Constellation
New member
Here is another excerpt:
In regard to this quote:
I received this answer:
In regard to this quote:
Alinei said:As a specialist in geolinguistics, I have always been surprised by the fact that Slavic specialists have failed in noticing or appreciating the extraordinary diagnostic value –from a geolinguistic point of view – of the asymmetric configuration of the Slavic area. Even more so since the cause of this asymmetry is quite well-known, and explicitly stated in all handbooks for first-year students of Slavic: Northern Slavic does not form a single unit, but each of its two branchings – the Western and the Eastern – shares different features with Southern Slavic. Now, from a geolinguistic point of view, there is just one explanation possible for this peculiar and transparent areal configuration: Southern Slavic must form the earlier core, while the two Northern branchings must be a later development, each with its proper history and identity. No other explanation is possible[...]
I received this answer:
For what it's worth, "geolinguistics" is not generally recognized as a specialty per se (i.e., with its own rigorous and predictive methodological standards) by linguists - including linguists like myself who research language variation in space and time. Alinei's statement here implies that the principles of "geolinguistics" are scientifically sound enough to serve as a primary basis for deduction, and that is simply not even close to the case. This passage is more reminiscent of a conspiracy theorist than a scholar, both in tone and content.
For a more data-grounded approach to something that could be called geolinguistics, I would suggest Johanna Nichols's "Linguistic Diversity in Space and Time."