makedonin
New member
I would not rely on Otto Hofmann and his assertion.
His tendencies are Pro-Hellenic and this can be seen through his book.
He reminds me of some Macedonian Digest linguists.
Example:
γοταν 'υν Μακεδονες where 'υν or συν as Otto states means Pig
He concludes that the Ancient Macedonian Word ΓΟΤΑΝ>GOTAN and the Greek word ΎΝ > HUN come from Pro-Greek HOFAN
Just to mention it that in all so called South Slavic languages, there is the word:
Serbo-Coratik: GUDA
Macedonian: GUDE
Bulgarian: G'DE,GODA
All mean PIG and it is more likely that the characters "T" and "D" change than "T" and "F".
This same rule Hoffman have used to prove that the Ancient Macedonian word ABRUTES> Macedonian OBRVI > Eybrows is of Greek Origin and has something to do with OFRUS.
He has to make up his mind, is it F for T or F for G sound
It should be Mentioned that "T" and "F" changings are found between Latin and Greek languages, but in rare occations.
But is Latin Greek because of that?
And in every South Slavic languages:
GOveDO, GOveDA > COWS, BULLS.
Sanskrit: GO > Cow
Modern Greek word for Pig: Γουρούνι > Guruni
In this way, I can prove that Chinese is Macedonian
His tendencies are Pro-Hellenic and this can be seen through his book.
He reminds me of some Macedonian Digest linguists.
Example:
γοταν 'υν Μακεδονες where 'υν or συν as Otto states means Pig
![]()
Quick Google Translation:
The only tame quadruped, whose Macedonian names we know, is the pig. The Hesych traditional Akkusativform γοταν > 'υν. Μακεδονες seems at first glance by the 'υν or συν to be so completely different that we understand it, if FICK try to explain by a bold etymological move. But appearances are deceiving: γοταν is nothing but the Macedonian Form of the word of the Greek 'υν and therefore linguistically special relationship valuable and interesting.
Look who is talking about bold etymological boldness
The initial G in Hesych not only from F, but from H, the symbol of Piritus asper, SOLMSEN in his "Untersuchung zur Grieschischen Laute and Verslehre 215" succeeded to secure evidence of tree Greek Glosses that follow this rule:..... .........
it corresponds to the specially for the Macedonian glosses "testified orthography" GOT-spoken HUUSound for Sound to the Greek Sounds in the word for pork HU-OOS, HU-OON
He concludes that the Ancient Macedonian Word ΓΟΤΑΝ>GOTAN and the Greek word ΎΝ > HUN come from Pro-Greek HOFAN
Just to mention it that in all so called South Slavic languages, there is the word:
Serbo-Coratik: GUDA
Macedonian: GUDE
Bulgarian: G'DE,GODA
All mean PIG and it is more likely that the characters "T" and "D" change than "T" and "F".
This same rule Hoffman have used to prove that the Ancient Macedonian word ABRUTES> Macedonian OBRVI > Eybrows is of Greek Origin and has something to do with OFRUS.
He has to make up his mind, is it F for T or F for G sound
It should be Mentioned that "T" and "F" changings are found between Latin and Greek languages, but in rare occations.
But is Latin Greek because of that?
And in every South Slavic languages:
GOveDO, GOveDA > COWS, BULLS.
Sanskrit: GO > Cow
Modern Greek word for Pig: Γουρούνι > Guruni
In this way, I can prove that Chinese is Macedonian
Last edited: