than 400 years after Alexander’s death, and yet classical historians still consider them to be trustworthy. The fabulous legends about Alexander the Great did not develop until during the centuries after these two writers. According to Sherwin-White, the writings of Herodotus enable us to determine the rate at which legend accumulates, and the tests show that even two generations is too short a time span to allow legendary tendencies to wipe out the hard core of historical facts. When Professor Sherwin-White turns to the gospels, he states that for the gospels to be legends, the rate of legendary accumulation would have to be "unbelievable." More generations would be needed.

In fact, adding a time gap of two generations to Jesus’s death lands you in the second century, just when the apocryphal gospels begin to appear. These do contain all sorts of fabulous stories about Jesus, trying to fill in the years between his boyhood and his starting his ministry, for example. These are the obvious legends sought by the critics, not the biblical gospels.

This point becomes even more devastating for skepticism when we recall that the gospels themselves use sources that go back even closer to the events of Jesus’ life. For example, the story of Jesus’ suffering and death, commonly called the Passion Story, was probably not originally written by Mark. Rather Mark used a source for this narrative. Since Mark is the earliest gospel, his source must be even earlier. In fact, Rudolf Pesch, a German expert on Mark, says the Passion source must go back to at least AD 37, just seven years after Jesus’ death.

Or again, Paul in his letters hands on information concerning Jesus about his teaching, his Last Supper, his betrayal, crucifixion, burial, and resurrection appearances. Paul’s letters were written even before the gospels, and some of his information, for example, what he passes on in his first letter to the Corinthian church about the resurrection appearances, has been dated to within five years after Jesus’ death. It just becomes irresponsible to speak of legends in such cases.

5. The Gospel writers have a proven track record of historical reliability. Again I only have time to look at one example: Luke. Luke was the author of a two-part work: the Gospel of Luke and the Acts of the Apostles. These are really one work and are separated in our Bibles only because the church grouped the gospels together in the New Testament. Luke is the gospel writer who writes most self-consciously as an historian. In the preface to this work he writes:

Inasmuch as many have undertaken to compile a narrative of the things which have been accomplished among us, just as they were delivered to us by those who from the beginning were eyewitnesses and ministers of the word, it seemed good to me also, having followed all things closely for some time past, to write an orderly account for you, most excellent Theophilus, that you may know the truth concerning the things of which you have been informed. (Lk. 1.1-4)

This preface is written in classical Greek terminology such as was used by Greek historians; after this Luke switches to a more common Greek. But he has put his reader on alert that he can write, should he wish to, like the learned historian. He speaks of his lengthy investigation of the story he’s about to tell and assures us that it is based on eyewitness information and is accordingly the truth.

Now who was this author we call Luke? He was clearly not an eyewitness to Jesus’ life. But we discover an important fact about him from the book of Acts. Beginning in the sixteenth chapter of Acts, when Paul reaches Troas in modern-day Turkey, the author suddenly starts using the first-person plural: "we set sail from Troas to Samothrace," "we remained in Philippi some days," "as we were going to the place of prayer," etc. The most obvious explanation is that the author had joined Paul on his evangelistic tour of the Mediterranean cities. In chapter 21 he accompanies Paul back to Palestine and finally to Jerusalem. What this means is that the author of Luke-Acts was in fact in first hand contact with the eyewitnesses of Jesus’ life and ministry in Jerusalem. Sceptical critics have done back-flips to try to avoid this conclusion. They say that the use of the first-person plural in Acts should not be taken literally; it’s just a literary device which is common in ancient sea voyage stories. Never mind that many of the passages in Acts are not about Paul’s sea voyage, but take place on land! The more important point is that this theory, when you check it out, turns out to be sheer fantasy. There just was no literary device of sea voyages in the first person plural—the whole thing has been shown to be a scholarly fiction! There is no avoiding the conclusion that Luke-Acts was written by a travelling companion of Paul who had the opportunity to interview eyewitnesses to Jesus’ life while in Jerusalem. Who were some of these eyewitnesses? Perhaps we can get some clue by subtracting from the Gospel of Luke everything found in the other gospels and seeing what is peculiar to Luke. What you discover is that many of Luke’s peculiar narratives are connected to women who followed Jesus: people like Joanna and Susanna, and significantly, Mary, Jesus’ mother.

Was the author reliable in getting the facts straight? The book of Acts enables us to answer that question decisively. The book of Acts overlaps significantly with secular history of the ancient world, and the historical accuracy of Acts is indisputable. This has recently been demonstrated anew by Colin Hemer, a classical scholar who turned to New Testament studies, in his book The Book of Acts in the Setting of Hellenistic History. Hemer goes through the book of Acts with a fine-toothed comb, pulling out a wealth of historical knowledge, ranging from what would have been common knowledge down to details which only a local person would know. Again and again Luke’s accuracy is demonstrated: from the sailings of the Alexandrian corn fleet to the coastal terrain of the Mediterranean islands to the peculiar titles of local officials, Luke gets it right. According to Professor Sherwin-White, "For Acts the confirmation of historicity is overwhelming. Any attempt to reject its basic historicity even in matters of detail must now appear absurd." The judgement of Sir William Ramsay, the world-famous archaeologist, still stands: "Luke is a historian of the first rank . . . . This author should be placed along with the very greatest of historians." Given Luke’s care and demonstrated reliability as well as his contact with eyewitnesses within the first generation after the events, this author is trustworthy.

On the basis of the five reasons I listed, we are justified in accepting the historical reliability of what the gospels say about Jesus unless they are proven to be wrong. At the very least, we cannot assume they are wrong until proven right. The person who denies the gospels’ reliability must bear the burden of proof.

Now by the very nature of the case, it will be impossible to say a whole lot more beyond this to prove that certain stories in the gospels are historically true. How could you prove, for example, the story of Jesus’ visiting Mary and Martha? You just have here a story told by a reliable author in a position to know and no reason to doubt the historicity of the story. There’s not much more to say.

Nevertheless, for many of the key events in the gospels, a great deal more can be said. What I’d like to do now is take a few of the important aspects of Jesus in the gospels and say a word about their historical credibility.

1. Jesus’ Radical Self-Concept as the Divine Son of God. Radical critics deny that the historical Jesus thought of himself as the divine Son of God. They say that after Jesus’ death, the early church claimed that he had said these things, even though he hadn’t.

The big problem with this hypothesis is that it is inexplicable how monotheistic Jews could have attributed divinity to a man they had known, if he never claimed any such things himself. Monotheism is the heart of the Jewish religion, and it would have been blasphemous to say that a human being was God. Yet this is precisely what the earliest Christians did proclaim and believe about Jesus. Such a claim must have been rooted in Jesus’ own teaching.

And in fact, the majority of scholars do believe that among the historically authentic words of Jesus—these are the words in the gospels which the Jesus Seminar would print in red—among the historically authentic words of Jesus are claims that reveal his divine self-understanding. One could give a whole lecture on this point alone; but let me focus on Jesus’ self-concept of being the unique, divine Son of God.

Jesus’ radical self-understanding is revealed, for example, in his parable of the wicked tenants of the vineyard. Even sceptical scholars admit the authenticity of this parable, since it is also found in the Gospel of Thomas, one of their favourite sources. In this parable, the owner of the vineyard sent servants to the tenants of the vineyard to collect its fruit. The vineyard symbolizes Israel, the owner is God, the tenants are the Jewish religious leaders, and the servants are prophets send by God. The tenants beat and reject the owner’s servants. Finally, the owner says, "I will send my only, beloved son. They will listen to my son." But instead, the tenants kill the son because he is the heir to the vineyard. Now what does this parable tell us about Jesus’ self-understanding? He thought of himself as God’s special son, distinct from all the prophets, God’s final messenger, and even the heir to Israel. This is no mere Jewish peasant!

Jesus’ self-concept as God’s son comes to explicit expression in Matthew 11.27: "All things have been delivered to me by my Father; and no one knows the Son except the Father; and no one knows the Father except the Son and anyone to whom the Son chooses to reveal Him." Again there is good reason to regard this as an authentic saying of the historical Jesus. It is drawn from an old source which was shared by Matthew and Luke, which scholars call the Q document. Moreover, it is unlikely the Church invented this saying because it says that the Son is unknowable—"no one knows the Son except the Father"—, but for the post-Easter church we can know the Son. So this saying is not the product of later Church theology. What does this saying tell us about Jesus’ self-concept? He thought of himself as the exclusive and absolute Son of God and the only revelation of God to mankind! Make no mistake: if Jesus wasn’t who he said he was, he was crazier than David Koresh and Jim Jones put together!

Finally, I want to consider one more saying: Jesus’ saying on the date of his second coming in Mark 13.32: "But of that day or that hour no man knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father." This is an authentic saying of the historical Jesus because the later Church, which regarded Jesus as divine, would never have invented a saying ascribing limited knowledge or ignorance to Jesus. But here Jesus says he doesn’t know the time of his return. So what do we learn from this saying? It not only reveals Jesus’ consciousness of being the one Son of God, but it presents us with an ascending scale from men to the angels to the Son to the Father, a scale on which Jesus transcends any human being or angelic being. This is really incredible stuff! Yet it is what the historical Jesus believed. And this is only one facet of Jesus’ self-understanding. C. S. Lewis was right when he said,

A man who was merely a man and said the sort of things Jesus said would not be a great moral teacher. He would either be a lunatic—on the level with the man who says he is a poached egg—or else he would be the Devil of Hell. You must make your choice. Either this man was and is the Son of God: or else a madman or something worse. You can shut him up for a fool, you can spit at him and kill him as a demon; or you can fall at his feet and call him Lord and God. But let us not come with any patronizing nonsense about his being a great human teacher. He has not left that open to us.

2. Jesus’ Miracles. Even the most sceptical critics cannot deny that the historical Jesus carried out a ministry of miracle-working and exorcism. Rudolf Bultmann, one of the most sceptical scholars this century has seen, wrote back in 1926:

Most of the miracle stories contained in the gospels are legendary or at least are dressed up with legends. But there can be no doubt that Jesus did such deeds, which were, in his and his contemporaries’ understanding, miracles, that is, deeds that were the result of supernatural, divine causality. Doubtless he healed the sick and cast out demons.

Back in Bultmann’s day the miracle stories were thought to be influenced by stories of mythological heroes and, hence, at least in part legendary. But today it is recognized that the hypothesis of mythological influence was historically incorrect. Craig Evans, a well-known Jesus scholar, says that "the older notion" that the miracle stories were the product of mythological divine man ideas "has been largely abandoned." He says, "It is no longer seriously contested" "that miracles played a role in Jesus’ ministry." The only reason left for denying that Jesus performed literal miracles is the presupposition of anti-supernaturalism, which is simply unjustified.

3. Jesus’ Trial and Crucifixion. According to the gospels Jesus was condemned by the Jewish high court on the charge of blasphemy and then delivered to the Romans for execution for the treasonous act of setting himself up as King of the Jews. Not only are these facts confirmed by independent biblical sources like Paul and the Acts of the Apostles, but they are also confirmed by extra-biblical sources. From Josephus and Tacitus, we learn that Jesus was crucified by Roman authority under the sentence of Pontius Pilate. From Josephus and Mara bar Serapion we learn that the Jewish leaders made a formal accusation against Jesus and participated in events leading up to his crucifixion. And from the Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 43a, we learn that Jewish involvement in the trial was explained as a proper undertaking against a heretic. According to Johnson, "The support for the mode of his death, its agents, and perhaps its coagents, is overwhelming: Jesus faced a trial before his death, was condemned and executed by crucifixion." The crucifixion of Jesus is recognized even by the Jesus Seminar as "one indisputable fact."

But that raises the very puzzling question: Why was Jesus crucified? As we have seen, the evidence indicates that his crucifixion was instigated by his blasphemous claims, which to the Romans would come across as treasonous. That’s why he was crucified, in the words of the plaque that was nailed to the cross above his head, as "The King of the Jews." But if Jesus was just a peasant, cynic philosopher, just a liberal social gadfly, as the Jesus Seminar claims, then his crucifixion becomes inexplicable. As Professor Leander Keck of Yale University has said, "The idea that this Jewish cynic (and his dozen hippies) with his demeanor and aphorisms was a serious threat to society sounds more like a conceit of alienated academics than sound historical judgement." New Testament scholar John Meier is equally direct. He says that a bland Jesus who just went about spinning out parables and telling people to look at the lilies of the field-- "such a Jesus," he says, "would threaten no one, just as the university professors who create him threaten no one." The Jesus Seminar has created Jesus who is incompatible with the one indisputable fact of his crucifixion.

4. The resurrection of Jesus. It seems to me that there are four established facts which constitute inductive evidence for the resurrection of Jesus:

Fact #1: After his crucifixion, Jesus was buried by Joseph of Arimathea in the tomb. This fact is highly significant because it means that the location of Jesus’ tomb was known to Jew and Christian alike. In that case it becomes inexplicable how belief in his resurrection could arise and flourish in the face of a tomb containing his corpse. According to the late John A. T. Robinson of Cambridge University, the honorable burial of Jesus is one of "the earliest and best-attested facts about Jesus."

Fact #2: On the Sunday morning following the crucifixion, the tomb of Jesus was found empty by a group of his women followers. According to Jakob Kremer, an Austrian specialist on the resurrection, "By far most exegetes hold firmly to the reliability of the biblical statements concerning the empty tomb." As D. H. van Daalen points out, "It is extremely difficult to object to the empty tomb on historical grounds; those who deny it do so on the basis of theological or philosophical assumptions."

Fact #3: On multiple occasions and under various circumstances, different individuals and groups of people experienced appearances of Jesus alive from the dead. This is a fact that is almost universally acknowledged among New Testament scholars today. Even Gert Lüdemann, perhaps the most prominent current critic of the resurrection, admits, "It may be taken as historically certain that Peter and the disciples had experiences after Jesus’ death in which Jesus appeared to them as the risen Christ."

Finally, fact #4: The original disciples believed that Jesus was risen from the dead despite their having every reason not to. Despite having every predisposition to the contrary, it is an undeniable fact of history that the original disciples believed in, proclaimed, and were willing to go to their deaths for the fact of Jesus’ resurrection. C. F. D. Moule of Cambridge University concludes that we have here a belief which nothing in terms of prior historical influences can account for—apart from the resurrection itself.

Any responsible historian, then, who seeks to give an account of the matter, must deal with these four independently established facts: the honourable burial of Jesus, the discovery of his empty tomb, his appearances alive after his death, and the very origin of the disciples’ belief in his resurrection and, hence, of Christianity itself. I want to emphasize that these four facts represent, not the conclusions of conservative scholars, nor have I quoted conservative scholars, but represent rather the majority view of New Testament scholarship today. The question is: how do you best explain these facts?

Now this puts the sceptical critic in a somewhat desperate situation. For example, some time ago I had a debate with a professor at the University of California, Irvine, on the historicity of the resurrection of Jesus. He had written his doctoral dissertation on the subject and was thoroughly familiar with the evidence. He could not deny the facts of Jesus’s honorable burial, his empty tomb, his post-mortem appearances, and the origin of the disciples’ belief in his resurrection. Therefore, his only recourse was to come up with some alternative explanation of these facts. And so he argued that Jesus had an unknown identical twin brother who was separated from him at birth, came back to Jerusalem just at the time of the crucifixion, stole Jesus’s body out of the grave, and presented himself to the disciples, who mistakenly inferred that Jesus was risen from the dead! Now I won’t go into how I went about refuting his theory, but I think that this theory is instructive because it shows to what desperate lengths skepticism must go in order to deny the historicity of the resurrection of Jesus. In fact, the evidence is so powerful that one of today’s leading Jewish theologians Pinchas Lapide has declared himself convinced on the basis of the evidence that the God of Israel raised Jesus from the dead!

In summary, the gospels are not only trustworthy documents in general, but as we look at some of the most important aspects of Jesus in the gospels, like his radical personal claims, his miracles, his trial and crucifixion, and his resurrection, their historical veracity shines through. God has acted in history, and we can know it.

http://www.reasonablefaith.org/site/News2?page=NewsArticle&id=5207
Greco-Roman historian Michael Grant, who certainly has no theological axe to grind, indicates that there is more evidence for the existence of Jesus than there is for a large number of famous pagan personages - yet no one would dare to argue their non-existence.

Meier [Meie.MarJ, 23] notes that what we know about Alexander the Great could fit on only a few sheets of paper; yet no one doubts that Alexander existed.

Charlesworth has written that "Jesus did exist; and we know more about him than about almost any Palestinian Jew before 70 C.E." [Chars.JesJud, 168-9]

Sanders [Sand.HistF, xiv] echoes Grant, saying that "We know a lot about Jesus, vastly more than about John the Baptist, Theudas, Judas the Galilean, or any of the other figures whose names we have from approximately the same date and place."

On the Crucifixion, Harvey writes: "It would be no exaggeration to say that this event is better attested, and supported by a more impressive array of evidence, than any other event of comparable importance of which we have knowledge from the ancient world." [Harv.JesC, 11]

Dunn [Dunn.EvJ, 29] provides an anecdote similar to the one above regarding Shakespeare. Referring to Wells' thesis, he writes:

The alternative thesis is that within thirty years there had evolved such a coherent and consistent complex of traditions about a non-existent figure such as we have in the sources of the Gospels is just too implausible. It involves too many complex and speculative hypotheses, in contrast to the much simpler explanation that there was a Jesus who said and did more or less what the first three Gospels attribute to him. The fact of Christianity's beginnings and the character of its earliest tradition is such that we could only deny the existence of Jesus by hypothesizing the existence of some other figure who was a sufficient cause of Christianity's beginnings - another figure who on careful reflection would probably come out very like Jesus!

Finally, here are these words from a hardened skeptic and an Emeritus Professor of History, the late Morton Smith [Hoff.JesH, 47-8] . Of Wells' work, this historian and skeptic of orthodox Christianity wrote:

"I don't think the arguments in (Wells') book deserve detailed refutation."
"...he argues mainly from silence."
"...many (of his arguments) are incorrect, far too many to discuss in this space."
"(Wells) presents us with a piece of private mythology that I find incredible beyond anything in the Gospels."

None of these scholars, we emphasize, are friends of fundamentalism or evangelical Christianity. Contrary to the protestations of the "Jesus-myth" proponents, they make their statements based on evidence, not ideology.

the fact that we have as much information as we do about Jesus from non-Christian sources is amazing in itself. Meier [Meie.MarJ, 7-9] and Harris [Harr.3Cruc, 24-27] have indicated several reasons why Jesus remained a "marginal Jew" about whom we have so little information:

1. As far as the historians of the day were concerned, he was just a "blip" on the screen. Jesus was not considered to be historically significant by historians of his time. He did not address the Roman Senate, or write extensive Greek philosophical treatises; He never travelled outside of the regions of Palestine, and was not a member of any known political party. It is only because Christians later made Jesus a "celebrity" that He became known.

Sanders, comparing Jesus to Alexander, notes that the latter "so greatly altered the political situation in a large part of the world that the main outline of his public life is very well known indeed. Jesus did not change the social, political and economic circumstances in Palestine (Note: It was left for His followers to do that!) ..the superiority of evidence for Jesus is seen when we ask what he thought." [Sand.HistF, 3]

Harris adds that "Roman writers could hardly be expected to have foreseen the subsequent influence of Christianity on the Roman Empire and therefore to have carefully documented" Christian origins. How were they to know that this minor Nazarene prophet would cause such a fuss?

2. Jesus was executed as a criminal, providing him with the ultimate marginality. This was one reason why historians would have ignored Jesus. He suffered the ultimate humiliation, both in the eyes of Jews (Deut. 21:23 - Anyone hung on a tree is cursed!) and the Romans (He died the death of slaves and rebels.).

On the other hand, Jesus was a minimal threat compared to other proclaimed "Messiahs" of the time. Rome had to call out troops to quell the disturbances caused by the unnamed Egyptian referenced in the Book of Acts [Sand.HistF, 51] . In contrast, no troops were required to suppress Jesus' followers.

To the Romans, the primary gatekeepers of written history at the time, Jesus during His own life would have been no different than thousands of other everyday criminals that were crucified.

3. Jesus marginalized himself by being occupied as an itinerant preacher. Of course, there was no Palestine News Network, and even if there had been one, there were no televisions to broadcast it. Jesus never used the established "news organs" of the day to spread His message. He travelled about the countryside, avoiding for the most part (and with the exception of Jerusalem) the major urban centers of the day. How would we regard someone who preached only in sites like, say, Hahira, Georgia?

4. Jesus' teachings did not always jibe with, and were sometimes offensive to, the established religious order of the day. It has been said that if Jesus appeared on the news today, it would be as a troublemaker. He certainly did not make many friends as a preacher.

5. Jesus lived an offensive lifestyle and alienated many people. He associated with the despised and rejected: Tax collectors, prostitutes, and the band of fishermen He had as disciples.

6. Jesus was a poor, rural person in a land run by wealthy urbanites. Yes, class discrimination was alive and well in the first century also!

A final consideration is that we have very little information from first-century sources to begin with. Not much has survived the test of time from A.D. 1 to today. Blaiklock has cataloged the non-Christian writings of the Roman Empire (other than those of Philo) which have survived from the first century and do not mention Jesus. These items are:


  • An amateurish history of Rome by Vellius Paterculus, a retired army officer of Tiberius. It was published in 30 A.D., just when Jesus was getting started in His ministry.
  • An inscription that mentions Pilate.
  • Fables written by Phaedrus, a Macedonian freedman, in the 40s A.D.
  • From the 50s and 60s A.D., Blaiklock tells us: "Bookends set a foot apart on this desk where I write would enclose the works from these significant years." Included are philosophical works and letters by Seneca; a poem by his nephew Lucan; a book on agriculture by Columella, a retired soldier; fragments of the novel Satyricon by Gaius Petronius; a few lines from a Roman satirist, Persius; Pliny the Elder's Historia Naturalis; fragments of a commentary on Cicero by Asconius Pedianus, and finally, a history of Alexander the Great by Quinus Curtius.
Of all these writers, only Seneca may have conceivably had reason to refer to Jesus. But considering his personal troubles with Nero, it is doubtful that he would have had the interest or the time to do any work on the subject.

  • From the 70s and 80s A.D., we have some poems and epigrams by Martial, and works by Tacitus (a minor work on oratory) and Josephus (Against Apion, Wars of the Jews). None of these would have offered occasion to mention Jesus.
  • From the 90s, we have a poetic work by Statius; twelve books by Quintillian on oratory; Tacitus' biography of his father-in-law Agricola, and his work on Germany. [Blaik.MM, 13-16]

To this Meier adds [ibid., 23] that in general, knowledge of the vast majority of ancient peoples is "simply not accessible to us today by historical research and never will be." It is just as was said in his earlier comment on Alexander the Great: What we know of most ancient people as individuals could fit on just a few pieces of paper.
Thus it is misguided for to say that we know so little about the historical Jesus, and have so little recorded about Him in ancient pagan sources. Compared to most ancient people, we know quite a lot about Jesus, and have quite a lot recorded about Him!
http://www.tektonics.org/jesusexist/jexfound.html
Further information: http://www.carm.org/non-biblical-accounts-new-testament-events-andor-people


The Accuracy of the New Testament

None of the gospels mention the destruction of the Jewish temple in 70 A.D. This is significant because Jesus had prophesied its destruction when He said, "As for these things which you are looking at, the days will come in which there will not be left one stone upon another which will not be torn down," (Luke 21:6, see also Matt. 24:1; Mark 13:1). This prophecy was fulfilled in 70 A.D. when the Romans sacked Jerusalem and burned the Temple. The gold in the Temple melted down between the stone walls and the Romans took the walls apart, stone by stone, to get the melted gold. Such an obvious fulfillment of Jesus' prophecy most likely would have been recorded by the gospel writers if they had been written after 70 A.D. Also, if the gospels were fabrications of mythical events then anything to bolster the Messianic claims -- such as the destruction of the temple as Jesus prophesied -- would surely have been included. But, it was not included suggesting that the gospels (at least Matthew, Mark, and Luke) were written before 70 A.D.

