Amphipolis said:
Where does Herodotus say that?
I never wrote that Herodotus said that. I wrote that, according to Herodotus, Macedonians were not Greek and did not speak Greek. This is the only logical inference one can make from reading Herodotus.
I have asked you this before, and I will ask you yet again, if you have evidence to the contrary, please present it.
Amphipolis said:
First of all, I don’t mind your genetic approach; I’m not saying I accept it but at least I understand it.
Judging from your other comments, you obviously do not understand the genetic approach. Hence, the present problems in our present discussion.
Amphipolis said:
Your narrative seems to emphasize on the area, to define a nation, while the Greek narrative emphasizes on the language, not the area.
Not quite.
Genetic studies establish a number of things as pertaining to the identity of Macedonians.
First, we are indigenous to the Mediterranean.
Our results show that Macedonians are related to other Mediterraneans...
And
Macedonians belong to the ‘‘older’’ Mediterranean substratum, like Iberians (including Basques), North Africans, Italians, French, Cretans, Jews, Lebanese, Turks (Anatolians), Armenians and Iranians,
A fact which is impossible for a people who first arrived in the Balkans in the 6th century.
Genetic studies establish that Macedonians are genetically distinct from their northern linguistic relatives.
A similar difference has been previously reported between Bulgarians and a few other Slavic populations (Roewer et al.2005), and our results demonstrate that other Southern-Slavic populations, namely Macedonians, Serbs, Bosnians, and northern Croats are genetically distinct from their northern linguistic relatives as well.
Genetic studies establish that the genetic profile of the Pathan population of Pakistan is consistent with a specific gene in the Balkans, and it is found in highest frequency among Macedonians.
Clade E3b1 lineages, which were frequent in the Greeks but not in Pakistan, were nevertheless observed in two Pathan individuals, one of whom shared a 16 Y-STR haplotype with the Greeks. The worldwide distribution of a shortened (9 Y-STR) version of this haplotype, determined from database information, was concentrated in Macedonia and Greece, suggesting an origin there. Although based on only a few unrelated descendants, this provides strong evidence for a European origin for a small proportion of the Pathan Y chromosomes.
This confirms that portions (at the very least) of the modern Macedonian population descend from a union between ancient Macedonian soldiers and the Pathan population of Pakistan.
This evidence does not establish a Macedonian nation. And no one is claiming that it does. It establishes our presence in the Balkans as one of the first peoples of Europe, and that some Macedonians living today can claim a genetic link to the Pathan population, and hence to ancient Macedonian soldiers.
Now working with these facts, and they are facts, and other facts, such as the ancient Macedonians being a distinct people from Greeks, and that they spoke a non-Greek language, and that we have historical records of a Macedonian ethnos from as early as the 1500s, it is not hard to come to the conclusion that we have always self-identified as Macedonian.
This is in stark contrast to the traditional theory that claims we descend from Slavs and our presence in the Balkans dates back to the 6th century, and we lived in the Balkans as some confused Slavic people, became Bulgarian, and then “woke up” to be Macedonian in the 1800s or when Tito waved his magic wand and made us “Macedonians”.
Amphipolis said:
Anything else would seem illogical as it would imply that Slavic-Slavonic language was always there in Macedonia (yet with a different name) but nobody ever noticed it.
This has been discussed many times on this forum. The language was not known as Slavic, it was Macedonian. Slavic is an anachronistic term, and did not enter the lexicon until Byzantine historians used it. What did you expect ancient historians to write regarding this language? Considering how shoddy the ancient history is on this subject, what do you expect?
Amphipolis said:
In our historical texts, first there are no Slavs, then Slavs appear.
Three quick points. First, Slav is an anachronistic term. Second, no people identify as Slavs. And three, you are extracting a literal reading of Byzantine sources about Slavs. This reading has multiple problems.
Amphipolis said:
That doesn’t mean that “you” came in 6th Century but it says something on who your cultural and national ancestors are. It also gives a clue on what your history books could write in the Chapter “9th Century AD” if there is any.
There is no Slavic culture. You are either extremely naïve or willfully dumb. Are you actually suggesting that the culture of Macedonians is the same as Russians, Poles, and Ukrainians? By this rationale, Romanians should have the same culture as Italians, as Romanian is an Italic language.
Amphipolis said:
I believe that given the present formation of nations the Bulgarian Empire and the very recent centuries (post-1000AD but mostly post-1800) are more decisive.
What are your thoughts on the Macedonian Lexicon of the 16th century? We have a Macedonian lexicon written in Greek using the Macedonian language in Aegean Macedonia in the 1500s at a time when a Macedonian ethnic identity should not (according to Greeks) have existed. Why would a Macedonian lexicon exist if no Macedonian ethnicity existed?
Amphipolis said:
Lastly, a few words regarding your genetic evidence: This isn’t exactly so. The Slavs were/are a linguistic family or a relatively primitive family of tribes, not a R$$@5435 whatever genetic type. National identities are also not genetic identities or racial profiles.
Here is the problem. You do not understand the science of DNA or genetic studies. Genetic studies measure lineage, human migrations, and genetic mutations.
Amphipolis said:
Those poor bastards. So, nobody identifies with them, yet you’re somehow stuck with their language and their literature. But that is of course (as George S. always calls it) a very small linguistic influence (we didn’t even notice it).
George S believes “Slavic” originated in the Balkans, so under his reasoning, “they” are “stuck” with our language. So nice try, but no.
Amphipolis said:
This isn’t so. The rest Slavic countries do not have an allergy on the term (I think).
I was referring to a Ukrainian identity, not Slavic. Second, Balkan people have been, by and large, brainwashed into believing that they are Slavs and descendants of ethnic Slavs. So it is no wonder that some people identify as Slav.
Amphipolis said:
The fact that Australians speak English is a reminder that your (developing) nation was formed on British fountains (whether you like it or not) and your culture is primarily British.
I wrote I am from an English speaking country, not Australia. I am not Australian. In addition, you are entirely misunderstanding my comments.
I do not deny I identify with the English language, English literature, and English culture. However, if someone asks me for my ethnicity, I am not going to claim I am an Englishman or an Anglo. My ancestors are not English, and me speaking English does not make me an Englishman.
Let me give you a few examples.
Andrew Rossos is a Greek born Macedonian. His surname is Greek. He speaks Greek. Yet, he also speaks English and Macedonia. He is described in Wikipedia as a “Canadian Macedonian historian”. What are we to make of him? What is he?
Second, what are your thoughts on Jews? There are Jews scattered all over the world. There are Russian Jews, Polish Jews, Czech Jews – all kinds of Jews. If you ask how these people identify, they will say Jewish, even though their surnames may be Slavic, and even though they may not speak an iota of Hebrew. Their ethnic identity is Jewish.
Would we be wrong to tell them that they are not Jews? What is a Jew?
Amphipolis said:
Well, are you at least interested?
Judging by the fact I have never explored this, and my academic background and interests lie elsewhere, I would have to state (for the present) “no”.
Amphipolis said:
Why do you prefer Homer and Herodotus over medieval texts?
In what sense “prefer”? We study ancient texts in the context of the Macedonian Question.
Amphipolis said:
I’ve seen you more comparing your modern language with Homer that with Cyril’s translation.
We are working under the assumption that Slavic may be indigenous to the Balkans, and therefore some words may be present in ancient Mediterranean literature.