”Sovius” said:
Then please provide evidence to support your statement or withdraw it. This sentence carries the weight of a hot air balloon. I also recommend re-reading my previous post. Better yet, read the entire study. Empirical evidence is not the same thing as theoretical inference. Arguments based on empirical evidence are not bound by theory and the limitations of speculation. Most scholars must be idiots then, to ignore that which is self-evident to researchers who actually study language structure. I don't believe most scholars are idiots, but forming professional opinions without accounting for evidence from all available disciplines tends to produce irrelevant research and "professional opinions" when speaking about something so broad as half of Europe's populations. I have a sneaky suspicion that you're reading research made prior to the age of population genetics. Look up the definition of Copernican. Curta's making progess. No doubt he'll eventually trip over what's been staring him in the face for quite a while now. Like so may scholars in the West, he's just now seeing the benefits of inter-disciplinarianism over specialization. I believe Dr. Savli out of Slovenia sent him a letter regarding the matter a number of years ago. May he rest in peace. It's up to Curta now to use the information to further his understanding of his chosen field or to continue on down the path that he has erroneously chosen. Not that I don't appreciate his effort, but he is still out in left field, regardless of the evolutionary leap in understanding amongst "Westerners".
Your argument rests in the fact that certain linguists have theorized that the southern Slavic branch is the oldest. Mario Alinei believes there is no northern Slavic, and in fact derives from southern Slavic. This cannot qualify as an immutable fact. It qualifies as linguistic analysis. This is theory, and a theory held by a very small amount of scholars. If this were an objective, measurable, quantifiable fact, no one would question it. No University Slavic language department, however, recognizes the validity of this theory. I have never seen information apart from a small number of scholars who believe this. How can so many experts on Slavic languages not see this immutable fact? The answer is because it is not an immutable fact. It is a theory buttressed by a minority's interpretation of linguistic evidence, but it is not widely accepted. The theory that the Slavic language originates in the south also seemingly contradicts all known historic and genetic evidence.
There may be a rational explanation for these contradictions, however, and it may be possible to reconcile them.
If we start with the premise that Slavic is the oldest branch, and that it originated in the Balkans, we have to work on the assumption that this language was never called Slavic. The next thing we have to figure out is how was this language spoken in much of the Balkans? The traditional theory is that so-called Slavs migrated into the region, and introduced Slavic to the indigenous people. This theory makes sense only from the perspective that it explains how today's Balkan people generally speak a common Slavic language. It is grossly deficient in many other respects. Vinko Pribojević hypothesized that all Slavic speaking people descended from a common ancestor, Tiras. If true, this would provide the framework necessary to argue for a common ancestor of Slavs and a common Slavic language long before Slavic migrants migrated the Balkans. Science has conclusively established that Pribojević was wrong, however.
In 2007 Rębała and colleagues studied several Slavic populations with the aim of localizing the Proto-Slavic homeland. The significant findings of this study are that:
Two genetically distant groups of Slavic populations were revealed: One encompassing all Western-Slavic, Eastern-Slavic, and few Southern-Slavic populations (north-western Croats and Slovenes), and one encompassing all remaining Southern Slavs. According to the authors most Slavic populations have similar Y chromosome pools — R1a. They speculate that this similarity can be traced to an origin in the middle Dnieper basin of Ukraine during the Late Glacial Maximum 15 kya.
However, Southern-Slavic populations including the Bosnians, Croats (excluding north-western Croatia), Serbs, Bulgarians and Macedonians are clearly separated from the tight DNA cluster of the rest of the Slavic populations. According to the authors this phenomenon is explained by "... contribution to the Y chromosomes of peoples who settled in the Balkan region before the Slavic expansion to the genetic heritage of Southern Slavs ..."
Based on this study, it would appear that so-called southern Slavs share genetic similarity with each other, not because of migrating Slavs from the north, who are genetically distant, but because of “contribution to the Y chromosomes of peoples who settled in the Balkan region before the Slavic expansion to the genetic heritage of Southern Slavs”. In other words, the haplogroup I2a seems to be most common in the Balkans, though there are exceptions, including the population of Sardinia. Northern Slavs, however, are very low in I2a.
This study seems to suggest that northern Slavs contributed to the gene pool of southern Slavs, and one can argue Albanians and even Greeks in fairly same proportions, though in this study only Slavic speaking people were sampled. There is no genetic study that suggests southern Slavs contributed to the gene pool of northern Slavs, though I do not doubt that people of Greek, Albanian, Macedonian, Bulgarian, Serbian, Bosnian, and Croatian heritages have intermixed with northern Slavic people in the past and do so even in the present. These are generally isolated examples, however, and they do not measurably affect the northern Slavic gene pool. If you have studies that document otherwise, please, by all means, forward me the links.
The problem I have with Rębała et al., is that they used a broad stroke to define southern Slavs. However, southern Slavs are not one broad lump of people. Southern Slavs differ broadly in I2a, E3b1, J and J2 haplogroups, for example. In addition, studies such as the Rębała et al., seem to suggest that the Balkan Slavs are primarily of ethnic Slavic descent (from the Slavic migration theory), but differ from northern Slavs because they inherit genes of the indigenous Balkan people. When in fact it is the opposite. We are a Balkan Mediterranean people with predominately Balkan Mediterranean genes with some northern Slavic admixture, namely R1a, and in fairly similar proportions in the whole southern Balkans, including Albania and Greece.
Another problem I have with the study by Rębała et al., is the ignorant assumption that because Greeks and Albanians do not speak Slavic, the Slavs in those regions were smaller in numbers and were absorbed by the indigenous people. However, the Slavs in Macedonia and elsewhere were allegedly more dominant, a fact not supported by any genetic study, and because of this dominance, the indigenous people were absorbed by the Slavs. How could nearly the same level of Slavic proportion in today's Greek, Albanian, and Macedonian populations produce three different linguistic results? And how is it that Romanians, who have more R1a than most Balkan Slavic people, did not adopt Slavic? Yet in Montenegro, where there is very little R1a, even less than Albania and Greece, Slavic prevailed?
So there are problems here. Not with genetic studies, but the historical interpretation of the data. Before the advent of genetic studies, for example, virtually all historians and anthropologists assumed that today's Balkan people descended from migrating Slavs because they speak Slavic. Unfortunately, much of the world still thinks this, even though it is unquestionably a myth of history. The Slavic Migration Theory has long been used to deny the unique nations of the Balkans, and has been used to deny the claims of modern Macedonians. However, assuming the historic record of the Byzantine authors is accurate, or even fairly accurate, it cannot be denied that people of the north contributed to the gene pool of the indigenous Balkan people.
So what alternative theory exists? Was there a common proto-Balkan language before the Slavs migrated to the Balkans? If so, what can account for a common proto-Balkan language? If a common language was spoken in much of the Balkans before the Slavs migrated, and that Slavic in fact originated in the Balkans, how can this be explained?
Was it because all the Balkan nations who spoke this language were kinsmen? Or was it because the language developed in one Balkan nation and spread throughout the Balkans? If so, how did this happen? By conquest? Again, as previously stated, Vinko Pribojević hypothesized that all Slavic people descended from a common ancestor, Tiras. This theory, however, is not correct, as previously stated, because the Macedonians did not descend from Tiras. Moreover, today's northern Slavs descend from Magog, not Tiras. This fact is corroborated by the genetic studies which show today's Balkan people genetically inherit the Thracian, Illyrian, and Macedonian gene pools, but the gene pool was “muddied” with Magog DNA, namely, northern Slavs.
The Slavic speaking people of the north are genetically distant from the Slavic speaking people of the south. In addition, genetically speaking, the Balkan people are fairly similar, as one would expect from neighboring peoples, but they are obviously not the same, with considerable differences between northern Balkan people and southern Balkan people.
So if “Slavic” did originate in the Balkans, as some linguistic experts believe, it would have to mean, when understood in the context of genetics and history, that this language was never called Slavic and the people in the Balkans were never called Slavs, and that this language was adopted by unrelated peoples. If these statements are true, the question is: what language did today's Russians, Ukrainians, Poles, etc speak in the distant past? Was it Slavic? And if so, when did the southern branch migrate north? And why was it adopted by the north? If these events took place in the distant past, long before Byzantine writers referenced the “cursed” Slavs, which by all accounts were not flattery, why did they not make no reference to the similarity in language and appearance (if genetically related) to the people of the south? Could an argument be made that when the Slavs invaded the Balkans that it was at this point in time of history that they first learned Slavic, and prior to this, spoke another language? How plausible is this theory?
So what you're saying is that the opinions of poorly educated people are more important to you than the research of trained professionals who have tirelessly worked their whole lives to reconstruct the past in a manner that leaves no room for contradiction. Again, fascinating, and, my apologies, very Greek-like. The source region of Haplogroup I2a and its universal presence throughout Southeastern Europe is enough to refute these dingbats' archaic nonsense. Cultures are genetically heterogeneous and evolve in a stationary manner. Cultures grow where they are planted. This is not my opinion, this is what genetic research clearly demonstrates and always has.
The scholars who disagree with your thesis are not poorly educated. They are highly educated. They may be wrong, and history is replete with examples of where the interpretation of historic and scientific data by the preponderance of scholars has been wrong. No one doubts this. However, to make the statement that scholars who disagree with this thesis are poorly educated and that people who do agree with this thesis are trained professionals is inappropriate. This is not a scholarly argument.
I2a is considered the southern counterpart of the northern R1a. Whereas R1a is common in northern Slavs, southern Slavs are high in the haplogroup I2a, but the frequency of this haplogroup varies considerably in the Balkans. I do not think this proves your point. I think it works against the argument for a common origin. The scientific data clearly establishes that northern and southern slavs are distantly related because the haplogroup R1a is ubiquitous in northern Slavs and the haplogroup I2a is ubiquitous in southern Slavs. Other haplogrups also suggest genetic distances between these peoples. E1b1b or E3b1, J and J2, for example, confirm not only distances between northern and southern Slavs, but considerable differences between northern Balkan Slavs and southern Balkan Slavs.
In addition, Central and southern Greece, for example, has similar I2a levels to Poles, Russians, and Ukrainians. Should we assume that northern Slavs are related to Greeks?
Haplogroup I2 is the most common paternal lineage in former Yugoslavia, Romania, Bulgaria and Sardinia, and a major lineage in most Slavic countries. Its maximum frequencies are observed in Bosnia (55%, including 71% in Bosnian Croats), Sardinia (39.5%), Croatia (38%), Serbia (33%), Montenegro (31%), Romania (28%), Moldova (24%), Macedonia (24%), Slovenia (22%), Bulgaria (22%), Belarus (18.5%), Hungary (18%), Slovakia (17.5%), Ukraine (13.5%), and Albania (13.5%). It is found at a frequency of 5 to 10% in Germanic countries.
It is also found in high numbers in northern Greece.
R1a alone is not a "Slav" gene, nor areI2a or E3b1. The source regions of I2a and R1a now provide migration paths to other regions through the chronology of their mutations. Language follows genes and genes follow languages. One set of evidence is practically worthless without the other. Frequency is less important than where a subclade is within a haplogroup's chain and its geo-spatial relationships to older subclades and new subclades. I recall reading a passage that stated that the Romans crucified around 200,000 Macedonian soldiers after the fall of the Macedonian Empire. That event alone would have had the potential to wipe out an as yet discovered haplogroup subclade from the Macedonian gene pool or dramatically reduce any of the still existent haplogroups that contemporary Macedonian populations continue to carry, although it is still a massive victory to find high frequencies of a certain subclade in a source region amongst sets of earlier mutations that gave rise to that subclade. This is called an intra-haplogroup validation and if you can find an even earlier divergence to the preceding subclade in the same general area, it's even more significant. It is an anthropological triple crown. It changes the way researchers see the past of a certain area, regardless of what "the cool kids in school may think". The truth of things isn't a popularity contest.
All national identifications are social constructs. There is no Slavic gene, any more is there a Greek or Russian gene. R1a is not Slavic, but in European populations, is heavily concentrated in northern Slavic speaking people, and indeed even in some non-Slavic speaking people. I2a is concentrated in the Balkans. And E3b1 is concentrated in the Mediterranean.
Outside Europe, E1b1b is found at high frequencies in Morocco (over 80%), Somalia (80%), Ethiopia (40% to 80%), Tunisia (70%), Algeria (60%), Egypt (40%), Jordan (25%), Palestine (20%), and Lebanon (17.5%). On the European continent it has the highest concentration in Kosovo (over 45%), Albania and Montenegro (both 27%), Bulgaria (23%), Macedonia and Greece (both 21%), Cyprus (20%), Sicily (20%), South Italy (18.5%), Serbia (18%) and Romania (15%).
I would point out that these numbers differ from iGENEA's database. In that database, measuring the Y-Haplogroupgs, Albania has E1b1b at 16%, and Macedonia is at 25%. In addition, I2a, the so-called Slavic Balkan gene, is 30% in Albania, and 32% in Macedonia. The differences could be the result of Y-Haplogroups and differences within in populations. However, I would not rule out the falsification of data either, as genetics and politics do not mix.
Vinko is not here to defend himself and you are dodging the question. The fact that you are using the term "controversial" means you lack evidence to support your argument. I realize people educated according to the Victorian Age Model of historical and anthropological interpretation tend to see the world in a certain way. I am on record as stating that they suffer from an involuntary form of ethnocentric retardation. Now genetic evidence is forcing scholars to re-evaluate their previous conclusions or learn to navigate their local landfill. During the Renaissance Period it was common knowledge among Polish scholars that Alexander of Macedon and his father spoke a language similar to but not the same as Polish (the essence of what slavjani or slovenskii mean and meant during the period in time in question). What evidence did the cultural negationists use to discount the prior consensus? If Alexander the Great spoke the language of the commoners, what did the Macedonians that followed him on his campaigns to end Greek encroachment into sovereign Macedonian territory speak?
Well, first, my educational backgrounds are in very different fields than linguistics and anthropology. Second, I am not dodging your question. You are entitled to believe the thesis that Slavic is the original branch. You are also entitled to believe the thesis as advocated by Slavic thinkers throughout the centuries of a common ancestor of Slavs. The veracity of the first thesis I am not sure on. The veracity of the second thesis is not in question: it is bogus.
Third, I am well aware that so-called Slavic writers in the past have written of their opinion that the ancient Macedonians were Slavs and spoke Slavic. Vinko and Orbini are among the most well known advocates of this theory. The problem we have, however, is that very few written words of the ancient Macedonians have been preserved. Some of these words are loan words from the Hellenic language. Others appear to be Macedonian. No one is certain what this language was, though scholars in the past have blindly assumed it was Greek (and unfortunately many still do). Donski believes that the ancient Macedonian language is similar to today's Macedonian language, and that some of these words are still used today. This is widely considered to be pseudo science. Personally, I do not think it is a pseudo science, but I do believe more research is needed.
The theory held by Orbini is that, similar to Vinko, all Slavs descend from a common ancestor. These writers were writing at a time when a people calling themselves “Macedonian” spoke a “Slavic” language, and deduced from this, and from the historic record that the Macedonian language was a barbarian tongue to the Greeks, that the Macedonians have always spoken this language. A lot of assumptions were made by these writers, assumptions which are not widely accepted by mainstream scholars. Theologically speaking, it is not accurate. Genetically speaking, it is not accurate. Linguistically, when examined in the proper framework, it may be accurate, but more research is needed.
Vinko's belief's regarding some supposed ethnogenesis of the Illyro-Sarmatian populations of Europe are not what is important about his work, I assure you. I can find no better source than the Bible for moral guidance, but will require a DNA sample from this Magog fellow to evaluate Vinko's beliefs versus historical and pre-historic reality. Vinko's work regarding the linguistic similarities of neighboring populations reflects what was common knowledge at the time, as it ran parallel with many other authors' documentation regarding a number of different cultures and documentation from previous periods, as well. Just like newscasters report the news, Vinko recorded what was commonly understood during his period in time.
I do not think you understand the point. I am not arguing Vinko's writings are of no value or his understanding on the origins of Illyro-Sarmation populations is what is most important or even important about his writings. What I am trying to convey is that Vinko's fundamental premise regarding the common origins of Slavic speaking people is historically, theologically, and genetically inaccurate.
All populations who continue to speak an Illyro-Sarmatian language have ancestors who spoke an Illyro-Sarmatian language and these languages had to have held together so well throughout the millenia due to what geo-linguists refer to as high frequency contacts. Translate this to mean roads, economic and political cooperation at some point in time for a very long time. I would like to take this brief moment to stress "a very long time". After taking a very long time to consider the significance of Professor A's evidence (most certainly not some subjectively stunted opinions or assumptions), please take a very long look at what you've yet to comprehend regarding his research.
I do not entirely agree with the first statement. I think Slavic began somewhere and spread to unrelated peoples who in different times and seasons adopted this language for different reasons.
If this is not contested then please provide the evidence necessary to prove it, because I can prove that your ancestors, if you are Macedonian, migrated north and became my ancestors (in part and broadly speaking, of course). Kind of Biblical, but not so Biblical, really. What R1a subclade are you using to push this "Slav" gene concept that you're positioning as a supposedly valid assertion?
Please provide evidence that Macedonians migrated north and intermixed with today's northern Slavic speaking people? When did this happen? And why is it not reflected in the historic and genetic records?
Do you have the educational background necessary or access to evidence to address anything that I've requested of you from my previous post or to refute any new ground that I've made against you? If you do not, I might be able to help you out, but, then again, there's a reason why I have responded the way I have. Please remember that we are still only on exhibit 1. I've promised you four distinct proofs. Alinei was using 1st Generation genetic evidence when he wrote that paper, but you need to catch up before we can move on in a meaningful way. Brushing aside evidence without support is a sign of weakness. Producing no relevant evidence at all, but continuing to rest on your "laurels" is potentially a sign of a modern Greek upbringing. Yes, you can still be a Macedonian, but still be a "Greek". It's all a matter of who you're willing to die for in the end. Indoctrination is a huge problem in Greece and if contemporary Macedonians have fallen victim to such a cruel event, then you as a Macedonian, I would hope, would be working tirelessly to provide a "new" set of facts to consider.
My educational background is not in linguistics and anthropology. I think I have provided plenty of evidence – objective scientific evidence – to support my thesis that northern Slavs are genetically distant from southern Slavs and that northern Balkan Slavs are genetically distant from southern Balkan Slavs. Your whole argument up to this point has consisted of a minority interpretation of the origin of the Slavic language which may or may be accurate. As I wrote earlier, I am not arguing against this, as I do believe it is possible under the proper framework. What I am arguing, however, is that it is not an immutable fact, and to dismiss the consensus of scholars because they do not agree with this thesis is not logical.