Similarly, this argument is important when we consider the dating of the book of Acts which was written after the gospel of Luke by Luke himself. Acts is a history of the Christian church right after Jesus' ascension. Acts also fails to mention the incredibly significant events of 70 A.D. which would have been extremely relevant and prophetically important and naturally would have garnered inclusion into Acts had it occurred before Acts was written. Remember, Acts is a book of the history of the early Christian church. The fact that the incredibly significant destruction of Jerusalem and the Temple is not recorded is very strong evidence that Acts was written before A.D. 70. If we add to this the fact that Acts does not include the accounts of "Nero's persecution of the Christians in A.D. 64 or the deaths of James (A.D. 62), Paul (A.D. 64), and Peter (A.D. 65)," and we have further evidence that it was written very early and not long after Jesus' ascension into heaven.

If we look at Acts 1:1-2 it says, "The first account I composed, Theophilus, about all that Jesus began to do and teach, 2 until the day when He was taken up, after He had by the Holy Spirit given orders to the apostles whom He had chosen." Most scholars affirm that Acts was written by Luke and that Theophilus (Grk. "lover of God") "may have been Luke’s patron who financed the writing of Luke and Acts." This means that the gospel of Luke was written before Acts.

· "At the earliest, Acts cannot have been written prior to the latest firm chronological marker recorded in the book—Festus’s appointment as procurator (24:27), which, on the basis of independent sources, appears to have occurred between A.D. 55 and 59."

· "It is increasingly admitted that the Logia [Q] was very early, before 50 A.D., and Mark likewise if Luke wrote the Acts while Paul was still alive. Luke's Gospel comes before the Acts (Acts 1:1). The date of Acts is still in dispute, but the early date (about A.D. 63) is gaining support constantly."

For clarity, Q is supposedly one of the source documents used by both Matthew and Luke in writing their gospels. If Q actually existed then that would push the first writings of Christ's words and deeds back even further lessening the available time for myth to creep in and adding to the validity and accuracy of the gospel accounts. If what is said of Acts is true, this would mean that Luke was written at least before A.D. 63 and possibly before 55 - 59 since Acts is the second in the series of writings by Luke. This means that the gospel of Luke was written within 30 years of Jesus' death.

http://www.carm.org/apologetics/evidence-and-answers/when-were-gospels-written-and-whom
The bible describes places, people, and events in various degrees of detail. It is essentially an historical account of the people of God throughout thousands of years. If you open to almost any page in the Bible you will find a name of a place and/or a person. Much of this can be verified from archaeology. Though archaeology cannot prove that the Bible is the inspired word of God, it has the ability to prove whether or not some events and locations described therein are true or false. So far, however, there isn't a single archaeological discovery that disproves the Bible in any way.

Nevertheless, many people used to think that the Bible had numerous historical errors in it such as Luke's account of Lysanias being the tetrarch of Abiline in about 27 AD (Luke 3:1). For years scholars used this "factual error" to prove Luke was wrong because it was common knowledge that Lysanias was not a tetrarch, but the ruler of Chalcis about 50 years earlier than what Luke described. But, an archaeological inscription was found that said Lysanias was the tetrarch in Abila near Damascus at the time that Luke said. It turns out that there had been two people name Lysanias and Luke had accurately recorded the facts.

Also, the walls of Jericho have been found, destroyed just as the Bible says. Many critics doubted that Nazareth ever existed, yet archaeologists have found a first-century synagogue inscription at Caesarea that has verified its existence. Finds have verified the existence of Herod the Great and his son Herod Antipas. The remains of the Apostle Peter's house have been found at Capernaum. Bones with nail scars through the wrists and feet have been uncovered as well demonstrating the actuality of crucifixion. The High Priest Caiaphas' bones have been discovered in an ossuary (a box used to store bones).

There is, of course, a host of archaeological digs that corroborate biblical records on places such as Bethsaida, Bethany, Caesarea Philippi, Capernaum, Cyprus, Galatia, Philippi, Thessalonica, Berea, Athens, Corinth, Ephesus, Rome, etc.

http://www.carm.org/can-we-trust-new-testament-historical-document
Finally, a brief word on prophecy. I’ll give you one to grapple with. The prophet Isaiah, writing about 700 B.C., names Cyrus as the king who will say to Jerusalem that it shall be built and that the Temple foundation shall be laid (Isaiah 44:28; 54:1).

At the time of Isaiah's writing, the city of Jerusalem was already fully built and the entire temple was standing.

Over 100 years later, in 586 B.C., the city and Temple were destroyed by King Nebuchadnezzar.

After Jerusalem was taken by the Babylonians, it was conquered by the Persians in about 539 B.C. Shortly after that, a Persian king named Cyrus gave the decree to rebuild the Temple in Jerusalem. This was around 160 years after the prophecy of Isaiah!

Thus Isaiah predicted that a man named Cyrus, who would not be born for about a hundred years, would give the command to rebuild the Temple, which was still standing in Isaiah's day and would not be destroyed for more than a hundred years.
 
Last edited:
What could be more important than the topic of God?


Do not be afraid of truth as unpopular it might be. Beware that you are not allowing emotionalism to determine your world view.

You ask what is more important than God? My real life, my Family and the rest of it!

Do you have life out of that what you do here? I do, and it needs my attention and care! You should get yourself Life out of the kake you babble!

In the short Random interaction I had with you, you think you know me or anything about my world view. You sure jump on conclusion. How old are you? 10!

I ain't afraid of the truth, and I surely did Not See any presented by you! I did not go emotional, I was serious! It is your Problem what you think of what I said, and that is certainly was not the Best articulated by me, but if I get to spend my time to chew for you and Write assays, what is I to get out of it? Will you pay the Time I invest inthat? Get real, we are on forum and Not on the Academy!

I gave you small insights and you think you accomplished crushing something, the joke of the Day!

Sayonara Smart Ass !
 
Vangelovski, chill out dude, you take some People to seriously.

Use your Head and produce something your self, don't repeate others thoughts and View. Grow your self Balls and Look at the World with your eyes, not with someones elses. You will spend your Life trying to prove someones elses thoughts and miss the whole Life. When you get older, you will regret it, mark my words.

Spare me the copy paste and don't talk to me again.
 
Vangelovski, chill out dude, you take some People to seriously.

Use your Head and produce something your self, don't repeate others thoughts and View. Grow your self Balls and Look at the World with your eyes, not with someones elses. You will spend your Life trying to prove someones elses thoughts and miss the whole Life. When you get older, you will regret it, mark my words.

Spare me the copy paste and don't talk to me again.

Makedonin,

You came on here making huge claims about the inaccuracy of the Bible and questioning the very existence of Jesus and now that I provide you with evidence, that is your response???
 
Makedonin,

You came on here making huge claims about the inaccuracy of the Bible and questioning the very existence of Jesus and now that I provide you with evidence, that is your response???

Learn what evidence really means how is to be Provided and than collect some and show it here, than and only than maybe we can come to tems to discuss. If I have Time, that is.

No Religion have yet Provided reproducable evidence as Science has done.


Give it a rest dude. Get your self à real life and Start to use your head.
 
Last edited:
Learn what evidence really means how is to be Provided and than collect some and show it here, than and only than maybe we can come to tems to discuss. If I have Time, that is.

No Religion have yet Provided reproducable evidence as Science has done.


Give it a rest dude. Get your self à real life and Start to use your head.

Makedonin,

Perhaps you can inform us of what constitutes evidence in your own mind because clearly you dismiss what constitutes evidence in the fields of science (you have contradicted yourself here), history, philosophy and archeaology (noting the fundamental differences in each) OR you have not bothered to read or listen to anything already provided.

Your suggestion that scienfic principles of evidence relate to ALL fields is ridiculous. How can the principle of observation and repetition be applied to history for example? What you are basically saying is that we can only prove something happened (i.e., that Alexander the Great did in fact exist) if we can observe it and repeat it. That may apply for the laws of nature, but to suggest that in order to prove Alexander the Great actually once lived we would have to observe/witness his life and then be able to repeat his life is absolute nonsense.

Or maybe it is that you just do not have a rebuttle to what has been provided and it has brought your own world view into question?
 
Last edited:
Vangelovski, I asked you to give it a rest!

I don't intend to go on to your questions or "evidence".

I told you already, move a Mountain, or bring a dead of my choice to an life, than I will throw my self on my knees before your God!

Before that happen, I ain't interest in your "evidence" or what you have to preach, cause you fart hot air, as any other of your kind does.


But just for clarity, I will post the simplified way how Hawking's defined a scientific theory and what it is based on! I won't use my interpretation, cause I want to save me the time writting consistent description.

In order to talk about the nature of the universe and to discuss questions
such as whether it has a beginning or an end, you have to be clear about
what a scientific theory is. I shall take the simpleminded view that a
theory is just a model of the universe, or a restricted part of it, and a
set of rules that relate quantities in the model to observations that we
make. It exists only in our minds and does not have any other reality
(whatever that might mean). A theory is a good theory if it satisfies two
requirements. It must accurately describe a large class of observations on
the basis of a model that contains only a few arbitrary elements, and it
must make definite predictions about the results of future observations.
For
example, Aristotle believed Empedocles's theory that everything was made out
of four elements, earth, air, fire, and water. This was simple enough, but
did not make any definite predictions. On the other hand, Newton's theory of
gravity was based on an even simpler model, in which bodies attracted each
other with a force that was proportional to a quantity called their mass and
inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them. Yet it
predicts the motions of the sun, the moon, and the planets to a high degree
of accuracy.
Any physical theory is always provisional, in the sense that it is only a
hypothesis: you can never prove it. No matter how many times the results of
experiments agree with some theory, you can never be sure that the next time
the result will not contradict the theory. On the other hand, you can
disprove a theory by finding even a single observation that disagrees with
the predictions of the theory. As philosopher of science Karl Popper has
emphasized, a good theory is characterized by the fact that it makes a
number of predictions that could in principle be disproved or falsified by
observation. Each time new experiments are observed to agree with the
predictions the theory survives, and our confidence in it is increased; but
if ever a new observation is found to disagree, we have to abandon or modify
the theory.

At least that is what is supposed to happen, but you can always question the
competence of the person who carried out the observation.
In practice, what often happens is that a new theory is devised that is
really an extension of the previous theory. For example, very accurate
observations of the planet Mercury revealed a small difference between its
motion and the predictions of Newton's theory of gravity. Einstein's general
theory of relativity predicted a slightly different motion from Newton's
theory. The fact that Einstein's predictions matched what was seen, while
Newton's did not, was one of the crucial confirmations of the new theory.
However, we still use Newton's theory for all practical purposes because the
difference between its predictions and those of general relativity is very
small in the situations that we normally deal with.

A Brief History of Time!
Stephen Hawking's

You leck empirical evidence, which can be reproduced, but you have theory! In other words, your belif is another theory, which is not based on observation. You can't observe God! If you insist that you can, than provide how you do that! Which means or instruments you are using. Unlike scientific theories, your Dogma is meant to be everlasting and can't be proved and disproved, we have to believe in it!

