aleksandrov
New member
"For you to claim" doesn't mean you do, it was said as a condition and it can be general to 'anyone' to claim the same thing.
I precizely explained the 'purity' claim and where it stands in the claims of genetical continuity but maybe your lack of logic and vanity doesn't go together.
I wonder why I had the feeling that I was talking to his advocate.
Continue with your advocacy and do what pleases you, you might be still incapable to understand anything from what I tried to explain in very simple way but you also might be pigheaded on this subject because it suits to you this way.
'Your' - plural, also directed to you since you started your ongoin advocacy of somebody else's statement.
dogmatism
1. a statement of a point of view as if it were an established fact.
2. the use of a system of ideas based upon insufficiently examined premises. — dogmatist, n. — dogmatic, adj
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/dogmatism
lol .. ask your friend and then claim continuity on his behalf.
It was a friendly instruction in order to prevent the idiocity of the 'continuity' and I think you should ask Indigen what is native and what foreign even though I would expect from you to know it already since you are so vocal in his advocacy about the "genetical continuity".
It;s a derevative of "your" concept of 'continuity'.
Aleksandrov,
a friendly remark, first of all you have no idea at all what you are talking about but you are persistent in doing that. Secondly, you opposed me on this subject not because you agree with Indigen but because you tend to disagree with TM, irrespective of what argumentation is given
Pozdrav,
Mihail
Mihail,
I don't mean to be unfriendly, but your offensive arrogance in a situation where you clearly are not making logical sense is getting a bit too much. I suggest that you carefully re-read all of the relevant posts from the point at which you supported TM in baselessly accusing Indigen of having made a claim to 'genetic purity', and perhaps get somebody to help you with English comprehension, before you continue to open yourself up to ridicule.
I would hate to have to start reposting everything from the beginning, for the benefit of those who may be becoming more confused about the basis for this argument with each of your subsequent nonsensical posts. I suspect that these comments will bruise your ego even more than it is currently bruised, and will make you come back with more spiteful 'inaetenje', but if you take some deep breaths and try to think prudently and rationally about what you are reading and writing you might be able to do yourself a favor by avoiding that. This is my idea of honestly friendly advice. I would offer the same advice to my brother, father, mother, wife, children and best friends, in the given circumstances.
Pozdrav,
And two questions to make the long story short, if you will be kind to answer, do you consider yourself to be a DIRECT descedant of the ancient Macedonians?
Firstly, this is not something that I concern myself with. Secondly, I am not quite sure what 'DIRECT' is supposed to mean in this context. If it means that I have a family tree that I can trace back to the ancient Macedonians, my answer is no. That's why I made a HYPOTHETICAL suggestion about direct genetic continuity from the ancient Macedonians, in an argumentative question that was supposed to help you distinguish between the meaning of genetic continuity and genetic purity. I specifically used the word HYPOTHETICAL.
And talking about genetical continuity do you have genetical evidence of this continuity or you just decided you take it for granted?
I think I have made it pretty clear in previous posts that I do not purport to have evidence of genetic continuity from ancient ancestors, and that it is not something I concern myself with.
Do you have any evidence of your claims about mixed ethnic genes?
Last edited: