• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Mandella is dead

RTG, I'm not so sure about that. if you read back the cultural homeland of Albanians seems to have always been Albania, and it still seems to be that way. Albanians in Macedonia and Kosovo wave an Albanian flag, in my opinion if the opportunity were offered they would more then love to merge with Albania. I think what you are getting at is the fact that Albanians in Albania dont really like Albanians from Kosovo or Macedonia, but this has more to do with primitiveness and barbarism and also a Yugo era misconception that the majority of Albanians in Albania are Catholic and therefore dont like other Albanians because they are Muslim, which is nothing but a lie, then a perceived cultural difference or identity.
The Ghegs have enough difference from Tosks to consider them distinguishable. They are mostly from Kosovo and Macedonia.

Again, I am looking at Tom's interpretation of indigenous people and would think they actually qualify under that definition. I don't agree with the definition. I don't regard them as indigenous. Nor would I regard Zulu's who come from somewhere else as indigenous to South Africa.
 
While there may be some differences, there are also regional differences within Albania itself, just as there are regional differences among Macedonians. Regional differences don't exactly mean seperate nation/culture. If that were the case, then Macedonians aren't really Macedonians but a collection of different peoples using the term "Macedonian" as an umbrella term. Is that what you're suggesting?
That is a separate discussion. Truth be told, any race separated by artificial borders long enough will begin to develop their own unique characteristics. However, I'm just going with your definition of indigenous people.
Indigenous is better defined as having some cultural connection to the land - e.g., that a particular culture or identity actually formed within that territory. Other definitions include subjugation, marginalisation or dispossession (which could include all Black South Africans regardless of when they arrived) or self-identification (which I imagine would be a majority).
Ethnic Albanians of Macedonia easily fit into all of the above. They were recognised as early as the 1300's as pastoralists in the region. The world feels sorry for them and feels they have been marginalised etc. I cannot see why they wouldn't be included in your definition.
 
Risto, for starters, you've confused my definition with what others use that I simply mentioned but never said I agree with.

I would not consider Ghegs and Tosks as separate nations or separate cultures. I think that is a gross misunderstanding of the Gheg/Tosk delineation, which is more linguistic than anything else. Granted, there are some cultural variations, but nothing greater than the cultural variations between Struzani and Bitolcani. They are simply the two key dialects within the Albanian language, and have further subdivisions within them. If you look at Macedonian, you’ll find greater diversity than that. Any superficial differences you put forward for Albanians apply just as much to any other nation. And your whole argument has been that Albanians in Macedonia are different from Albanians in Albania and therefore must be indigenous according to my definition, so no, its not a topic for another discussion.

Further, the Albanians in Macedonia are made up of Ghegs and Tosks. So what does that do for your idea that they are two separate peoples when they clearly consider themselves to be one? More importantly, when have Gheg/Tosk divisions ever had any substantive impact on broader Albanian identity/culture?

I don’t know why, but you keep assuming that my definition of indigenous somehow includes Albanians in Macedonia. On what basis does it do that? I mean, specifically? Have you taken into account the historical ethnogenesis of the Albanian identity/culture? Have you thought about where and when this occurred? From the research that I have done, most independent scholars don't even think that Albanian identity was formed in Albania, let alone Macedonia. Most importantly, have you noted when Albanians actually arrived in Macedonia? How would any of this fit in with my definition, not the one you seem to have ascribed to me.

In relation to Zulu’s not countingas indigenous if they arrived there at some stage, well, that would mean no one anywhere is indigenous because everyone’s ancestors arrived to where they currently are at some point in history. Humanity started at ONE point and spread out from there. In which case, this entire conversation is irrelevant and there can be no moral outcry for any indigenous peoples in South Africa simply because none exist - according to the definition you just provided.
 
Risto, current origin theories for the Albanians put their ethnogenesis north of the Jirecek line, which is north of both Albania and Macedonia. At best this would mean Kosovo, but no scholar has ever even considered Kosovo as a place of Albanian ethnogenesis. Many contend that it could have been north-eastern Serbia/south-western Romania due to the heavy influence of the Romanian version of Latin on the Albanian language. Some others locate their ethnogenesis in the Croatia/Bosnia area. No one, other than Albanian historians, place their ethnogenesis in Albania, let alone Macedonia, which as far as I'm aware, has never been promoted even by Albanians. Why you would suggest it is beyond me.

That means a group of people with an existing Albanian identity/culture moved south into what is now Albania and later moved into Western Macedonia, though in relatively small numbers. Lets not also forget that a great proportion of the current Albanian population in Macedonia originated in Kosovo and moved to Macedonia during the 20th century as fully established Albanians prior to their move. How does that allow for Albanians to be indigenous according to my definition of the concept?
 
Risto, for starters, you've confused my definition with what others use that I simply mentioned but never said I agree with.

You said the following earlier:
Indigenous is better defined as having some cultural connection to the land - e.g., that a particular culture or identity actually formed within that territory. Other definitions include subjugation, marginalisation or dispossession (which could include all Black South Africans regardless of when they arrived) or self-identification (which I imagine would be a majority).
Did you copy and paste this? You are saying it is a better definition but now you say you don't agree with it. What am I supposed to do with this? You win on obfuscation points.

I would not consider Ghegs and Tosks as separate nations or separate cultures. I think that is a gross misunderstanding of the Gheg/Tosk delineation, which is more linguistic than anything else. Granted, there are some cultural variations, but nothing greater than the cultural variations between Struzani and Bitolcani. They are simply the two key dialects within the Albanian language, and have further subdivisions within them. If you look at Macedonian, you’ll find greater diversity than that. Any superficial differences you put forward for Albanians apply just as much to any other nation. And your whole argument has been that Albanians in Macedonia are different from Albanians in Albania and therefore must be indigenous according to my definition, so no, its not a topic for another discussion.
I don't think we will see greater diversity amongst Macedonians than between the Ghegs and Tosks. Either way, I don't want to include or regard them as indigenous people. But the definition you have now distanced yourself from would tend to favour that approach.

Further, the Albanians in Macedonia are made up of Ghegs and Tosks. So what does that do for your idea that they are two separate peoples when they clearly consider themselves to be one? More importantly, when have Gheg/Tosk divisions ever had any substantive impact on broader Albanian identity/culture?
They are predominantly Ghegs. There are also Ukranians in Macedonia.

I don’t know why, but you keep assuming that my definition of indigenous somehow includes Albanians in Macedonia. On what basis does it do that? I mean, specifically? Have you taken into account the historical ethnogenesis of the Albanian identity/culture? Have you thought about where and when this occurred? From the research that I have done, most independent scholars don't even think that Albanian identity was formed in Albania, let alone Macedonia. Most importantly, have you noted when Albanians actually arrived in Macedonia? How would any of this fit in with my definition, not the one you seem to have ascribed to me.
Have you thought about the Zulu identity in the same fashion? Why are they indigenous to South Africa when the ethnic Albanians are not for Macedonia? I think neither are.

What is your definition? All I read was the one where you were saying it was better defined as ....having some cultural connection to the land - e.g., that a particular culture or identity actually formed within that territory. Other definitions include subjugation, marginalisation or dispossession (which could include all Black South Africans regardless of when they arrived) or self-identification (which I imagine would be a majority).

In relation to Zulu’s not countingas indigenous if they arrived there at some stage, well, that would mean no one anywhere is indigenous because everyone’s ancestors arrived to where they currently are at some point in history. Humanity started at ONE point and spread out from there. In which case, this entire conversation is irrelevant and there can be no moral outcry for any indigenous peoples in South Africa simply because none exist - according to the definition you just provided.
So are the white settlers in Australia indigenous to Australia under the definition you may or may not have embraced? Why?

I regard Macedonians as indigenous to Macedonia because they are the native people in the region who are uniquely identifiable and are the product of many events over an extended time frame and are not known to have come from anywhere else.

Perhaps you should clearly state your definition and then we can see what your really mean.
 
having some cultural connection to the land - e.g., that a particular culture or identity actually formed within that territory. Other definitions include subjugation, marginalisation or dispossession (which could include all Black South Africans regardless of when they arrived) or self-identification (which I imagine would be a majority).
Do you see the clarifyer there in bold? The definitions following the word 'OTHER' are actually OTHER definitions, not the one I was referring to. You lumped them all in with mine and made a mess of them.

So are the white settlers in Australia indigenous to Australia under the definition you may or may not have embraced? Why?
No, because they have a preexisting culture prior to moving to Australia. White Australian identity/culture which is mainly British was not developed in Australia. While that culture has been influenced to some degree while in Australia, it is clearly British for the most part, with German, Macedonian etc. Over time, should a new identity/culture evolve, then yes, it would be indigenous to Australia as it is unique and specific to this territory and actually formed on this territory.

I regard Macedonians as indigenous to Macedonia because they are the native people in the region who are uniquely identifiable and are the product of many events over an extended time frame and are not known to have come from anywhere else.
What do you mean by "native people"? Also (I'll put this in atheist terms) did Macedonians evolve out of apes in Macedonia, separate to the rest of humanity? Did they spring up like plants from Macedonian soil? Is that what you mean when you say they are not known to have come from anywhere else?

My definition of inidigenous, is when a specific and unique identity/culture develops in a specific territory. That would make that identity/culture indigenous to that particular territory because that is where it was formed (through whatever process).

Albanian identity/culture did not develop in Macedonia. That identity/culture was already preexisting prior to its members settling in Macedonia. Macedonian identity/culture developed in Macedonia. The ancestors of Macedonians obviously came from somewhere, they didn't just spring up like plants from the soil. They may not necessarily have been the first to pass through Macedonia, but the Macedonian identity/culture had its ethnogenisis there, making Macedonians indigenous to Macedonia. That pretty much agrees with your definition, if you agree that Macedonians didn't grow on trees in Macedonia and humans arrived there at some point in time from somewhere.

The Zulu's and the others I named, obviously didn't spring out of the ground in South Africa, their ancestors just like everyone else's got there at some point of time from somewhere. But the Zulu etc identity/culture was formed in South Africa. Those cultures were born there. The Zulu and other cultures/identities did not already exist prior to their members moving to South Africa - they were formed in South Africa through the process of ethnogenesis. That is what in my definition makes them indigenous.
 
why tell a different story of a minority indigenous people being taken over.,But Tom's research puts a whole different view on it in fact of their being a majority..I wouldn't like to live in a primitive society like Africa.I don't think they will recognize or give people basic human rights.Primitive societies don't even recognize basic law or order & some hav been fighting wars for years.Tom RTG you all right in your comments .
 
Do you see the clarifyer there in bold? The definitions following the word 'OTHER' are actually OTHER definitions, not the one I was referring to. You lumped them all in with mine and made a mess of them.
I didn't make a mess of it. Any part of what you stated, including the "better" part still applies to the discussion. You didn't refute the "Other" parts, you included them. In fact, you used them to increase your majority calculation if they were applicable. You can refute them now if you want.

No, because they have a preexisting culture prior to moving to Australia. White Australian identity/culture which is mainly British was not developed in Australia. While that culture has been influenced to some degree while in Australia, it is clearly British for the most part, with German, Macedonian etc. Over time, should a new identity/culture evolve, then yes, it would be indigenous to Australia as it is unique and specific to this territory and actually formed on this territory.
I think it is a vague notion you rely on. You can be indigenous after a while is what I think you are saying. Other than language, I don't believe the culture here is British.

So, according to your views, perhaps in 200 years we will be the indigenous people of Australia. But surely the aborigines will still be "more indigenous" than us white folks. Can someone be more indigenous?

What do you mean by "native people"? Also (I'll put this in terms you'll understand), did Macedonians evolve out of apes in Macedonia, separate to the rest of humanity? Did they spring up like plants from Macedonian soil? Is that what you mean when you say they are not known to have come from anywhere else?
Maybe they evolved out of Greek apes. Point being is they are not known as coming from somewhere else. Which is what I and most people mean by "native". Which actually means "indigenous".

My definition of inidigenous, if you haven't already understood it is a specific and unique identity/culture which has developed in a specific territory. That would make that identity/culture indigenous to that particular territory because that is where it was formed (through whatever process).
Sounds reasonable.

So would the Zulus of Zambia, Mozambique and Zimbabwe be "more indigenous" if that is where they originally came from. Or do their origins mean nothing?

Albanian identity/culture did not develop in Macedonia. That identity/culture was already preexisting prior to its members settling in Macedonia. Macedonian identity/culture developed in Macedonia. The ancestors of Macedonians obviously came from somewhere, they didn't just spring up like plants from the soil. They may not necessarily have been the first to pass through Macedonia, but the Macedonian identity/culture had its ethnogenisis there, making Macedonians indigenous to Macedonia. That pretty much agrees with your definition, if you agree that Macedonians didn't grow on trees in Macedonia and humans arrived there at some point in time from somewhere.

The Zulu's and the others I named, obviously didn't spring out of the ground in South Africa, their ancestors just like everyone else's got there at some point of time from somewhere. But the Zulu etc identity/culture was formed in South Africa. Those cultures were born there. They were not preexisting prior to their members moving to South Africa. That is what in my definition makes them indigenous.
Your assumption is their identity/culture was formed in South Africa. Which then allows you to believe they are indigenous to South Africa. Given the fact historians indicate the Zulus moved to the South African region (from the Congo region) 400 years ago, you seem to rely more on the notion that they sprang out of nowhere more than me. That their ethnogenesis never happened until they moved to South Africa 400 years ago. Were they nothing 400 years ago? No ethnicity? If yes, same goes for ethnic Albanians in Macedonia. I still barely see a difference. Can you be indigenous to more than one region? Could the Zulus of 400 years ago be indigenous to the other places, then indigenous to South Africa later on?

Were the Albanians of 400 years ago any different to today? Would the Yugoslav experience of the Albanians in Macedonia have caused them to shape a different culture to that of Albanians in Albania? If the experiences were dramatic enough, you would have to say they are indigenous to Macedonia. Just like the Zulus.
 
Risto, now I think you’re just been silly for the sake of being argumentative.

I didn't make a mess of it. Any part of what you stated, including the "better" part still applies to the discussion. You didn't refute the "Other" parts, you included them. In fact, you used them to increase your majority calculation if they were applicable. You can refute them now if you want.
I made my definition quite clear and I also clearly delineated the other theories by the use of the clarifier ‘other’. We are, after all, writing in English. We can switch to Macedonian if you like.

I think it is a vague notion you rely on. You can be indigenous after a while is what I think you are saying. Other than language, I don't believe the culture here is British.
My notions are not vague at all. Language, social structures, values, ideology, social conventions, gender roles, cuisine, religion are some aspects of culture. I don’t see any meaningful distinctions between British and Australian (British) culture. I’m sure you could make some superficial observations, but then you would have to accept that the same apply to the British in Britain and we would end up at the starting point, that they are essentially the same. In order to argue for a separate British/Australian culture, I think you would need to make the case rather than simply state it and have us accept it.

So, according to your views, perhaps in 200 years we will be the indigenous people of Australia. But surely the aborigines will still be "more indigenous" than us white folks. Can someone be more indigenous? .
Now you’re just putting words into my mouth. I never said time has anything to do with it, though it usually takes time for a new identity/culture to evolve. I said that if a new identity/culture evolved in Australia (regardless of time) it would be indigenous to Australia because this is where it formed/developed/evolved. It would be unique to Australia and it would have formed in Australia.

Maybe they evolved out of Greek apes. Point being is they are not known as coming from somewhere else. Which is what I and most people mean by "native". Which actually means "indigenous".
So where did humans in Macedonia come from? How did humans get there in the first place? Or is it that not knowing where they came from originally make them native? That sounds vague because we know that humans must have come from somewhere before they got to Macedonia even if we don’t know where exactly.

So would the Zulus of Zambia, Mozambique and Zimbabwe be "more indigenous" if that is where they originally came from. Or do their origins mean nothing?
I don’t think you get what I’m saying. Humans did not originate in South Africa. They came from somewhere. If you do some very basic research, you’ll see that a group of people known as Nguni migrated to South Africa (among other places). Over the next few centuries, some of the Nguni tribes underwent the process of ethnogenesis (key word here) and became what are now known as the Zulu people. The Zulu identity and culture formed in South Africa. It evolved in South Africa. Their ancestors migrated their, but they were not Zulu’s, they were Nguni, with a different identity and different culture. This is what I have read.

Your assumption is their identity/culture was formed in South Africa. Which then allows you to believe they are indigenous to South Africa.
This is not my assumption. Its what I’ve read over the course of today.

Given the fact historians indicate the Zulus moved to the South African region (from the Congo region) 400 years ago, you seem to rely more on the notion that they sprang out of nowhere more than me. That their ethnogenesis never happened until they moved to South Africa 400 years ago.
Actually, scholars indicate that the Nguni moved to South Africa as part of the Bantu migrations. For the development of Zulu culture and identity from then on, see my response above.

Were they nothing 400 years ago? No ethnicity? If yes, same goes for ethnic Albanians in Macedonia. I still barely see a difference.
I don’t understand what you are trying to say here. In relation to Zulu’s and their ancestors the Nguni, see my responses above. In relation to the Albanians, I’ve already discussed their ethnogenesis and current theories in another post which you seem to have ignored, or maybe missed. Albanians, as current theories go, went through their ethnogenesis on the Serb/Romanian border zone (some say in the area of modern Croatia/Bosnia). Then, once they already had developed a distinct ‘Albanian’ culture/identity and language, they moved to present day Albania. Then, they moved into parts of western Macedonia and Kosovo. Albanians could be said to be indigenous to the northern Balkans, not Albania and definitely not Macedonia. I really can’t understand what you don’t understand about that and why you think that Albanians could be indigenous to Macedonia when no Albanian ethnogenesis has taken place in Macedonia and you have not provided any evidence or details in relation to Albanian ethnogenesis taking place in Macedonia other than simply saying my definition of indigeneity alludes to that possibility, when it clearly does not.

Were the Albanians of 400 years ago any different to today? Would the Yugoslav experience of the Albanians in Macedonia have caused them to shape a different culture to that of Albanians in Albania? If the experiences were dramatic enough, you would have to say they are indigenous to Macedonia. Just like the Zulus.
I don’t think the Yugoslav experience did anything of the sort to Albanians in Macedonia, but if YOU think that it did, then please provide details. I’m quite confident that Albanian culture and identity in Macedonia falls well within the umbrella Albanian culture and identity that covers Albania, Kosovo and Macedonia. In addition, you either are unaware of the fact or are simply ignoring it, that a substantial part of the current Albanian population in Macedonia migrated from Kosovo post-1945. These Albanians were very well Albanian prior to migrating to Macedonia and I’m confident no process of ethnogenesis has taken place since. Therefore, they cannot, even under your wildest imagination, be considered as indigenous by my definition of indigeneity.
 
Risto, now I think you’re just been silly for the sake of being argumentative.

I made my definition quite clear and I also clearly delineated the other theories by the use of the clarifier ‘other’. We are, after all, writing in English. We can switch to Macedonian if you like.
You then suggested using the "other" theories could increase the majority under your calculations. You should read what you write! I spell better in English. Please stay in English.

My notions are not vague at all. Language, social structures, values, ideology, social conventions, gender roles, cuisine, religion are some aspects of culture. I don’t see any meaningful distinctions between British and Australian (British) culture. I’m sure you could make some superficial observations, but then you would have to accept that the same apply to the British in Britain and we would end up at the starting point, that they are essentially the same. In order to argue for a separate British/Australian culture, I think you would need to make the case rather than simply state it and have us accept it.
Are Americans and British the same culture also? Croatians and Serbs are essentially the same too I suppose.

Now you’re just putting words into my mouth. I never said time has anything to do with it, though it usually takes time for a new identity/culture to evolve. I said that if a new identity/culture evolved in Australia (regardless of time) it would be indigenous to Australia because this is where it formed/developed/evolved. It would be unique to Australia and it would have formed in Australia.
So, if white settlers were in South Africa BEFORE the Zulu migration. And the Zulu identity/culture developed after, we should regard them as indigenous and afford them some special status? I think we should. But it makes me worry about the ethnic Albanians in Macedonia. Because it won't be long before they are indigenous under your logic. Their culture can change. If it does, you will have to support them as indigenous people of Macedonia.

So where did humans in Macedonia come from? How did humans get there in the first place? Or is it that not knowing where they came from originally make them native? That sounds vague because we know that humans must have come from somewhere before they got to Macedonia even if we don’t know where exactly.
Didn't we all come from Ethiopia? The problem is that you provide a mechanism whereby anyone can become indigenous over time given the right kind of "ethnogenesis". And 400 years sounds like a time frame you are comfortable with.

I tend to afford indigenous races certain concessions and rights. I think they might need more time to earn it.

Albanians could be said to be indigenous to the northern Balkans, not Albania and definitely not Macedonia. I really can’t understand what you don’t understand about that and why you think that Albanians could be indigenous to Macedonia when no Albanian ethnogenesis has taken place in Macedonia and you have not provided any evidence or details in relation to Albanian ethnogenesis taking place in Macedonia other than simply saying my definition of indigeneity alludes to that possibility, when it clearly does not.
YOU are saying it is possible if they "ethnogenesisise". And subscribing to your definition will see the former Turkish nationals who now dominate Greek occupied Macedonia as absolutely indigenous to Macedonia. Which makes me feel sick. So please think about your definition.

How silly is it to think the former Turkish nationals are now indigenous Macedonians?
 
Vangelovski:

Clearly, you have moved this topic from one of substance to one of semantics. If we get back to my original post, and use your idea of indigenous, you'll see that my statement about indigenous people is sort-of rebutting what SofM said about how the "indigenous" populations of South Africa have been suffering for centuries. My point was that: what SofM considers indigenous populations were actually not there (as a distinct identity group) before white settlers were there (as a distinct identity group). How could the Zulu people (named after Shaka Zulu, born in the late 1700s) be more indigenous than the Dutch, who arrived in the 1650s. Thus, which indigenous people that SofM talking about were the ones suffering? Zulu, the Dutch, British, and others were fighting each other, all the meanwhile exterminating the indigenous populations classified as according to the website I provided.

If all of Macedonians in Greece reject their Macedonianism and consider themselves ethnic Greek, and do so for generations, and 200 years from now none want anything to do with the Macedonian name or culture, yet their "blood" is still Macedonian, are they Macedonian or Greek? Unfortunately, they are Greek in my eyes and then we could theoretically say that the population of Macedonians have been wiped out from Greece, even though the people never moved or never were killed. One culture was exterminated for another.

Thus, using this definition, the Dutch are more indigenous to South Africa than the Zulu, because the Dutch were there well before the Zulu appeared, even though the Zulu may have had ancestors in that part of South Africa.

Of course, this is all really using your definition of indigenous and semantics is a game for people who just want to take something off topic, or have a grudge to continually emphasize...which I think is the case for you.
 
Tom,

What about a place like the USA?

Its is inhabited by many peoples but There is a specific group which is the majority here that identify as nothing else but Americans. That would be white western European immigrants who immigrated to the USA prior to the 20th century. They are typically English, Dutch, German, and for some odd reason Polish. They have formed there own identity and culture on this continent which is clearly different from any of there originating identities. They no longer know where they came from or who they are other then American. Every other ethnic group in the USA identities with there place of Origin. I've seen it over and over again, anyone who is of color, or clearly looks different from a typical Anglo Germanic person is automatically "something" American, Italian American, African American, Japanese American, Mexican American. The only group who do not identify with any other nation or ethnic group are white people from Anglo Germanic, and Polish backgrounds.

So by your definition of indigenous then the group of white people are indigenous to North America? They fulfill all your criteria.

We know the Native Americans were here first, have never been linked with any other land so they have to be indigenous, but by your definition they are not but white western Europeans are because they formed a specific identity and culture on this land.

The other problem in the USA example would be that you would alienate all the other Americans who are not white (which already happens). Even I who am white but have dark hair and dark eyes get asked all the time where I am from? I have no accent, I go by George most of the time, but still because I am not blondish and fair skinned people ask if I'm Italian or Greek. My brother who is slightly more fair skinned and has green eyes and lighter hair, never gets asked if he is anything but American, he is automatically excepted, where I am not. I've even been told that I do not look American, but that I obviously look foreign. So clearly the American identity is not all inclusive and I think its because of some interpretation of a definition like the one Tom has given.

Can we at least agree that the definition you consider most correct, does not apply and can not apply to the United States?
 
Last edited:
Gocka,

Your point on Native Americans not being able to be indigenous under my definition (which really isn't mine) is incorrect. They developed, as far as I'm aware, their identity and culture in that particular region. Your other point about Americans being separate culture/identity from the British is probably partially correct and I agree with it to some extent. Whether that classifies them as indigenous to the US, I'm not sure. I think they are in the process of ethnogenesis, but such things are not inevitable. Only time will tell how far apart American identity/culture diverges from British/European culture/identity.

Chris,

You're beginning to get really silly about all this. I'm still waiting to hear where you think people came from in Macedonia. I'm serious - you're trying to make a rebuttal of my point but you're avoiding scrutiny of your "native people" that have not come from anywhere else idea. There are obviously people in Macedonia. Where did they come from originally, according to you? Did they migrate there from somewhere else or did they just pop out of thin air?

On the Albanians supposedly going through some form of ethnogenesis in Macedonia, I have never, ever seen any evidence of that whatsoever anywhere. Please provide something, anything to back up your claim that they are doing so. The other obvious thing you are missing here is that if Albanians are going through some form of ethnogenesis, then they will no longer be Albanians - they'll be something else - so what are you worried about?

And no, I didn't need the other definitions to get the indigenous population to 51 per cent - I simply used my own. The relevant post is here:

Having done some further reading, it appears that while the ancestors of the Zulu migrated to South Africa, the Zulu nation (11 million) was actually formed in South Africa. This appears to be the same for the Xhosa (8.5 million) who consider the Transkei region of South Africa as their homeland. The Sotho (3.5 millioin) people also formed their identity in South Africa after their ancestors migrated there nearly 2,000 years ago. These three groups make up 23 million people.

In addition, 3.9 million Tswana live in Northern South Africa and from my research, they are also indiginous to that region the same as Macedonians are indigenous to Aegean Macedonia. The Tswana have their own state (Botswana), but this area in South Africa that is populated by Tswana seems to have come under South African control through colonialism and is actually Tswana territory, making them indigenous to the area.

This is a total of 26.9 million people out of 52 million that are indigenous to South Africa (on the points of cultural/identity formation in the area and self-identification) and I haven't even started on the smaller nations/tribes. I think that is a majority.
I provided a quick explanation of the other definitions and examples of how they might play out, but when I originally explained the definition I think best fits I distinguished the other definitions as separate from mine with two qualifiers, one which you missed in your quote. The first qualifier was "Indigenous is better defined as" [insert my definition] and then the second qualifier was the term "other" for the definitions that did not fit the first "qualifier".

Victor,

This isn't a matter of semantics (though I highly doubt you have the intellectual capacity to even distinguish between varying theories of indigeneity so it probably just seems that way to you). If you bother to read my posts you will realise that everything you just wrote in response is completely irrelevant. As such, I can't really comment on anything you wrote.
 
Vangelovski:

If you bothered to have read SoM's post, you would have taken issue with his statement about indigenous people. And if you weren't an intellectual and egoistical brat who is trying to compensate for his physical and emotional shortcomings, you would have actually addressed the real issue in this topic.

Good luck :001_smile:
 
Vangelovski:

Oh, and as far as my intellectual capacity: I really do love your comment on how "beautiful" of a place the state that allowed my post-undergraduate intellectual capacity to expand just oh-so-beautifully is -- Vermont.

https://www.facebook.com/LDP.australia?ref=stream&hc_location=timeline&filter=2

Their education system and institution are ten times as beautiful as their gun laws. I'm glad I have your support and admiration, even though you don't directly admit it. Thank you, Tom. Just so touching...I didn't know you felt this way.
 
Last edited:
Vangelovski:

Oh, and as far as my intellectual capacity: I really do love your comment on how "beautiful" of a place the state that allowed my post-undergraduate intellectual capacity to expand just oh-so-beautifully is -- Vermont.

[URL]https://www.facebook.com/LDP.australia?ref=stream&hc_location=timeline&filter=2[/URL]

Their education system and institution are ten times as beautiful as their gun laws. I'm glad I have your support and admiration, even though you don't directly admit it. Thank you, Tom. Just so touching...I didn't know you felt this way.
Again Victor, you completley misunderstand what that comment was about. No big surprises there.

I took issue with you trying to undermine the indigeneity of the indiginous peoples of South Africa. But that is just semantics to you and a 'collateral damage' to your making idiotic statements in order to support your point of view.
 
You're beginning to get really silly about all this. I'm still waiting to hear where you think people came from in Macedonia. I'm serious - you're trying to make a rebuttal of my point but you're avoiding scrutiny of your "native people" that have not come from anywhere else idea. There are obviously people in Macedonia. Where did they come from originally, according to you? Did they migrate there from somewhere else or did they just pop out of thin air?
It's fine. But you (under your definition) will have to accept the former Turkish nationals in Greek occupied Macedonia as indigenous Macedonians now. They have indeed had an ethnogenesis in Macedonia. THAT is silly. When they call themselves Macedonian, you should accept them as indigenous Macedonians with rights equal to our own.

Macedonians may have come from somewhere else, but there is no clear indication from where. Where there is a more than clear indication of different origins, it is safe to say the people cannot be construed as indigenous to a region. Which is my point.
 
Well vicsinad where did the Macedonians come from ?? and no silly ideas like the monkeys.
Pretty soon you'll be wanting rights for them too.
 
It's fine. But you (under your definition) will have to accept the former Turkish nationals in Greek occupied Macedonia as indigenous Macedonians now. They have indeed had an ethnogenesis in Macedonia. THAT is silly. When they call themselves Macedonian, you should accept them as indigenous Macedonians with rights equal to our own.

Macedonians may have come from somewhere else, but there is no clear indication from where. Where there is a more than clear indication of different origins, it is safe to say the people cannot be construed as indigenous to a region. Which is my point.
Ok, you might have a point in relation to the Greek settlers in Macedonia.

However, your idea of indigeneity does not work for Macedonians because there is quite a lot of evidence as to who was in Macedonia prior to the formation of Macedonian identity/culture and historians like Eugene Borza have gone into quite some detail on it. Even SoM has touched on it with his reaseach on linguistics. We can very safely assume which tribes of peoples Macedonians grew out of and in most instances we know where these people migrated from - and these originated in the Middle East. If we take it back far enough (and assume that humanity began/was created in Ethiopia) then we're all indigenous to Ethiopia and only Ethiopia. Even if we don't go that far back, and start from Asia Minor, then Macedonians are really indigenous to the Middle East, making us a settler people in Macedonia. That fact that Macedonian identity/culture developed in Macedonia is irrelevant, according to your definition, because we do know which peoples lived there prior to the creation of that identity/culture and where they came from for the most part.
 
Perhaps the word indigenous itself is flawed, and should not be used other then in very specific circumstances like in the Americas in relation to all the Native tribes that inhabited it prior to colonization. Also perhaps in areas like Macedonia where an identity was formed on that land so far back that its hard to even know where they peoples originated from. But in my opinion when it comes to most places no one is really indigenous and the word itself can cause unnecessary division and discrimination.

Going back to the South African example, Neither the Dutch nor the newer African settlers are indigenous so both have just as much claim to the land as the other, Obviously by being black the African settlers are perceived as being indigenous and thus deserve more claim but I am not so sure about that. Just as white Anglo/Germanic Americans dont have more claim to the USA as any other ethnic group, neither does any specific group in South Africa. Really if you want to be proper, Native Americans have claim to the Americas, and that small percentage of indigenous South Africans to SA.
 
Back
Top