And just to add the clarification what empirical evidence is:
Miriam Webster online dictionary empirical means:
1 : originating in or based on observation or experience 2 : relying on experience or observation alone often without due regard for system and theory 3 : capable of being verified or disproved by observation or experiment

The diference between your view of the world and mine is simple: I have a dynamic view of the world. I don't presupose anything and am ready to learn. If some theory is disproved, I don't go to the ground, as your comrade Atanasovski wanted to state. In a dynamic world, no knowlege is static and finit or complete. On the other side, your view is static. You have attached your self to a book, and are on the quest of proving it's consistency! In a dynamic world to have a static view can be devastating.


And just to correct your false statement from the other post of yours, I never said that God does not exist, show me where I did that. Nither any real scientist does that. Science is not really concernedwith God, cause it can't observe him, not yet!
 
Last edited:
In other words, your belif is another theory, which is not based on observation. You can't observe God! If you insist that you can, than provide how you do that! Which means or instruments you are using. Unlike scientific theories, your Dogma is meant to be everlasting and can't be proved and disproved, we have to believe in it!
There are so many things that cannot be "observed" but are all rational to believe. The idea that you need to observe something before being able to rationally believe it is nonsense. I bet that i could list a number of things that you have rationally believed even though they simply cannot be scientifically proven. Not that i dont think there is a scientific/emperical evidence in the case for christianity.

The diference between your view of the world and mine is simple: I have a dynamic view of the world. I don't presupose anything and am ready to learn.
Your world view is already broken internally because it undermines science. If there is no god, your beliefs and scientific theories are ultimately the results of the motions of atoms in your brain produced by an unguided, random, mindless process. Why should you believe them? What makes anything you think true or rational? In fact, there is no sense to speak of rationality and truth. In his book the god delusion, Dawkins admits that in the absence of God there are no absolutes. The example he uses is 911. There is no sense in saying that it was right or wrong - the terrorists were simply “dancing to their DNA.” On atheism, you are just an unguided, random, mindless bio-chemical machine evolved on a spec of dust lost in a hostile and mindless universe. We are all just the atoms, dancing/fizzing/moving about. Why should we believe the illusory meanings of life and understanding of the universe? The reason theism doesn't have this problem is because there is the foundational presupposition that the universe is rationally intelligible since it was created by the rational mind of God.
 
Last edited:
There are so many things that cannot be "observed" but are all rational to believe.
.....
Dawkins admits that in the absence of God there are no absolutes.
The example he uses is 911. There is no sense in saying that it was right or wrong - the terrorists were simply “dancing to their DNA.”
I never said that God don't exist or exists! To know God is to observe him, which you can't! That is why you talk about belief, it is assumption, an Idea which is not based on observation!

It may be rational to believe that God exists, but which will be the right rationality?! Yours?

The things you say that are "rational" to believe are "rational" to you, but not to milions others!

That is why you have so many belief systems! There will never be a consensus on what is "rational" to believe or not!

Philosophers, Religious People will or will not agree upon what you think it is "rational" to believe!

What Dawkins said is true, there is no absolute in this universe! Everything is changing! Only you hang on some static dogmatic knowledge which will not change! And you dare talking about my world view! Pathetic!

The 911 terrorists did that because for them exactly that was "rational" to believe!
Israelites were "told to do" similar things by God! (Deuteronomy 20:17) Why do you say their deeds were wrong? Is it not "rational" to believe for you? Don't be a child!

You don't have to go to the core of the atom!

PS. I get to kick this habit of mine replying to you! It costs me money!
 
Last edited:
Yes, it is true that not all philosophers and scientists share a common world view. That alone is enough to show that it’s simply not the case that atheism is some sort of proven world view and that only religious nuts hold onto theistic views.
At the end of the day, only one of them is correct and what we have both been trying to establish here is that one of our world views is less rational to believe. So far it appears that the "dynamic" or should i say "illusory" world view that you have created for yourself is moot.

Let’s have a look at your beliefs from our discussion:
1. Everything in this universe has a physical “form” - WRONG
2. Everything in the universe occupies space - WRONG
3. Everything in the universe is in time - WRONG
4. If God exists, it would not be possible for Him to become the man Jesus – WRONG
5. We have to go outside of the “bounds” of the universe in order to know God – WRONG
6. In order to know something is true you must be able to observe it AND it must be reproducible – WRONG

I have also stated that in the absence of God there are no absolutes. There is no truth - You agree.

Your world view is internally incoherent since it undermines logic and science - you seem to agree with this too.

Moving on, if the Christian God does exist, then your beliefs and views are simply wrong. But the hilarious thing about this is that in your world view, if God does not exist, your beliefs and views are still only an illusion since there is no real truth, it is "dynamic" and relative - Anything you have observed and accepted as true is no more rational/true/logically coherent than someones belief that they are, well i dont know, anything, they may decide to believe that they are themselves dreaming the world into existence and controlling the universe with their mind.
 
Last edited:
That alone is enough to show that it’s simply not the case that atheism is some sort of proven world view and that only religious nuts hold onto theistic views.

Who is here atheist. Drop your sun glasses and stop puting me in categories where I don't belong!

You can't get that in your thick head, do you?

All I am saing that you have no basis to claim that the Bible is the word of God, as well as any other religious book! As you say your self, about atheism, it is the same case for theism, but you dogmatically prefer to claim it as some "proven" world view!

So, I am off, you have no legitimity to say anything about God, cause you don't know him (can't observe him), and have no basis on which you claim your knowledge about God, i.e. some book ("rational" believe)!

Sayonara!
 
Vankelovski have a look at this i read your material check this out.

watch


watch
 
Last edited:
Makedonin,

In response to your post about scientific theories and observation - I agree. I never questioned that as the scientific method for specific fields such as physics.

I asked you how that methodology relates to the fields of history, philosophy, and archaeology? You implied that what constitutes evidence in the scientific fields must also constitute evidence in all other fields. And you implied this by dismissing the historical, archaeological and philisophical evidence that I provided as not being "observable" and "reproducable", a methodology appropriate to 'prove' the laws of nature, but not historical events or the accuracy of historical documents.
 
Last edited:
Makedonin,

In response to your post about scientific theories and observation - I agree. I never questioned that as the scientific method for specific fields such as physics.

I asked you how that methodology relates to the fields of history, philosophy, and archaeology? You implied that what constitutes evidence in the scientific fields must also constitute evidence in all other fields. And you implied this by dismissing the historical, archaeological and philisophical evidence that I provided as not being "observable" and "reproducable", a methodology appropriate to 'prove' the laws of nature, but not historical events or the accuracy of historical documents.

But that is how it goes, historians rely on archeology and provided documents! Archeology relies on provided documents and makes assumption and trys to make findings upon those assumptions! New documents and archeological findings (the observation) prove or disprove some theories which were put forward by previous historians! Every new evidence is to be reexamined and compared with the theory if it still fits. Where would the Macedonians be if we did not reexamined those sources etc? That is also what happened with the Slavic migration theory etc.

On the scale of natural science and accuracy, history is before philosophy of science while philosophy is the last of them and I don't even count it as science! The brunch philosophy of science is concerned with the assumptions, foundations, methods and implications of science. But it never preaches dogma!

Begining with History, they are prone to manipulation (the Greek case) and it is hard to prove much, cause the interpretation of the material is based or poluted by individuals motives!

In order to fill the gaps they have in their theories, they enter the realm of the mentioned "rational" belief, which is more than obvious that does not function, that is why so many historians or philosophs tend to disagree with one another, thus build camps based on their motives, the Stephan Miller case!

The religion can't be even seen as a science, cause it utterly rely on the "rational" belief realm, which may or may not produce some valid points, and are prone to be manipulated to the core! If we say, it produces some "rational" things we can believe, who is to decide which are those things? Are we to go by numbers of followers who accept or don't accept what seems to be "rational"? That is what religious people do all the time! That is why we have so many religious beliefs, and recruiting of religious followers all around the world! Is that accurate? In no way! The prove is found in the fact that even the same book, say the Bible or the Quran, is interpreted differently by different members of different brunches!

Religious belief is something that each individual decides for it self, and that is mostly based on the background and cultural environment this individual comes from. It is more than obvious!
 
Last edited:
Makedonin,

It now appears that you do accept historical (documentary and archaeological) evidence.

So back to the original question - among all the claims that you made, one was that there is no evidence (outside of the Bible) that Jesus even existed. I provided you with excerpts from contemporary (non-Biblical, Jewish and non-Jewish) writers that demonstrate otherwise. You rejected the information provided by these contemporary writers on the basis that historical documents do not fit into the methodological criteria that you would use for, say physics (observation and repetition) and therefore do not constitute evidence.

Seeing as you have backflipped on this, do you now accept that along with the Biblical record, there were also non-Biblical documents that record the life of Jesus?

Finally, rather than throwing in more red-herrings, you should try to deal with the multiple issues that you have already raised and have been found lacking.
 
Makedonin,

It now appears that you do accept historical (documentary and archaeological) evidence.

So back to the original question - among all the claims that you made, one was that there is no evidence (outside of the Bible) that Jesus even existed. I provided you with excerpts from contemporary (non-Biblical, Jewish and non-Jewish) writers that demonstrate otherwise. You rejected the information provided by these contemporary writers on the basis that historical documents do not fit into the methodological criteria that you would use for, say physics (observation and repetition) and therefore do not constitute evidence.

Seeing as you have backflipped on this, do you now accept that along with the Biblical record, there were also non-Biblical documents that record the life of Jesus?

Finally, rather than throwing in more red-herrings, you should try to deal with the multiple issues that you have already raised and have been found lacking.

I told you that history is inaccurate. Second history must be backed up by archeology to gain some credibility! You seem that you avoided that part of my post!

Are there archeological findings that he was existent as a person? Or just some historical books? There are some serious reasons why some of those books ain't telling what you read in there! See the links I posted below!

Books are not enough! I know of none archeological findings proving that he existed as person. It is not enough to show some archeological findings that some places mentioned in the Bible are proven to exist! For other books, there are similar proofs! Not even the Caiaphas Tomb is prove of his existence as a person! People who were writting the NT had the means to know who Caiaphas was! He was the high priest after all! Other Books have their own archeological evidence of this caliber!

So what are you accusing me of!?

As I said there is no empirical evidence for Jessus existence as person. That does not means that there will be none in the future.

If there will be some archeological evidence to substanciate his existence as person, we will than have to find empirical evidence that those who wrote about him told the truth about his deeds! That is also important, cause religious people tend to exaggerate things and blow them out of proportions!

For now, it is a fact that all those who wrote about him had many motives to tell the story they told us. There are other Gospels who wrote about Jesus, but they bring different light on him!
All of them even might believed what they wrote, but there are many cases of notorious liars believing their stories. Their belief in the story ain't empirical evidence.

If I would be like you, and foreward with the "evidence" you like to use here, I will put you the following readings which disclaim your "evidence":

http://www.jesuspuzzle.humanists.net/jhcjp.htm

http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/scott_oser/hojfaq.html

http://www.bandoli.no/historicalrecords.htm

http://www.rationalresponders.com/silence_screams_no_contemporary_historical_accounts_quotjesus

http://www.godwouldbeanatheist.com/2problem/202jesus.htm


We can wage a war all day long like that, we won't come to consensus, and on the end of the day, we lose money cause not doing our jobs! If I would be stupid enough, I would spend my life debating with you. You ain't worth it!

It is like some drug you pouring in here!

So let it be, hold on to your belief, don't bother me, you ain't gonna turn me or anyone else over! That does not mean that I don't like the described character of Jesus, but that is another story!

Give it a rest!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top